Curator's Den 15: Baroque Masters

Baroque Art
20 followers
3 Video Views·Mar 24, 2025
In July's Curator's Den episode, explore Baroque Masters at the Washington County Museum of Fine Arts with Agnita M. Stine Schreiber Curator Daniel Fulco.
Hi everyone, my name is Daniel Fulco. I'm a D. M. Stein Traber Curator at the Washington
County Museum of Fine Arts in Hagerstown, Maryland, and it is my pleasure to welcome
you back to the latest edition of the Curator's Den. And today I am going to talk to you about
some Baroque art in our collection. And this is in conjunction with a special exhibition that
is on view at the museum now, and that I encourage you to come and attend if you are able to.
The program today is sponsored by Mr. Louis Kalbaja. I'm going to be looking at several
works by two Italian artists and then one by an artist from the Netherlands. These were all made
sometime between the late 1600s and the early 1700s. This presentation today is done in
conjunction with that special exhibition that I mentioned Bernini and the Roman Baroque Masterpieces
which is on view through September, as you can see there. And you're going to see the works that
I'm presenting today discussed in another context for my second lecture that is upcoming on August
12th at six o'clock, and I hope that you'll be able to join me for that. But today what we're
going to do is we're going to look and see how these paintings fit in with the museum's history
and also in the broader context of Roman art, and look at some very interesting issues connected to
them. But I just wanted to put that out there that these works, you may see them come back in
my second lecture, but they will be in relation to specific works that are in the Bernini and the
Roman Baroque show. So stay tuned for that. To situate you with the context that we're looking
at today geographically, we're going to be talking about actually Genoa. We'll also be mentioning
Rome and a little bit about Naples. We'll also talk about the relationship between Genoa, which
is an important city in the province of Magria in northern Italy in the early and mid-1700s,
and its relationship to Antwerp, specifically what's today Belgium, in exchange. How does that
inform, how does it change Italian Baroque art? So this is just to give you a sense of where we're going
virtually. But a little background before I launch into my discussion today. These paintings
that we're looking at go back to a time in the museum's history with a very significant director.
He's shown here on the upper left, named Bruce Etcheson. He was the director from 1949-1950 to
1964. Here you can see him on towel explaining a portrait that is done in the tradition of Rembrandt,
but that for many years was believed to be a Rembrandt. I discussed it before in previous
curators' dens, and also in Let's Talk Art, for example. But I bring him in here because he is
the one who was responsible for acquiring the works that we're looking at today, two of the first two.
And the painting that's going to be the first subject of our discussion is this painting
that depicts Saint Michael defeating Satan, which was given by an important
donor to the museum, Mr. Stuart Houston, Coatesville, Pennsylvania, which is just southwest of
and outside of Philadelphia. Mr. Houston is an important figure in the museum because he donated
a number of pieces, two of which we'll be looking at today. His name will come up again, but essentially
he was a connection to our former director Bruce Etcheson. Bruce Etcheson also oversaw the acquisition
of this painting depicting Lott and his daughters. So that just places it a little bit within our
context in Hagerstown. And, of course, these relationships would not have been able to come
about without the assistance of Agra Silverman, shown on the left here, with Bruce Etcheson
at a reception at the museum for an exhibition in 1964 of Old Masters. And what was important was
Agra Silverman was a key art dealer in New York between the late 1930s all the way through the
mid-60s. He dealt in Old Master paintings and he helped facilitate many acquisitions for the museum
and specifically in introducing clients of his to Bruce Etcheson who may become potential donors.
So this was an important part of how the museum got to know these certain individuals.
Here's Bruce standing with a painting that was on loan to our museum for some number of years,
believed to be done in the tradition of Albrecht Dürer, but actually not by Dürer himself.
And Bruce is shown here standing in the gallery looking at it and preparing to speak about it
in a newspaper clipping here at the time of our 25th anniversary exhibition
back in the 1950s. So, a little bit of history.
Now, what's really interesting about this painting is when I first got to the museum
it was displayed very high up on the Schreiber Gallery wall, which is a gallery full of Master
paintings, and it piqued my curiosity. It had been studied by several of the museum's Samuel H.
