Memory Improvement: Say No to These Medications

Health Everyday
15 followers
Well, hello everyone. I'm Dr. Leslie Kernison, board-certified geriatrician and the founder
of BetterHealthWhileAging.net. In this video, I'm going to talk about one of the top things
that I address in my practice to help my older patients live better, especially if they've had
any concerns about memory loss or brain health. And that is the four types of brain slowing
medication to avoid if you've been worried about memory or brain health. This is something that is
foundational in geriatrics, checking for what we call the Beers criteria medications, which means
medications that are known to be drugs that older adults should avoid or use with caution. So this
is a list. It's a pretty long list of medications that geriatricians have been maintaining for over
20 years. And so in the practice of geriatrics, we especially look for medications that might be
affecting an older person's thinking. And why is this? Well, it's because thinking abilities are
so important in later life to help older adults maintain independence and quality of life. Also,
the same medications that affect memory and thinking also tend to affect balance and worse
than falls. And that's another issue that we're very concerned about in geriatrics.
And then these medications that slow down the brain and affect thinking are especially important
to identify if you or if someone you care about has a diagnosis of something like mild cognitive
impairment, Alzheimer's, or another form of dementia. Now, if you're not quite sure what it
means to have mild cognitive impairment, or how it gets diagnosed, or how to know if it's mild
cognitive impairment or Alzheimer's, I have a video that is just about that. And you can watch that
next. Let me now get back to the four types of medication that I look for because they are
especially likely to affect memory and brain function in older adults. So I'm going to go
through them. I think you should know about these and you should know to ask questions if your doctor
is recommending these to you. So the first type is a class of medications that is called benzodiazepines
or we often say benzos for short. Benzos are a type of sedative tranquilizer and commonly
prescribed benzos include lorazepam, diazepam, temazepam, alprazolam, and clonazepam. And the
brand names for these are Ativan, Valium, Restoril, Xanax, and Klonopin respectively. So benzos are
most often prescribed either to help a person manage anxiety or for sleep. In much older patients
such as the ones that I tend to see in person, they are also often prescribed to manage agitation or
difficult behaviors in Alzheimer's disease or other forms of dementia. But it's important for you to
know that they are not FDA approved for this indication. So what are the risks of benzos?
Well it turns out that benzos work actually quite well in the short term for anxiety and insomnia.
That's why they have been relatively popular with patients and with providers. They give people
really pretty quickly that ah I feel more relaxed feeling which can help with anxiety or can help
people get to sleep. Benzos actually work in the brain on the same receptors as do alcohol. The
thing is as people get older the side effects of benzodiazepines become more and more significant.
So first of all benzos are slowing the brain. They are also slowing the brain of people who are in
their 20s and 40s but it's less important when people are younger. Whereas when people are older
this brain slowing can cause a noticeable decline in memory function or in other thinking functions.
Benzos are also habit forming. So people quite easily can become physically dependent on them
especially if they use them every day or quite often. And this is both a, there can be a
psychological dependence as in people feel like they can't handle the situation without the benzo
but there's also a very real physical dependence and adaptation to the medication. So what this
means is first of all some people do develop an addiction to benzodiazepines or start to use them
in an unhealthy way. You know basically a form of substance abuse and we see this more often in
people who have already tended to abuse other substances like alcohol or other kinds of
prescription medications. So that can really be a concern if people are using benzos but even if
they don't get addicted in an unhealthy way the body becomes dependent on it in a significant way.
Another problem with benzos is that they have been associated with later on developing dementia in
life. There is still research going on about this. The association is not 100% clear but
I think that's concerning and another reason to avoid using them if possible. And what benzos will
definitely do is make confusion, memory loss, or other symptoms of dementia worse in people who
clearly already have developed brain changes. Benzos also do increase falls and worsen balance. So
these are some of the reasons that geriatricians love to hate benzos. This is why we almost never
start them on our own patients and this is why we try to help our older patients get off them if
it is at all possible. So let me say a few words now about discontinuing benzodiazepines. So in
general you always want to be careful before stopping a medication cold turkey but it's more
important for some medications than others and for benzos it's actually really really really
important to not stop them cold turkey if a person has been taking them every day or quite often. It
can be very dangerous. So again benzos work on the same receptors as with alcohol and so just as
we don't want to take a heavy drinker and have them quit cold turkey they can have life-threatening
withdrawal. The same thing applies to benzodiazepines. So if we are trying to stop benzos we always want
to taper them slowly and under medical supervision. Now some people who have been on benzos will say
well I tried to stop and it didn't work. Tapering benzos can and does work. This has actually been
studied in clinical trials that were developed by geriatricians to help people get off these
dangerous medications. So I have a related link about these four types of medications on my
website and if you visit that page over there I have a link to a special handout that was clinically
tested. They would actually give this handout to older adults at the pharmacy when they came to
pick up their benzodiazepines and the handout would inform them of the risks of benzodiazepines
other ways to manage anxiety or insomnia and it provided them with a tapering schedule that they
could show to their doctor and kind of work from there. And many older adults were successfully
tapered from their benzos with this method so it definitely is possible. That said there is one
situation where I found that it is quite difficult to get people off of benzodiazepines and that is
when the older person actually has developed ongoing memory loss or has been diagnosed with
a condition like Alzheimer's or dementia. So in that case the thing about tapering benzos is that
the older person usually has to experience at least temporarily a little bit of an increase
in sleep difficulties or in anxiety as the body adjusts to making do without this medication.
