We’re told the Earth is experiencing a climate crisis and that manmade emissions are to blame. Environmentalists want us to stop using fossil fuels, but could we function in our world without them? Would the cost be too much to bear? Chris Wright is the CEO of Liberty Energy and has dedicated his career to finding the most efficient energy sources. He was recently tapped by President Donald Trump to be Secretary of Energy. He sits with PragerU CEO Marissa Streit to have an honest conversation about climate change and fossil fuels.
is there a climate crisis are there more
extreme weather events are fossil fuels
to blame and is it possible to live in a
world without fossil fuels
Chris Wright is the CEO of Liberty
Energy who has dedicated his career to
finding the most efficient energy
sources let's cut through the political
bias and have an honest conversation
about climate change and fossil fuels
Chris thank you so much for sitting down
with me thrilled to be here Marissa I
want to start with the elephant in the
room this conversation is about climate
change it's about fossil fuels and it's
about these issues that create a lot of
tension right now in our country and you
are in the fossil fuel world I mean
you're really in the trenches you're an
investor or you run a company you've
been outspoken about your thoughts on
this issue and I know that people are
going to hit me up and say well why are
you interviewing someone who has really
a vested interest in us working with
more fossil fuels so let's just address
that why do you think that you should be
the right person to speak about it and
then I will bring in my personal
interpretation of why I think it's
important to speak to somebody like you
about this issue I mean that's only
natural reaction of course you wish
people would engage with ideas more than
who the who the person is saying but I
mean of course that's human nature but
my story is a little bit different you
know I I grew up also in a time where
there was this fear of the world ending
fossil fuels were also the bad guys then
but the fear was we were going to run
out of them this early 80s when I'm in
high school you know industrial
civilization was going to collapse we
needed a new energy source solar was hot
then there was a talk about a wind
although it never took off much back
then but I went to MIT specifically to
work on Fusion Energy running out of
fossil fuels the world needs energy I
quickly realized I didn't have the
patience for big science ended up going
to graduate school briefly UC Berkeley
and I worked in solar energy there and
then geothermal energy in graduate
school and a little bit afterwards so I
don't care where energy comes from it's
just got to be affordable reliable and
better people's lives I did get into the
oil and gas business my wife thankfully
is is how I got here and today the
opposition to fossil fuels that I do
push back against but the opposition of
fossil fuels is actually tremendous for
my business and for the business this of
all of my customers because think about
that this doesn't do anything to change
the demand for oil and natural gas but
if you incrementally restrict the supply
of those things you just drive up to
prices today we have artificially high
prices for oil and natural gas and we
have absolutely record profitability at
my company Liberty Energy and at my
customers companies so interesting so
it's actually in your best interest that
there'll be more regulations and less
supply of fossil fuel because you
essentially would then be able to you
know charge more and make more money
yeah if you make an essential commodity
scarce the price will go up every time
right but you're not one of those
I'm not for making it scarce I want to
make it abundant I'm the weird oil and
gas guy that celebrates lower prices the
Shale Revolution you know over the last
decade or 15 years to me the greatest
thing it did was dramatically lower
Global oil prices dramatically lower
Global natural gas prices saving
consumers around the world you know one
to two trillion dollars a year I'm proud
of that yeah I would say the other
reason why I wanted to sit down with
someone like you as opposed to you know
a researcher or a scholar and we've done
many many interviews with you know
whether it's Michael schellenberger or
Steve coonan or Alex Epstein who I'm
going to speak a little bit about their
books and how they've influenced me the
reason I wanted to sit with you is
because you are in the trenches you're
in the trenches you're putting your
money your time you're investing I mean
such a big portion of your life and so
you really know what it's like to work
with fossil fuels and I I want to have a
real authentic conversation with someone
without the politics without any skin in
the game because frankly I'm raising
three kids on this planet I live here I
want to have a good environment I don't
want to be attacked by hurricanes I
don't want to have my cities flooded I
don't want to have polluted air I don't
want to drink polluted water you know I
want to hear the real deal I don't want
to politically charged conversation I
want the truth and so my hope is that
given that you're in the trenches I can
ask you some of these difficult
questions that I think many families
around the country are are really
wondering about I do think it's one of
the mistakes of our industry you know
that it doesn't speak out very much and
then when it does it sort of carefully
scripted talking points No One Believes
carefully scripted talking points when I
go speak at universities I it goes well
generally because I only have one way I
speak it's honest in candid it may be
embarrassing I may be saying things I
shouldn't say but that's just the way I
roll but I think if you speak sincerely
that's the only thing people listen to
anyway okay so I'm going to start asking
you some questions the bottom line first
question is is the climate changing and
should we worry about it climate is
changing both it's always changing
because of natural forces but human
impacts today are definitely significant
enough that they are additive they are a
meaningful force in and of themselves
driving changes in the climate so we
should be concerned about it we should
be focused on it we should be studying
it but to date the changes are rather
modest rather slow moving there's almost
as many positive changes the planet's
getting greener and agricultural
productivity is going up with more plant
food in the air it's probably almost as
many positive changes as there are
negative changes but you know that
calculus probably changes with time so
it's a very real issue dominantly caused
by our industry so real issue yes is it
a crisis is it the world's greatest
challenge or a big threat to the Next
Generation no well wouldn't it be a huge
threat to the Next Generation if you're
saying that you know the use of fossil
fuels is heating the earth I mean you
can't you can't scale that back and so
why are you saying it's not you know
something that we should be alarmed
about well in the last hundred plus
years the world's warmed a little over
one degree C and again today probably
more positive than negative five times
more people die from the cold than die
from the heat globally and a little bit
warmer Planet also means a little bit
wetter Planet necessarily those two to
get go together that drives up
agricultural productivity most of the
increase in agricultural productivity I
think is technology better farming
practices better fertilizers but the
climate's been a little bit of a
Tailwind there at the time of the
