An Italian Tries CATHY MITCHELL's Pasta Recipes (it didn't go well)

Italian Dishes
155 followers
Comments are disabled for this video.
Have you ever heard of Kathy Mitchell?
Hi, Kathy Mitchell here with my new dump dinner cookbook.
I bet a lot of you have probably seen her infomercials.
That's kind of what she's famous for.
She was like a TV personality
who wrote a bunch of cookbooks,
which actually I sort of collect, weirdly.
I've been slightly obsessed with her for a long time
because I find her to be fascinating and entertaining.
This is pita bread,
and it tastes almost exactly like pizza crust.
Her whole thing is trying to make cheap, affordable,
quick, and easy dinners for families,
which is an admirable goal.
She's done some cooking appliances,
various different sort of cooking gadgets, stuff like that,
but what she's most famous for are her dump cookbooks.
Now just dump and bake for full meals in minutes.
Yes, dump cookbooks.
This is a classic, quick and easy dump dinners.
Another example is dump cakes and more.
The basic concept with her recipes
is that these are dishes that generally only use
one sort of casserole dish or pot or pan,
and the recipes are designed
so that you have just a few ingredients
that you literally just dump
into whatever this pot or pan is, and then just cook it.
So there's not a lot of prep work or anything.
It's just literally dump and cook.
I've been checking out her cookbooks for a while now,
but have never actually tried any of her food,
and I finally decided that it's time to do so.
Specifically, what I want to take a look at today
are some of the pasta recipes in dump dinners,
but I'm not gonna cook them myself.
I have a better idea.
So, I have all of your ingredients here
that you need for the first dish.
So, what I have in front of me is some ground beef.
This is Italian dressing.
It's Italian dressing seasoning.
For me, it doesn't make any difference.
By the way, and here we have some shredded mozzarella.
Mm-hmm. Mozzarella.
Here we have some ricotta cheese.
Here I have a jar of marinara sauce.
Here there is a package of penne lisce,
and I don't know why the brand decided
to call them mostaccioli.
Yeah, the recipe called for penne,
so I couldn't resist mostaccioli pasta.
So, based on everything you have here in front of you,
what do you think you're going to be making?
Okay, we have meat, we have sauce, we have ricotta,
we have cheese, pasta.
It's pasta forno.
Baked pasta?
Si.
Why are you laughing?
It's hard to explain because you're sort of right,
and you're sort of wrong.
What you're going to be making today is lasagna.
And where is the lasagna?
How can I make a lasagna without lasagna
when I make a lasagna with penne?
Well, see, this is called a skillet lasagna.
Skillet?
Yeah, you're going to cook lasagna with penne,
for some reason, in a pan.
That is not a lasagna.
It's not also pasta forno.
I don't know what it is.
Heat a medium skillet over medium heat.
Add the ground beef and Italian dressing packet.
So this is a fat-free recipe.
I don't have to put any oil, nothing.
It says nothing about adding oil to the pan.
So just the meat?
Yeah.
Like it is?
Yeah.
Sugar, because how we can make sugar in a plate of pasta?
Sugar, salt, sodium citrate, garlic, onion,
spice, red bell peppers, carrots,
some thyme gum, maltodextrina, parsley,
war gum, natural flavor, soy sauce.
No salt?
Well, there's salt in that packet.
Ah, yes, it's the second ingredient, after sugar.
Cook until beef is no longer pink.
Add the water and pasta.
It already looks really delicious.
It looks great.
It doesn't look great after, it doesn't look great.
And it doesn't smell great.
When you cook the ground meat, the ground beef,
whatever, because you want to make a sauce,
the smell of the soffritto is one of the best smell in life.
But here, it's that.
Bring to a boil and reduce the heat to medium low.
Cover and cook for 10 minutes until pasta is tender.
There is no salt, it tastes weird,
but the cooking time is okay.
Add the sauce, stir in the cheese,
and it's through.
Yeah, which kind of cheese is this?
So, yeah, you got to add all that.
All? All of it, the whole jar.
Then, cheese.
Look, I'm not going to try this thing.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no.
To everything in life, there is a limit.
And here, I reached my limit.
This is just the first one.
I don't care, it's like my limit.
There's much more to come.
I'm sorry to inform you.
I reached my limit already with this.
I'm not going to try it.
This is the one I thought you might like the most.
What, Alfredo?
I'm feeling sick.
Why, it looks great, Eva.