And when people have developed Alzheimer's or dementia they usually have very very little
tolerance for that discomfort. Their memory gets a lot worse when they're uncomfortable or they get
very agitated or it becomes really really hard for their family to take care of them.
So we still often try to lower the dose but I gotta tell you it's hard. Ideally we don't want
to wait until somebody is frankly having real memory problems before we stop the benzodiazepines
and we will still try to reduce them at that point. It just is much much harder to do it
than if we attempt it earlier in their life. Now before I go on to the other types of medications
that I recommend stopping just a few words about alternatives to benzodiazepines because I don't
like to tell people to stop a medication without offering a few other ways that they might manage
their symptoms. So first of all anxiety. Anxiety is really common right now in the United States
in people of all age groups and there are other ways to manage anxiety. So first of all there are
other prescription medications that have been clinically shown to be effective for anxiety and
they don't slow the brain down as much. So in particular medications in the class of selective
serotonin reuptake inhibitors, that's a mouthful, SSRIs as we say in medicine are effective for
anxiety. So in geriatrics we especially like escitalopram and sertraline. The brand names for
those are Lexapro and Zoloft. Another popular SSRI that you may have heard of is Prozac. That was the
first one that made a big hit in the 90s. Prozac interacts with a lot more medications than Lexapro
and Zoloft that's why we use it less. So those medications do work for anxiety. They don't work
within hours in the same way but they can be effective when people take them in an ongoing way
and then there are many non-drug therapies that are very effective for anxiety. Certain forms of
cognitive behavioral therapy or other forms of psychotherapy. So there are options other than
benzos to manage anxiety. As for insomnia this is another condition where non-medication approaches
can and do work and they are much safer. Also if you are trying to treat insomnia I highly recommend
first making sure that you have had a thorough evaluation for what might be causing the sleep
problem because sometimes it can be another health condition that needs treatment such as sleep apnea.
Do we ever use medication to treat insomnia or sleep difficulties in geriatrics? Yes we do
after we've tried lots of other things. People sometimes ask is there an easy safe fast option
to help an older person sleep. Not really. There are some medications though that we would try,
not benzos, if we are working on that and those are also mentioned in articles that I have on my
site. All right let me now move on to the next type of medication that I'm looking out for that I
consider a brain slowing medication that is worth avoiding and that would be non-benzodiazepine
prescription sedatives. These are medications that in medicine, the most commonly prescribed ones
right now because we no longer prescribe barbiturates and some of the other non-benzo
sedatives that used to exist. The most common ones right now are what we refer to as Z drugs
because all the generic ones start with a Z and the best known one is zolpidem brand name Ambien
and then there are a few others the brand names are Sonata and Lunesta that are also sometimes
prescribed. So these are fairly popular because lots of people do have sleep problems but we try
to avoid them in geriatrics because they again slow down the brain and they have been shown in
clinical studies to impair thinking and balance in older adults the next day. Now do they also
increase the risk of developing something like Alzheimer's disease over time or if you use them
for years and years? We don't really know. The research on that is kind of you know a little bit
unclear right now because we actually know that if people are developing Alzheimer's or other forms
of dementia, the brain changes start 10 to 15 years before and those can in of themselves interfere
with sleep. So that does not mean that if you are having sleep difficulties you should panic and
worry that you're in the early stages of Alzheimer's. That's not very useful to think about. This is just
to say that this is part of why the research has been a little bit hard to sort out on this
question. But these medications definitely will affect balance and thinking in older adults and
again especially if a person is already struggling with memory or thinking or is a lot older, slowing
down the brain further is a bad idea. So that's another type of medication that I look out for
and try to discontinue whenever possible. Now for the third type of medication that I'd like to look
out for. This is a group called anticholinergics. This is a very big group of medications actually.
