2025 Regular Session - Sine Die - HB 622 FCCR Debate

Kentucky House GOP
24 followers
1 Video View·Mar 29, 2025
(The entire thing, except for a small cut due to a broadcast interruption.)
mr Speaker I move you sir that House
Bill
622 with conference committee and free
conference committee be taken from its
place in the orders today for
consideration of those conference
committee reports Without objection so
order Mr Clerk please report
Senate Bill 622 an act relating to
government contracts and declaring an
emergency Representative McFersonen
Gentleman from McGregor Mr Speaker would
you have the clerk report the conference
committee report to House Bill 622 mr
Clerk please report The conference
committee on House Bill 622 has met as
provided in the rules of the House and
Senate and hereby reports they cannot
agree Gentleman from McCracken move
adoption Motion made for the adoption of
conference committee report one All
those in favor please signify by saying
I I All oppose nay Motion carries
The report is adopted Gentleman from
McCracken Mr Speaker would you have the
clerk report the free conference
committee report to House Bill 622 mr
Clerk please report free conference
committee report to House one to House
Bill 622 Gentleman from McCracken Mr
Speaker I
move that we do adopt the free
conference committee report to House
Bill 622 Motion made for the adoption of
the free conference committee report one
Is there any discussion chair recognizes
a lady from Jefferson 32
Yes sir May I ask a question he will
yield Okay So on the bottom of page one
of the free conference report it states
"Once each local district has staffed
and continues to maintain one school
resource officer for each campus in that
district the local district is then
eligible to apply for reimbursement for
additional assistance So does this mean
that you know a lot of our schools are
struggling to hire SRO's does this mean
that if they can't fill the positions in
all of their buildings they're not
eligible for reimbursements or is this
above and beyond what they get to try to
fill the buildings they already have
gentleman from McGra
Uh as I understand it and the gentleman
from Todd will back me up on this but uh
if if I get something wrong but we set
aside money to pay for SRO's in the last
budget This is the mechanism to allow
schools to apply for those We are saying
before you can apply for a second SRO in
an individual building you first have to
make sure that there's one in every
campus of your school district Lady from
Jefferson Thank you for the
clarification
Chair recognizes a lady from Jefferson
35
Thank you Mr Speaker Uh will the
gentleman yield to a question he will
yield So I actually have a along similar
lines as the lady from Jefferson 32 It
looks like there's a provision in here
to require KDE to pay non-public schools
up to
$20,000 per SRO and given amendment two
last year and no public dollars to
private schools and uh that's what our
constitution says How is this
constitutional
gentleman from McGra Mr Speaker law
enforcement is called on private
property or public property whenever
there's a disruptance Uh we think the
children in public uh and private
schools should both be safe and uh if
right now if they were they would could
call 911 and the police would show up
for a private school as well It is not
unheard of It is not unprecedented and
we do not think that is unconstitutional
uh for various reasons School
transportation has been treated this way
for several years uh longer than any of
us have been here except for maybe of
course the gentleman from Webster Uh
that deals with allowing for
transporting private school students Uh
we also have CAP and KTG which are
scholarship programs that are allowed uh
taxpayer dollars to be used in
post-secary education as well as key
scholarships that uh that they're also
eligible to be used in private
institutions We think it's about a
matter of public safety Uh we think that
it would be treated more like a grant
for these schools and not just funding
uh for them and we just feel like that
we want to ensure the safety of all
children not just those that are
enrolled in public schools
chairs
that was very helpful Would the
gentleman yield to another question he
will yield
Um first of all I mean of course
everyone in here wants all kids to be
safe regardless of where they go to
school I just want to put that on the
record I'm confident that all 100 of us
feel that way Um I'm curious since I
know many schools have had a hard time
hiring um SRO's there just not people
available to take these positions And
would a a private school be able to have
an SRO and get funding from KDE
uh before the local
uh public schools have been able to
staff their positions
gentleman from McGregor I would yield to