founding of our nation in what was
called the little Ice Age Life's a
little bit tougher if it's a degree or
two degrees C colder so a little bit
warmer is isn't a threat if we were five
seven eight ten degrees C warmer that
would be meaningful changes to the
planet
um humans would likely adapt but it
could it would be disruptive for sure I
mean it is an issue and it should be
considered okay so you're saying that
fossil fuels are increasing or
decreasing the temperature of the
climate and increasing it it is
increasing the temperature of the
climate and so you're saying that right
now it's not that much but if we don't
stop using the fossil fuels isn't it
going to get worse we don't know is the
real answer
um the warming certainly will continue
it's a logarithmic function so the
amount of carbon dioxide we put in the
atmosphere of the last 70 or 80 years if
we put that same amount in probably in a
shorter time period in the next 20 or 30
years the impact of that will be much
less than the original molecules is
logarithmic you have to double the
concentration again to get the same
impact you've got well so far it's just
been a 50 rise but the the effect should
continue to grow absolutely we should
monitor it the ipcc has done extensive
economic worth work on it and their
estimates are maybe a 0.2 to two or
three percent reduction in per capita
income around the end of this Century so
that's negative two or three percent of
you know 100 trillion dollar global
economy is a lot of money
but you know that's a few months of
economic growth between now and the year
2100 we have 10 million easily
preventable deaths on the planet today
that we could solve and of course the
most important ingredient in solving
those is to energize those people that
are living in energy poverty so climate
change is a negative but there's bigger
negatives and more solvable negatives in
the short term technology and societal
Evolution will eventually decarbonize
our economy but you know that's probably
a hundred years of order that time frame
to do that we simply don't have the
Technologies to do it today can you
explain how fossil fuels work because
we're hearing the term fossil fuels and
we're hearing climate change and we're
hearing them together mostly in in terms
of we need to give up our fossil fuels
because it's heating up the climate but
I think would be helpful to understand
is how important are fossil fuels to our
daily lives like how do they actually
provide us with whatever it is that we
have today and what would it look like
if we didn't have fossil fuels for
example well 30 years ago the world got
about 87 percent of its total energy
from fossil fuels 30 years several
trillion dollars of of subsidies
mandates desires for an energy
transition but we've gone from 87 to
about 83 percent in 30 years so we are
slowly reducing the percent of fossil
fuels in in in the total World Energy
System but World demand for coal oil and
natural gas today or at all-time highs
so you know they're a dominant source of
energy over 60 percent of clothing
Fabrics globally are made of fossil
fuels our cars the painting our Plastics
our iPhones the internet
fertilizers in food is just incredibly
important fossil fuel agricultural is
why the world supports 8 billion people
today we're just 150 years ago we had a
billion people mostly in wretched
poverty so it's pretty game-changing
technology that has allowed people to
live longer healthier more opportunity
Rich lives and all these fancy materials
and we can fly around the planet and
drive a car to go visit Grandma for
dinner 100 miles away these were just
unimaginable before the arrival of
fossil fuels one of the things that
helped me really wrap my head around the
whole concept of fossil fuels is that
it's not necessarily just about
electricity or or gas in your car but
the biggest consumer of fossil fuels are
actually the agriculture Industries is
that right and how does that work and
would that mean that if we stop using
fossil fuels then our food basket
essentially would be much more expensive
because how would we you know get
agriculture dramatic exactly
manufacturing is the largest user of
fossil fuels and I'll come back to that
in a second but agriculture maybe we
could say is the most important users of
fossil fuels you think of tractors and
mechanized farming materials those big
storage bins the ability to transport
grain all around the country and all
around the world
all those are of course important but
let me just focus on one which is
nitrogen fertilizer historically the
biggest limiter and how much food grows
in a certain plot of land is nitrogen in
the soil this came from planting peas or
legumes when you did crop rotation came
from bat guano and human waste night
soil they call it in India until
recently their largest source of new
nitrogen into their soils but about a
hundred years ago two German chemists
developed a Haber Bosch process that
takes natural gas and a catalyst at high
temperature where natural gas supplies
both the energy and the raw material the
hydrogen that is then stripped from the
carbon and bound onto a nitrogen atom
that makes nitrogen fertilizer
synthetically produced and dispersed on
soils so if we took out just this one
piece of hydrocarbons synthesized
nitrogen fertilizer Global food
production would drop in half of course
not only when crop prices go up but you
know within a few years of order half
the planet would starve maybe less than
half because everyone else would just be
on smaller calorie diets but it would be
absolutely transformative to world
living condition if you remove fossil
fuels just from that one sector we don't
know starvation in America right I mean
I know my grandparents would have known
about it and the Great Depression where
you had to stand in line to get food but
that would be a reality again
quickly I mean if you've got rid of
nitrogen fertilizer with certainly
within 12 months there would be food
lines we would have starvation on a
large scale I have so many y's in my
head right now but let me start with
this
why would they push for wind and solar
wind and solar doesn't solve this issue
of Agriculture given the agriculture is
so dependent on fossil fuels and so when
they want to go zero on fossil fuels how
are these policy makers answering the
question of Agriculture and
Manufacturing if in fact the biggest
consumer of the fossil fuels are not
necessarily you know turn on the lights
or drive you know Teslas or whatever
cars they're claiming that we will solve
this fossil fuel issue like it just
doesn't make any sense to me yeah look
energy is complicated and it's hard and
when you hear politicians say that they
don't have a deep well thought out plan
about all these questions you're asking
it's politically popular youth of today
loves it solar and wind are sort of
romantic but solar and winter only in
the electricity sector right electricity
is 20 of delivered Global energy we
paved the whole planet in solar panels
and got all our electricity from that
that'd be 20 we'd still have to supply
the other 80 percent of energy and that
other the biggest piece of that other 80
is manufacturing there's sort of four
materials that make up the modern world
cement steel Plastics and fertilizer
like almost nothing happens on our
planet that isn't either made of those
or came from something that was made
with those including wind turbines
they're just giant towers of Steel with
cement bases and those giant blades are
made out of oil so that you know they
are giant physical embodiments of
hydrocarbons you couldn't have wind and
