Do Taiwanese Take China's Threats Seriously? | Guest: NTD News' Brendon Fallon

The Andres Segovia Show
161 followers
194 Video Views·Mar 26, 2025
China is reportedly preparing to invade Taiwan by 2027.
In this abridged version of a June 7, 2023, Instagram Live, Brendon Fallon, former host of The Wide Angle, and I discuss the preparedness of the Taiwanese people.
It aged well.
https://theandressegovia.start.page/
This is the Andres Segovia Show.
All right, good morning everyone. I'm hoping that this is transmitting just right.
For those of you on the west coast, yeah, it's probably still too early. I'm going to be having
a unique coffee time moment with y'all. So if you're able to join me live, great, otherwise
you're going to catch it on the replay. And I'm going to be very careful here where it's just
going to mess up my camera. I'm going to have a guest on because I put up the poll on purpose.
For those of you that participated, thank you. And the poll I'm talking about is with respects
to the, if you feel the threats of the CCP, which is the Chinese Communist Party,
are they concerning to you or are they not? And the poll, if you saw the poll,
you can still see the results here on my Instagram stories. If you're seeing this
from the time I go live, if you're seeing it, the concern is that most people do have a concern.
But when you see the results though, the results are people are not living in Taiwan.
And those that are living in Taiwan, friends and family that I have over there,
most of them feel it's exaggerated. It's no big deal. This is China just being China,
the same old talking points. They don't feel that threat. So let me see. I'm going to try to get my
guest on here. Hey, Brennan, can you hear me? Andres. Yeah, I can hear you. All right. Well,
a lot of people on my side are going to tune in a little later because they're asleep.
And where you are, you're probably going to sleep soon too, right? Because it's what,
almost midnight in Taiwan? Yeah. Hey, it's almost midnight. And fingers crossed, I will be asleep
in a minimal amount of time. Gotcha. Not during this interview.
I try to do it a little earlier. I usually work on my show between 9 PM and 2 AM. So that's okay.
So if I'm doing a late shift, I can make this happen in the morning. So I'm glad we're able to
work around the crazy time schedules to make this happen. I appreciate it. I'm happy to be here.
Well, dude, I reached out to you because... Live from Taiwan. Yeah. Well, dude, I reached out to
you because you saw the poll that I put out there. I put, are the threats of the CCP against Taiwan
concerning or exaggerated? And for the most part, most of everybody on my account,
they saw the results and thought, yeah, it's pretty straightforward. And so I explained to them
that those that are saying exaggerated are people in Taiwan, living in Taiwan. And everybody that
said that they were concerned are living outside of it. And I thought about you because when you
were doing the wide angle, because right now you're doing a more health-focused show, but when
you were focusing the wide angle, you covered a lot of this and it was concerning then and it's
more concerning now. But for some reason, the Taiwanese are not really feeling that. And since
you're in Taiwan and you come across people on the everyday, is there anybody preparing for the end
of the world over there? I think my impression of the general culture here is that it's a society
where people are very focused on their day-to-day lives, on their work. And it's a very work-driven
study-driven culture. And I think there's also a divide in the perception of this threat and also
a divide in the kind of relationship that Taiwanese people want to have with China,
which is unfortunately governed at the moment by the Chinese Communist Party.
So I can see where there would be people who perceive that there isn't a great threat from
China. And perhaps if other countries weren't involved, if other countries weren't signaling
that they would be involved, like the US, then there really wouldn't be much of a threat
facing Taiwan. Whereas there's other Taiwanese people who perceive a significant threat.
From my own experience, I was out to dinner last year while I was visiting Taiwan. And
we were with a family, and the two children there asked their parents,
if China invades, if the CCP invades, can we go and stay with these guys in America?
So I think it's there, and it's quite prevalent, this threat. But you've got to remember that it's
also been hanging over the head of the Taiwanese for 70-odd years, this threat of potential CCP
invasion. Although it's escalated significantly at this point in time.
With my in-laws, when they were here recently, every single year that I visited Taiwan,
and then they came over here, I would have these conversations about the what if, do you have a
safety net planned in case the CCP does make their move? Because all their kids are over here now.
In other words, the future is the United States for them. But to them, they can't visualize
leaving Taiwan. So I don't know if it's the fear of having to move from Taiwan that puts them in
denial, or if they're just like, we don't perceive that threat. They're always talking.
