James Lindsay On Critical Race Theory: How Worried Should You Be? | Interviews

PragerU
799 followers
PragerU's Taylor Trandahl interviews James Lindsay, an expert on Critical Race Theory. A superb interview along with REAL, PRACTICAL advice for what you can—and should—actually DO about it.
#criticalracetheory #wokepolitics
Watch James's 5-Minute Video, "What Is Critical Race Theory?"
https://www.prageru.com/video/what-is-critical-race-theory/
How concerned they should be is extremely.
Like on a scale of one to 10, 12.
Social justice, white privilege, anti-racism.
Are you hearing these buzzwords
all the time in America today?
What do they all have in common?
Do they all trace back to something similar?
What if I told you they do?
And it's called critical theory,
better known as wokeism.
I'm Taylor Trandall with PragerU
and joining us today is one of the world's foremost experts
on critical theory or the wokeism movement.
He's also one of the world's foremost critics of it
and his name is James Lindsay.
James, thank you so much for joining us.
Thanks for having me.
I saw the other day that Richard Dawkins
gave you a shout out on Twitter
and like endorsed your book,
Cynical Theories, which people should check out.
But then like a few weeks ago,
you were on Ali Stuckey, a conservative Christian,
her podcast.
So there's this strange confluence
of conservative Christians
and legendary atheists, new atheist intellectuals
are finding, what's that common ground
that they're finding today
that you seem to be in the center of?
Reality.
It's the pursuit of objective truth.
And so I know a lot of people who are watching
or listening who are atheists are gonna say,
ah, you just said objective truth in Christianity.
But the thing is,
whether you believe the Christian framework or not,
the Christians believe they are pursuing objective truth.
They believe there is an objective truth worth pursuing,
that everything's not subjective.
And they ground that in scripture
and they try to get to that through exegesis,
which is a rigorous methodology.
People who are like Richard Dawkins
who come from the rationalist scientific perspective
believe there's an objective truth in nature.
And of course, many Christians of course,
see nature as reflection of God's creation.
So they see objective truth in nature as well.
And so there's actually more agreement there
than people realize,
because they've been so busy fighting about
whether or not religion is true.
There's a deeper level question is,
is something true at all,
rather than is everything subjective and up for grabs?
And that's what people are catching on to.
So I wanna get into,
we have many questions from our audience,
various sectors of our audience,
students, young professionals, parents.
So this first question is from a Prager 4 student.
And he says, I want to speak up against my woke friends,
but I'm afraid of being called a racist.
At what point is being silent worse than being canceled?
So that's a tough question.
It's an easy one for you.
Yeah, what point do you have to make a personal decision
based on your integrity?
It's really difficult.
So the truth is,
it is ultimately an individual circumstance.
You have to read your own circumstance.
You have to decide for yourself,
when are the costs going to be greater?
But what you have to understand is
that unless people start speaking up
and unless people start taking that risk,
it's only going to get worse
and therefore it's only going to get harder.
So what I would tell people to understand is
that the way that the trajectory of this movement
is going so far,
there may be some people who can lay low and get through it
and just keep their head down and they win, I guess.
But the truth is,
the longer you wait to speak up, the harder it is.
As hard as it is now,
it will only become harder to resist later.
So I advise people like that
to do what they feel like they can.
There are other ways
than just speaking up and speaking back.
There are other ways.
If you listen to Alexander Solzhenitsyn
in Gulag Archipelago,
he says, let the lie come into the world,
let it triumph even, but not through me.
So find ways to live in your own integrity
and you have to make those decisions for yourself.
I can't tell somebody,
yeah, now's the time to just blow up your career
or lose all your friends.
Right, that's great.
That's really good advice.
Okay, so we've got another question
from a Prager 4 student here.
She says, I think many of my woke friends and family
started down the path with good intentions,
just wanting to be against racism and for equality.
But it seems like all of a sudden,
they're talking about dismantling capitalism,
they're justifying violence as long as it's on their side
and ignoring any facts that contradict their narrative.
Why does this seem to brainwash people so quickly?
And is it even possible to wake up someone who's woke?
That's a hard one.
