❄The true story behind the whale made famous by Free Willy (2002) | The Fifth Estate

Sea animals
11 followers
The story of the killer whale called Keiko.
When human beings fool with mother nature, mother nature always seems to come out
second best. But every once in a while, with the best of intentions, we do try to do the right
thing. That's how Keiko found himself in Icelandic waters. Now it was all up to him. Would he come up
with the happy ending? Turn fiction into reality? Become free Keiko? A lot was riding on the answer
and we were there. This is where the famous movie was supposed to end. The Westman Islands,
a cluster of volcanic rocks in the middle of the North Atlantic just south of Iceland.
Jaime is the only one with people. Until three years ago, Jaime was known for its volcano
and an eruption in the 70s that almost plugged its harbor. The harbor survived. Now Jaime is home to
possibly the most famous animal in the world. He's the killer whale named Keiko.
Like many other pampered mammals, he owes his fame to Hollywood.
He was the star of one of the most successful movies of the 90s,
Free Willie. Willie the captive whale who in the end went free with the help of a troubled little boy.
The real life Willie wasn't free and a lot of people are starting to wonder, will he ever be?
Charles Vinnick is vice president of Ocean Futures, the company that owns the real life whale
and spent millions trying to make a movie plot come true, freeing Keiko. This was the whale in
the movie. This was the whale a million children wrote about. This was the whale that the emotional
tie existed to to try it. Keiko's life began somewhere near here in the mid-70s. These were
perilous times for whales. Icelanders were still killing them or capturing them for marine amusement
parks in Europe and North America. Sometime in 1979, they caught the whale we'd come to know
as Willie. He was about two years old and he already weighed half a ton.
And this is where he landed, Niagara Falls, Ontario, where he spent three unhappy years.
Next stop, Mexico. And a little marine park called Reno Aventura, where he spent the next 11 years
amusing small children. It was not a happy gig for Keiko, whose name is Japanese for lucky one.
His luck was running out. Warm water, a tiny tank, parasites, and a poor diet ruined his health.
Keiko's days were numbered. In ideal conditions, a killer whale can live for 50 years. In Mexico,
Keiko was growing old before his time. Then a twist in his story that was right out of a Hollywood
script, literally. A couple of movie producers were looking for a star for a low budget flick
about an unhappy whale whose fate was in the hands of an unscrupulous owner.
The role was perfect. Keiko didn't even have to act. He just had to be himself.
Producers Lauren Donner Shuler and Jenny Lou Tugend were horrified by what they found in Mexico.
For me, it broke my heart. I mean, it really did. It was life imitating art. You know, it was
a whale that was too big for its very small and warm water tank. And it was clear that it
had a rash and it was rubbing up against the sides to itch the rash. His teeth was ground down.
He would sometimes, he would swim in circles really quickly because he couldn't splash water.
Yeah, he couldn't displace water. And he couldn't spy hop because his tail hit the bottom. Right,
he was longer than the tank was deep. And so, you know, he would do this and flop over. And
it was very sad, terrible, very sad. He was one miserable mammal. But before long,
he'd learned that Hollywood, for all its glitter, has a soft spot, at least for whales.
When we went down to Rainier Ventura for the day to begin shooting, the first day shooting,
Jenny and I made a deal with each other that we would get him out of there. We couldn't stand it.
In the movie, a lonely boy befriends the captive whale called Willie and cooks up a simple scheme
to get him free. The movie made it look so easy, learning the skills he'd need to survive in the
wild. But even in the movie, the task wasn't quite as simple as it seemed. They had to build a
mechanical whale since no real whale would ever learn to do all the stunts the movie script was
calling for, especially the climactic scene. Willie's magical flight to freedom. The end of
the movie, but not the story, not for Keiko, nor it seemed for the producers who discovered him.
We bond to him. He's the star of our movie. We hung out with him every day. We became friends.
And when we're done with our business, it became very sad,
the idea that we would go on with our lives and leave this whale in this swimming pool.
They decided that the story couldn't end like that and launched a public campaign to rescue him.
Kids around the world responded. They wrote letters and they sent money.