And even some of the younger generation that I've spoken with up until recently,
they just brushed it off like it's nothing. But last week, I was able to gather up with
several guys for a friend's party. And most of all of them are Taiwanese. And I just brought it
up because like, hey, guys, I wanted to do an episode for my show about this for those that
know. And when I asked, for the first time, I got much more varied questions. I mean,
much more varied answers, where some of them were finally expressing concerns.
I've never seen them so invested in an upcoming election, because they feel the fate of Taiwan
hangs on the balance. And I'm like, well, it's about time you guys are paying attention.
But a part of me feels that your family over there isn't. And I guess that led to the question that
my wife and I had an exchange recently, which is, well, even if Taiwan was concerned about this,
well, what can they do? Well, readiness is for one thing. A lot of it's mental.
And I just feel that there's a dependence on Taiwan that the United States is going to go out
to save them. And I'm like, well, don't depend on us, especially right now. But that's just been
the general sentiment for me. I haven't been to Taiwan in several years. So based on what you
just highlighted versus what I've experienced, I think that there is more a change. But with that
poll that I just put up, not much has changed. A lot of my friends and family have been posting
there and just saying, no, that's exaggerated. You guys still think that? I sometimes wonder
if the media in Taiwan might be influenced by the CCP. You're in media. Do you feel a
little bit of that? Have you seen that? I have no doubt there's a strong influence
from the CCP in Taiwan's media. I mean, the CCP has an influence worldwide in various medias.
So it's almost unimaginable that it wouldn't have its stake in Taiwan's media as well.
And my understanding of the situation in Taiwan, it's kind of a cultural thing that
their political reporting commentary, it's got often quite a combative nature to it.
Maybe this is something I guess the audience appreciates as well, where you have one side
getting hotly antagonistic towards the other one, and you have the side that is anti-CCP,
and you have the other side that wants a closer relationship with China, as they put it.
The CCP, no doubt, has its influence in many commentators who are pushing for that relationship.
Based on just anecdotal stuff, but just the people you come across, because in your case,
when you mentioned it, there was a family and the kids, like, can we hit your eye with the
way back to the United States? Have you felt that the generation, let's say the 20s and the 30s,
are the ones that don't feel the threat from CCP, and it's the more senior that are probably more
concerned, or vice versa? I ask because it's almost like the reaction of South Korea,
how much a generation that didn't live those threats and concerns of North Korea, and I was
like, North Korea's all talk, it's all talk, and they don't take it as seriously. I sometimes
wonder if that might be the same for the generation in Taiwan, because everyone's
saying that CCP's threats are exaggerated, are my age or younger. That's my general sentiment
from what I come across, and in your day-to-day while you've been out there, even recently,
have you felt that the concerns come more from the older generation, or is the new generation
expressing just as much? I don't know if I could divide it in that way. I mean, I've known young
people who are adamantly opposed to the CCP, young Taiwanese people, and I think you could look at
the protest movement in Hong Kong as a reference. I mean, that was a youth-driven movement,
and I think that it's something in the youthful spirit internationally that you see obvious
restrictions on people's freedoms, and you want to do something about it. If you've lived,
these young Taiwanese, they've grown up in democracy. Democracy is relatively new to Taiwan,
but the people in their 20s and 30s, they've basically grown up with that, and they can see
the potential for that to be decimated if the CCP is to move in on Taiwan.
And you mentioned something about democracy being new enough to Taiwan, but I love this
highlighted piece that you did when you did a two-part series about the defense of Taiwan,
and in comparison as to what's going on between that and Ukraine. Taiwan has predated the CCP.