solar without hydrocarbons I have to ask
the question why again what is the
incentive to push things like wind and
solar and ESG and you know all of this
you know anti-fossil fuel agenda where
is this agenda coming from when I speak
in universities kids are idealistic they
they're maybe more physically
comfortable than even you and I where we
grew up the world's a wealthy wonderful
place today and they want to have
meaning they want to be part of
something bigger than just getting a job
been paying their bills and I think the
sort of climate alarmist story that the
world's going to end if everyone doesn't
change their behavior that's that sort
of fits a religious hole for children
today they can be part of the solution
they know who the devils are I wish it
was only children right
exactly there's so many threads to it
and look among politicians the biggest
driver ever think is by far is if you're
going to redesign the Energy System it
means you're going to redesign Society
so if you're sort of a top-down
politician you want a larger government
control you want to pick winners and
losers and and redesigns that's that's
intoxicating to a politician I talk to
politicians all the time about this they
know very little about climate change
but it's a reason to do things maybe
they wanted to do anyway I mean take
electric cars they're barely needle
movers in reducing greenhouse gas
emissions but maybe not even positive
needle movers but they displace gasoline
demand into the diesel that's used to
mine and process and build these cars
takes far more energy to build an
electric car than to build a
gasoline-powered internal combustion
engine you've got to drive it like 70
000 miles before its greenhouse gases
are equal for the first 70 000 miles is
higher so you know that's not a
meaningful climate solution but well-off
people love electric cars they're neat
they're sexy they're fast so look
politics is politics there's not
generally a deep thought out plan to
save the planet that's not what's
driving politics and the policies you're
hearing about okay so I want to go back
to really fully understanding so fossil
fuels predominantly are not going
anywhere right now because we need them
for manufacturing we need them from for
agriculture there is no viable
alternative right there is a possible
viable alternative for electricity which
is wind and solar but is not in fact a
viable alternative because it still
relies on fossil fuels to create the
wind turbines and and all the glass
metal pieces that are involved then and
the battery correct and so California is
claiming that they're going to switch
off into electric vehicles so what are
your thoughts on that is is our electric
bill just going to go Sky High I mean
how is that viable well I I think it's
very unlikely to happen this getting rid
of internal combustion engines is the
seventh clean fuel mandate passed in
California they're oh for six on the
first six I think it's a safe bet
they're going to be over seven on this
time frame you can Electrify small
vehicle transportation with big trucks
ships with airplanes like that's not
going to happen you can Electrify small
vehicles but it's problematic it's more
expensive and batteries don't last very
long so resale cars have dropped of cars
fall rapidly and then you gotta recycle
or do something with the batteries so I
think electric cars are going to grow
and maybe they should I think they're
going to grow a lot in the next decade
but are they going to completely
displace internal combustion engines in
California nearly zero chance of doing
that and of course the cost would be
enormous but the pushback from people
would be
no I mean is there really going to be a
push back from people I mean they're
very very smart people Gathering whether
at Davos or there was the Paris climate
Accord where they're pressuring
countries to move away from fossil fuels
zero emission I mean we saw what
happened in Germany actually let's talk
a little bit about what has happened in
Germany because last time I checked
their electric bills are even higher
than California which I think is already
so high so in in Germany they pay 40
cents per what is it one kilowatt hour
and in California we pay 19 cents and in
many other states around America they
pay 9 10 11 cents and so would if we go
down this route that Europe has gone
down are we possibly looking at 40 50
cents for electricity alone of course if
we tried to design our Energy System
like they've done in Europe of course it
would lead the same place Germany you
mentioned is a funny case study because
Germany they shrunk their subsidies to
buy an electric car right in January 1.
so in December you could get 6 000 Euros
to buy an electric car now it's more
like 4 000 Euros and in the month of
January EV sales dropped over 80 percent
so if you remove the subsidies and and
they removed they shrunk those subsidies
because it's a huge budget impact you
know you you change human behavior so
with subsidies and mandates can you
drive change yeah of course you can
drive chains but only so far Germany
invested massively to try to change its
electricity grid to dominantly wind and
solar they built a grid the capacity of
the winded solar grid is as big as the
capacity of the thermal grid they had
before but they still need the original
grid because at times when the wind's
not blowing and the sun's not shining
which is exactly when you need
electricity it'll go down to less than
five percent of the capacity of the
whole electric and solar so you need a
grid almost the same size of the
reliable power to keep the lights on so
that's expensive because you're
basically running two electricity
generating systems and as one floats up
and down with the weather the other one
you've got to turn up and down to match
that with the weather it's not very
practical and in Germany as a whole
that's just electricity their largest
source of electricity is still natural
gas by far and coal is number two so
they have their total energy went from
81 one percent fossil fuel to 75 in
their 25-year energy transition
aggressive plan almost a trillion
dollars in US in a much smaller half a
trillion dollars in a much smaller
economy than the US so it's just hard to
do well correct me if I'm wrong about
this but many of the countries that have
decided to go you know zero emission or
don't want to do their own fracking or
extracting of of natural gas for example
will buy their natural gas and fossil
fuels from terrorist countries so one of
the ways that I like I I like to think
about it logically is while Germany is
all feeling good about itself because
they're you know all in compliance with
the Paris climate Accord and you know
they're being all green they're actually
subsidizing Russia right because they
buy all of the natural gas from Russia
and so they're essentially subsidizing a
war right or at least subsidizing a
regime which I'm assuming they don't
align with but they have no other choice
because they still need the same amount
of fossil fuels to power their own
country
yeah I think there's this
misunderstanding that Russia's invasion
of Ukraine caused this energy crisis I
think the causality is the other way
Russia invaded Ukraine at this time
Putin's wanted to do it for 22 years
he's been in power but we entered a
global natural gas crisis not enough
natural gas that could be moved on
Seabourn not a crisis in our country or
in Canada but a global natural gas
Crisis began about September of 2021. so
about five months before Putin invaded
that skyrocketed natural gas prices as
