Which is the Best Underseat Roller? Travelpro vs. Briggs & Riley vs. Hanke vs. Nomad Lane

Voyage Hacks
34 followers
2 Video Views·Nov 14, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
In this video we're comparing four underseat roller bags
and they all range in price from $75 to $350.
But they're all very similar but do have a few differences.
So we'll look at their features
and functionalities and the pros and cons of each.
Then we'll do a test pack to see how much they each hold
and then I'm going to talk
about who each bag is best suited
for in terms of types of trips and travelers.
We'll be comparing bags from Briggs and Riley,
Hankey, Nomad Lane, and Travel Pro.
And before we get into it I just want
to say I don't want to waste a bunch of your time
reading all the specs and dimensions and weights of each bag.
All that information is free and
available on the websites.
So I've put links to each bag down below in the video description
or you can scan the QR codes
when they pop up on the screen if you're watching on your TV.
Because what I want to do instead is show you the things that you can't
easily just read about and compare from online descriptions.
Alright, first up is the Travel Pro Crew
Classic Rolling Under Seat Carry-On.
This is a two-wheel bag
and one of its best features is the way that it opens.
You can unzip just the top to quickly reach inside
while it's standing upright
or continue down the sides and open the front all the way for packing.
This is actually one of Chris's favorite all-time bags to travel with.
There are also several exterior zippered
pockets including one on each side along
with some internal organization
so if you like having separate places for all of your smaller
items there's quite a bit to work with here.
Now because of its size it's a good candidate
as a smaller carry-on if you're flying
on the smaller regional jets without any anxiety
worrying about the overhead bin size dimensions.
But under seat fit is a little more complicated
We tested it on a 737
and it wouldn't fit underneath the seat that we tried that had
a life jacket box underneath.
But for those seats without boxes, it should be able to slide under.
This bag has been around for a long time
and it's been used by many travelers under the
seat.
So you can also just check reviews if you want to read more about that.
And if you do use it as an under seat bag,
the top opening is useful because you don't
You don't have to open up the whole bag to get something out.
One detail I'm less keen on is the carry handle.
There's quite a bit of a gap between the handle
and the top of the bag and I usually prefer something
that sits a little closer.
For me a closer fitting handle would make
the bag feel a little more controlled when you're
quickly picking it up. This one has a bit of room to swing.
It also just creates extra
unnecessary material if you are trying to squish it into a bin.
Looks wise, because that is important, I'm giving it a 5 out of 10.
It has that classic
travel pro appearance.
It's practical and familiar but it's a little dated for my taste.
Next up is the Nomad Lane Bento Underseat Roller.
This is another two-wheel bag but the layout is
quite different from the Travel Pro.
So you've got the smaller front pocket to organize things like
your passport, pens, and other little essentials,
while a separate compartment
gives you access to your laptop
and tech without opening the main packing section.
And here you can see what I mean about the grab handle,
it's a lot closer to the top of the bag
and I find it just makes it really easy to grab
and pull out when the bag is under the seat.
It is worth noting that in our testing it did fit under the seat
when we were on a 737 aircraft
and I think because of the black color
and the inset wheels and just kind of like the overall
sleek look of it, I think it looks smaller than it
is so no one made us test it in the sizer before boarding.
Now the main compartment opens up like a clamshell
so you can lay it completely flat and access
both sides while you're doing your packing.
If you like organizing your belongings into separate
sections rather than one main compartment
this layout should be pretty appealing to you. It also
expands which gives you some flexibility
when you need extra packing space. Now there's no exterior
water bottle pocket. Personally I wouldn't purchase
or not purchase a bag based on that though.
And there are no backpack straps on this or any
of the other bags in this category.
A lot of you pointed this out
in the last video I made about the bento roller.
I think the main appeal here is being able to
roll the weight though instead of having to wear it.
In terms of accessing the main compartment,
it's not quite as straightforward as reaching into a top opening bag.
But there is a workaround for this.
You don't have to open it completely.
If you pack the things that you'll need near the top of the bag,
you can partially unzip it and reach in just fine.
You might just have to be a little more intentional about where
and how you would pack your items.
Looks wise, for me this gets an eight and a half out of ten.
I think it's sleek and minimalist and I really like the shape of it.
It's structured without looking overly boxy.
It would be nice if it came in more colors though.
So that's an 8.5 out of 10 for looks
but there's one number I care about even more when I'm traveling
and that's my phone's battery percentage.
Which brings us to the sponsor of this video,
Anker, because I want to show you their new power bank.