Kress Foundation fellows, but they came to some different conclusions about the authorship
and when I discovered the connection to Mr. Huston, I became particularly intrigued by his
role. This was actually his first gift to the museum, and I should mention that it had had a
number of attributions on it. But I did some research and as I'm going to explain, I believe
that it is not done by the previous artists to which it has been attributed, and I think it is
actually done by either this painter you're looking at, he's Roman, Benedetto Lutti, or a
member of his workshop. And I came to these conclusions based upon the use of color and form
and also the compositional technique as a whole. Benedetto Lutti, in addition to painting religious
subjects that you see here, he also was a pastelist. By that I mean he created these pastel
portraits. This one in the middle is an engraving likely done after the artist's own self-portrait
in pastel. Pastels became very popular in the late 17th and specifically well into the 18th century.
So this artist that we're looking at, Lutti, he was originally from Florence, but what he does is he
settles down in Rome. He has his ground training in Florence, but then he makes his way from Rome,
and he had a number of very key patrons, including Cosimo III Medici, among the last Medici
of Florence, the Buller's Tuscany. And then he came to Rome where he received patronage from
many artists, actually, that had patronized Gian Lorenzo Bernini, including the members of the
Colonna family, Pallavicini, the Barberini, and the Ore Scalchi family. So some very important patrons.
What led me to believe we were looking at a different artist is the use of color, and I'm
going to talk about it a bit more. In addition to the fact that some of the previous attributions
were not accounting for the use of oil sketches, as you see here with one of Lutti's confirmed works,
Christ on the Mount of Olives, it's in the Salzburg Museum's collection. So we'll draw those to
comparison in just a little bit, but here we've got on the left the original attribution to our
painting in the collection that we see here of Saint Michael. When it came to the museum,
it was attributed to the Spanish arts to work in Italy. It says on the label here
Giuseppe de Ribera. And Ribera was a Spanish follower of Caravaggio. He worked for quite
some time in Naples. First trained in Rome, he fell under the influence of Caravaggio.
And how this attribution got put on the Saint Michael painting is not entirely clear. However,
I could test that, and my other colleagues have too, because Ribera's style is very different.
He doesn't use those bright reds, those oranges. Instead, he uses a darker palette,
more in the vein of Caravaggio. He uses Tenebris technique, dramatic chiaroscuro,
like you see here in the Martyrdom of Saint Andrew, which is in the Museum of Fine Arts,
Budapest. So you're looking at a totally different artist. The subjects are much grander. He focuses
more on musculature, rather than building up anatomical proportions and features using color.
Now, one of my other colleagues, who was a Crest fellow, Dr. Leopoldine Prosperetti,
in the late 2000s, had thought that our Saint Michael might have been done by Luca Giordano.
However, I am of a different opinion, because again, Giordano, he often will use very loose
brushwork. But in a work like this, he tightens it up, and it's actually quite an academic
work. His representation of the eyes, the anatomical proportions, are much more exact
than, for example, the new attribution of Prosmena Dettoluti, which is closer to our painting.
And I think one of the things that led my other colleague to believe this is the very famous
representation that we see here of the fall of the rebel angels. This is circa 1666 by Giordano
in the Kunsthistorisches Museum in Vienna. I thought that perhaps our painting might be a
preliminary sketch for this, but I'm not quite certain about that. I think that it's more likely
for a totally different commission by a different artist in his workshop.
So moving back to our painting, thanks to a very important grant from the Stuart Houston
Charitable Trust, which is a foundation in Coatesville, Pennsylvania, that maintains the
legacy of Stuart and his philanthropic endeavors in Pennsylvania and also for other institutions
that received gifts from him, we have been able to clean this painting and restore it to its
former glory. And these photographs here show you the evolution of this process of the workshop of
Benedetto Dettoluti painting. This is what it looked like originally, very darkened, the color
is not particularly distinct. One can serve that here, and this is the work in process, those old
varnish layers are taken off, and you get to see what the artist's original intentions were. You
can see how the rays of light are beaming down here on Saint Michael as he's getting ready to
march his spear there. And I should mention that this is a very important subject that you see in
art. Giordano, of course, treated it. It's from the New Testament's Book of Revelation, in which
God charged Archangel Saint Michael with leading his armies against Satan's forces during the war
in heaven. In our painting, which is very lively and dramatic, the artist does make use of this
chiaroscuro, and Saint Michael is seen armed with a spear and chain, he's suspended in air, and he
prepares to capture Satan, sending him plunging back into the depths of hell. It's likely that an
associate of Mufi's workshop would have worked on this, perhaps with the supervision of the master
himself. And the piece that we have in the museum, I believe, is what we call a modello, a preparatory
oil sketch, which you can see many examples in the Bernini exhibition we have on Juneau. These were
the first idea of the artist that would be presented to their patron at the time. And the idea was that
the patron would look at it and decide whether or not they wanted to proceed with the idea, the
initial idea presented by the artist would suggest changes, and those would be made to the final,
very large altar piece. And this is what the painting looks like after restoration.