you said Marissa Russia supplies almost
50 percent of German natural gas biggest
supplier of their oil major supplier of
their coal so I think Russia thought
maximum leverage now is the time to go
that exacerbated and already unfolding
energy crisis Europe by reducing their
own fossil fuel production they didn't
reduce their consumption very much so
they went from producing most of their
oil and natural gas to importing most
other oil and natural gas and as you
said you know Russia is the biggest
supplier Algeria is another big supplier
Norway is the one local Supply the
Iranians as well right Iran is a major
supplier of oil to Europe so yeah it's
you know these these policies that as as
we started are not deeply thought out
that hey this is going to lead to a
better world a safer world a cleaner
world it's just politically popular to
oppose hydrocarbons and we have a
growing industry now that's now sizable
that if you give out money to wind and
solar you know or buy a fuel subsidies
there's a big political interest group
there there's an impression that soon
will be done with oil and gas people
honestly believe that in 10 20 or 30
years at most we won't use hydrocarbons
nearly zero chance of that happening one
of these conventional view why why is
there zero chance that this could happen
because we don't have replacements for
so many of the things we use
hydrocarbons for I said nitrogen
fertilizer look we have no other way to
make nitrogen fertilizer but natural gas
and a catalyst in a high energy process
steel cement Plastics and fertilizer
those four pillars of the modern world
we use almost as much energy to produce
those as the entire Global electricity
system and those are take this high
temperature process heat that right now
you only get from hydrocarbons you
cannot get it from electricity from wind
or solar you could get it from nuclear
power I'm a huge fan of nuclear and have
been since I was a kid like we should be
doubling down ahead of your time we
should be tripling down a new cutter
ultimately we will because it's an
alternative that works it has the high
energy density it can it works when it's
dark it works when the wind's not
blowing it's reliable power and it can
do more than just electricity nuclear
can supply high temperature process heat
that can Aid in manufacturing if we look
out several hundred years from now
nuclear is probably the largest energy
source on the planet and you probably
still have quite a significant role for
hydrocarbons for their materials and
specific applications fifteen percent of
oil is not burnt for energy it's used to
make Plastics and materials asphalt
roads Teslas Tesla has a thousand pounds
of oil in the car
can you explain why there's so much
pushback against nuclear is it just the
trauma that we have from what happened
in uh Chernobyl or any of the other
disasters
well it started even before that you
know they formed the nuclear Regulatory
Commission in 1974 you know to Safely
permit nuclear power plants and and get
and you know they formed a new
government agency it has not permitted
one new nuclear power plant why not one
why why it works it's clean you can you
know I'm assuming you can somewhat
dispose of it and if you store it safely
why
fear is powerful very powerful it's the
same thing with climate if you can make
someone scared of something you can
generate opposition to it so nuclear
power has an incredible safety record
the best safety record of every energy
alternative we have out there including
my industry oil and natural gas it's the
safest power thing it uses the smallest
amount of land the smallest amount of
materials the waste disposal thing is
scary but practically it's actually a
pretty simple problem almost all the
waste today is sitting in swimming pools
70 years of waste from 100 nuclear power
plants around the United States it's all
just stored locally it should be stored
deep underground but still not a problem
or in these giant canisters that are so
heavy no one can move them so it's a
great technology even in its first
generation iteration now obviously the
Soviet Chernobyl plant that was in
Ukraine was a horrific design and they
did a crazy experiment and they blew it
up and these killed of order a hundred
people or so plus destroyed the
environment right not as much as you've
heard or seen you know that has not
always been if you look at the UN report
the follow-up on that they actually
attribute 56 deaths to Chernobyl 10 or
20 years after so it's much smaller than
you think Fukushima in Japan a magnitude
9 earthquake I think two people died
neither from radiation they just drowned
because the diesel generators the backup
generators were in the basement so all
sorts of mistakes that should have been
done differently and of course would be
done differently in something built now
but the safety record is strong in spite
of these flaws so nuclear will come back
unfortunately with the political
environment it's likely going to start
coming back in China and India and
elsewhere the fear and the bureaucratic
nature of the United States it's just
impossible the new the only two nuclear
plants that have come on in my adult
life are coming on in South Carolina
recently they were permitted 40 plus
years ago
it's just so crazy so basically the way
I understand it is this we have to have
fossil fuels in our lives it's not going
anywhere we need it for agriculture we
need it for manufacturing we need it
pretty much also for electricity and for
for commute the alternative of wind and
solar don't work because they're
actually more expensive to maintain than
what we gain and they're actually not
that really good for the environment
either and so it's not a proper
alternative nuclear energy is a great
alternative but for whatever reason the
government is not moving forward because
there is fear or bureaucracy or whatever
and so fossil fuels is still here to
stay
but we're not denying that the climate
is getting warmer we're not denying that
fossil fuels contribute to the increase
in the climate's temperature but every
time we talk about fossil fuels and the
fact that the alternatives are not good
enough we're being called climate change
deniers is that a fair synopsis of the
situation it's not that we're denying
that there is a problem we're just
saying that there isn't a viable current
solution to get rid of fossil fuels and
frankly nobody wants to give up their
current way of life
I think that's indicative of the
struggle with the dialogue today that is
a reasonable summary of what goes on
right now you know I wrote this
bettering human lives report 100 page
long report to go over where the world
gets energy how that's evolved with time
this problem of energy poverty I wrote
12 pages on climate change explaining
the chemistry and physics of it showing
the data the climate economic work the
intergovernmental panel on climate
change is done you know and then you
know you put these things all in
trade-offs or issues and I get called at
denier all the time like I've been
speaking on climate change for 20 years
I mean not once did you say to me that
you're denying that the climate is is
Heating and not once did you say to me
that you think that fossil fuels has
nothing to do with it but I think that
the real bottom line is that we're
spending so much time and energy and on
fear-mongering having everybody
basically freak out over climate change
that we're spending less time and energy
on supporting Innovation right I mean
isn't that at the end of the day what
our educational institutions should to
do they should invest more in research
