Upon further reading these books somewhat distinguish themselves more broadly as covering the time period from the early Renaissance to the Early Baroque period, however both of them are still fairly vague in establishing time periods, and credit the period of the High Renaissance (1500-1508) as spurring those that follow, which is why in the video I generalized it more as the broad Renaissance. The Michelangelo quote scribbled on a drawing of his student's is as follows "Draw Antonio! Draw and don't waste time."
As stated in the video, these books are not the most impressive as far as information goes, so unless you're reading carefully its pretty vague, so if you're interest is learning the history then definitely look elsewhere. I did take another look at the book Florentine Drawings and found that it did have some interesting anecdotes about the term "Disegno" in the introduction, explaining how it was seen as the animating force uniting the different arts as explained by Vasari in his book Lives of the Artists. It also contained an excerpt of a conversation between Pontormo and a man named Benedetto Varchi wherein Varchi asked Pontormo which was more noble, painting or sculpture, to which Pontormo replied that disegno was the only thing noble and an artist possessing that could work equally well in painting or sculpture.
Links to the books: Great Heritage: Renaissance and Baroque Drawings at Chatsworth https://www.ebay.com/p/927769 and
Hi everyone. We are back with another book review video. It has been a while since the last one. I
published on YouTube to the general public. These first go out to newsletter subscribers,
and it's been a minute for them too because, you know, got married, I moved, and now I finally have
a little bit of time to catch up and get into these review videos for you guys again. So I've
changed a little bit how I'm doing these videos. They're still the same. We're still going to have
the format of flipping through and looking at them, but in the past I have flipped through
them and kind of tried to say some historical information, and in the past I've gotten some
of that information from the book and some of it from just my own research, and I've decided to
make it all exclusively from the book. That way it's more comprehensive. That way you're actually
getting a better idea of what content these books hold, you know, like are they, is it going to be
very informative? Is it not? And I think these two books are good examples of that because honestly
I didn't get a lot of good information from them. But that aside, they are good books. They're still
worth going over. So let's go ahead, get started, and I'll show you guys these books. So we're
gonna start this book. It's called Great Heritage Renaissance Drawings from Chatsworth. What that
means is these are all drawings from a specific collection. These were all in the collection of
the Duke of Devonshire. I don't know how to say that. I do apologize for my pronunciations,
but it starts with the Italian drawings in his collection and goes through, let's see,
Italian, German, Flemish, Dutch, and French. So it does have quite a wide variety
of drawings in here, all roughly like renaissance time period though, and I think that's pretty broad
renaissance time period. I don't think it's necessarily focused on too early renaissance or
late renaissance or anything like that. So it's a really beautiful book. It is,
the image quality in this is really good. I don't know how well you can see it with the sun spots.
I do apologize for that. It's the issue of living where there's now a lot of many beautiful trees
cast quite colorful shadows. But it, the image quality is really good, so I can vouch for that.
The one thing that I, honestly the only written thing that the written info talks about is kind
of how the drawing ended up in the Duke's collection. It might go into a little blurb of
like, oh scholars noticed this mark on this drawing, and it might be a sign that the artist,
you know, had another version that they drew darker over, like things like that. You know,
nothing really exciting or groundbreaking, no real technical information. So yeah, written content,
I, it's not a book I'm going to sit down and read. However, it is a book that is really good to sit
down and copy from. So in that sense, I highly recommend it if you are looking to copy renaissance
drawings. So I, I really like it for that reason, but in my new scheme of things to try and create
videos that have our research based off of the books, not of off of online sources. Unfortunately,
I don't have a ton of exciting stuff to say, since the book doesn't have a ton of exciting stuff to
say. As you can see, it does have a blurb about each piece, but I just found it really lacking.
Like it was very scholarly, and it was very dry, and it was honestly like, I will gauge things by
how interesting they are historically, and how interesting they are for an artist. And to be
quite honest, I didn't find this book to be interesting for either, unless you're just
really interested in understanding how the Duke of Devonshire came to own these drawings, which
personally, I don't find that illuminating. But if you're a nerd in that way, then hey,
this is a great book for you. But for an artist, the quality of prints is really, really superb.
If you are an artist who wants to get better at drawing from doing master copies of drawings,
this is a great book to own. So that is what all she wrote. That's all we have.
Okay, so this is a book on Florentine Renaissance drawings.
It is from the High Renaissance to Early Baroque period, so roughly 1500 to 1615,
is the time span of the drawings that we'll be seeing in this book. And that's kind of,
I mean, it's kind of interesting to get the variety of time. I don't know how broad the
time range was on the last book that we looked at, but there was a wide variety in terms of artist
and region. In this one, it's a little bit more focused to a specific region,
but you get a wide variety of time periods and still of Italian artists.
How this book is grouped into it groups into artists. So it has like the section on Raphael,
section on Michelangelo, etc. So you can look up a specific artist's work
in this book if it pertains to the right time period and the right region.
It does, these are all, it's similar to the last book in that these are all from
a specific collection. These are all drawings in the British Museum,
or drawings that were in the British Museum's collection, because this is a slightly older
publication. But really good. I mean, high quality prints, even if they aren't as
all big as the last book. That's probably my only complaint with this one is I find
some of the images kind of small, and that would make it harder to do like a drawing copy from.
But that being said, in the grand scheme of drawing books, it's not bad because I've had
books that are mostly white paper with a teeny tiny drawing in the center. And,
you know, those are far worse and far more frustrating. So yeah, so as far as written
content goes, not very groundbreaking, not very exciting. It is mostly about how,
again, the work ended up in the collection, so the history of the drawing and its exchange of hands,
but not really any kind of exciting information or information about the artist. Maybe alluding
to it here and there, but not really done in a very interesting way. So the one thing that I
really did enjoy about this book is that it talked about a quote on one of the drawings
in here. It didn't say, in the collection, it didn't say whether or not that drawing was in
this book, but it was the, it's a drawing that is done by a student of Michelangelo,
and it, on the paper, it said, draw, Antonio, draw, and don't waste time.
There may be a slight misquote of it. I'll put it in the description,
quoted verbatim, but I thought that was really funny, a really funny quote to have said by
Michelangelo on the page of another artist, and actually a rather valuable quote,
as we should all draw and not waste time. So yeah, so it at least had that. This book at least had
one interesting quote, but otherwise, yeah, it stacks up fairly well against the other one.
Good quality prints. The other one's slightly better for copying just due to the amount of
large prints, but if your thing is more Italian Renaissance drawings, especially Florentine
Renaissance drawings, then this is the better, better pick for you. So I think that brings us
to the end. I hope you guys enjoyed going through this with me. I find them very good for reference,
very good for copying, even if the written content isn't as exciting. Next time, we're
going to go through two really interesting books with really interesting written content.
One with slightly less good image quality, but it's still worth showing, and I'll show you what
I mean next video. So if you're interested, stay tuned for that one, and I'll see you next time.