Bringing back the colors, the original intention of the artist here, you can see how the light
shines down on Satan, the details of his wings, and you can also see his claw here. Saint Michael's
So it really shows quite nicely. It's on view in the lobby of the museum, and I encourage you to
come back and see it. On the left, the before, very darkened, and on the right, really quite
brightened up. It's much more vibrant, and you get to see what's actually going on in the painting.
Muti, in his workshop, specialized in creating frescoes, oil paintings, and pastels. As I
mentioned, both religious and secular subjects, Muti would go on to train a significant generation
of artists in Rome, including Giovanni Paolo Parmini, French artist Charles-Andre
Van Loo, and many others. Van Loo being a court painter to King Muti in France.
Paintings like this were very important in asserting Roman Catholic beliefs during the
And the basis for my reattribution comes from the use of colors, as well as the elements in the sky,
the atmospheric effects. See those oranges? We see them playing out in the Hagerstown painting
down below. Here's one of Muti's works called The Oration in the Garden of Olives, shown here.
Again, you can see how this is working. Also, another thing that got me on to Benedetto Muti
is the shape of the eyes, as well as the hands, the facial expressions of the figures. We see this
also in a study he did of the penitent man from about the late 17th to the early 18th century.
The coloristic inspiration is critical when you're trying to look at a reattribution,
or Christ on the Mount of Olives here. Like our painting, this is an oil sketch. Note the sky up
above with those oranges and browns that are incorporated in, and also the oval eyes of the
figures. See how the anatomical proportions are not as exacting as Luca Giordano we saw before?
We can see that here with the Saint Michael. Some attention to detail to the anatomy, but it's
actually more about color. And it's really amazing, our painting, especially after restoration, as you
can see the light shining down on his head, representing the divine good nature of God and of
Saint Michael, triumphing over the evil darkness over here of Satan. And see how there's the fires
of hell are alluded to down below with this burst of flames. It's just a wonderful work of art.
Now, transitioning from that, we move on to another painting attributed formerly to Giovanni
Andrea da Ferrari. And here we have a picture that is actually Genoese. And by that I mean that
it was produced in Ireland in general. A prolific easel painter, Giovanni Andrea da Ferrari created
many religious subjects such as the one you're looking at. But again, after I looked at this
picture, I thought that we were looking at something that was actually not by this artist
Ferrari, and I'm going to explain why. Again, one of my colleagues had a different opinion,
this often happens in art history where people, art historians have different beliefs about what
the authorship of a specific book is. What I will say to give you an overview is that the artists
to whom I've attributed to possibly collaborating with Giacomo Legge here, you have a work that's
done in the tradition of Caravaggio. Originally, when it came to the museum, it was thought to be
by somebody in the circle of or even by Jan Lievens, who is a slightly older artist than Rembrandt.
He was a rival of his in Leiden. And this is not the case. After more research, this painting
really does show the influence in the blending of Flemish tradition in the north and Italian
forms in the south. So we can leave behind the Jan Lievens attribution. Again, we're looking more here
at the Caravaggio attribution. Strong contrast between light and dark and the tremendous emotion
that you see here with Caravaggio. Using people from daily life, from the experience of the artist,
and actually pulling those in. This is part of the Catholic Counter-Reformation that makes us want
to believe more foreseen in order to understand and grasp the teachings of the Catholic Church more.
I've re-attributed it to Domenico, pardon the typo there, Domenico Fiacella and Giacomo Legge,
who were both artists working in Genoa in the mid to late 1600s. It was a gift of Hobart McVicar
Agnew, who is an ophthalmologist who worked in New York and New Jersey in the 50s and 60s,
and happened to collect some of this artwork. And as you can see here, Lot and his daughters
are being led out of Sodom, and this is actually an angel. It's hard to see in this photograph,
but actually this figure has wings and it's leading the figures out of the sea. It's happening
outside of a home as these figures are being led away. And here's Lot right there. A little bit
about it. This subject is quite well known throughout history, and basically it is the
story of life, comes from the story of the lives of the patriarchs in the Old Testament.
A kinsman of Abraham, Lot was the only male to survive the destruction of Sodom.
