Hard Shell vs. Soft Carry On Luggage (In-Depth Buyer's Guide)

Voyage Hacks
34 followers
6 Video ViewsยทMar 28, 2025
Choosing the right carry-on luggage can make all the difference between a stress-free journey
and a travel nightmare. Today, we're going to dive into a hot debate in the travel world,
hardshell versus softshell luggage. I'll walk through some key considerations and work to
highlight the pros and cons of each so that you can make an informed buying decision.
Okay, let's dive in and first talk about the most obvious difference between hardshell and
the materials. Hardsided luggage can be made from many materials like polypropylene,
polycarbonate, ABS, which is an acronym for this long scientific name, and aluminum. Personally,
I'd recommend opting for polycarbonate, which is incredibly durable, lightweight, and resistant
to cracks. As far as hardshells go, polycarbonate is going to offer that sweet spot of affordability
and durability. Aluminum bags like this one from Level 8 Cases are also very, very cool,
but they are easily going to be the most expensive and the heaviest. Softshell luggage is often made
from fabrics like nylon or polyester, which provides a bit more flexibility. The distinctions
between the materials here translate directly to some of the key differences between the bags.
First, hardsided luggage is going to be more protective and durable in general, and I'm more
inclined to recommend a hardsided bag if you're traveling with something fragile. Whereas,
softshell luggage is going to lend itself better to flexibility. Softsided luggage will typically
be more forgiving in terms of how much you can fit into the bag and could also be a difference
maker when it comes to squeezing your bag into that overhead bin space. Now, this completely
depends on the bag, but softshell luggage is usually going to be lighter weight as well.
Although neither is going to be completely waterproof, hardsided luggage will be more
water resistant. We experienced this torrential downpour in Croatia, and what I noticed is
items near the zippers in our hardsided bag still got a little wet, but thanks to the shell,
things stayed mostly dry. A softsided bag would have gotten completely soaked through. In the same
vein, hardsided luggage is usually easier to clean. You can typically just wipe it down or use a magic
eraser to remove stains or marks. The downside is it will show scuffs, scratches, and dents
much, much easier. Softsided bags won't look as scratched or scuffed, but the fabric can stain.
This is a very minor consideration, but hardsided bags' rigid structure makes them easier to stack,
which could come in handy in crowded luggage compartments if you need that.
When it comes to some of the features you might find in hardsided and softsided luggage,
there's a huge variety of options out there as you get into specific bags. What I'm going to do
is point out what is commonly the default and give you some advice in terms of features that
you should be on the lookout for, no matter which option you go with. Let's start with wheels.
Most hardsided carry-ons these days use 360 degree spinner wheels. These are most easily
pushed alongside you, but they can also be pulled behind you. Softsided carry-ons come in both two
and four-wheel varieties, and I'll just say if you're after a two-wheel rollerboard,
it's more common to see that as a softsided piece of luggage. Zippers. Many hardsided carry-ons also
feature TSA-approved locking zippers with a built-in combo lock mechanism. You don't see this
as commonly on softsided bags, but they are out there, so I advise you to be on the lookout for
that feature. Pockets. Softshell suitcases usually have external pockets, which offer easy
access to items that you might need during your trip. I would say pockets are the default,
typically, when it comes to softsided bags. Now, you can get hardsided suitcases with external
pockets, but if you want that feature, that's something you're going to have to seek out. One
example is the Roadrunner by Level 8 Cases, which even has TSA locking zippers for that external
pocket, which I think is really cool. Hey, real quick, if you're getting value out of this video,
I would love it if you would hit that like button so that YouTube will recommend this
to other travelers like you. Okay, let's move to the inside of these bags. Most hardsided
luggage opens clamshell style or like a book, where the bag is split 50-50, and you'd pack
evenly into each of the two sides. Softsided luggage tends to open like a bucket with a lid.
You fill the contents and then the lid flips down, you just zip it up. Many prefer that style for
its ease when packing, and a common complaint against hardsided luggage is the shallow depth
of each of the two sides. It also tends to take up a little more space when it's unzipped. If
you're using a hardsided carry-on, I would definitely recommend a good set of compression
packing cubes, which will help you keep your items compartmentalized, compressed, and more easily
held in place. If you're a souvenir person, or if you have large or oddly sized items,
a softshell bag is probably going to be a better bet for you. I'd advise to look for a bag with
some element of internal organization, and you'll be able to find that in either hardshell or
softshell varieties. Also, consider if you want a bag with the ability to expand. Some people call
this a compression feature, and I get it. I commonly see this more as a help-me-over-pack
feature. Sorry. So, which one of these is right for you? This is very subjective,
and I would say it very much depends on your personal needs and preferences. I know plenty
of people who swear by their softsided bag. I'm sure that's many of you watching. I used a
softsided bag for years. Personally, I've used both, and I've come to a place where I personally,
again this is me personally, prefer hardsided luggage. I like the added durability, resistance
to the elements, and the overall aesthetic. If you're curious my take on which hardsided
carry-on is worth your hard-earned money, you'll want to check out this video where I purchased and
tested seven of the most popular hardsided carry-ons out there. And if you want to see me
do a similar video for softsided bags, comment bucket below. Thank you so much for watching.
It means a lot to us that our community is growing and that people are finding these videos
helpful. Consider subscribing if you haven't already, and happy travels.