I'm like, well, yeah, that's true. And it's so easy to forget that. It's like, huh. And
the younger generation never had to grow up with that, which is why I always feel when I teach my
children history, because they have to learn history. If you don't learn from history,
you're doomed to repeat it. So my wife asked me, well, the reason they don't feel the thrust from
the CCP is because, well, besides the whole planes maybe threatening Taiwanese airspace,
they haven't done anything to Taiwan. I said, well, that's because they're not interested in
blowing up the island. They want to subjugate the people. And besides the resources that Taiwan has,
particularly in the semiconductor business, is what they want. And the only thing, a natural
barrier for them, kind of like how Great Britain survived all those world wars without being
invaded, is the Taiwan Strait. I've heard some analysis about the possibility, if there is a
land invasion, why it can't just be at the whim for China. It has to be around these two
opportunities seasonally, and that's just too much for them. And it's one of your pieces, too,
that I saw on the wide angle, where it said, yeah, but if Taiwan remains standing and the CCP
doesn't get a hold of them, that they could very much see a collapse of the CCP back on China,
for which is why this is such a strategic thing for them. That's a piece of the puzzle I never
actually saw. And I think that's the only thing right now that people don't realize unless they
analyze it very well. But overall, I just think that Taiwan needs to, they do need to take this
more seriously. And at the very least, their military budget, I don't know anything about
how much they spend, they got to triple, double, whatever it is, and take it seriously. So that's
been my take on all this. But I was curious if you were on assignment out there, or for pleasure,
or both, if you came across a lot of this, particularly as of late, because it looks
like China's been a lot more aggressive these past few days, and some people don't even know
about it. I can't say personally that I've seen any specific signals of that. But during a trip
out to Hualien, one of Taiwan's very beautiful tourist locations on the seaside, I saw a jet
flew overhead. It was probably a Taiwanese jet, but it just occurred to me, this is the kind of
lifestyle, this is the kind of situation that the Taiwanese people are living in,
where if you see that, if you hear that, you're naturally going to wonder, is this one of ours,
or is this a CCP jet that's invading our airspace once again? And what is the signal for the next
escalation in this tension? Yeah, because I have a buddy of mine
who's very Taiwanese. He moved to Taiwan, and we were talking recently. He's like,
are you considering moving back? Because he's out here in Southern California too.
He's like, no. If anything, he was encouraging me to move to Taiwan. I'm like, really?
You guys really don't feel it? It's like, eh, what can you do?
Well, I've been here for a month this time around, and I don't feel in a hurry to leave.
It's interesting. Taiwan, it doesn't have a lot of the trademark tourist attractions. It doesn't
have the inspiring architecture of places like France or even New York, but it's very comfortable
here. For one, you get fantastic service. If you go to a restaurant, if you stay in a hotel,
you get exceptional service. People really seem to care about making sure you have the best
experience. That's a testament to the mentality that widely pervades Taiwanese society.
They've had to be very resilient because they've faced this ongoing threat. It was 2 million
people having to flee the recently communist-occupied China to make a new life on this
island. That culture of determination, of hard work, it's instilled very much from what I see
in Taiwanese culture. I think that's probably one of their greatest assets in facing the threat that
they continue to face. There's this whole culture about eating and drinking. That's why it's the
heart of Asia. It's the Formosa Island. It's just a place that you're a foodie where you want
to be. It's just so comforting. You said the culture, the service that you get. Unless you're
there, it's really hard for people to really experience it because there's a lot of Taiwanese
places here where I am. It's like, yeah, but it's not the same. To me, it's something worth
preserving. People do need to experience it. Even though they're resilient, I believe a lot
of that resilience of the people recently has been because they felt the cover of the United
States. I think it was under Bill Clinton's presidency that we had a little bit of war
games over there to defend Taiwan. Other than that, I haven't heard of anything more massive
than that kind of response to defend Taiwan. The threats are even worse now. That's how I've come
across in my short experiences with that. A lot of what you said has tied into both on the
wide angle and both as just a passerby and a tourist. I think people are waking up a little
more, but I guess we shall soon see because the government is the one that needs to really react
to all this. I was recently reading an article from the Japanese Japan Times. It was an interview
with a former Taiwanese admiral, Lee Su-Min, and he was saying that really Taiwan is not prepared
at this point in time militarily at any stretch of the imagination to fend off a CCP attack.
The reality is that it is very much how much of a stake America and the Western world
signals that it has in Taiwan. Like the recent G7, it was a mixed message again from America and
from the G7 in terms of where it stands with Taiwan. I'll give you an example.
There's a clear consensus among our allies, this is from Biden, that there will be a response if
China unilaterally takes action. It's a clear response. It's a clear consensus,
but the idea of a response is somewhat vague. What kind of response can we expect?
This is what we've come to expect from the Biden administration, where Biden will say,
if there is an attack from the CCP, we will take action. Then a few days later,
you see the White House comes back and retracts the statement. I think at the same time,
that does serve some purpose. I don't think it's a faux pas on Biden's part. I think it's
probably a strategic move by the Biden administration because they don't want to
send a clear message. You could say that this strategic ambiguity policy has worked for decades.