Another simple one for you.
No, that one's really hard.
In fact, that one's really hard.
I honestly, so woke is like,
I hate to say it this way given the circumstances,
but woke is like a spectrum.
But you can think of it like with a religion,
like with Christianity,
you've got like probably the pastor's really into it,
the theologians are really, really into it.
And then you have kind of people who go to church
and they really, they try to be serious
and they're varying degrees of serious.
Then you have that, you know, yeah, I'm a Christian,
but they probably haven't been to church
in like three months.
You have the same things happening in woke.
So when you say, can you wake up a woke person?
The question is, how far in are they?
Are they like all out?
If they're already defending violence,
you're probably going to have a hard time.
If they're talking about dismantling capitalism
and they're serious about it,
you're probably going to have a hard time.
If however, they're kind of, you know,
well, I put the black square on my Instagram or whatever,
you can probably walk them back still.
You can probably show them, you know,
this is actually a lot scarier,
or this is a lot grosser.
Neo-racist is a word that we've been using.
It's not racist in the usual sense.
It's this neo-racist and new racism
that it's being reinstalled.
And that's kind of gross really.
And you can kind of get that little bit of a gag reflex.
You can get them to laugh a little bit and say,
yeah, that is kind of silly, you know.
If you can show them places where the theory
is self-contradictory or where the activities
look like they're self-serving or whatever.
So you can, if they're not too far in, wake them up.
But if they've gone all the way in,
this thing's like a cult
and you can't just wake a cult member up.
And that's why it brainwashes people
so quickly and effectively
is because it preys upon people's,
A, desire to be a good person
and B, vulnerabilities that they might not be.
And it's tapped so effectively
into their social strata, right?
So somebody else was just asking,
you know, I'll get canceled by all my friends.
Well, it's so much easier to just start mouthing it
and going along with it.
And then that social pressure
just makes it so much stronger.
So it's difficult, but try to tell the truth,
try to be sensitive and try to be open
because eventually the bubble will burst.
And the thing that's most important here
is that when somebody comes out of the cult,
whether it's woke or whether it's any other cult,
you have to be willing and ready to welcome them
and affirm them and say, you know what?
It's not a big deal.
Let it go.
We're all cool now.
You know, you've gotta be there.
Give them an exit ramp and then kind of love bomb them
to be honest with you.
Like don't take this combative posture
or, you know, beat them down.
Yeah, like, don't be like, look what you did.
Can you see how terrible, you were, you know,
you were crazy, but that's not gonna help.
Invite them in.
You know, glad you're here.
Yeah, exactly.
Glad you're here.
Welcome to the club of reality.
You're back in.
Welcome back.
Moving to, this is a question
from a young professional audience.
It says, my work has just scheduled a training seminar
about diversity, equity, and inclusion.
Does this mean that they're teaching critical race theory?
And should I refuse to participate
or at what point should I draw the line?
All right, so this is tricky.
Again, I can't get you fired, but okay.
Are they teaching critical race theory?
It is, I can't say for sure that they are.
It is possible to teach these things without it.
And there are a handful of programs that teach it,
teach diversity or whatever,
do diversity training without it.
There are a growing number of them.
I know that because some of them are asking me
how to help design them.
So I know people are trying to create
alternative diversity training.
So it's not guaranteed.
That said, the overwhelming majority of these trainings
are based in critical race theory
to where I would say that it's a virtual certainty
that if somebody's taking it up at your workplace,
unless it explicitly says
we're not using critical race theory on purpose,
it probably does.
Should you participate?
I don't know.
It's up to you and your situation.
If you've got like a kid at home
and you've got to keep the paycheck,
you've got to check in with yourself, right?
Same advice I gave earlier applies though.
The longer you wait, the harder it gets.
The longer you wait,
the harder to live with yourself it's going to get.
I have heard a lot of success though
because a lot of people in the business world
and even in the political world aren't that aware of it.
This is usually being pushed
by a fairly small number of activists.
So if you get a little bit informed about this
and then you go talk to your boss
and I've published some resources on my website,
New Discourses, about what you can actually say.
You go talk to your boss
or you go talk to whoever is in charge.