the gentleman from Todd chair recognized
gentleman from Todd If I understood the
question correctly there shouldn't be an
issue These are two different funding
sources Uh we have general fund dollars
that are being dealt with with the
public schools It's an NGE set up out of
the budget reserve or the general fund
surplus that's actually um taking care
of the private security issues shouldn't
run into each other Laden Jefferson
again very helpful Thank you Uh may I
speak on the bill yes ma'am Thank you I
just want to really focus on this SRO
piece that the gentleman did a great job
of answering my specific questions Um I
do want to say in terms of school safety
and keeping kids safe uh in their
schools uh research has shown so clearly
that what helps is to have adequate
wraparound services to have strong
mental health uh presence in the schools
and we have funded that um consistently
for the past several years uh ever since
the um passage of the school safety and
resiliency act But that amount has been
held pretty steady at $7.4
million for all 171 public school
systems So $7.4 million Um and that's
actually been much more highly
correlated with student safety than
bringing police officers into schools Um
and while I understand this I understand
the sentiments behind this I would
really love to see us put that
additional money for private school
SRO's toward more wraparound services
more mental health supports in our
public schools Um so thank you very much
Chair recognizes a lady from FET 93
Uh thank you Mr Speaker
Um may I have to speak on the bill yes
ma'am Thank you
On its face this bill originally the the
original purpose of this bill is
fantastic and um 100% support everything
um in this in HB 622 that supports
Kentucky nonprofits Um we need to make
sure that this mechanism
um that that nonprofits receive their
payments on time My issue is is it is a
hard it is difficult to swallow the
addition to this bill that was added in
the free conference committee
Um Kuckians spoke
overwhelmingly last year we defeated HB2
More than 70% of Kuckians were opposed
to using public funds for private
schools
And I I'm sure the headlines will be
like Democrats don't want to support
don't want to keep kids in private
schools safe That's not true That is
completely not true Um but what we can't
do is then go back to the public saying
"You sent us a clear message but we're
going to ignore what you're going to do
what you wanted us to do and we're going
to do it anyway." Taking this money from
the rainy day fund is is not the way
that we should be doing business But we
do have other ways that we can protect
kids Um we can do common sense gun
safety We can um do more as my colleague
from Jefferson said do more wraparound
services Make sure that we are providing
the services that kids need to keep them
safe But one of one of the other
concerns is we have five districts in
the state that don't have an
SRO They're small and most of them are
independent
the data that we the data that we get on
um SRO's in school is self-reported Um
and what what the data shows is that
there there are 82 schools public
schools right now that don't have an SRO
Um a lot of districts have SRO's but
they've got more schools um than they
have SRO's And one example is um Carter
County next to the county where I grew
up They've got nine schools but only two
and a half SRO's
So my concern is that we aren't doing
what we need to do to make sure that the
public schools have what they need but
instead this bill seeks to then add
funding take funding away from private
schools without accountability without
knowing for sure that we have taken
we've done our due diligence for the for
the public schools So I just I have a
lot of concerns about this I wanted so
badly to support this bill but with with
what I'm seeing in the from the free
conference committee I I I can't believe
I'm going to have to probably be a no on
this So thank you Mr Speaker Gentleman
from Ken Mr Speaker I do wish to clarify
just a few more things on this topic
Uh first
off there should be no schools after
this money goes through no public
schools that don't have the resources
now to apply for an SRO there's plenty
of money here to cover all the campuses
in the state So that that's not that's
been taken care of should have been
taken care of last year uh when the
money was originally appropriated This
is just clarifying how that all works
out Secondly the money is not going to
the private
schools for police and SRO's It will go
to the departments and we quite often
give money to individual police
departments uh across the state uh in
the forms of grants and other things So
this money will not be handed directly
to private schools It will be handed to
the departments where they have all
kinds of accountability in local law