It's a very common medication property and there are drugs in several different classes that fall
into this. This group covers most of the over-the-counter sleeping aids that you might find
at the drugstore and antihistamines such as Benadryl along with many other commonly used
prescription drugs. And what these medications all have in common is the chemical property of blocking
the neurotransmitter acetylcholine. So this is a neurotransmitter that first of all your body
definitely needs it for your brain cells to communicate with each other and your body also
uses it elsewhere in the body for certain types of neurons to communicate with each other. And
acetylcholine is so important to thinking that actually when they want to develop a medication
for Alzheimer's, the medication they developed, Donepezil, brand name Aricept, is actually
designed to boost levels of acetylcholine in the brain. So when people take anticholinergics,
they're taking a medication that is the opposite of what we give people to help their brain function
if they have been diagnosed with dementia. So now which medications are anticholinergic? There are
actually so many of them that I have a video that covers seven common types that are very easy to
encounter either in the drugstore or easy to be prescribed to. So if you want to learn more,
I highly recommend that video. But briefly, the medications to look out for are sedating
antihistamines like Benadryl, PM versions of over-the-counter painkillers because they add
something like Benadryl to it to make you sleepy, medications for overactive bladder for vertigo
or motion sickness or nausea, oral medications for itching, muscle relaxants, and also an older
type of antidepressant that is now usually used for nerve pain or to treat shingles pain.
The antidepressant Paxil, which is an SSRI, is also anticholinergic. And that's interesting
because the other medications in the SSRI group are generally much not very anticholinergic. So
that's a reason why you will almost never see a geriatrician prescribed Paxil. So again, if you
want to access a longer list of anticholinergics, please see the other video and my related article
on better health while aging. But in general, a little tip is that you can often recognize
anticholinergics because they have very typical anticholinergic side effects. They tend to cause
dry eye, dry mouth, constipation, and drowsiness. So if you're on a medication that along with
its intended effect is giving you dry mouth, chances are good that that is an anticholinergic
medication. Okay, and let me now go through the fourth type of medication that I often look out
for and try to stop if possible. And that is antipsychotics and mood stabilizers. So these
are medications that were originally developed to treat serious mental illnesses such as
schizophrenia and bipolar disorder. And they still have a very important role in the treatment of
those illnesses. Now, some of the mood stabilizers were originally developed to treat seizures and
they might be used for that purpose as well. The thing is, among older adults, I see these
medications quite often prescribed to manage difficult behaviors related to Alzheimer's
disease and other dementias. So they might be prescribed for somebody who is having hallucinations
or delusions or just extreme paranoia. Or often they're prescribed to people who are, quote,
agitated, which means they get revved up, they get upset, they're uncooperative, or they're making
life difficult for other people. So this might be an older person who gets upset when caregivers
come to them and try to help them change their clothes or bathe or, you know, isn't cooperative
with instructions. So here again, it's really important to know that antipsychotics are not FDA
approved for this purpose. In fact, there is a black box warning on them for using them for
people with dementia because the research found that when we give these medications to people
with dementia, they have a higher chance of dying within the next 6 to 12 months. So the most
commonly prescribed antipsychotics these days are what's known as second generation, and they
include medications such as risperidone, catiopine, olanzapine, and eripraprazole. And the brand names
for those respectively are Risperdal, Seroquel, Zyprexa, and Abilify. There's also a first
generation antipsychotic that is still used fairly often because it's cheap and pretty effective,
and that is haloperidol, brand name Haldol. And then the mood stabilizer that I see often
prescribed to some older adults is valproate. The brand name for that is Depakote. So again,
the risks to older people when we use these drugs. So they definitely slow down the brain
and thinking. So when we are using them for behaviors, it is essentially a chemical restraint
for agitation. And if you are trying to manage, you know, a very psychosis-like symptom like
hallucinations, they can help with that, but it's at the cost of otherwise slowing down the person's
brain and thinking and other cognitive abilities. They also definitely affect balance and can cause
falls. And then again, the antipsychotics do increase the risk of dying within the next 6
to 12 months. And the research shows that the absolute increase in mortality risk is somewhere
between 2% and 4%. So what would be some alternatives to using antipsychotics and
mood stabilizers? Well, so again, this is especially if they're being considered for
difficult Alzheimer's behaviors or agitation. If we are talking about a person who has, you know,
a history of schizophrenia or bipolar, that is another story. But if it's for managing agitation
or difficult behaviors, we always, always, always want to start off by trying other things
to manage the behavior. So in people with dementia, agitation often represents an unmet need. And so
it's important to explore and figure out what is that need? Is the person bored? Are they scared?