Then a twist in the plot, right out of the world of make-believe. A soft-hearted cell phone
billionaire named Craig McCaw offered two million dollars to help turn fantasy into reality.
If you convince several billion children that the whale got free by showing them
very difficult conditions and, as it were, creating the case
and making that case very compellingly on film, and then you don't fulfill that dream,
you've broken a promise to children all over the world.
McCaw's money made it possible to move him out of Mexico. He didn't object, not for a minute.
It helped that he was underweight by a couple of thousand pounds.
And before long, he was in a United Parcel Service airplane heading for a new home.
Newport, Oregon, a real aquarium with a brand new seven million dollar tank,
especially designed to get Keiko in shape for his return to the wild. It was time to start
cutting his ties with people, but the planners hadn't counted on the star factor.
Layton Blackwell was 12 at the time. He knew about the whale from the movie. When he heard
the world's most famous whale was coming to Newport, it was almost more than he could stand.
I was just, you know, as an eye-opener, I was just like, wow, we have a whale in our town.
Keiko coming to Newport.
January 7th, 1996, UPS delivered, and the whole town turned out along with the international media
to see the splashdown. This was supposed to be a training stop on his way back to the wild,
to freedom, but he soon became the star attraction at the West Coast Aquarium.
I went there every chance I got to see the whale and, you know, I would chase him around,
try and get as close to him as I could, you know, it was always packed with people.
You know, I didn't expect to get to even touch him. I did, I touched him. It was, you know,
that was really exciting. Wow, I touched such an enormous movie star.
Like most performers and especially movie stars, Keiko thrives on attention. The more fuss people
made, the happier he was. He wasn't getting any closer to the wild. There are no people in the
wild and very little pampering. Keiko had a lot of work to do to get toughened up.
Keiko's trainer was Jeff Foster. He probably knows the whale better than anybody.
Keiko would not have been the first choice for a reintroduction candidate. He was probably the
worst candidate, but he has learned a tremendous amount. Nothing like this has ever been done
before, so it was a learning process and it was like climbing a mountain. It was one step up and
two back oftentimes. The learning process involved the basics, like feeding yourself.
Remember, Keiko had spent 20 years on a diet of dead and frozen fish.
Okay, there's a guy right on the bottom there. Come on, Keiko, do it. Catch your own dinner and
eat it alive. It was about as disgusting a notion to the whale as it would have been to the guys who
were trying to persuade him to do it. By 1998, he'd gained a ton. The parasites and skin problems
were gone. He was, as the old saying goes, as healthy as a trout. But Keiko was in no hurry to
leave friendly Newport, and Newport was in no hurry to see him go. It was costing $100,000 a
month to look after him, $10,000 a month for antibiotics alone, but he was putting Newport
on the map. Inevitably, it came time to tackle phase two, moving him to Iceland. I was so happy
he was getting out of there, you know. I wasn't twisted or sad at all about it. A lot of people
were angry. You know, a lot of people wanted him to stay there. I was just thinking, you know,
free Willy, he's going home. You know, gosh, if I were him, I would so much rather be in my home,
When we come back, a time to fish or eat bait. He just had this little bitty fish in his lips,
and it was still alive, you know. And so, you know, I mean, you could tell that he was real
curious. In Iceland, the traditional view of killer whales like Keiko is that they're worse
than useless. You can't eat them, but they eat tons of the fish that make up tiny Iceland's only
economic resource, which is why Icelanders once were only too happy to sell killer whales to
foreigners. Ken Balcombe is one of the world's leading experts on whales. Iceland was of the
mindset that these are noxious predators to be eliminated anyway. They're eating our fish.
They're eating our fish. So if I can get a hundred thousand dollars for something
that I want to get rid of, let's do it. Which is how Keiko ended up sailing off to America
in the first place. And according to Johan Sigurdsson, he should have stayed there.
He's director of Iceland's Marine Research Institute.
We think it goes against the principle to play with such things. So that was our recommendation.
We shouldn't be playing with it. We shouldn't be importing the animal for that reason.
We also pointed out that there was not a lack of killer whales in our water,
so it did not have a conservation aspect as such.
Iceland lives almost entirely off the sea. Before 1989, whale hunting was a big part of the economy.