It doesn't look great, Alfredo.
Do you want to try it?
I don't.
Don't you feel like you're back home?
Absolutely not, Alfredo.
Sunday lunch.
That is my hell.
I'm trying to mix it.
What is it, more I mix?
Oh my God.
I thought that I saw everything in my life
in all these four, five years, but no.
Oh no, here we are touching little that.
Serve.
And now what I need to do is like, it's...
You just got to heat it and then serve it.
It's basically ready to serve.
But look.
I know.
How?
I mean, at least it looks like the lasagna.
No, it doesn't look like a lasagna.
It doesn't look like anything edible.
It's the first time in my life
that I'm sitting in front of something.
And the only thing that I want to do is run away.
It's really...
Not the first time.
You've wanted to run away many times before.
I want to run away.
I understand.
And it's like this, maybe, maybe.
And the way it smell and the way it looks, believe me.
It does smell...
Bad.
Very bad.
You know, it's, yeah, it's...
And it looks even worse.
I really don't get why it's called lasagna.
There's nothing about it
that even remotely resembles lasagna.
And it's kind of weird
because if you're making like dump and bake recipes...
At least bake it.
Well, like also lasagna kind of works for that,
even though it's not the best way to cook lasagna.
You can, if you have a liquid enough sauce,
just layer in raw pasta.
And so you could easily, in a casserole dish,
just like dump some lasagna things and bake it
and it would sort of work.
I don't know why this is the lasagna,
but so I got both forks and spoons
because I wasn't sure which was more appropriate.
Because that's so super because I'm sick.
So I need a spoon.
No, it's a...
All right.
Should we try it?
Should I have a try?
Anyway, you put all of this time and effort
into making this.
You should at least try it.
No, try it.
Try it, you know.
Get some of the sauce.
Get some of the meat.
I can eat the pasta depending with the spoon.
It's bueno.
It's bueno depending you eat it with a spoon.
Get in there.
Now that I understand,
I need to take a little bit of the sauce.
Yeah, there you go.
Okay.
Buon appetito.
No, not buon appetito.
Also you can.
No, it's really...
Also you can.
One thing good to do is...
Actually, she nailed the cooking time of the pasta.
The cook time of the pasta.
Yes, the pasta is perfectly cooked.
The cook time of the pasta.
The pasta is perfectly cooked.
It's al dente.
And for this, I can't tell her anything bad.
But for all the rest, even, I don't know,
it's like even a miracle I can see this.
It's pretty rough.
It's very bad.
Yeah.
It's sweet, acidic, no salt, no flavor.
You have all these elements
that they are not combined in between them.
So then you don't really understand what you're eating.
Can you imagine if this was like
just a good bolognese sauce with just a good sofrito,
some just normal tomatoes,
not a jar of prego sauce,
which just has that awful, awful taste of...
With a real parmigiano.
Yeah.
With some good cheese.
Yeah.
In this moment, we were enjoying life.
It would be really good.
Okay.
So, off to a great start here today.
Well, maybe you'll like the next pasta a little bit better.
Cathy Mitchell dish number two.
Can you guess, judging from this array of ingredients
I've prepared for you, what you will be making today?
So, what we have here is fettuccine.
Not real egg-fresh fettuccine,
the like store-bought fettuccine,
which for reasons that you'll see soon,
I'm pretty sure that's what she means.
Garlic powder.
Our beloved Italian seasoning, dressing.
A cup of white onion, chopped.
This amazing shredded mozzarella.
And here we have
petit diced tomatoes in juice.
So, cubed tomatoes in juice.
Here we have some cooked sausage.
I assume they are pork sausage.
And here we have some chicken stock.
Now, just to give you a clue, you need all of that.
All of this?
The whole thing.
This actually is the element of the ingredient
that doesn't make me really understand
what I'm going to do, what I'm going to cook.
Because until here, I can imagine.
But what this has to do with all the rest,
actually, I don't know.
Does it help you figure out what you're doing
if you know that you need two bags
of chopped, frozen spinach?
Even less, Albert.
You're going to be making something called
Italian fettuccine pot.
Bring the stock to a rolling boil in a large pot.
Add the pasta, and then the tomatoes, spinach,
onion, garlic powder, and seasoning.
So, we need all the package, right?
The whole thing.
And before you put it in,
she specifically says that you need to break it in half.
This is something that it should be bent
from an old one teaspoon.
Yeah.
This?
Yes.
There?
Yes.