research and Innovation if you want to
get off of fossil fuels you can't
eliminate fossil fuels from our lives
because nobody wants to give up their
way of life and frankly we need to
maintain the type of way of life that we
have right we want to get people out of
poverty not bring more people into
poverty which what eliminating fossil
fuels would do to a big segment of the
world so why why aren't we seeing more
incentive in Innovation and why aren't
we seeing educational institutions push
for more Innovation instead of
fear-mongering now you're right that's
the right answer this fear cell has a
snowballing problem it's made kids
fearful and therefore less optimistic
you know less people are having kids
because they say they're worried about
the world they're bringing them into
less people are studying Science and
Engineering in our country the jobs are
awesome I go to schools and and pound
the table for people to do it but but
their view of science is its Authority
Aryan you know there is climate science
and if you'd say anything different than
this unknown you know sacred scroll
you're unscientific well that's that's
the opposite of what science is it's
about challenging and engaging and
learning how's our Energy System going
to get cleaner and lower greenhouse gas
emissions Innovation better energy dense
Technologies if we have Energy
Technologies that are better than the
one today it won't take any government
policy people will shift to stuff that's
cleaner and cheaper that's the future is
to drive things to become better
have you seen any progress in Innovation
I know there was something about algae I
mean you know anything about that well
Algerian biofuels the problem is that
that's that's again solar energy that's
coming from the Sun it just takes a fair
amount of land on land it's not
practical at all algae maybe in water
could be a little bit more viable but
it's just still a lot of resources to
create a smaller amount of energy what
is oil oil is hundreds of millions of
years of stored marine life these tiny
phytoplanktons that lived in the oceans
100 million years ago the world was much
warmer much higher CO2 concentration
than today so much more Abundant Life
think of the dinosaurs they're so
gigantic but there was enough plant
matter you could feed these animals that
were monstrously bigger than elephants
and the oceans were incredibly rich with
life so it's it's those phytoplankton
that fall to the bottom of the ocean
they get buried they get cooked that's
how oil and gas gets created it's
hundreds of millions of years of stored
solar energy in these little dense
packets it took CO2 out of the
atmosphere and buried it and we are
burning it today and releasing it back
into the atmosphere at a faster rate
than it got buried which is why
atmospheric CO2 concentration is going
up but they're just pretty awesome
sources of energy but will Innovation
and Technology improve things of course
it will and we should focus on that
instead of subsidizing things that now
we've got decades showing they don't
work we hear endlessly wind and solar
are cheaper where have they ever been
installed and electricity prices came
down
has there been evidence of that none
none there's a thing called the
levelized cost of energy well when I put
up a wind panel a turbine it cost me
this amount and I maintain it for 20
years then I divide by how much energy I
get out hey it's it's almost as cheap as
natural gas the problem is it's a
different product I give this Uber
example if if you if you called an Uber
and you weren't sure when it was going
to show up and you weren't sure where it
was going to drop you off would you pay
the same for that Uber as the one you
get today that tells you when it's going
to show up and actually drives you
wherever you want those are just two
different products Texas had that giant
blackout and is really destroying their
electricity grid because they pay the
same amount per unit of electricity from
something that's erratic and
intermittent versus something that turns
on and turns off and matches Supply with
demand so what do you get if you're
going to pay just as much for a lower
quality product as a higher quality
product and you got subsidies to produce
more lower quality product they're going
to get more and more more wind on their
grid and 200 people died a couple years
ago in that cold spell that swept
through Texas now you're a little more
than a year ago just last winter I
always say energy is too important to be
politicized or fear-mongered it needs to
be a little more sober a little more
fact-based because it enables Our Lives
as you keep saying you make energy more
expensive and less reliable people have
lower quality lives what's also bizarre
about the whole situation is the
censorship that we're experiencing you
just recently experienced some
censorship you had a video explaining
fossil fuels and you uploaded it onto
LinkedIn and apparently LinkedIn had
that video removed and Prager you many
of our videos have been removed or
targeted by YouTube or Shadow band on
Facebook or we've received threatening
emails from newsguard telling us that we
can't show it our videos with you know
whether it's shellenberger or coonan or
or any of those you're not running for
office I'm not running for office I
think both of us just want to have a
better world uh for for ourselves and
for our children for our community and
we want viable Solutions and so when we
try to speak about these things in a
non-political way we get targeted by
these big tech companies why is that
there's surely a crew of activists
around there like my LinkedIn Banning I
don't think that came from someone who
worked at LinkedIn I think people who
are climate alarmists this is a
profession you know it's a money it's a
faith it's a movement that any video
that says the world isn't ending and we
must do you know our our formula they
try to get banned you know and they file
complaints and they push and they find
something you know as you saw the Wall
Street Journal did a story on this
looked into it and they found a climate
scientist my 12 and a half minute video
who said one claim I made that droughts
have not increased was incorrect and it
turns out my claim was correct but I had
to again provide the references and
sources to show that it is sad to see
big Tech sensor ideas or perspectives
they don't like that's not healthy for
society it's too bad but they're not
going to shut me up and they're not
going to shut you up and so well I did I
see an article I watched your video and
then I read the article that was written
about you in the journal and then you
had a rebuttal to that and it was
focused on
your claim or I guess you cited claims
that there are not more hurricanes and
the droughts are not getting worse I am
hearing claims everywhere and I'll also
hear many people say well I'm seeing
more hurricanes than I've ever seen in
my lifetime so are hurricanes actually
increasing either in strength or in
frequency or are they not they are not
depends on Cross winds depends on sea
surface temperature so hurricanes go in
in Cycles some year could have a lot
some year less maybe there's a 30-year
swing where they're more frequent and
then they're less frequent but if you
look at the entire hurricane daddy set
globally United States all land falling
hurricanes all major hurricanes there's
not an upward Trend in any of them and
again I show all of that data in
bettering human lives in fact all of
that data is in the intergovernmental
panel on climate change reports which is
where their conclusion is is there an
