Design in Mind | Unlocking the Mysteries of Place with Gil Shafer

Nature House
39 followers
Award-winning architect Gil Schafer, a leading practitioner of contemporary classical design, examines how he draws upon the power of memory to create extraordinary homes. At the height of his craft, Gil leads viewers through three spaces that exemplify his work: his firm’s renovated design studio in Manhattan, a Hudson Valley home inspired by English estates, and a summer house on the shores of Lake Champlain. Influenced by the elegance and charm of classical American architecture, and also adept at accommodating a modern lifestyle in his designs, he reflects on his design process and the particular qualities that define an unforgettable place.
#Architecture #Naturehouse
Comments are disabled for this video.
Residential architecture, maybe more so than a lot of other kinds of architecture, is so
personal.
The ultimate goal is to give your client a house that has a sense of place.
There's your site.
You want the house to have a sense of inevitability about how it sits on the land.
Do you want it to feel like it had always been there?
Do you also want it to feel like it belongs in the larger context in which it's set?
To understand the architectural traditions of a given place.
Memory is something that I think comes out when you start to work with a client.
I had such powerful childhood experiences of places and architecture, and I think that's
true for a lot of people, that buildings from their past resonate with them, and it's
important for us to pay attention to that, and then to find ways to manifest it.
I'm Gil Schaefer.
My firm is called G.P.
Schaefer Architect.
Our work is rooted in classical and vernacular traditions of American architecture.
We've been in an office in Soho for, I don't know, probably 15 years, and we grew out of
it, and so we tried to find a space that was in a neighborhood that felt like a neighborhood.
This space has this great overlook onto Union Square, sort of right at the treetops.
It's a wonderful place to be, because the scale of this part of town is very human scale.
It's very walkable, and it's in Greenwich Village, which I've always loved.
I lived in the village for many years.
It's a kind of microcosm of New York.
I think architects, when they make their own space, they want to obviously express something
about the work that they do, so I thought it was important to create, at least in part
of the space, an environment that clients could relate to as being somewhat domestic.
There's a sense of proportion and scale and architectural detail, making it feel tailored,
the way our work is.
The back of the office really needs to be very functional and organized around all the
different studios, and then running right down the middle of it like a spine is our
library, which is sort of the backbone of, literally and figuratively, of what we do.
When you're in architecture school, you're kind of led to believe that you do it all
on your own.
You know, it's that myth of the sort of hero architect, the lone genius, which of course
is not at all true, right?
It takes many, many people to create a building, and that's what's so kind of funny about the
Fountainhead, you know, where there's this heroic character who designs these buildings
all by himself at his drafting table.
Nobody is really Howard Roark.
I think it's so important to surround yourself with the most talented people that you can.
When you start with a new client, you work up a program, as you call it, for their house.
How many rooms?
What kinds of rooms?
When are you going to use the house?
How does their family live?
And then you draw very schematic, conceptual drawings about how the different rooms relate
to one another.
The team will come and we'll review all of this material, looking at both historic precedent,
because pretty much everything we do has some foundation in historic precedent, and then
how we are adapting that to the rooms and spaces that we are creating.
We look at a lot of options, and then you begin to turn that gradually into architecture.
From a very young age, I was always building things.
I was definitely a kid very much wired to being an architect.
I had a somewhat peripatetic childhood.
I spent a lot of time on a farm in a rural part of New Jersey, but my parents divorced
when I was young, and my dad moved into New York City.
We also moved out to Southern California and lived in this crazy beach shack on the coast
just south of Santa Barbara, and we had this house with this wacky glass garage door that
would kind of roll up onto the ceiling and open up the whole room to the beach.
We even lived for a time in the Bahamas, and I had a grandmother who had this house in
Southern Georgia that was actually painted pink, and I think that's where I got a sense
that houses didn't need to be opulent to be elegant.
I think it gave me a sense of how you live differently in different places and the kind
of architecture that you find in each of those places.
I also had a grandfather, actually my namesake, who was an architect.
He had a fairly large firm in Cleveland, Ohio, and he himself was the grandson of an architect.
And then I had parents who were always building things.
There was always some sort of building project going on when I was growing up.
I have a kind of almost Proustian reaction to the smell of timber studs and fresh paint,
so I think I was set very early on a track to being an architect.
It probably was inevitable.
After college, where I really focused on architectural history, I went into architecture school,
and when I got to Yale at that time, which was the mid-80s, I quickly learned that not
all of that was thought of as architecture.