Aye.
Because how we can miss our Italian seasoning?
Well, then otherwise it wouldn't taste Italian.
So, do you know what it looks to me?
Like that big pot of, like, the wizard?
It's the same.
Can I stir?
Yeah.
This is an ananas boba, Albert.
So, this is worse than a mappazzone.
If you call this a mappazzone, it's a compliment.
Ananas boba.
No salt, nothing?
Nope.
Like that?
Nope.
No oil?
Nope.
No butter, nothing?
Nope.
Ananas boba.
Boom.
Cover and boil for one minute.
Reduce the heat to medium and continue cooking
for 15 minutes, stirring every three, four minutes.
The smell is unbelievable good.
And I'm very sad.
But food makes me sad.
Smells so garlic.
I love the smell of garlic, the bad smell of garlic.
The smell of garlic powder.
It's terrible.
It's like something unbelievable disgusting.
So, I guess this one is literally meant to be a soup.
Soup?
Look at it.
I understand that.
How can you eat this in a soup?
Well, that's why she has you break them in half.
But it's still too long.
So, you're saying that Kathy Mitchell
should have had you break the pasta even more.
At least go big or go home.
You know, we have also in Italy,
we break the spaghetti when we eat, for example, the soup.
But we break the spaghetti in pieces like that,
that you can actually take with a spoon.
Not like that, in half.
When the pasta is cooked,
stir in the cooked sausages and cheese.
So, the one before looked very bad.
But this, look, even worse.
Mamma mia.
Even if Harper, you want to give me a million dollars,
I'm not going to try it.
You've got to try it.
I don't, Harper.
What if it's really good?
More than I possibly.
You don't eat just with the mouth.
You eat also with the eyes.
You eat also with the nose.
Here is like, the mouth, the nose, and the eyes,
they are completely destroyed.
Mine are on strike today.
Yeah, it's ready!
This is an actual soup.
The other one was soupy.
This one is a soup.
This is not a soup,
because a soup you could eat with a spoon.
I challenge you to eat this with a fork.
You can't eat with a fork,
because of how you take the sauce.
If you're willing to eat with a fork, it's not possible.
Okay, I'm starting to regret this.
No, it's like, they're regretting.
Mamma mia, you should be the only one to try this.
It's just fettuccine, just in like, water.
All right, let's do this.
Let's do this.
With what?
Let's do the fork.
Is that really with a fork?
Yeah, we'll eat the pasta with the fork.
But then you don't try the sauce with the fork.
What am I supposed to do?
Buon appetito!
No, no.
No, that's bad.
That one's bad.
I'm so sorry, but it's like,
did you swallow?
Yes, I swallowed.
Thank you, yes.
It's not even for human conception.
It's like, my opinion.
It sort of tastes like if you cooked just pasta,
bland, without any salt,
in like, the leftover water in a sink
after you've washed the dishes.
You know what I mean?
No!
You've never tried that before?
No.
You don't know what that tastes like?
No!
It's what I imagine that would taste like.
Like, just sort of dirty water that has scraps.
Harper, you are not helping me.
I already have in the nose the smell of the garlic
that will never go away.
All it's missing is some soap,
which actually might improve the flavor.
Maybe, yeah.
Some dish soap.
That one's really bad.
I thought the last one was bad,
but this makes the last one actually seem-
No, that was Star Michelin.
Yeah, yeah.
Like, the other one was Star Michelin compared to this.
Okay.
I've got one more.
And it's-
I'm divorcing it.
So guys, the pasta grammar ended here
because I can't take another think of all this.
Okay.
Third Kathy Mitchell dish.
I don't see any sauce.
I don't know what is this.
That is vegetable oil.
Olive oil?
No, vegetable oil.
So here's the thing.
In order to make this particular Kathy Mitchell dish,
you need cooked pasta,
whereas everything up till now you used raw pasta.
However, we are going to cook the pasta
according to Kathy Mitchell's
how to cook pasta instructions.
Okay.
Bring water to a boil.
No, no, no, no, no.
No salt.
I put the pasta with salt?
Yes, no salt.
Add pasta and cook until done
according to the package direction.
I think you're actually broken.
Today I'm not broken.
Today I am.
Now you're laughing.
I feel sick and you're laughing.
Drain.
Toss with the oil and allow to cool.
Allow to cool.
Pasta.
When cool,
store in plastic freezer bags
in one or two cup portion.
Store in the fridge for a week.