observable Trend in hurricanes no is
there an observable increase in
tornadoes no is it an observable
increase in meteorologic drought like
it's raining less no
um is there an increase in floods no so
these are everybody believes they are
yeah and even the intergovernmental
panel and climate change think of that
this is a bureaucracy that only exists
if climate change is a problem if you
thought ah it's not that lower problem
you don't work for the IP you know
you're not an ipcc out of the job so
they're reasonable humans the technical
people are following the data but that's
what the data says but then you have the
summary for policy makers and the media
and politicians and of course some
activist scientists that say well if I
start the hurricane data in 1980 and
from the low we had and then I plot It
Forward I can show an upward Trend hey
you do it my state in Colorado all the
time you know we have a snotel data
monitoring network from 1936. there is
no Trend in a change in the snowpack in
Colorado over 86 years but if you start
it from a year of heist snowpack you
could show a downward Trend they do it
all the time now we've had huge snow
packs
that's basically data manipulation I
mean that that's like them making it up
for what for the case of a good story to
what to fit a narrative that there is
some catastrophe coming our way the
media loves this they love it I I send
them data all the time it does not stop
them from saying these increasing storms
due to climate change you know the it's
it's I call weather porn people are so
obsessed with with storms and tornadoes
and stuff all around the world and of
course everyone is seeing more
hurricanes today because every hurricane
everywhere if it's hitting where people
are is on social media and everybody 100
years ago you didn't see it unless it
hit your town right but I mean I would
believe the same thing if I didn't dive
into the data and all of it's pretty
easily accessible this is not
controversial like the oil guys data
versus the climate data there is pretty
good databases on hurricanes in all
different forms accumulated cyclonic
energy or Ace is the sum of all
hurricanes time intensity over the world
no upward Trend well I I would say that
I would believe all this stuff from the
media and the education system too
because they're unless you search for an
alternative perspective and you really
look under the hood and you're willing
to do all the work which I had done it's
hard to really believe otherwise I mean
this is really why I wanted to have
these books up here because I think that
if you read Michael schellenberger's
research and book and you read Steve
coonan's book and you read Alex Epstein
then you'll be in a place where I'm at
where you're asking these questions of
why why why why
would we ruin our way of life and not
also provide the opportunity of the way
of life that we have to folks in Africa
right if Africa had more access and I
think they're starting to realize that
right if they have more access to fossil
fuels they will be able to lift their
people out of pover when you lift people
out of poverty that means better
education better medical condition you
know probably less civil unrest am I
right here's my biggest biggest problem
with the climate alarmist movement so
the world's about 8 billion people
roughly a third of them two and a half
billion people cook their daily meals
burning wood dung and agricultural waste
indoor in their Huts those Smoky fires
that we think are romantic they're
basically breathing suit and they're
breathing that soot that particulate
matter and the court of the World Health
Organization that kills about 3 million
people a year three million people a
year every year die because they do not
have access to phones because they don't
have access to a thing a simple clean it
costs about fifty dollars to have a
propane cook stove and a refillable
canister now about a hundred million
people a year are making this jump to
clean cooking stoves and who are the
three million people who die women and
children who's over the fire all day who
gathers the wood who cooks and who does
that so these enormous Health impacts
three million deaths a year that's of
ordered the rate of deaths we had from
covid globally during the during the
last three years well everybody is
worried about the nuclear plants that
you know essentially exploded but the
deaths are much more severe when people
have no access to energy dramatically so
three million just from clean cooking
stoves and at the cop conference the
Congress of the parties the climate
conference in Glasgow a year and a half
ago so the fall of 21 a year and a half
ago 19 Nations including the United
States the United Kingdom Canada the
wealthy nations of the world pledged
they would no longer lend to developing
nations poor Nations for hydrocarbon
infrastructure development they will not
help reduce that 3 million deaths a year
comes another way I mean why what is the
motive to do that
because a they're uneducated shallow or
evil or some combination of that too and
they're playing to Their audience at
home that is bombarded with fossil fuels
are evil they're destroying the planet
they're the greatest human health
basically Rich educated people who have
access to fossil fuel don't understand
how good we have it and so we just don't
care whether poor people have access to
it or not I mean that is bluntly what is
going on it's shameful and and they're
proud to pledge that they're going to
try to stand in the way of the access
for that two and a half billion people
to get lives like you and I have and to
save three million lives a year like to
me you know that's not just nuts it's
immoral it's really wrong it's wrong so
I can't tell you how many businesses are
visited where they have proudly told me
that they're now implementing ESG
environmentally and socially governed
and they're actually doing this because
they're claiming that it's the moral
thing to do I mean we just talked about
morality and how wrong it is that we're
not offering access to fossil fuels to
countries that are developing and need
access to that and now American
businesses are implementing ESG what is
going on over there a minority of people
but the people that control the large
investment firms have bought onto this I
don't know why they bought onto it for
sure you make a higher fee if you're
running an ESG fund than just a blind
Index Fund so there's a business reason
if you're a money manager it's a premium
product just because you can charge
people who bought into this whole farce
you charge more for managing that fund
because you have to go out and evaluate
who the most virtuous companies are by
this ESG Criterion so when I wrote Our
ESG and maybe it's more of an anti-esg
report this I mentioned bettering human
lives I talk about two things really
changed the world we had 30 years
roughly 30-year life expectancy
throughout all human history until about
200 years ago today it's 72 more than a
double and you're climbing right yes
incline more than a doubling of human
life expectancy inflation adjusted more
than tenfold increase in the average
wealth of each person extreme poverty
went from 90 of the world to eight or
nine percent of the world so this
incredibly positive thing two things
drove that in my opinion one is
bottom-up social organization human
Liberty kings and queens or or
mercantilism you only can start a
company if the government gives you a
license that only changed in the 1840s
you and I could just go out and start a
company that wasn't true 200 years ago