enforcement I also want to point out one
other provision and we think this is is
very important We're dealing with a
situation right now where in the same
county and the same city some of these
school districts are contracting with
priv uh with public law enforcement and
they're charging different rates to the
private schools than they are to the
public schools We just clearly state in
this that whatever rate you charge the
private school whatever rate you charge
the public schools it must be the same
and it should be the lower of the two
You shouldn't we shouldn't differentiate
on those kids based on where where they
go to school It should be the same rate
for protecting but the money goes
directly to the departments in the
NGE This other money is set aside There
should be plenty enough money to cover
all the school campuses SRO's in the
state uh that as they apply for it So I
don't really think I think that much of
this concern we can redate a
constitutional amendment last This is
nothing to do with private schools but
this is about safety of all kids And uh
look I I think it's very important
Former Representative Brer used to stand
here and he's like "We we we need SRO's
in the building We need SRO's in the
building." And we always say as funding
becomes available as funding becomes
available now funding is available So
they should be covered There should be
plenty for the schools to be able to
have SRO's in every one of the schools
Lady F do you have additional
comments may proceed Thank you And I
appreciate that information Um I do want
to say that I agree that if if a an
agency is charging different amounts
that there should be parity in what is
being charged but I I disagree in the
sense that it is still taxpayers that
fund that that put the money into the
rainy day fund And so that is my concern
Um I agree with public safety There are
so many things that we can do and every
child in every school setting should be
safe I I could not agree with you more
on that I'm not sure that this is the
bill This is the way to do it because
the intention of this bill originally
was to make sure that we are doing what
our nonprofits needed us to do So thank
you Chair recognizes gentleman from
Campbell 67
Thank you Mr Speaker May I ask um the
gentleman from McCracken a question we
you I do not Gentlemen from Campbell Um
I mean because part of my I look I was
trying to do a Google search I got
answers from 200 to 400 You know if it's
200 I guess $5 million would be enough
Um I I guess can I ask a follow-up
question please hey you Yeah I just was
are are we sure that $5
million of a cap is sufficient to cover
what what what we're trying to do here
gentleman from Craig We are not certain
that that will be enough but that will
be what uh will be eligible to be
applied for Uh and I will remind
everybody that we will be back here or
in the parking lot across the way in
just a few short months Gentleman from
Campbell Um thank you May May I ask just
one more question you um thank you I I
actually have a question on a different
topic on section 8 um of this the free
conference committee report It deletes
section 21 of a bill we recently passed
on uh House Bill
695 I I just was curious is this was
this to resolve an issue that was raised
in the governor's veto message to this
bill originally
gentleman from McCra This deal with the
rebid portion of House Bill 695 uh which
was one of the reasons the governor
cited for one of the many reasons the
governor cited for uh vetoing 695 Uh
upon further review and conversations
that uh the people involved with
drafting this section and that section
of that bill they thought that rebidding
right now was not the best time Uh and
so we we feel like that we have gone
back to revisit that and we will not
require a rebid
Gentleman from Camel That's it Thank
you Chair recognizes a lady from Fiat 75
Thank you Mr Speaker Will the gentleman
please yield to a question he will yield
I
am trying to
compare and maybe it's apples and
oranges here but I'm looking at um page
one the bottom section 16A which is
about the public schools and then
section B on the following page about
private schools My question is are they
applying the same
standard for payment or do the public
schools have a different procedure they
have to follow
is the procedure different for public
and private schools I guess is my
question Gentleman from McGrack
You go to the gentleman from Todd Chair
recognized gentleman from Todd There is
no separate procedure that's set up It's
for KDE to develop a way to administer
both of these and it would be consistent
with the way that we have set up for
school grant programs reimbursements
Lady Lady Fet Thank you I appreciate
that Um in considering this I just
really wanted to make certain that we
wouldn't be treating those two schools
