US trade policy causes carnage on global markets as recession fears grow | Close of Business

Wealth Wizards
9 followers
#finance
Fears of an economic downturn spooked investors and sparked a $US4 trillion sell-off on Wall Street, as on-again-off-again tariff threats from the White House against allies like Canada and Mexico ramped up uncertainty.
The Australian share market followed suit, tumbling to a 7-month-low, narrowly avoiding a technical correction, which is a 10% fall from the most recent peak.
Leading independent economist Saul Eslake told Close of Business the moves from the US administration are creating volatility and uncertainty not just for investors, but US households who will ultimately carry the cost of tariffs. He spoke to business presenter Alicia Barry
Hello and welcome to Close of Business, I'm Elisha Barry.
US President Donald Trump's stated policy of making America great again came at a big cost this week.
Fears of an economic downturn saw spooked investors drive a $4 trillion sell-off on Wall Street,
as on-again, off-again tariff threats from the White House against allies like Canada and Mexico
ramped up uncertainty. The ASX followed tumbling to a seven-month low
as investors here joined the global route. Rachel Clayton has the story.
In no time at all, Wall Street was in a tailspin.
The Nasdaq plunged 4%, its worst day since September 2022.
The S&P 500 closed 2.7% lower and the magnificent seven stocks were all down,
Markets continue to sell off in the wake of additional and continued uncertainty around
what the Trump tariff situation is going to look like. Market participants hate uncertainty.
The Aussie share market joined the sell-off with stocks losing $50 billion by mid-morning,
but the ASX recovered to close almost 1% lower.
As expected, we are down. We are not as violent as what's going on over the US. We have been
moving up and down, less volatile as they have, but we have now declined 7.5% since the peak in
mid-February. Falls on the US stock market will also hit the retirement savings of Australians.
Superannuation funds have had two very good years in terms of returns,
and so it's, I guess, par for the course that you do go through bouts of volatility every so
often. You can be alert, but you don't need to be alarmed. If you think about the GFC during
COVID, during other times during super, these blips happen. The key question is being able
to hold your nerve and remember it's all about the long term. US recession fears have flowed
through to money markets where interest rates have dropped, helping to reduce payments on
government debt. President Trump's comments come against the backdrop of a potential government
shutdown as Congress struggles to pass a spending bill and Elon Musk's aggressive
cost-cutting measures. I'm just here trying to make government more efficient.
The goal here is let's not have America go bankrupt with waste and fraud.
Volatility is quite normal, and trying to time markets is very, very difficult. But I would say
though the risk is that given the uncertainty around tariffs in the US and the hit of that
to the US economy, along with the Musk's doge, government spending cutbacks and so on,
all of that could risk further falls in share markets in the very short term before we finally
reach a bottom. Market stabilisation at the whim of a president. Just a day later,
hopes for an exemption for Australia from Donald Trump's scattergun tariffs were dashed,
with steel and aluminium exports slapped with 25% tariffs. The Prime Minister called the move
unfriendly and unjustified, and the steel and aluminium industries have expressed their
disappointment, as Amelia Turzon reports. Donald Trump's America First policy is putting
Australia back in the pack. The United States' decision to impose tariffs on Australian steel
and aluminium as part of a global decision are concerning. Such a decision by the Trump
administration is entirely unjustified. This is against the spirit of our two nations' enduring
friendship. A US ally of five armed conflicts, Australia has been lobbying hard for a carve-out
from the 25% tariffs. But trade hawk and Trump advisor Peter Navarro says Australia is not a
The policy is no exemptions, no exclusions, and that will change if the president changes his
policy. This is a bad day for Australia. A bad day because of the decision that our ally in America
has made. The country's biggest steel maker, Blue Scope, says it's still hoping the tariffs will be
In a statement to the ABC, Blue Scope said,
The company is adding that it's working closely with the Australian trade and diplomatic staff
to ensure that Blue Scope investment proposition is fully understood.
But the tariffs may have a silver lining for the company's US operation Northstar in Ohio,
which delivered more than 40% of Blue Scope's profit last year, as the company's boss Mark
Vassalla told the business last month. So 300,000 tonnes of tariffs on exports that go out of
Australia to the US versus 3 million tonnes of benefit that we get from the tariffs driving up
Overall, economists say the tariffs have more bark than bite.
Steel and aluminium tariffs into the US only account for 0.2% of Australia's goods exports.
Adelaide Timbrel says the real worry for Australia is if these tariffs impact China,
our biggest trading partner. For Australia, the risks around US tariffs are less about
what is hitting us directly, and more about how tariffs on other countries are affecting global
growth. What this means in the interim is that business confidence will be affected.
Another actual impact is the R word. The hint that the US could head into a recession is sending
markets into a tailspin this week. But the American president keeps saying his taxes on
imports will help the United States. Do you think there will be a recession?