I get to one of my very first reviews.
I had done this, what I thought was somewhat modern, but nevertheless symmetrical facade.
The critic got up and looked at my project and he said, what is this symmetry?
Why is this symmetrical?
Symmetry is for dogs.
This project is for dogs.
And it was incredibly shocking because I hadn't really realized that architecture would be
so limited or so defined.
I loved my time at Yale.
I got an amazing education, but it wasn't really an education in things that are very
much central to my work now.
In my last semester, I was lucky to place into a studio with an architect named Bernard
Schumey who was connected to a group of what they called deconstructivist architects.
His philosophy of architecture was that life was chaotic, full of accidents and happenstance
and that architecture could and should relate to that somehow and maybe even express that
and celebrate it.
He was an up-and-coming star architect at the time and it was very exciting to get into
his studio.
At the end of it, he asked me and another guy from my class to come work for him in
New York.
I fairly quickly realized that this was the kind of architecture, while it was really
interesting, my soul wasn't in it and I needed to switch gears completely.
I remember seeing a cover story in Architectural Digest of this brand new house that was built
in Palm Beach with Bunny Williams as the designer and Mark Ferguson as the architect.
I thought, oh my God, I want to go work for these people because they're just trying to
do something that really looks at history but makes a building that's livable now.
Ferguson Murray and Shamomian was a wonderful place to be.
It's where I got my second advanced degree, I think, in architecture in the sense of learning
finally about classicism.
And then later, a landscape designer friend of mine named Debra Nevins came to me and
she said, I'm doing a vegetable garden and they want to build a potting shed.
So I started my practice doing the most simple building, which was a sort of 15 foot by 20
foot potting shed and then a very small guest cottage up in Sharon, Connecticut and then
my own house, which I had just started to design.
I've always been interested in historic buildings and I found when I built my own house, where
I was trying to find an old house to live in and then couldn't and so built one as best
I could that had the feeling of an old house, I've discovered that that really resonated
with people.
I thought, well, can we retain some of the authenticity and essence of those historic
houses but make it work for the way you want to live now?
And I think that's what we really work on every day in my practice.
I've known this part of New York for more than 40 years.
I went to high school up here and then about 20 years ago, built a house for myself not
too far from where we're standing in the northern part of Dutchess County.
And so I was very excited when a couple contacted me a few years ago to design a new house for
them on some farmland that they bought up here.
The property is made up of several farm fields that string together and rise up a hillside.
And I think what attracted them to it is that it's very much like the English countryside
with the rolling fields, hedgerows, old stone walls.
It has a wonderfully romantic quality.
My clients are an American couple, but they had lived in England for a number of years.
So they were looking to build a weekend house that would eventually become their full-time
residence.
Farmland is an interesting and challenging site for a new house because there's a lot
of openness and usually not something that's going to anchor the house into the land.
The clients had spent time on the land before we first met.
They were really keen to build on the top of the property.
And so we walked up that steep hill to the top with Debbie Nevins, the landscape designer.
And there is a spectacular view, but she immediately said, you can't build the house here.
In addition to the fact that there would be no sort of level land on which to set a house
and create a kind of precinct for it, the driveway up there would have been tremendously
difficult to build.
And so instead, we thought it would sit much more comfortably lower down on the slope.
And what was interesting to me about that was that there was also this wonderful stand
of trees and that had a kind of sense of place that I always look for.
Because the clients had this really strong sense of what English country houses looked
and felt like, they'd actually lived in one, that immediately gave me some ideas about
what it could be stylistically, rooted in the 18th century, early 19th century Georgian
Palladian traditions of the English country house.
And we settled on something that was very centered, very formal and symmetrical.
A lot of these houses in England are made of stone, cut stone.
And I felt like that was going to be much too formal for this environment.
And so that led me to think about a local field stone, because it would have some of
the tonality of the land here.
Also houses that are cubic can easily have very plain exterior walls.
So we wanted to create some undulation in the surfaces of the wall to create visual
interest and hierarchy.
There's a tremendous tradition of 19th century architecture in the Hudson Valley, much of
it Greek revival, but also Gothic revival.
And that extends from very elaborate houses that overlook the Hudson to much more vernacular
farmhouses that you find where we are, which is about 45 minutes from the Hudson River.
I thought it would be interesting to try and weave some of that character into this design.
And so the portico is a Greek Doric entry portico.
There's a Greek key detail on the entablature frieze that actually allows for venting for
the HVAC systems in the house.