You have to cook the pasta for a week.
When needed, you can either reheat the pasta
for a minute in a pot of boiling water
or toss the pasta in a skillet dish to reheat.
Yes, I can't do that.
Okay, now we're ready to actually cook the dish.
So what we have here is cooked pasta.
We have salt.
And cold.
Shredded chicken.
Here we have chunky blue cheese dressing.
We have some Tabasco.
A cup of shredded mozzarella cheese.
And this is cream of celery.
Cream of celery.
Condensed cream of celery soup.
I actually had never heard of that.
I still don't know what it is,
but that's what it called for.
So that's what I got.
My first thought, looking at all this,
it's cold pasta, so you're making a pasta salad.
Not quite.
What you'll be making now is a buffalo chicken casserole.
You like buffalo chicken wings, right?
I love buffalo chicken wings.
But I don't know what they have to do with this.
Preheat oven to 350 degrees.
Spray a casserole dish with cooking spray.
Combine everything except for half of the shredded cheese
in a large bowl.
What is it?
I don't even know what it is.
I don't know.
You ask me?
What does it taste like?
Taste it.
No, no.
I'll taste it.
Oh, you're gonna love that.
Cement.
It's cement.
What do you?
Oh.
On the plus side,
this is the first one that isn't super watery.
Maybe it's super dry.
So dry that it's glow.
Pour mixture into casserole dish.
Top with leftover cheese.
Bake for 25 minutes until casserole is hot and bubbly.
25 minutes are gone.
As you can see, there is no bubbles involved
because this pasta is so dry that how can get bubbling?
I don't know.
But this is the result.
This is the last one.
I promise, this is the last one.
Because I can't really handle a fourth.
I know.
I've pushed you beyond your limit today, I think.
This needs to be the last one.
Now, credit where credit is due,
this, out of everything we've tried today, looks the best.
It's not so difficult.
Not that it takes a lot.
It's not, like, the first one was really soupy
and I don't think it was supposed to be.
The second one looks like pasta floating in garbage water.
This at least looks like...
This looks like a little bit anemic because it's pale.
Yeah, but you can imagine, like, if you didn't know,
you might think that this was, like,
a good pasta al forno made with,
because you can't really tell that there's chicken in it,
maybe made with, like, a bechamel and some good cheese.
In my dream.
The smell does give it away a little bit, but...
See, the smell is pretty acidic.
Yeah, very sour.
I think it's the cream, well, also the...
Tabasco?
That's what it is.
It's the vinegar and the Tabasco, yeah.
Help yourself.
Take as big of a piece as you'd like.
I was going to tell you, help yourself, Arthur, please.
Okay, so...
Oh, yeah, now I really smell the Tabasco.
See, it's like...
It wasn't very much that you put in
and it barely changed the color at all,
so I was expecting it to be like, oh, it did nothing,
but I really smell it.
Actually, when you have a pasta al forno,
the smell that you have is more fatty.
It's like that cheesy, fatty, beautiful, amazing smell
that you start drooling
while the pasta is still in the oven.
Here is a pretty salad-y.
Salad-y?
Salad-y.
Make sure you get some chicken.
Si, Albert, don't worry, don't worry.
I have to oversee your bite selection here.
It's like...
Buon appetito.
Yeah.
It comes later.
You okay?
It comes later.
What comes later?
The deep flavor of this pasta.
The aftertaste, you mean?
Yeah, I think the cream of celery soup
is what you are partially reacting to at this moment.
I told you, you were gonna love it.
May I have some water before I talk?
Here you go.
Thank you.
Now.
So, what do you think?
When I took my bite,
the first taste that you have,
more or less, I don't want to really say cheesy
because it's not that you really taste the cheese,
but it was that soft.
Then, as soon as I started chewing,
it came out the vinegary taste of, I assume, Tabasco.
Well, it's kind of a combination.
It's a combination of the blue cheese dressing,
the cream of celery soup,
which is also very kind of sour and acidic, I would say,
and the Tabasco sauce, which is basically vinegar.
Actually, maybe the best part of this dish is the chicken.
This dish has pushed you to actually praise
the chicken in the pasta over everything else.
If I need to rank them,
my three experience of today,
this wins, like, the best.
This is the best out of all of them?
This is the best.
This is, like, the best.
We are talking about something
that doesn't make you puke now
or something that makes you puke in 10 minutes.
So, this is number one.
Then, we have the-
The lasagna.