A lot of times you can make more headway than you think
and you can come up with either an alternative
or to get them to start looking to build
and find that alternative
that doesn't use critical race theory.
And that's, I think, a superior thing than quitting.
Taking a stand at work
is probably going to get you nuked out of your job.
So if you do so, do so strategically.
I don't mean to tread on toes,
but the Christian world, I've tried to listen very well.
You mentioned Allie Stuckey a moment ago.
I try to listen.
And one of the things I talk about a lot
is the gifts of the spirit.
And you can't, like, don't deny that, right?
So you being able to function within that space
is also a thing.
But at the same time, you've got to remember Solzhenitsyn.
Let the lie come into the world.
Let it triumph even, but not through me.
So you have to find that line for yourself.
And then throughout thousands,
we've seen parents are talking all the time
about how thousands of school districts
across the country are adopting Black Lives Matter
at school curriculum and things of that nature.
So the question is basically,
how concerned should parents be about woke indoctrination
and critical race theory in schools?
And what can they do to fight against it?
How concerned they should be is extremely.
Like on a scale of one to 10, 12.
This isn't playtime anymore in the schools.
I say that with no reservation.
The level of alarm you should have
about what's happening to your children in schools
right now is 12 out of 10 alarm.
It's a nightmare.
It is an absolute nightmare.
It's in most, if not all schools.
People think, oh, well, I can pull them out
and put them in a private school.
It's in most, if not all private schools,
even big religious private schools are taking it up.
There's not any kind of safe harbor.
And it's a real emergency
because you're going to be spending all of your time
basically learning about this
and trying to deprogram your kids
instead of genuinely bonding with them
or spending time with them,
if you want to try to prevent it.
Or you're gonna have to try to homeschool,
but they will probably try to outlaw that,
to get around that, or to force particular curriculum.
Do you think that's coming?
I almost guarantee you that it's coming.
The attempt is coming.
I don't know if it'll succeed.
So it's a dire situation.
What can you do?
Same kind of advice as talking to your boss.
Talk to the school administrators.
Start finding out.
I have a guy I know in a school system in a big city.
I don't want to give too much information.
We got looking into it,
and he found out that his school district,
which serves thousands and thousands of families
and their kids, was being hustled by 12 people.
12.
You found all the names of the activists pushing this.
The entire school system's being pushed around
by 12 activists.
So imagine if 120, 10 times that many,
parents band together and say, no, no.
Here are the people doing this.
Some of these, I've heard in a city,
I spoke to the mayor that was getting hustled,
a small city somewhere in USA town,
and they looked into it,
and there were about 20 activists hustling the city,
and it turned out that only one of them was a constituent.
These are activists who are acting
largely through the internet,
and it's usually a very small number of them.
So what you have to do is you have to become
that counterforce.
You have to organize, get informed, and start showing up.
Go to the school board meeting,
even if all you can do is throw sand in the gears
by asking questions that they don't want asked
or pointing out things they don't want
to have aired.
Get on the school board if you can.
Call the, not just, it's tough to bother the teachers,
principals though, and especially school superintendents.
Get them to explain what's going on in the school,
why is this critical race theory?
If it's not, explain how it's not.
Here are these terms I'm concerned about.
You will have to do some work,
but getting involved and getting in their face
and making them work,
if they're gonna indoctrinate your kids,
make them work for it.
Don't give it to them for free.
Yeah, and the cost of doing nothing
is exponentially worse than the time it takes
to get organized and try to organize resistance.
The other piece of advice is find a lawyer.
And in fact, if you can, find one who's ready,
who's hungry for litigation.
Because, and I say that like, oh, we're gonna bury him.
No, it's not that.
A good litigator does a lot of what's called discovery.
And that's basically like,
they have almost subpoena powers.
They can really do a lot of deep digging research
and unearth a lot of corruption,
and a lot of times, this is being paid for somehow.
They can unearth how it's being paid for.
They can find out what organizations are being involved.
Also agitate your local and especially state governments.
State governments control a lot
of what's going on in education.
Write your state legislatures.
I was just, in fact, today,
I testified in the legislature of the state of New Hampshire.