bottom up Liberty and hydrocarbons are
Why We Live Twice as longer why we have
Planes Trains and Automobiles and modern
medicine and and multiple outfits of
clothes and all these and all these
other things and the ESG movement in my
opinion is mostly against both of those
they're preaching you've got to show
your Net Zero path to 2050. hectic
intergovernmental panel on climate
change their own economics shows Net
Zero 2050 as it tens of trillions of of
dollars human impoverishment program
mean the costs massively exceed their
own projected they know that and they
know that and they want to Define they
want you to fill in numbers and check
boxes to see how virtuous you are so
it's a top-down definition
maybe it's well intentioned but I think
that I I find it appalling we're not
going to have a few people on the coast
decide which Criterion are going to
decide which business is virtuous and
which is not and they clearly know
nothing about the trade-offs of
greenhouse gas emissions versus energy
resources versus poverty and so what I
did was write a report and say this is
this is what I think the world actually
right now needs a lot more hydrocarbons
not less particularly in low-income
Nations and low-income countries and we
need a sober long-term mentality about
better Energy Technologies just further
subsidizing technologies that don't work
that's not there's no human betterment
in that the government gets involved and
puts on these regulations I mean
essentially ESG especially when we
specifically the environmental side of
it it may even cause people to not focus
on Innovation because they think that
they're helping let's put more money in
Innovation rather than and waste money
on things that don't work
exactly if the government is picking
winners and losers it's not going to be
a lot of service that's going to do I
mean that's that's sort of a case of
history and think of the whole societal
impact in the United Kingdom the U.S in
total greenhouse gas emissions has
reduced ours way more than anywhere else
but we're by far the biggest economy so
the largest in percentage terms is the
United Kingdom they've dropped their
greenhouse gas emissions by 40 that
sounds heroic but they've also had a 30
percent drop in total energy consumption
so what happens if you make energy
expensive and unreliable all the
manufacturing all the stuff that uses
energy intensely just leaves your
country so instead of being built with
blue collar workers in the Midlands of
England in a modern natural gas powered
Factory it's being built in Vietnam or
China or Indonesia in a coal-fired plant
and then they're loaded on a giant ship
powered by Diesel and brought back to
the United Kingdom and they think this
is green this isn't green this isn't
greenhouse gas reduction it's ultimately
just reducing the job opportunities of
blue collar lower income people working
more energy intensive jobs and energy is
a larger percent of their expenditures
so it's sort of a reverse Robin Hood
scheme when you make energy expensive
and subsidize Rich connected business
people you're just floating money to the
top and you're draining opportunity and
money from people in the bottom half so
when you're saying that the UK's energy
consumption went down it's a bad thing
because it caused Less jobs and less
manufacturing within the UK I mean has
their GDP decreased no their GDP grew
because they're huge in finance and
Technology London is boomed it's like
New York and San Francisco booming but
Alabama but they're still relying on all
the natural sources that natural energy
sources that they need so they just
import that they import it the
birthplace of the Industrial Revolution
where Modern manufacturing they they
were sending textiles around the planet
British manufacturing now it is mostly
gone it's it's just tragic oh God I'm
glad you brought this up because I have
another question and that is another
thing that I just learned recently the
difference between the independence
which are the independent oil and gas
manufacturers in the United States
versus the large Global ones my reaction
when I heard about them was why did I
never hear about these Independents why
aren't we supporting them so that we
don't become more reliant on what I call
terrorist regimes which include Russia
China Iran Etc where you know ultimately
we don't want to rely on external
factors to have them here in the United
States why are we squashing the
independence again politics explain what
Independents are because I'm not sure
that others have learned what we call
the majors or the integrated companies
you know Exxon Chevron Conoco Phillips
you know British Petroleum so these are
large companies that produce oil and gas
around the world they refine oil and gas
into diesel fuel and jet fuel and
gasoline they were operated pipeline
Network so they're big awesome companies
but they're very different than the
Independent by the way I learned that
they're also big investors in solar and
wind
right many of them actually have a
vested interest in solar and wind and so
they push both well they do it for
political purposes British Petroleum was
the leader in that remember Beyond
petroleum yeah so BP just announced
record ever earnings last year but from
oil and gas and that they were going to
roll back their rate of investment in
alternative energies because the returns
were not there their stock has been
crushed people think you don't even know
what you want do you want to be an oil
and gas company or do you want to be a
renewable company or they want to be an
apologizing oil and gas company that
also dabbles in Renewables maybe not a
great business model I don't know it's a
great virtue signaling okay it hasn't
yeah I don't think it's worked great for
the business and of course the oil and
gas production parts of BP are great I
mean bpx is sort of the American Oil and
Gas it's like American Independent owned
by BP it's a hard driving fabulous
company that's growing its oil and gas
production in the United States the
other Independents are like you know EOG
and Devin you know or PDC smaller
companies these are sort of you know
market cap you know one to 40 billion
dollar companies much smaller than the
majors but they're the main oil and gas
producers in this country and they're
the people who drove the innovations
that started the Shale Revolution if you
make it harder to drill for oil and gas
in the United States you don't reduce
the demand for oil and gas right you
just produce less of it the United
States and we import more from Iran or
Saudi Arabia or Venezuela or somewhere
else overseas which of course means
dirtier practices higher greenhouse gas
emissions higher pollutants the whole
band drilling on Federal Land I'm like
the only thing we know for sure if we
did that was we'd have higher Global
greenhouse gas emissions and higher
pollutants nothing else might change
meaning because it wouldn't be produced
in the United States with you know
tighter regulations and you know more
modern wealthy high-tech companies that
do this with the smallest footprint
possible it would just be produced
somewhere else so our independent
American oil and gas companies being
limited are they you know being squashed
or are they being supported I mean I
hope we're supporting them we're not
supporting them you know right right now
we're making them their ability to drill
oil and gas Wells harder very hard to
get permits on Federal Land so some of
these companies half their acreage might
be on Federal Land have fun private
they're having to disproportionately
driven drill on private lands very hard