That one.
Yeah, by far the worst was the fettuccine pot.
That is, like, the taste of the death.
If death has a taste, that is the taste.
No, I agree with you.
This looks the best and resembles food the most,
I would say.
If you just changed out the ingredients,
if you made some substitutions,
I know that you will never like pasta and chicken together,
and I get that, but if you imagine this
where instead of, like,
just some, like, store-bought blue cheese dressing,
you used, like, Gorgonzola cheese,
or you used, and you used, like, a bechamel sauce
and, like, actual good cheese-
And some salt.
That would be good, too.
Maybe you skip the vinegar.
Maybe you skip the sour celery thing.
Yeah.
So, if you just make a proper pasta al forno,
yes, it can taste better.
And that's also the thing,
is that, like, just a real good pasta al forno.
We have a whole video on how to make pasta al forno.
I'll put a link up here.
It's one of the simplest, quickest,
just like, ah, crap, I need a family-sized meal in a hurry,
and it's so easy to make,
and you can use good ingredients
that are not any more expensive
than buying the stuff you need for this,
and it takes just as much time.
It's like, you could just make a real pasta al forno.
It is something.
It is.
The book that I really want from her,
but I cannot find a copy-
It's not a problem, Albert.
No, the book that I really want,
I think it's called Eat This Book.
It's called something like that.
The entire book is made out of big sheets
of, like, parchment paper, cooking paper,
and on the paper is printed
just, like, pictures of different ingredients.
Like, it'll be, like, brussel sprouts,
and fish, and whatever, and tomatoes,
and you just take the sheet,
and you put the ingredients where they're supposed to go,
and then you just wrap up the paper,
stick it in the oven, and you have your dinner.
That's the one I want.
I can't find any copies
because, naturally, the book self-destroys,
so there are probably almost no new copies out there.
I love Cathy Mitchell.
I love her infomercials.
She makes me laugh,
and I thought that this would be funny to try her recipes,
and I, you know, I didn't expect it to be, like, great food,
but I thought that they would be kind of funny,
and creative, and whatever,
and...
Creative?
No problem.
It's, like, no doubt that they are very creative.
Honestly, though, it was,
and this ended up being much worse than I was expecting,
and kind of sad that this is, you know,
a, or was, a best-selling cookbook.
I get that people often don't have time
to spend a lot of time in the kitchen and cook,
and I get it.
You've worked a long day and stuff,
but, like, this can't be the answer.
Not, because if you think after a day spending working,
and you go back home,
and need to eat something like that pot,
it's not pretty.
Comfortable, pretty fun.
There is something better.
Yeah, I mean, you cook a lot of things
that are pretty fast and easy to make,
and even, like most of Cathy Mitchell's recipes,
only use one dish,
or, like, they're one-pot recipes,
and they use really simple,
common, and affordable ingredients.
They're almost like,
you could call them Italian dump recipes.
God, that just doesn't sound good.
No!
I'm sorry.
This came out really bad.
It doesn't sound good.
The Italian dump recipe doesn't,
let's find a name for them,
but, like, dump recipe.
What if, next week, we came back,
and you shared some of these Italian dump dinners?
Let's say that we will come back.
We'll think on the name a little bit more.
Maybe, if you have any suggestions for a better name,
leave it in the comments below.
But until we come up with something else,
we'll be back next week with some Italian dump dinners,
easy meals, on a budget, no stress.
And good.
And, oh yeah, yeah, and good.
And really good.
No stress, not this, not this, that's all okay,
because also this, they were stressed,
and all that, but.
Quick and easy and good.
And good.
So, tune in next week.
We'll give you guys some quick and easy
and good dinner ideas.
Give this video a thumbs up if you enjoyed it
at least as much as Ava did.
This is normally the part where I say,
if you try any of these recipes,
don't, don't try any of these recipes.
And if you try, don't tag us.
Don't tag us.
It's not our responsibility.
Speaking of one pot or one pan recipes,
here is a pasta grammarian who made a great example
of one polo a la cacciatora.
Oh man, I'm thinking about polo a la cacciatora
after everything we've eaten today.
And it just seems like, just heaven.
Four star, no three, four star Michelin.
It's in four star Michelin.
Oh, so good.
Thanks for trying the recipe.
It looks delicious.
All right, guys, we will see you next time
with some Italian dump dinners.
No, seriously.
The people who bought this book.
Number one bestselling author, Cathy Mitchell.
What?