Do they need reassurance? Do they need attention? Do they need some stimulation? Are they in pain?
There are many ways that we can explore what is driving the behavior and then usually it's
possible to manage it without medication. So when it comes to difficult dementia behaviors,
medication should really only be used as a last resort after other approaches have been tried
and the smallest effective dose should be used. And if you would like to learn more about managing
dementia behaviors with less medication, I definitely have articles about that on my website,
Better Health While Aging. So those are the four kinds of brain slowing medication that are worth
avoiding or minimizing, especially if you have any memory concerns or want to optimize an older
person's memory. So again, they were benzodiazepines, non-benzodiazepine prescription sedatives,
so medications like Ambien, anticholinergics, and then antipsychotics and mood stabilizers.
Now, what should you do if you have been taking these medications? So first and foremost, please
don't panic. Don't panic. Don't panic. It's okay. But I do want to encourage you to bring it up to
your health provider. So because again, this is a risky medication for older adults. Now,
this doesn't mean that these kind of medications can't ever be used or that it's always wrong
to prescribe these medications. But ideally, if a medication is risky, we want to only use it as a
last resort when safer options have been tried and have failed. And if we're going to use a risky
medication, we want to use it at the lowest dose possible. If you're taking one of these medications,
especially if you have not yet tried alternative ways to manage your symptoms, it's really
important to ask your health provider for help. Now, I'm going to tell you right now the problems
that many of you will run into because I work a lot with families and I hear what happens when
I talk to doctors. The problem you're going to run into is that you might encounter a little bit
of resistance from your provider. And there are a couple reasons for this. First of all, your doctor
is likely very busy. This is not their fault. This is partly that we have a terrible setup for
especially outpatient care, where doctors are given very little time with patients. Your doctor
also may not be aware that these medications are all that risky or discontinuing because they may
not have had enough training in geriatrics. And lastly, for a doctor to revisit a medication that
they've been prescribing takes time and effort. It's not the path of least resistance for them
to try to get you off these medications. And it's also often more work for them to try to find,
help you get access to these non-drug approaches, you know, like the right kind of therapy for,
you know, anxiety or the right kind of assistance to help with sleep problems. In medicine, especially
in American medicine, where we give doctors very little time, by far the easiest thing is to
prescribe a pill. So you just should be aware that this is definitely worth bringing up and it's going
to work better if you come in prepared to politely advocate for yourself. So for instance, here are
some things that you could consider saying. You could consider letting your doctor know that it's
a value for you to be on as few medications as possible. Save you money and it's safer as you
get older. So you could say something like, you know, I've thought about it and I've realized that
I would like to be on as few medications as possible. You could also say something like,
I've also been trying to educate myself and I recently learned that certain drugs are on a
beers list of medications older adults should avoid. Apparently this medication I'm on is on
the beers list. So I'd like to discuss why I'm on it, what are alternatives to be on it, and how we
can get me off of it. That would be something that you could try and hopefully your providers will be
receptive. You can also potentially talk to a pharmacist for help as well as they are also very
knowledgeable about medications and most of them are familiar with the beers criteria. Now what
should you do if a provider wants to start you on one of these medications or maybe they want to
start your loved one who has dementia on one of these medications? I would encourage you to ask
to try an alternative treatment first. First of all, ask are there any non-drug approaches that
can help me with this problem? Because often there are, especially when it comes to things
like anxiety and insomnia or many of the conditions for which doctors prescribe anticholinergics. A lot
of those have non-drug options as well. And if a drug is necessary, is there one that's not on the
beers list that we could start with? If you have to start one of these medications, aim to be on
the lowest necessary dose and then pay attention to what is the symptom that is, you know, being
treated and don't stay on the medication if it's not helping with the symptom. Some of these
medications are very effective for certain symptoms and others are actually not, you know,
in clinical trials. They haven't been found to be that much more effective than doing nothing
or doing a non-drug option. So if it's not helping a lot, what is the point of staying on a risky
medication? So with that, I'm going to wrap up this video. I hope this has been useful. For more
details regarding what I covered in this video, please see my related article on better health
while aging. You can also subscribe to my channel as I plan to be sharing more videos soon about
aging health and how to help older adults have the best quality of life and well-being possible.
Take care, thank you for watching, and hope to see you again soon!