There hasn't been a war, so it's understandable to some degree why they'd continue in that manner.
This is important. The signaling of the world, the signaling of America is crucial. You can't
get away from the fact in Taiwan's security at this point in time.
Yeah. I just think that, as I told my wife yesterday, I just feel that
Taiwan, if they took an approach similar to Israel, where we have two nations that
are literally dependent on us, but where you have Israel that's like, hey, everybody needs
to get trained here because you never know, we're going to call a man or woman, it doesn't matter,
you hold up a rifle, we're going to train you. I feel that the same at the various in Taiwan.
I saw some videos and I re-went through them recently. I'm like, is that really
soldiers training with airsofts in Taiwan? I wanted to believe the video was fake,
and supposedly it was real. Can they not afford, or is it just so anti-gun that they wouldn't use
guns to train even with real guns, or they just couldn't afford the weapons and the ammunition
that they're trying to preserve? Those answers were not provided. But that's what I mean.
These are a little bit older videos. Taiwan, at the very least, they're used like, yo,
you guys got to be ready. You guys need to invest in your budgets. Expect urban warfare,
because Taiwan, if China really wanted to, they would have blown it up a long time ago.
That's not what they want. They wouldn't do that. So expect some kind of land war that
they're not able to win. We don't know, but it doesn't hurt to be prepared.
There's been more of mine like, you need air defenses, you need your air force,
and you need your soldiers trained. Man, woman, you guys all need to do your part.
So that's been my thing. If they have taken a more Israeli model in that sense,
I think it'll work. Not so much an iron dome, because they wouldn't need it per se,
but hey, if you can, why not? So that's really been my thing with all that.
I can't remember his name. You had Dr. Su Yun. I'm not good with pronunciation names.
Pretty close.
He actually did say that on your show when you interviewed him, along those lines, like, hey,
that's what I was saying. That was last year. So I'm glad that I'm trying to tell my family
very things that people very much over there and involved in strategic decisions,
at least have that in mind. I'm just hoping that they at least allocate the budget for it,
and at least have done so, a lot more so than the past year. But the next election,
apparently it's going to be very, very interesting. I'm not going to ask you about
that one, but we'll see where that goes. I'll let you have a last word in, but I
didn't want to keep any longer because for you, it's midnight.
Yeah. I mean, along the lines of what you're saying, Taiwan has invested in that kind of
anti-ship missile technology more of late. The extent to which that puts Taiwan in escalates
its ability to really defend itself. There's different opinions on that. I think largely,
it's the positioning of the US and the global community that Taiwan is dependent on at this
stage. I agree that it does need to foster that mentality really, particularly its use
in that kind of prepare for war mentality. Just visiting a hospital here, you have all these
military hospitals because there was such a large military in Taiwan before. Now, these military
hospitals are basically servicing civilians because there just isn't a population of military
to service. But another factor is that China may not present the formidable threat that it would
like the world to believe. I mean, China is facing a number of problems of its own that
is probably beyond the scope of our conversation today, but major economic problems. Goldman Sachs
recently rated it as an estimate of China's debt at $1.23 trillion. We've seen unprecedented
protests internally in China with the zero COVID policy. We've got teachers protesting in China
recently because they're not getting paid. It's teachers who haven't been paid for four years,
which is also pointing to a probably heavily concealed economic problem there in China.
Is China really ready? Is it economically ready? Does it have the cohesion socially to really wage
war at this point? That's another important consideration. I think there's many factors
suggesting it's not. I totally agree with you. The economy over there has definitely been
unconcealed, and that's something we can unpack and spend so much time on. But of course,
I don't want to keep it any longer because it is midnight. I'm just getting my day started.
You're done with yours. Well, it's been a great way to end, to be honest.
Thanks for coming on. For those that don't know, Brandon used to do the wide angle over at the
Epoch Times, but he's now focused on health. I'm going to ask him privately if he is doing
a health segment on Taiwanese food over there. We'll talk about that. Hey, but hey, thanks so
much. Keep doing what you do, man. Godspeed. Have safe travel when you come back to the States.
Ted, great to be on. Speak to you soon, Andres. Thank you.
All right. Talk to you then.