differently if we were choosing to spend
our money in this way Thank you
Chair recognizes a lady from Jefferson
34
Thank you Mr Speaker I'd like to speak
on the bill please Yes ma'am Thank you
so much Um House Bill 622 is a bill that
I was a co-sponsor on I was on this bill
last year and was sad to see that we
couldn't get across the finish line then
Um it was a a cleaner stronger bill then
Um but this is the situation that we are
in today Um I am not a fan of making
changes at the last minute and popping
um pieces of legislation in that don't
uh correlate with the initial bill to
begin with I understand it was done in a
free com or in a conference committee
and that's the point of it Um but I I
just find this point in the session to
be problematic Um that being said I am
I'm not comfortable with the things that
have been added but I will most likely
continue to be in support of this bill
But I will say
this I expect to see legislation in 2026
from this general assembly to invest in
proactive legislation that addresses the
root causes of why kids and
adults are bringing guns into schools
and taking the lives of teachers and
students We've got to be able to walk
and chew gum at the same time So if you
want to pay for metal detectors you want
to pay for SRO's before we're doing that
we need to make sure that we have mental
health professionals in every school We
need to make sure that children are fed
breakfast and lunch We need to make sure
that there is summer programming at our
schools available for students who need
that additional support We need to make
sure that people have stable and safe
housing We need to make sure that people
have access to health We need a whole
lot of everything And if we are willing
to put our energy behind those things I
am confident that we will start to see a
lot less issues at our schools because
what schools have always been in my
opinion and I have said this for years
we hold our schools hostage for what are
social social service problems outside
of the schools We expect our schools to
be everything to our kids and we have to
be willing to step up and step in and
give our schools the the legislation and
the funding with it because if we're not
willing to allocate the dollars towards
it then it's completely
performative These are the things that
we need to do to keep our kids safe and
to keep our teachers and our other staff
at schools safe SRO's are that is being
reactive I want to see this body take
proactive measures to address the root
causes Thank you Chair recognizes lady
from pay 76
Thank you M Thank you Mr Speaker Would
the sponsor yield to a question he will
yield All right Thank you And forgive my
ignorance here You you answered a
question earlier about the money the
public funds not going directly to the
school districts You said that it goes
to the department Which department
gentleman McCracken
The law enforcement department offering
the protection services Okay Lady Fette
Thank you Would you yield to another
question he will yield Thank
you Doesn't the legislature control how
these departments spend the money
gentleman from McCracken No Lady from
Pay It
Um may I speak to the bill please yes
ma'am Thank you
Um I feel like we've had a lot of
conversations over the last few weeks
and months that the legislature does
control how we spend money So I'm a
little confused by that
Um the gentle from gentleman from
McCracken rightfully said that we are
all eligible for law enforcement Um
which of course we are Um I I'm one of
the probably few members in this body
who has a child in public school and a
child in private school Um I want both
of them to be safe of course
Um what I don't want is for the cost of
keeping private school children safe to
come at the detriment of the overall
public good Um I I have major concerns
about taking money out of our rainy day
fund or our budget reserve trust fund
that is there for rainy days and to make
strategic investment in our in our
commonwealth to benefit the public or
the private schools that our voters have
already said they don't want to
fund I like my colleague from Jefferson
I was I am still a co-sponsor on this
bill um because I support and love our
nonprofit community And what this bill
originally aimed to do was to correct
errors to make sure that our nonprofit
partners were getting paid on time for
the work that they had contracted to do
for our government
So to then come in and say that we're
going to use public
dollars for the benefit of a select few
in private school I I have a problem
with that And I feel like right now like
I'm I'm being asked to choose
between safety and nonprofits who are
doing great work And that's that's a
really difficult spot So I I will be
withdrawing my sponsorship of
this bill and I'm not sure how I'm going