I got invited to talk.
And so, and that was about critical race theory
in schools and state institutions.
And so, bother your state representatives
until they bring the issue to the floor.
It's something everybody can do.
This is great practical advice for parents.
All right, so we wanna end with a sort of rapid fire.
Lightning round.
Lightning round, true, false.
True or false, all white people have internalized racism
and white supremacy.
False.
It's absolutely preposterous to say
that all white people have a particular disposition of mind.
If you wanna understand the theory,
what it says is that the system benefits white people.
So therefore, white people have comfort in the system.
Therefore, they have no motivation to overturn it.
And that therefore makes them complicit.
They call it white complicity.
Brown people are complicit too.
They call it brown complicity in white supremacy.
And it's a preposterous thing to accuse people of,
especially the majority of whom aren't just not racist,
but they are against racism in the way
that the word anti-racist used to mean.
Statement number two, true or false,
America is fundamentally a racist country.
False.
America is not a fundamentally racist country.
America is in fact a fundamentally anti-racist country
in the old sense of the word.
It starts from the Declaration of Independence saying,
all men are created equal.
It is true that at the time when that was written
for various reasons, that was not being lived up to.
And we put forth a lot of work through history
to get to that point.
But you look at the former slave, Frederick Douglass,
where he speaks in 1852 or three on 4th of July,
very famously, and what does he appeal to?
The Declaration of Independence and the Constitution
and says that we have to live up to those things.
America is fundamentally anti-racist, right?
And then what does Martin Luther King say?
Martin Luther King says that there was a promissory note
written in those founding documents
that has not been paid yet.
What's he appealing to?
The fundamentally anti-racist nature of the United States.
It is absolutely a distortion.
It is a willful and evil distortion to say
that the United States is intrinsically racist
because it had to struggle its way out of racism
that existed when it was founded.
Love it, yeah, there's no reason to deny
the incremental progress.
That's literally what sort of liberalism
and enlightenment values and Judeo-Christian values
allow for that.
But this neo-Marxist woke world view
doesn't allow for that incremental progress.
We need to blow up the entire system
because it's fundamentally through and through racist.
Yeah, they say that explicitly.
The very first paragraph of the book
Critical Race Through an Introduction
says that explicitly.
They say, unlike traditional approaches to civil rights
which value step-by-step and incremental progress,
we have this other thing
that completely repudiates the liberal order.
They say it explicitly.
Not even hiding it.
Not first paragraph, not even trying to hide it.
Yeah, don't bury the lead, as they say.
All right, last question we have
in our rapid-fire true and false session.
This one is true or false,
the end goal of wokeism is a Marxist revolution in America.
This is Jeopardy theme song time.
That is more true than false,
but it's complicated, with a little bit of,
it's complicated.
The truth is that the ideology of critical race theory,
et cetera, critical theory behind that
does come out of the attempt
to figure out how to make a communist revolution take place.
Whether it's going to be strictly Marxist
is not likely to be the case.
They call it liberationism.
It has a new utopian endpoint
that's not the proletariat owning the means of production.
Its new endpoint is called equity.
We're going to have a perfectly equitable society.
I've heard of that word before.
Yeah, and so it's not strictly Marxist,
but it has the same shape.
I mean, if we were gonna be word dorks,
we'd call it Marxoid.
Indeed, it certainly seems like that.
All right, well, thank you so much for joining us.
How can people support what you're doing
and find more of your work and find you on social media?
If you want to find me off of social media,
you can find me at my website, New Discourses.
It has social media accounts.
They're all at New Discourses.
It's all crowdfunded,
so if you choose to support me there, I love you for it.
Thank you very much.
I am also completely crowdfunded,
so I try to put out special content
for everybody who subscribes,
so come be a subscriber.
Come listen to my special subscribers-only podcast
called James Lindsay Only Subs.
You can catch me there.
All right, well, James,
this has honestly been super helpful for me,
and I'm sure a lot of people watching.
For you guys watching at home,
make sure you like this video,
share it with someone who needs to hear it,
comment your thoughts down below,
and subscribe to PragerU for more.
We'll see you next time.
