Please join my mailing list here 👉 https://briankeating.com/list to win a meteorite 💥 -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Explore the riveting realms of science and integrity with Eric Weinstein as he challenges the modern perception of physicists as mere "oatmeal sellers". Delve into thought-provoking discussions about the true value of scientific discovery, the ethical dilemmas faced by today's researchers, and the hidden influence of economic incentives on innovation.
Join Eric Weinstein, Avi Loeb, and Brian Keating as they passionately defend the embattled legacy of science and its indispensable role in shaping the future.
the basic point is we made you safe we
made you strong we made you rich what is
your effing problem period the end okay
we be we mean scientists well let's be
more specific
physics okay I am physics adjacent in
this conversation as a mathematician but
basically the key point is whether it
was inventing molecular biology putting
you in instantaneous communication
inventing the semiconductor the
worldwide web give me a break this stuff
did not come out of nowhere it's not all
based on startups every scientist should
learn that they produce a public good
which is both inexhaustible and
inexclusive if done correctly and the
key question is why do we see ourselves
incorrectly we are this incredibly
dangerous ninja
priesthood and pretending that we are I
don't know that science is interesting
and it's good for you and it makes it
sound like some sort of you know we're
trying to sell oatmeal or something I'm
not quite sure or pandering for our
existence AR well which is absurd the
basic point is you have the world's
greatest deal which is that you keep us
protected and able to work on things
that we want to work on and when you
want to call on us we're there and when
we start badmouthing our own country we
are breaking the deal when they start
saying what is it that you are good for
you know go get real jobs they are
breaking the deal and I'm watching a
bunch of people who don't even remember
the deal who don't remember what vavar
Bush was trying to do saying we won't do
this work in National Labs we'll do it
universities maybe the idea is that it's
too dangerous to do physics in an open
environment we took out two Japanese
cities with a little bit of physics
imagine what we could do if we really
started pushing things I mean I think
what people need to realize is science
isn't always interesting sometimes it's
dull as church sometimes it's the most
riveting thing on the planet it's not
it's not always successful sometimes it
changes everything often times it it it
lags
but the key point is it is absolutely
consequential that the Cavalier way in
which increasingly this this imited Tech
right which is very recent in its origin
I thought these guys were going to be
our biggest friends and maybe even Our
Saviors and in part lying about things
like string theory and lying about
things like cures for cancer and lying
about peer review and pretending that
public health is science when it
absolutely in no uncertain terms is not
has caused this Rift and so in part what
we have to do is we have to reinvent
scientific credibility and institutional
credibility to people who don't go to
seminars and I was at the Caltech
colloquium last week in physics and I
didn't see anybody from the crowd of
people that gets asked about science and
technology policy they're never there
they don't even understand the
difference between a college and a
university a University's Chief mission
is not teaching it is research and the
mentorship of people who are to become
researchers Eric you you have dinners
with those Tech Executives what do you
tell
them I fight alone my friend I mean I'm
having one tonight with with very
prominent people in the tech world and
my claim is I will almost certainly be
the only person defending science and
they will they will look at me and they
will say you realize you're defending
the people who attack you at your core
in the physics Community but that's you
have integrity Eric and and most many
scientists don't I think AI does and he
gets he gets a sale you know maybe not
as much as you do but but I think like
the comment you made about he see plenty
of negativity thrown his way the key
point is do you stand alone when it
comes time a scientist does not fall
back on peer review they fall back on
scientific method consistency and the
key question is are you willing and
capable of standing alone now the
problem is we need need more people in
those Tech dinners because if it's only
one per dinner if that okay Eric I'm I'm
happy to join you I think it's it's
really important that you know there was
a sense of humility because many of
these Tech Executives went to colleges
you know and they studied there and they
had some respect to the people who
taught them but it was lost because
because of the interaction that they had
later on so I think the it's really
important to restore that and you know
it's not by these tech people being the
tech support of the White House and
controlling the conversation about AI
it's about natural intelligence not
artificial intelligence that we should
isn't there a danger of the same thing
happening and I don't think I'm telling
Tales out of school is what happened
with Mr Epstein but you know to replace
Tech Bros by you know super successful
hedge fund entrepr that had connections
all around the world we can't figure out
exactly what he did but Eric couldn't
that lead to the economic incentives
that you pointed out which I agree with
but but couldn't that lead to this you
know very dastardly influence of both
non-scientific and maybe immoral or
unethical individuals like Epstein look
the key issue is what when I look at the
unethical behavior of our colleagues in
trying to destroy new ideas and the
proponents of new ideas I look at them
and I say would they be would they'd be
more ethical people if we paid them less
and tried to starve them or we paid them
properly they weren't so marginal and so
I have this terrible problem which is
that my my argument is you have to pay
my enemies more if you really want them
to evaluate my work and this is a
typical problem it happened in the New
Orleans Police Department where you had
an incredibly corrupt Police Department
New Chief came in and said we have we
have to pay everybody more so that they
feel like they have something to lose
and that they're valued within the
system so the key problem here is that
the sabinaa solution is to threaten to
dis connect more of these people people
and my solution is opposite which is
we've allowed scientists to become the
precaria precarious people who have to
more or less follow incentives jump on
every NSF initiative etc etc by the way
it's not the physicist are not supposed
to be paid chiefly out of NSF the
physicists are supposed to be paid out
of the Department of energy which is
really the department of nuclear weap
Sabina very much criticizes the next
accelerator and I think you know it's
important to to advocate for getting as
much data as possible in a way of
learning about nature rather than shying
away from experimental pro programs it's
actually the opposite that we want to to
cultivate because that's the only path
for learning something new getting as
much data as much evidence if you think
that the axis of having higher energy
will reveal new physics that's what you
should invest in but the the one thing
that should not be done is a press many
initiatives that go Direct that are not
traditional which is what and my
approach to that my solution to that is
you know if you don't want to get dirty
don't mud wrestle so there are all these
people who invite me for mud wrestling
and I just decline the invitation so I
Le it took me a while to learn that
because initially I would respond but
then as of now I just do what I think is
the right thing to do and avoid wasting
energy on people who just just you know
invite them the conflict y but the
problem that we're having in some of
these areas is that we want to be honest
about it and we don't want to pay for
our honesty with our lives are support
in our careers so right now we have this
really important thing that happened
that we haven't discussed on this call
anyway which is Mark Andre's
conversation at the White House but has
been replayed numerous times Well I
heard him on a podcast also he was
saying destroy all universities and
rebuild them Eric you're referring to
the that he said if if you discover
something that the government will
classify even up to mathematics is that
right ER that's right so explain that
because because I don't know if Obie
heard that particular clip what he said
was that he was given a courtesy heads
up as a billionaire do not invest in ai
ai startups will not be allowed to be a
thing we are going to choose a couple of
winners we are going to make them giant
corporations and we will put them in a
federal
cocoon and when andreon and horvitz said
back I don't know how you're going to do
this because that would mean that you'd
have to classify mathematics which is
being taught everywhere and you can't
classify math they said we took entire
entire segments of theoretical physics
offline during the Cold War and they
went dark now the interesting thing is
that there is absolutely no record of
any physicist that I know being told
this hey we're going to take portions of
theoretical physics and we're going to
make them go dark but the key question
here is if that's true Did the Federal
Government pull off what in corporate
Consulting is called management
consulting is called a soft Sunset a
soft Sunset is one in which you do not
alert the people who are being downsized
that they are being taken off long