The whaling fleet still waits at dockside for the end of an international ban on killing whales.
In the fall of 1997, a gambler could have made a pretty safe bet that Iceland would be the last
place on the planet to offer Keiko a new home. The official position was that Iceland, traditionally a
whale hunting nation, was no place for a celebrity whale. Then, surprisingly, the official position
changed. And the change was due to pressures that had some influential advocacy here.
They just didn't take this as any big deal.
De O. Mount was the United States ambassador to Iceland. And when Keiko's owners asked him to
help clear the way for the whales' return, he couldn't think of a single reason to refuse.
You want children to feel that some things can work out, after all. There's enough in life that's
sad and difficult. There's so much going on right now in the world that's terrible and awful.
And here you have a chance to put your shoulder to the wheel and make something,
this story, have a happy ending. And why not?
Then he discovered an unexpected ally in the White House. And so during a state visit by
the prime minister of Iceland to Washington, President Clinton broached the subject of
sending Keiko home. Compared to his other headaches at the time, like Saddam Hussein
and Monica Lewinsky, this was a no-brainer. The head of any country sitting there at your desk,
and all the stuff that comes across, all the problems and all the things you maybe would
rather not deal with. And here comes a winner. I mean, what is the downside of this? So I think
that maybe that's the appeal. Everyone got on board and said, gee, you know, this has a high
visibility. And the countries that are concerned are supportive. It's a win-win situation.
The prime minister of Iceland clearly thought so too.
And he knuckled under in spite of the opposition back home.
So what happened? I mean, how did all this get turned around? And how did Keiko get here?
We made our advice, our recommendation. The state veterinary officer did so as well.
And then a political decision was made. It was not more complicated than that.
September 9, 1998, Keiko is in the slings again, leaving behind the
comforts of the Oregon Aquarium and all the perks of fame bound for Iceland.
It was just as big a day for Leighton Blackwell, who had just won an essay contest
and the prize to be in Iceland when Keiko got there.
I was just overwhelmed with excitement to the, you know, almost to a nauseating point.
That's what I felt like. It was almost, it was like from the movie,
Free Will, you know. He was, he was in extreme danger being out of the water for so long.
And it wasn't the only danger. Unbeknownst to most of the onlookers, the military airplane
that landed Keiko in Iceland broke its landing gear when it touched down,
almost turning five tons of whale to sushi.
In the end, the country that didn't want him back,
rolled out the welcome mat. It was a hero's homecoming.
For Keiko, being lugged around seemed to have become routine.
Do you ever think they might drop him? He's like, he's like five tons of meat.
Oh, that was definitely, that was definitely a thought running through my head, you know.
What if something snapped? It was almost silent, you know. He's in there just
waiting, waiting, waiting for him to hit the, hit the water. And when he hit the water,
it was just, as soon as he touched, a loud roar. Everyone was just screaming at the top of their
lungs, you know. I was so happy. Ideally, Keiko was going to learn how to survive in the wild
here, then swim away to freedom, just like in the movies. And ideally, he'd be followed by
scores of others like him, once wild creatures who'd been turned into performers.
Nobody seemed terribly concerned that the cost of his upkeep had just increased threefold
to $300,000 a month. He had 24 hour a day supervision. He loved it. It didn't seem to
mind that this was all about getting him fit for life beyond the safety of his pen.
He was still less than enthusiastic about feeding himself. There was always someone
handy with a herring that was already dead. The first day that he was in the pen in Iceland,
he caught a little fish, a little bitty fish that he had on his lip and brought it back up to the
veterinarian. And I mean, I don't even know how you could pick it up, but he had, he just had
this little bitty fish in his lips and it was still alive, you know. And, and so, you know,
you could tell that he was real curious. The killer whale somehow lacked the killer
instinct or lost it somewhere in North America. High on a hillside overlooking his pen,
skeptical Icelanders watched with amusement as Keiko's trainers tried to help him get it back
to turn a giant tub toy into a self-sufficient hunter by playing with him. Einar Hallgrímsson.
From the first day they came here, they have been doing the same things.
Which is what?