All of our molding shapes, like the pilasters on the bay windows or the pilasters in the
south facade, are really Grecian rather than Roman Georgian classical, all which seemed
to me very appropriate for this place.
Once we settled on the idea that we needed to move the site of the house farther down
the meadow, we still had the issue of the slope to contend with.
We then created a courtyard on this north side of the house, anchored by four sycamore
trees, these two garden pavilions that would actually hold back the hillside, hedges of
clipped hornbeam to connect the two pavilions, and long grass steps gently rising up from
the courtyard to a small lawn terrace with a bench that overlooks the court, flanked
by two mulberry trees.
So it creates a distinction between the more formal courtyard and the wilder farm meadow,
but at the same time reconnects it to that landscape.
Because of the way we were essentially terracing the land now, the lawn on the south side of
the house is actually raised above the meadow below it, and it creates a kind of stone plinth
on which the house and its surrounding gardens sit.
English country houses often did this, and they called it a ha-ha.
From the downhill side, it's a kind of wall so that sheep or cattle couldn't actually
walk up to the lawn in front of the house, and it's invisible from the uphill side.
On the west side of the house, Debbie created this hemicycle hedge that completely obscures
your view of the driveway and creates this wonderful space.
And then on the east side, there's a pergola that overlooks the big meadows and is a wonderful
place to sit and eat.
What is fun about making an architecture like this that has these different outbuildings,
garden walls, and discrete garden spaces is that it creates a little bit of mystery and
adventure, and that's particularly fun if you're a kid.
I know from my own experiences visiting my grandmother's house and wandering in her gardens
and getting on my bike and discovering things just over the hill or around the corner.
That's a wonderful basis for creating memories, and that was something that I thought was
really fun here.
The doorbell is another thing that's very English and another way that we try to tie
our work into the lives of the people who live here.
In the end, a house like this looks quite formal, and of course, the models that we
base the architecture on are very formal.
The beauty of this project is that the clients have a wonderfully understated, informal character
that beautifully balances the formality of the architecture.
We had a fairly straightforward plan because the house is basically a cube.
We knew we were going to have a center hall with rooms that radiated around it.
And it's a fairly small house compared to English country houses that we were looking
to.
In those houses, the kitchen is usually miles away from the public rooms, the dining room,
the living room.
But of course, that's not the way we live today.
And so we moved the kitchen into the center core of the house so that the life of the
house can encompass all of the rooms.
The stair hall ends up being the most architecturally impactful space because of its height.
So we came up with the idea of making the space an oval.
In a traditional English country house, the staircases were often made of stone.
Here we did it in wood, but we wanted to have the character of those stone staircases.
So we cantilevered the treads out from the wall and continued all the way around to reinforce
the shape of the room, and in turn, the shape of the skylight above.
And because this is the most architecturally exuberant space in the house, it has the most
decoration.
And you see that in the design of the stair itself, with its thin colonnades for the stair
balusters, the mahogany handrail, a pair of columns that frame the entry into the primary
suite of the house.
Also inspired by English houses, we knew that we wanted to have a stone floor.
And it has a design of blocks of limestone with black marble as accents.
And then even in the skylight, with the Greek key border, which also works as a component
of the air conditioning system, and repeats the motif that you find on the outside of
the house.
As a classical architect, you're always looking to understand the language of classicism and
the moldings that articulate the architecture that you're making.
We were looking to English regency houses from the early 19th century, and the pattern
book that guided the design of the moldings for those houses, which have a very Grecian
influence to them, which ties nicely to the Greek revival that we tried to articulate
on the exterior of the house.
Decoration is equally important to reinforce the overall effect.
For this project, the clients worked with Thomas Jane, the decorator from New York.
I think that what makes a house like this not feel too formal is the life that's lived
within its walls.
They live in every room.
There's kids running around.
It's filled with people all the time.
All of this infuses architecture with life.
Memories of places can work as a kind of homing beacon on people, and that was certainly true
of this place for my clients.
The husband grew up in this region, which is nestled on Lake Champlain in northern Vermont.
He used to camp around here on the islands that are just off the shore.
The land really resonated with him, and pulled on him over the course of his life, and finally
pulled him back.
About 25 years ago, they bought this property, and then they held on to it for a long time
until they reached out to me and to my colleague, Debra Nevins, to come up with some ideas about
what they might build here.
It was fairly rough land.
It was wooded.
It was boggy, and so Debra Nevins needed to really make something of that, which I think
she did.