I am always excited when Anker
comes out with anything new, especially a power bank,
because honestly Anker powers
my every moment and for travel especially. One of these is a must-have.
Between using my phone for pictures,
using Google Maps, or my translator, or researching
somewhere to eat, I want
to make sure I have enough power to get through the day.
What I really like for travel is that it has two built-in USB-C cables.
So I can charge my phone without digging through
my bag for a separate cable, and Chris can
plug his in too.
And this has enough power to charge more than just your phone.
The dual port capability lets you charge two laptops simultaneously.
So if I want to get some work done
while we're traveling or maybe we're in the airport,
I don't have to choose my seat based on where the outlet is.
So in total there are four ports with 165 watts of total output
and a single port can deliver up to 100 watts of charging power.
The screen display also shows how much battery is left,
how fast your devices are charging, and the battery temperature.
And for when we're back in the hotel room
or even before we leave for a trip,
The Anker charger can get up to four devices charging together at once.
Then I pack the power bank somewhere easy to reach,
like in one of these personal item bags,
so it will always be by my side.
If you want to check either of these out for your next trip,
you can check out my links
in the video description below or the first comment.
Alright, now that we've got the power sorted, let's keep rolling.
With the most affordable bag in this lineup,
this is the Henke Underseat 16-inch Carry-On.
And it's the budget pick of the group coming in at around $75.
On the front there are two pockets.
I like the top one as I think it's the perfect size and position to
access and grab items that you're going to be using all the time.
I do find it quite stiff though.
The lower pocket is even more stiff
so reaching inside feels a little awkward.
It's not the best design so I would only use this pocket for something
relatively flat that I wanted to keep separate
rather than use it for anything I'd
be grabbing repeatedly throughout the trip.
I do really like how the main compartment opens up though.
The front panel unzips all the way down kind of like a drawbridge
which gives you a wide opening for packing.
And it comes with two clips to hold it halfway open as well.
There's also a zippered mesh pocket on the inside of that panel.
But it doesn't give you a whole lot of room
so this would just be good for some flat items.
Quality wise, especially considering the price,
it does feel well constructed and quite solid.
It is missing a laptop sleeve though
and a water bottle pocket and you might deal with
some inconsistency when it comes to whether
or not it will actually fit under the seat.
Looks wise I'm giving it a 7.5 out of 10.
It is a pretty clean and simple design,
but when beside the more expensive bags, the materials and finishes
definitely do look a little more basic, almost cheap looking.
But when it's on its own, I think it's perfectly fine,
especially for the price point.
Finally, we have the Briggs & Riley
Rhapsody Wheeled Carry-On Cabin Bag.
This is another four-wheel spinner.
This is a sharp-looking bag,
and one of the first things I noticed is how
soft and flexible the material feels around the main opening.
To me this is a really important detail because
when you only unzip it part way to grab something
you can easily peel back the opening without fighting a stiff edge.
I have definitely scratched my hand many
a time on cheaper stiffer bags.
Inside you have one main open compartment
with an integrated padded laptop sleeve.
It says it's designed to hold most 13 inch laptops.
The most noticeable difference
though is the completely flat packing surface.
And that's because the telescoping handle
is mounted on the outside of the bag
so you don't have those handle channels running through the inside.
This gives you an even surface for packing
and can even help keep your clothes wrinkle-free.
It also uses the interlocking handle system
to stack it on top of any other suitcase
instead of that regular trolley sleeve
and that's because the bars are on the outside.
I think this would work a little better though on top of an actual
Briggs and Riley suitcase but I don't have one to test it out.
On the front there's a soft line zippered pocket for smaller items.
There's also a side pocket that expands for a water bottle
and it compresses down when empty for more of a streamlined look.
You also can't beat the lifetime guarantee.
Briggs and Riley says that if your bag is ever damaged,
even by an airline, they will repair it for free.
You don't need to provide proof of purchase,
so you don't have to go find your old receipt
because each bag has a built-in barcode.
So that's definitely a major pro of investing in a bag like this.
You will literally have it for life.
Now the biggest thing about these two bags,
the Hankey and the Briggs and Riley,
is that they have four wheels.
And I have heard mention that on some flights or some airlines,
anything with four wheels needs to go in the overhead bin.
This is not necessarily on all flights,
this is just me passing along information for you to consider.
Okay now let's pack up these four bags with all
the same items to see how much they all fit.
Okay here's what we'll be packing.
So I've got two packing cubes that are full.
I think most of you probably have at least one
or both of these cubes so you know their size
and shape. Then I've got swim trunks,
a 3-1-1 toiletry bag, sunglasses, compression socks,
men's size 13 slippers, our chargers,
earbuds, passport, and a few provisions.