Training, just like before. We thought they were going to make him
train him for going out in the nature. But make him jump every day, give him the same food every
day. Not fresh herring. They tried it out in the sea. And this summer when they went to throw it
to the sea, he didn't eat it. Only once frozen. A bad sign. He isn't likely to find a lot of
frozen in the wild. And even if he did acquire a taste for live fish, killer whales tend to hunt
in groups. And so the hunt was on to find a group that might welcome a washed up movie star who
lacked any conspicuous survival skills, like catching food. And so for three summers, they
escorted him out for what they call his walks into the wild, introducing him to other killer whales
to see how he'll react to them and them to him.
This walk, recorded in May last year, pretty well sums up how Keiko feels about his peers.
When it comes to whales, he's just another whale watcher. The people who own him and manage the
Freedom Project aren't ready to give up yet, no matter what Keiko seems to be trying to tell them.
Charles Vinnick. Are you ready to say now that his reintroduction to the wild isn't going to
happen? I think it's way premature to say that. What's the incentive for him to take off now into
what is a completely hostile and strange environment? I mean, he's approaching middle age in
whale terms. He identifies with people. He likes people. He likes being around them. And he knows
that people will be nice to him. He chooses to interact with wild whales. That's an indication
that he's curious, that he's intrigued, and that he may want to spend time with them and they may
not have accepted him. I think it's way premature to say he's not going out. The question nobody
ever asked is, what does Keiko want? It's now becoming clear that he's trying to answer it
anyway. That Keiko doesn't realize that he's a whale and that he's really more at home with humans.
What's wrong with drawing the obvious conclusion that he just likes his life as it is? And if
that's the case, this is where his life is. We have to find ways to sustain a natural life in a
natural bay and still provide him that kind of life. Not necessarily, you know, what's the option?
Do you take him back and put him back in a tank because he didn't join whales? That's an absurd
conclusion to draw from a project like this. So far nobody is drawing that conclusion, but there
are unavoidable questions like, what now? If after six years and 25 million dollars all they've
learned is that once tame, an animal would rather not be wild again, what do you do with a five-ton
pet? The Seattle billionaire Craig McCaw has made it clear that he's growing tired of supporting
Keiko and his retinue. There's a plan to install a salmon farm near his pen in the Westman Islands,
a potential hazard to Keiko's health, which means he'll have to move again. But where next
and who's going to pay? The government of Iceland is saying bluntly that they're not prepared to
spend a plugged kroner on him. Magnus Johannesson of the Icelandic Environment Ministry issued the
permit to bring him here, but hastens to point out that the whale is an American responsibility.
The preconditions that we set for this was that it would be of no cost to us, and
that agreement I think is still valid. So I will not assume that there will be any
any cost to Iceland. Could you see yourself being drawn into a different position where you might
have to take some responsibility for the welfare of the animal? I would expect them to take the
responsibility of Keiko until the end. You're not going to get caught up in this paying for Keiko,
you haven't changed your position. That is absolutely clear. Keiko's former trainer
raises the possibility that he may once again find himself in a sling heading for yet another home.
We may not be able to maintain him there because Iceland is one of the more expensive countries
in the world. So you know we are looking into other options and that's relocating him to
another country, potentially even a land-based facility. But if they try to move him out of
Iceland or into another tank, they might encounter powerful opposition from the one constituency that
seems to know Keiko best of all. As long as he stays in Iceland, if they can find another
place there, you know he needs to stay in those in those waters that he's in. I think it'd be
really dangerous to put him in to make another trip like they did, you know.
Gosh, just let him let him be settled. He's been through so much, you know, let him move on with
his life. Ambassador Mount, who pulled the political levers to get Keiko to Iceland,
is retired now, living back in the U.S., having second thoughts. How would you,
if you're telling this story to your grandchildren, how would you end the story as you understand it
today? Well, I think you know you get to realism in the end. When we fool with nature, sometimes
the results are irreversible, that you can't go all the way back. We human beings have influenced
his life too much. It just may be that we have to learn that, you know, in the end maybe he can't
go free again. We called up Ocean Futures to find out how things are going for Keiko.
They tell us they're planning to take him out for a spin again this summer, but they have less staff
now and less equipment and frankly everyone is less certain that Keiko will ever opt for freedom
in the deep blue sea.
