Rep. Mike Waltz Presses Generals on Biden's Disastrous Afghanistan Withdrawal
Chair recognizes Mr. Waltz.
Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you for the witnesses for coming in.
I got to tell you, Mr. Chairman, the more I listen to this hearing, the more infuriated
I get.
And I know the Gold Star family sitting here have to feel the same way.
I know every veteran watching today has to feel the same way, because it's not about
us.
It's about them.
And I think what upsets them most, General Milley, General McKenzie, are some of the
statements from the president during this evacuation, including an interview that the
president gave on national television during the withdrawal on August 18th, saying the
generals never advised me to leave 2500 and the only air base, Bagram Air Base, in the
world sandwiched between China, Russia, Iran, and a platform to stay after counterterrorism.
General Milley, is that an accurate statement, that the generals never advised him to leave
a stay-behind force to keep a lid on half the world's terrorist organizations?
I will tell you what my thoughts were at the time, my assessment at the time.
Let me just say, you testified today, you both testified repeatedly that you advised
the National Command Authority we should leave a stay-behind force, including the base.
Did President Trump leave that stay-behind force despite his stated desire to get everybody
out because the Taliban didn't meet the conditions?
When the administration's changed hands, there were 2500 soldiers and that was a decision.
And you've stated today you didn't advise Biden to pull everybody out, you advised him
to stay.
That's correct.
So that's an inaccurate statement, but let's go down the list here.
Let's go back to July of 2021.
President Biden, there's a likelihood, the likelihood there's going to be the Taliban
overrunning everything and owning the whole country is highly unlikely.
Does that comport with your knowledge at the time?
In fact, you just a few weeks later said Kabul would be surrounded in 30 to 60 days.
My assessment at the time was if we went to zero in U.S. military forces, then there was
a high likelihood of a collapse of the government of Afghanistan and the ANSF with the Taliban
taking over.
Would collapse.
But I thought it was going to be, I personally thought it was going to be in the fall, somewhere
around Thanksgiving.
The assessments vary widely.
We're talking within months.
Within months of our withdrawal.
That's correct.
The next one, there's going to be no circumstance where you see people being lifted off the
roof of an embassy in an embassy of the United States from Afghanistan.
It's not at all comparable with Saigon.
I think this picture proves that not to be the case.
Fair enough.
Joe Biden, July 8th, 2021.
Next one, Americans should understand we're going to try to get it all done before August
31st.
And if you're an American, if there's American citizens left, we're going to stay to get
them all out.
Was that your understanding of the operational planning at the time, to stay beyond August
31st?
Or were you planning to get out by August 31st?
We're planning to get out by August 31st.
Last, but perhaps the most egregious.
We believe about 100 to 200 Americans remain in Afghanistan with some intention to leave.
You both testified today, you just testified, General Milley, that it was impossible to
know the number.
In fact, is that accurate?
It was very difficult to know the number.
Very difficult.
And I don't think the numbers were accurate.
Yet the State Department's revised that number since to nearly 1000 Americans left behind.
Look, in July of 2021, Bagram is closing.
We're withdrawing our four-star commander, General Milley.
Ghani is visiting President Biden, practically begging us to at least leave our contractors
and some little bit of air support.
General McKenzie, you've testified that you were so concerned in July of 2021 that you
put up recommendations, including lily pads to get our allies out, putting pieces in place
to process our SIVs faster, putting measures in place to get our American citizens out,
to get our allies out, and to take care of what American military should do, which is
protecting all Americans.
And you were so concerned in July of 2021, you put those recommendations forward.
That's what you've testified today.
That's correct.
And in fact, also, the diplomats on the ground, Mr. Chairman, sent a dissent cable, 23 diplomats,
saying if you continue down this road, disaster will ensue.
Was that dissent cable shared with either of you?
This is a formal channel going to the Secretary of State himself.
Was that shared with you as the chairman of the Joint Chiefs?
Was that shared with you as the commander?
I've never seen it.
I didn't see it at the time, and I haven't seen it since, and I would like to see that
dissent.
I think the American people would like to see that.
Chairman, here's my question for you.
Do you know where the Secretary of State was on August 13th, the day before Kabul fell?
Do you know where the Secretary of State was?
Despite all of your concerns, State Department wasn't planning fast enough.
We weren't getting our people out.
According to the Washington Post, he was in the Hamptons.
He was in the Hamptons on vacation.
Secretary of State Blinken.
I don't know.
I can't even imagine how that makes our Gold Star families feel.
Here's the bottom line, Mr. Chairman, and thank you for your indulgence.
I'll close with this.
The State Department, to use a military term, had its head up its rear.
It wasn't planning.
It in fact thought we could just have an embassy and the good Taliban terrorists will take
care of the bad Taliban terrorists.
I mean, that's essentially what happened, and because of that, we didn't get our people
out.
We didn't get our citizens out.
We didn't have the forced posture.
We didn't have the facing.
We failed, and their loved ones are dead because of it.
I apologize to you, to my Gold Star families.
Your government failed you.
There is a difference, gentlemen, and I know you both know this, in taking responsibility
and accountability.
A lot of people have taken responsibility.
No one has been held accountable, and they deserve better.
Your government failed you, and I'll give you an opportunity in my time remaining, Mr.
Chairman, if there's anything you all would like to say publicly on the record.
I'll give the witnesses time to respond, but the time has expired.
Thank you, Mr. Chair.
The gentleman's, they have a right to respond.
Well, I'd like to take you up on that offer.
I've talked to these families.
And I thank you for that.
And I've met the other families, and I have committed to them, and I will do so again
publicly to all of you, that I will work with them to get you the answers, to make sure
that accountability, transparency is established, and I'm going to do that until the day I go
in the grave.
That's what a soldier does, and I'm not going to turn my back on these families or any other
Gold Star families.
There are other Gold Star families in this room right now.
Jane Horton's in this room.
I've been working with her for years.
There's many others, and they know who I am, and I will work with them forever.
They deserve accountability, Mr. Chairman, and thank you, General Miller.