We're going to start from the least expensive to the most expensive.
So we'll start with the hanky.
This is another angle just to show you how it opens up.
And undoing the clips gives you the full wide open access.
The packing cubes were actually the perfect fit on all sides.
It was actually kind of satisfying the way they fit in there.
I put the swim trunks in the mesh zipper.
This would also be a good spot for pajamas though too.
Then I'm packing the power bank and then the slippers.
I did have to rearrange a little bit,
but the slippers fit width-wise stacked on top of each other.
And remember, these are size 13.
They do have to be squished down a bit,
but if you're okay with that, they fit.
And as an aside, this is mostly Chris's stuff.
I'll put the links to these items in the description.
So the front panel zipped up pretty effortlessly
and so far there isn't really any extra protrusion
of the bag beyond its normal rigid structure even when it's empty.
In the top zipper I added my
passport, other charger, and earbuds.
And in the bottom I added the wipes, sunglasses, tissues,
and socks, and then added the snacks to the top pocket.
So happy to see it fit
everything that I packed
and was only slightly bulging from the bottom pocket.
Now all packed up it weighed 8.5 kilograms or 18.8 pounds.
Next is the travel pro. You can see how it opens here.
I decided to leave it at the 45 degree angle
but you can see that there's snaps on the gusset
that would allow you to open it up all the way.
I stacked the two packing cubes
and once again they fit perfectly within this shape.
But right away I noticed
that it did feel considerably more restrictive.
So then I stacked the slippers vertically,
I added the toiletry case and the swim trunks into the front panel.
Then I decided to zip it up,
which as you can see took a fair amount of effort.
I started adding items to the front pockets
and you can see that it was really starting to bulge
out. So I decided to make use of the side zippers
and transferred some items into those pockets.
The only thing missing was the power bank.
I tried to add that to the top but it would just
not close so I took the slippers out
and then I was able to add it in. So with this bag I
couldn't fit it all in. I had to choose
to remove either the power bank or the slippers.
I had to really tug on the zippers to fit this much in,
though, and it was bulging
out of every side.
This was absolutely stuffed.
I also didn't particularly like how I had
to really jam in my passport in that front
admin pocket, so anything thicker than
that would pretty much render this pocket useless.
All packed up, the Travel Pro weighed 17.6 pounds or 8 kilograms.
Moving on to Briggs and Riley.
I will say this is definitely the smallest bag of the four that
we're testing so we'll see what happens.
Adding the packing cubes I decided to stack them
vertically for a better fit.
I wedged the power bank in between them and then added the toiletry
bag. I kind of struggled with the best placement
for the swim trunks as you can see so I zipped
I zipped up the bag to see how much more room I had to play with.
It really didn't want to close on the one side
and I didn't want to force it
so I undid the zipper and took the swim trunks out
and then zipped it up halfway.
So then I tried to put the trunks back in but it was just bulging out
way too much. So I left those out and started packing other items.
I put my passport and
earbuds in the front pocket and then unzipped the top again
and added my charger and socks on top.
So here it is absolutely jam-packed.
This thing is overstuffed I would say. I could not fit the
slippers, the swim trunks, or the snacks.
I also had to put the Lysol wipes and tissue in the side
pocket so that does make the side bulge out.
And the front pocket was once again being pushed out
making it a really tight fit for my passport which I'm not a fan of.
All packed up it weighed 7.7
Finally, we have the Nomad Lane Bento Roller.
So here I am packing it up.
I did have to play around with some different packing layouts,
especially with the slippers,
and I eventually decided I would have to try and fit the slippers
in at the end. So then I just began to layer everything
as evenly as I could. You'll notice
I packed almost everything into these two halves.
I will say it was very easy to close the bag and
and zip it up, though.
And for the last few small items I decided
the additional snap pouch wasn't really necessary
for this packout so I just put my charger
and earbuds in this separated compartment
and then my passport in the front.
So as you can see I was able to fit everything
except for the slippers.
I think the biggest difference is that I did not struggle to
zip this bag closed at all compared to the Briggs
and Riley and the Travel Pro.
Another important observation
is the added front gusset on the front pocket.
It's much easier to open
and grab from when the bag is fully packed compared to the other bags,
so I don't have to worry about something getting bent or snagged.
All packed up, the Nomad Lane bag weighed 8 kilograms or 17.6 pounds.