And part of that was in opening it up a little bit and creating some meadows so that there
was a contrast between a sense of enclosure and then openness.
What was ingenious about her approach, I think, was not just an opening up the meadow, but
then to create these different zones and areas in the land.
It needed not to feel overly contrived.
It needed to feel natural.
It needed to feel wild.
But at the same time, it needed to be shaped.
When Debbie and I first came to this property with our clients, they took us to see the
Shelburne Museum, which was the creation of Electra Havemeyer Webb, who had married a
descendant of the Vanderbilt family.
She had fallen in love with this land and the buildings of the region, and she was inspired
to create a collection of historic buildings, principally Vermont buildings, but also from
other areas in New England, and bring them together to create a kind of idyllic vision
to showcase the architecture of the region, but also exhibit her growing collection of
folk art and Americana.
The museum has a tremendous number of buildings dating back from the 18th and 19th centuries.
There's a lighthouse.
There's a railroad station.
There's an extraordinary round barn.
And then, of course, the Ticonderoga, which was a steamboat that ran up and down Lake
Champlain, which was fun to see because, actually, my client's father had worked on
that boat as a young man when it was still on the lake.
I remember visiting the museum when I was a young architect and being completely blown
away by what I had seen there, and it was such a treat to come back to it again because
it's such a tremendous resource, both architecturally and in terms of the landscape.
And we thought that it was really a wonderful inspiration for the work that we were about
to embark on together to reflect on the way that the buildings engage with the land.
The house we designed was for a couple with a large family, and there are always a lot
of people here, which is wonderful.
Very quickly, it became clear that we needed to have a way for larger groups to gather,
to have a meal where 20 people sit around a table, which was really important to this
family.
And that gave rise to the idea of maybe there could be a barn that could engage the site
in a different way.
When we visited the Shelburne Museum, we were particularly struck by the Vermont House,
one of the earliest structures brought to the museum.
The stone has a bold, graphic pattern, which I thought was a little bit unusual.
Our clients loved it, and it became the inspiration for the stonework that you find at the house,
but also we wanted to carry that into the outbuilding so that there was continuity from
building to building.
Given the kind of agrarian character of this region, it seemed natural that we would look
to barn forms.
We wanted the stone part to have classic proportions, and then I wanted the two wings, one of which
holds a little kitchen and the other a bathroom and a little entry, to be mismatched like
barns that grow over time and get added onto as needed, as opposed to something that had
been so perfectly symmetrical.
What's unique about this land is that it wraps around a point.
One of the reasons you want to be in this place is that engagement with the lake, that
sense of being on the water.
Creating that engagement with the view is going to be a very important part of how we
solve the design of this building.
One thing that's different but inspired by barns is the big opening in the middle.
Normally that would be large sliding wood doors.
In this case, we made these enormous glass doors that can pocket completely into the
thickness of the walls so that the building can become completely open air in the warmer
months.
While the inspiration for this building on its exterior was Vermont barns, on the interior
our clients wanted us to look to something a little different.
The wife is of Norwegian and German descent, and she thought it would be interesting if
the interior had a little more of a European feel to it.
We found in doing research that while American barns often have trusses that are fairly flat,
in European barns you find more curved timbered members.
And then in terms of the rest of the architecture for the space, we wanted to bring the stone
from the exterior into the building to make these strong chimney breasts at either end
of the room.
These materials, the wood, the stone, have a kind of tactile character to them, and we
thought that in the decoration of the interior it was important to somehow pick up on that.
And so we used a lot of linen.
That big long table is made from several pieces of 17 foot long timbers.
We found the bullseye mirrors over the fireplaces in England that came out of a railway station
in Prague.
So we had a lot of fun hunting for things.
My client is the daughter of an antiques dealer, and as a consequence she was very engaged
in this whole process and was as much a part of the entire collaboration as any of the
members of the design team.
So that became a very rich dynamic in the whole design process.
When you design a house for somebody, it's a fairly intimate experience.
You get to know your clients, and you get to know their families.
And then when you're done, you leave a little piece of yourself behind, and it's very gratifying
to be able to come back years later and see how the building has settled into the land
and how the family has settled into living in the place.
I often laugh with my clients that you don't need television when you're here because you
have this spectacular display.
It's a really wonderful reminder of why you do this as an architect.
You find yourself tapping into memories, but you also have an opportunity and kind of a
responsibility to create an environment where they can have experiences together that they
remember for the rest of their lives.