However, he disturbingly had incestuous relations with his daughters in order to ensure the
continuance of the human race. And in the 16th and 17th centuries, Lot was often considered to be
embodiment of licentiousness, of adultery in many cases. And a narrative like this was intended to
warn viewers against the dangers of succumbing to amorous temptation, while also providing an
opportunity for the depiction of erotic sensuality. Now, this one doesn't really show the erotic
sensuality that much. It focuses on this moment in time within the episode, that it's occurring,
at least in Fiasella and Legge's mind at night. Here's a detail of a bag that one of the daughters
carries. Look at how engaging she is. She looks right out at the viewer, making us wonder what's
going on in the scene. And over here is a maidservant, often something you see in the work
of cartography. Ferrari's technique does bear some resemblance to our painting in Hagerstown,
but this is actually quite different. Some resemblance, particularly in terms of the
light that shines on the figures, the use of the highlights on one of Lot's daughter's faces,
as well as Lot himself, gestures. But as you're going to see, the artist I'm looking at Fiasella
is quite different. Fiasella, again, being Genoese. Having gone to the John and Mabel Ringling Museum
of Art a couple of years ago, that's when it sort of drove it home to me that I was looking at
very much the possibility of the work of Fiasella, or at least his workshop. Particularly when I saw
Christ's face here, the nose, the modeling of the hands of the figures, the use of light,
is in many regards very similar to his daughter, which you see over here.
This is another one, which is part of the series Christ Tealing the Blind,
also in the John and Mabel Ringling Museum. And then when I found this one, by the way,
his nickname is Il Sargazana after his hometown. This being a collaboration between the artist and
likely Giacomo Leggi, who is a still life and market scene painter, that's when it drove it
home to me that the figures are really quite close. So what I'm arguing is that Leggi did
this painting here in another museum in France, likely collaborated with Fiasella to produce
the painting that we have in our house. Particularly when you look at the face here
in the depiction of Samson and Delilah, this really comes through quite significantly. Also
the use of the drape and the maidservant is another tip-off. Because of the use of the light,
also the wrinkles on the old woman's face, it's quite striking. So from there, I'd like to conclude
briefly with a painting that I've also re-attributed, and this had come again from the gift of
Stuart Houston. It's on view in the lobby of the museum right now. And I've re-attributed it to an
artist named Alexander van Galen, who came from Amsterdam, but actually moved around a bit in
Europe. He worked in the Netherlands, but he eventually would end his career in England
doing commissions for Queen Anne. And he trained under a battle painter named Jan van Ookdenburg.
This painting depicts a very dramatic battle, not of a specific scene in particular,
from historical events, but made up by the artist. These were very popular in the 1600s and even into
the 1700s, because they depicted grand architecture. And in particular, the use of long smoke, the use of
ruins. And in this case, it looks like Europeans clashing with non-Western peoples. In this case,
I'm arguing Ottoman Turks. The fact that it's suggested here that Ottoman Turks bring about
the downfall of Western civilization, hence the ruins. A statue, perhaps, of a goddess,
of a historical figure. We can see figures with turbans who are racing off towards the right here.
It's a very dramatic scene, but it doesn't pinpoint to a specific location. In the 1600s,
you have a lot of the confrontations between the Ottoman Empire and the Europeans, particularly
because the Ottomans were invading Europe. Think of the Siege of Vienna in 1683. You can see how
Galen, the artist I'm looking at, was being influenced by Jan van Ookdenburg, but actually,
the artist has a much looser, sketchier style. Here's another battle scene by him, with the use
of the temple and the architecture on the right-hand side, the long smoke, all the drama.
That's what's led me to believe that we're looking at a different artist. If you compare the two
slides here, you can see that. But, very interestingly, Alexander van Galen, the artist,
also looked at other painters, particularly Philippe Vallermond, who was a Dutch painter,
for inspiration. Vallermond has a much tighter style, which you see here on the left.
Other artists whose work you may have known are included on Yellow Falconet,
who's a Neapolitan artist. Battle scene of the mid-17th century. Another work by somebody in
the circle. Notice the use of the ruined column, very much tying us into the fact that our artist,
Galen, was well aware of these techniques and innovations in battle paintings of the mid-1600s.
Here's Jacques Cotoy with his battle, and you can see the relationship on the right with Galen.
So, thank you for joining me today, and I will look forward to welcoming you back to another
edition of The Curator's Den, in which we're going to look at some other old masters and
see how they relate to the Roman Baroque specifically. Thank you very much, and I hope
that you have a nice weekend.