to get a pipeline if you produce oil and
gas in a new area you got to build a
pipeline to move it to the refinery or
to the coast to send that natural gas to
Europe whatever it is but building that
infrastructure has become harder which
means on the margin they're drilling
less Wells than they would otherwise and
it means oil and gas prices are higher
so we're hurting their ability to drill
oil and gas Wells but we're driving
their profits up because this these
restrictions on Supply are driving the
prices of oil and natural gas up yeah
their stockholders are winning but their
hearts aren't winning
I don't care about their profits I want
America to be independent I don't want
to be dependent on terrorist countries
so any concerned citizen who is watching
this should say to themselves well wait
a second we know we're going to need the
fossil fuels anyway one when we want to
rely on our own American manufacturers
why not open it up to more opportunities
for more Drillers within the United
States to rely on the resources that we
have here in our country and not rely on
China Russia Iran Venezuela and all
these other places that simply don't
they simply wish us ill let's just say
it frankly I'm aligned 100 with that our
industry is aligned with it 100 with
that and that is the message we bring to
Carrie to Washington to our state
politicians to everyone even though in
the short run it's it's contrary to our
business interests but it's good for the
country and it's the right thing to do
if we have fantastic resources here and
great workers we can develop it in the
cleanest smallest impact way we should
do it so okay basic thing I learned when
I was in college there are a few things
I learned at UCLA supply and demand okay
so there's clearly a demand that's not
going to go away
Supply is being squashed
does that mean that if I invest right
now in in energy specifically maybe in
Independence if I want to invest in
something that I know all the major
financial institutions are virtue
signaling and are afraid to invest in
should it should that be something my
husband and I consider investing in I
think the answer is yes you look at
investment people say well of course
this is a great buy this is a great
company the question is it's a great
company are the expectations in it
better than it really is or worse than
it really is a great company that people
view as outstanding is not a good
investment but in our industry everybody
thinks we're going to be gone in 20
years is the reality going to be better
than expectations
I think yes it's one of the things
that's really caused a swing back in ESG
investing the ESG investing took off
maybe 10 years ago as the Shale
revolutions hitting its peak so the
Shale Revolution exploded U.S oil and
natural gas production great for America
drove down prices and all that not great
for the companies in our industry they
drilled too much they drove the prices
down good for the customers good for the
world not good for the companies so if
you were an ESG investor and didn't own
oil and gas well that was a benefit to
your performance but the last two years
by Far and Away the best performing
sector has been oil and gas so ESG funds
that weren't investing in oil and gas
companies have all underperformed the
average or the metrics and that's
hurting their business but today oil and
gas companies still trade at much lower
multiples on earnings multiples on cash
flow
um than all the other sectors so yeah
it's it's priced as if we're about to go
out of business but I think the odds of
us going out of business soon are pretty
low it sounds like I should run home and
tell my husband that we should invest
how does one do that is there like
public funds yeah I mean like I invest
only in individual companies but I know
them all but yeah they're they're
absolutely are uh index funds simple
ways to do it well I think this is I was
going to mention right the vet did start
one's called drill so the ticker's
d-r-l-l oh God I'm happy to give him a
shout out because his stuff is so good
yeah but Beck is right on and he's bold
and he's outspoken and drill is
fantastic because it is just a index of
all the large companies in the oil and
gas business with no no ESG no pleading
with those companies to get out of oil
and gas business but to celebrate what
they do and support them so that's
probably the single best way it's the
only fun I I buy individual stocks I own
shares and drill and I I'd recommend it
it's probably the best way if you want
exposure to the oil and gas sector oh
very cool Final note it's Earth Day
coming up this week yes yes indeed and I
know both you and I are conservatives
who love the Earth and so any final
words my wife and I are my mountain
climbers skiers outdoor passion I'm a
long time board member of a fantastic
free market Environmental Group called
perk so I celebrate making the earth a
better cleaner more more fabulous place
to live our lives in and I I would
recommend people look into the role that
hydrocarbons have played there I show in
in bettering human lives a picture of
the island of Hispanola you it's you can
see the border between North and South
Korea at night you can see the border
between Haiti and the Dominican Republic
during the day because Dominican
Republic is a wealthier country it's
almost all of its energy from oil and
natural gas it's got Lush rainforests
and a thriving tourist industry Haiti
right across the border still gets the
majority of its energy for more natural
gas but it's got enough people living in
the country that don't have enough
wealth that they still get energy the
way all of our ancestors did which is to
cut down trees and burn them for a fuel
source so I think my title over it is
energy access is green and the arrival
of fossil fuels making agriculture more
efficient has shrunk the amount of
Farmland we need to produce a certain
amount of food and in the U.S until the
ethanol mandates we were returning
enormous amounts of land back to
Grasslands and forests because of
efficiencies brought about by fossil
fuels do we have negative impacts sure
we do but we have positive impacts as
well and I think if you look at them and
balance the positives are much bigger
than the negatives happy Earth Day happy
Earth Day Chris and for those of you
watching if you want to get educated as
I have I really want to encourage you to
read these books you have Michael
schellenberger Stephen coonan and Alex
Epstein and if you don't have the time
to read the books we have five-minute
videos by all of these presenters great
thoughtful reads full of data by people
not in the oil and gas industry like me
in fact from very different yeah that I
am but uh but looking at the same data
and with the same human first mentality
of course you'll come to a a similar
perspective but told very differently
excellent books I recommend all the
Watchers awesome oh and also Bjorn
lomberg Bruno's latest book false alarm
from a few years ago is basically the
simplest way you don't want to read the
two three four thousand page ipcc
reports Bjorn lomborg summarizes what's
in those reports
um in a very digestible way great videos
as well and he's not a climate change
denier none of the ad hominem attacks
that people put on us it was a green
peace member and University professor at
arhus University in Denmark when he
jumped into this movement so a lover of
the environment driven by it and and
didn't get the role of fossil fuels
until he dove into the facts but a
brilliant guy and a great writer I
recommend that book as well right now
happy Earth Day happy Earth Day