I also wanted to try another test here
so I took out the items from each packing cube to see if I
could fit more in the nomad lane bag because
when I remove the clothes from the cube I can fill in
all the gaps so that there's no inch of space being unused
and lo and behold I was now able to
fit everything including the slippers
and it's actually not even bulging out too much for being
This is also the second smallest bag in terms of capacity.
20 liters right now being unexpanded,
but then you do get an extra few inches of packing
space with the expansion feature.
So who are the winners in terms of capacity?
Well, at 20 liters, I think technically the
Nomad Lane wins because the only other bag
that can hold everything is the hanky,
which says its capacity is 30 liters.
So perhaps this really speaks to the design and orientation
of the Nomad Lane being better for holding more items
in less space. That being said,
I think the hanky and the Nomad Lane are two completely different bags.
But if you need one that holds the most amount of stuff
and you want something budget-friendly,
then Hankey is the clear winner.
I will say I am a little disappointed with the Travel Pro.
I think it's because there's so much structure to this bag.
It's quite thick, so that really eats into your actual packing space.
Finally, the Briggs & Riley is a small bag to begin with.
It definitely looks and feels smaller than the other three.
But at only 2 liters less capacity than the Nomad Lane,
I would have hoped it would have held more.
Despite this though, it's Chris' favorite out of all four.
So I'm curious, let me know down
in the comments what you thought about the packing test results.
So let's talk about who an under seat roller is actually for.
I think there are two main ways these make sense.
The first being it's your only bag for a short
trip like a weekend getaway
or even a little longer if you're a light packer and maybe
something like a quick business trip.
The second use case would be as a companion to your checked
luggage. Your clothes go in the larger bag
and this keeps your valuables, medication,
electronics and maybe a backup outfit with you.
And in either case, a roller makes sense
if you're finding that the contents of your
personal item to be too heavy to carry on your shoulder or back.
So now you don't have to worry
about that. You can let the wheels do the heavy lifting.
So if an underseat roller sounds like
your kind of bag, which one makes the most sense
for the way you travel? I think you're a good fit
for the travel pro if you prioritize function first
and want something practical, accessible,
and uncomplicated.
If you find yourself constantly reaching
into your bag mid-flight to pull out things like
your glasses, a sweater, snacks, charging cables,
or a book, then I think you'll appreciate the
easy access of the Travel Pro.
Especially if you don't care for a super stylish or trendy exterior.
So if your personal item is basically
your little command center for the flight and you want to get
into it without having to unpack everything,
this is probably the one I'd look at. If you see
You see yourself as more of a...
Organized packer, I would lean toward the Nomad Lane bento roller,
especially if you want your clothing and
technology or flight essentials in separate deliberate spaces.
Obviously if you're a fan of the original bento,
but just can't carry it on your shoulder anymore,
this is the bag that you want. If you're someone
who always packs everything within a packing cube or a plain pouch,
the wide open clamshell design gives you
the freedom to organize how you want.
But also if you mostly travel with checked luggage
and you always make sure to pack some
sort of self-contained backup bag that stays with you
in the cabin in case your larger suitcase does
get lost, I think you'll appreciate using the bento roller.
And if you're constantly going back
and forth between leisure and work trips,
this is a sleek piece of luggage for business travel.
So if you love the idea of packing like
a miniature suitcase with your clothes organized inside and
your tech and other essentials in their own section I think
this will make the most sense to you.
Now the hanky is the perfect option if you
are a budget conscious traveler. If you're an occasional
flyer who can't justify a premium price
then I think you'll be pleasantly surprised with this.
And if you know you absolutely want four wheels in a smaller cabin bag
but can't justify paying
a premium price for it,
then I think this is definitely the choice for you.
I also know some of you are looking
to maybe try out using a four-wheel smaller cabin bag
and you don't know if this is actually going
to be suitable for you and suit your needs
but you don't want to spend a whole lot
of money without testing it, this could be a
good option.
This is also a good bag if you have a pretty straightforward
or minimal packing list
as you won't be fitting your laptop or your water bottle in this.
So if you're thinking I just need
a little suitcase that rolls beside me and
I don't care about all the extras
this is probably all the bag that you need.
And finally the Briggs and Riley is definitely
for you if you're a frequent traveler looking to
invest in something quality for the long term.
Definitely another good choice for business
travelers but if you know you need four wheels
as well as anyone who maybe already
owns a Briggs and Riley suitcase
and now you want the smaller cabin bag to match.
So I hope you are able to find the perfect bag for you.
Let me know in the comments what
under seat bag has been the best for you so far.
I'm always looking to test out more of
them for this channel.
Thank you so much for watching and we'll see you in the next one.