to end up voting but I have a whole lot
of questions about how this was done um
and how we end up putting two very
disperate things together into one bill
on the last day So thank you
Chair recognizes a lady from Jefferson
40
Thank you speaker Will the gentleman
yield to a question he will yield Thank
you Um and I appreciate all of this the
discussion and the answers that have
been provided so far I'm just trying to
wrap my head around the mechanics of
this So gentlemen you mentioned that the
funding would go not to the school
districts but to the departments the law
enforcement departments Is that correct
gentleman from McCracken Yes We yield to
a follow-up question Hey we yield Can
you speak a little bit to the timing of
this allocation for instance is the
funding allocated before so they can
budget for it or is it based on an
identified hire for instance gentleman
from McCracken So it's $5 million in
each fiscal year Keeping in mind as we
worry about wasting all the rainy day
fund or the budget reserve trust fund
There's currently after all
this still three and a half billion
dollars in the budget reserve trust fund
Healthiest one in the country Thanks to
the gentleman from Todd's
leadership this is five million Now
that's a lot of money $5 million would
change any of our
lives but it's not going to change the
budget reserve trust fund It's kind of
like when few years ago when I was ANR
chair the budget state budget director
called me and said "We're going to be
$250 million short." And I'm like "Oh no
What am I going to do?" He's like
"Nothing We got pretty close to the
estimate Less than 1% You don't have to
do anything." thing and I'm like well I
just argued with a man about $4 being
too much for six tomato plants Uh it
it's all about perspective like that So
no but this sets up a mechanism to
answer your question It sets up a
mechanism where KDE will come up with a
way to set up the regulations to be able
to divvy out this money that can be
applied for for individual police
departments that no we do not manage the
day-to-day budgets of They get that's
done with either city taxes or county
taxes Thank you Jefferson may I ask a
follow-up question you Thank you
gentlemen for that explanation Do you
know and please bear with me if you've
already answered this um in some way Do
you know what the impact on KDE will be
if any since we're sort of allocating
this money to them is there any
additional financial burden to KDE u for
providing this funding for non-public
schools gentleman from McCracken I
couldn't imagine it would be very much
at all The lady from Jefferson Thank you
Will you follow up can I ask him another
question he um thank you gentlemen but
do we have any kind of a ballpark
estimate of not that much gentleman from
Craig
I I don't know the specifics but I the
chairman from Todd may be able to shed
some more light on this I would yield to
the gentleman from Todd Chair recognizes
gentleman from Todd Thank you for the
question Based upon other uh similarly
situated functions of KDE relative to
programs that already exist in
expansions thereof I would anticipate
this to be nominal of a 100,000 or
200,000 just for bookkeeping purposes
which I think is extraordinarily high
but those are numbers we hear back at
times There is more than enough in their
current budget to absorb that plus many
times over
Lady from Jefferson Thank you gentlemen
Thank you Speaker
All those in favor of the adoption of
free conference committee report one
signify by saying I All oppose Nay
Motion carries Free conference committee
report one is adopted Gentleman from
McCracken
Mr Speaker I move final passage of House
Bill 622 as amended by the free
conference committee report
Motion made second for the passage of
House Bill 622 as amended by the free
conference committee report Is there any
discussion
seeing none Mr Clerk Sand Chimes now
proceed to vote All those in favor
please signify by voting yay on the roll
call machine Those opposed nay And the
roll call machine is open for your
voting Have all members
voted would any member like to change or
explain their vote chair recognizes lady
from Jefferson 41 for explanation of
vote not to exceed two minutes Thank you
Mr Speaker I voted no on this bill for
several reasons but the first being that
in November Kentucky voters voted
overwhelmingly that they did not want
taxpayer dollars that should be going to
public schools going to private schools
in any way shape or
form Number two it's a free conference
committee report that we just received
So since I have had some experience in
this
house I understand that there could be
four or five bills in there and who
knows what's in there So we have no idea
what we're voting on And number three
there is no fiscal note attached to this
and we don't know how many private
schools as as the sponsor said that
would even be trying to reach out for
public dollars to come to their schools
So I think this is a terrible piece of
legislation given that our public voters
voted this down in November Thank you Mr
Speaker Chair recognizes a lady from
Jefferson 43 for explanation to vote not
to exceed two minutes The good part of
this bill is we were trying to help our
nonprofits help our people The bad part
of this bill is that we have a blank
check given to private schools so that
they can have SRLs Yes every child
should be safe Yes every child should be
loved and nurtured And that's why people
send their kids to private schools let
the private schools take it out of their
private tuition And then
finally last session in this session we
never touched the rainy day fund for
Medicaid for people that needed health
care for people that needed to be not be
homeless We passed a bill criminalizing
homelessness and didn't give any funds
from the rainy day fund to help them not
be homeless
But now we're going to do this so that
people that afford to send their kids to
private school can also have help in
making sure their school's tuition is
not used for SRO's
Chair recognizes a lady from Bay 93 for
explanation to vote not to exceed one
minute
Um thank you Mr Speaker It really breaks
my heart to have to vote no on this bill
and I really want to thank um the
representative uh who carried the
initial
HB622 It was a fantastic bill Um I am
happy to see that it will pass because
it will give the muchneeded relief that
we need for our nonprofits Um this was
just not the mechanism to get another
bill through So um sadly I am a no today
Chair recognizes a lady from Fay at 76
for explanation to vote not to exceed
one minute
Thank you Mr Speaker I spoke a few
minutes ago that I was really struggling
with this one I'm intentionally not
voting on it I I can't vote against our
nonprofit community who need this relief
but I also can't vote for spending
public dollars on private schools So I I
am not voting Thank you
Chair recognizes a gentleman from Boone
66 for explanation to vote not to exceed
two
minutes Mr Speaker not one
Kuckian voted to punish parents for
making an educational decision Not one
parent in Kentucky voted to jeopardize a
student's safety based on the
educational decision of other parents
This bill ensures that no matter what
educational choice a parent makes their
children are entitled to the same level
of protection as they are in any other
school For that reason I voted yes Thank
you Mr Speaker Chair recognizes
gentleman from Jefferson 46 foration
vote not to exceed two
minutes Thank you Mr
Speaker Mr Speaker I have concerns for
some of the last minute changes that
were made
today I also have concerns that I was
asked and selected to be on this
conference committee and then was not
notified and the work was done without
my input Not sure how that happens or
why that happens Doesn't make any sense
to name somebody on a conference
committee and then don't invite them to
the conference committee I don't know
why we do that
stupid I voted for this bill today
though because I'm a
co-sponsor of
these nonprofit needs I understand
them I'm a founder of four different
nonprofits over the last couple of
decades I understand their needs I
support their needs It's terrible that
we're put in a situation where we have
to make a decision we shouldn't have to
make This this should have been
something done separately Thank you Mr
Speaker Chair recognizes a gentleman
from Oldm 59
Thank you Mr Speaker Explain my yes vote
Yes sir Mr Speaker I am um often amazed
by some of the things that I hear on
this
floor but to
hear the statement made that this bill
forces us to make a choice between
private schools and the public
good is one of the most absurd things I
have ever heard on this floor
And I keep hearing people say they don't
want to relitigate amendment
two Um so I won't relitigate amendment
too But you I've always known that there
was a disdain of some people
for private schools for
privilege for people that don't fit
neatly in
a a
pre-arranged spot where we want to put
them
But I
never I never really understood that
that
disdain reached the level of public
safety of our kids
So much
so that we are proudly vote We're
proudly not
voting to not protect a kid
because that kid goes to a private
school And on this
day
when many of us are serving the last day
that we will ever serve on this House
floor I proudly vote yes to protect
every kid in Kentucky
[Applause]
Clerk will take the role There being 84
members voting yay 13 members voting nay
House Bill 622 as amended by free
conference committee report one is
finally passed Gentleman from McCracken
Move the clincher Without objection the
clincher is applied