I don't see it at all. I think this country is going to boom.
But as I said, I can do it the easy way or the hard way.
Tariffs and escalating trade tensions are a form of economic self-harm,
and a recipe for slower growth and higher inflation. They are paid by the consumers.
This is why Australia will not be imposing reciprocal tariffs on the United States.
Holding off a full-blown trade war for now.
Investors hate uncertainty, but that's exactly what they got this week.
And what was worse for markets was Donald Trump's refusal to rule out a recession.
I spoke to leading independent economist Saul Eslake about how real the chance of a US recession
is. Saul Eslake, welcome to Close of Business. Thank you for having me on the program.
Investors have been spooked by the risk of recession, and Donald Trump himself
has dismissed the prospect. How likely do you think a recession is?
Well, it's clearly not zero. I wouldn't say it's the most likely outcome. I wouldn't put
the probability of a recession in the US at over 50%. But it's clearly more than zero.
And it's clearly going up. And it's something that investors need to think about. And indeed,
as the movement's not just in the stock market, which is in full-fledged correction territory now,
but the bond market and the US dollar itself are showing,
investors have been thinking quite seriously about that prospect.
And what's the risk that if these tariffs stick, inflation takes hold, particularly in the US,
and we see a situation where stagflation occurs in the US economy?
Well, that is a risk as well. And it's not just investors who know it,
consumers know it as well, as shown by the most recent surveys of inflationary expectations,
which indicate that households are expecting higher inflation as a direct result of the
tariffs that Trump is imposing on them. So they understand that they're going to be worse off
business understands that the economic climate and government policies are becoming much more
uncertain. And that's the most likely cause or source of a recession if the UN is having one.
It's the sheer uncertainty that Donald Trump has been creating, not only as a direct result of the
policies he's implementing, but of the extraordinarily haphazard way in which
those policies are being implemented. You know, one day, 25% tariffs are on,
and they're on everything. The next day, some goods are being exempted. The next day,
some countries' tariffs are being postponed for a month. And then the range of countries
that are being subject to tariffs are being increased. And when businesses are uncertain,
they pull up the shutters and stop making decisions about investment or creating jobs.
When households or consumers are uncertain, they put off buying particularly big ticket items like
motor vehicles or houses or going on overseas holidays. And that's the most likely source
of a downturn in the US economy. Now, if that's combined with higher inflation as a result of
tariffs, as it could be, then it puts the central bank, the Federal Reserve, in a dilemma as to
whether to cut rates in order to ward off recession or to raise rates in order to hose
down inflation. And the Fed, of course, meets next week. What do you think it's going to do?
I think it's going to stand pat. The most recent inflation data we've had this week for both
consumer and producer prices for February was a little bit better than expected. It doesn't
provide a justification for the Fed to cut rates again, but it certainly doesn't warrant them
talking about the prospect of any increase in interest rates in near term. Jay Powell,
as Fed chair, has said that there simply isn't enough data for the Fed to begin to assess the
likely consequences of the things that the Trump regime is now doing. They have to sit and wait
and see what the data tells them about not only how the US economy is tracking,
but also about the evolving risks facing the US economic outlook before they can decide whether
they need to cut interest rates again or whether they need to signal to markets that interest
rates could be on hold for a long time. It seems the people who voted for Trump
appear to be the ones who are paying the biggest price.
That's right. And indeed, many economists made that point before Trump's inauguration.
They made the point that the increases in tariffs, which to reiterate, are going to be borne by
American consumers, not by Chinese, Canadian, Mexican or European exporters, will fall
disproportionately on consumers in the bottom half of the income distribution. They're not going to
adversely affect the incomes or lifestyles of the tech bros that bankrolled Donald Trump's
campaign. Donald Trump isn't going to lose his job as a result of the recession that he says
the US might have to have. It's going to be people in lower income communities who lose their jobs,
and some of them might start to wonder why they voted for him. But of course,
that's too late to have those doubts. Part of the reason why Mr Trump is able to get away
with the things that he's doing is that he is subject to no restraints. He himself,
unless he manages to suborn the 22nd Amendment to the US Constitution, isn't allowed to run again.
Briefly, Saul, do you think there's a master plan here, a real end game,
or is it just noise and chaos coming out of the White House?
Well, some people suggest that there is a master plan, that Donald Trump and the people around him
genuinely believe that it's possible to restore US primacy amongst the community of nations
by reinstituting the sort of policy regime that the United States had in the latter part of the
19th century and the early part of the 20th century, when government was a lot smaller
than it is today, and it was possible to fund the operations of government through taxes on
imports, otherwise known as tariffs. This was before the federal income tax was invented in
1913 and before the US had to develop the range of sales taxes that its states now evolve. Donald
Trump thinks that that kind of combination of policies is the way to make America great again.
There aren't many economists who believe that. Maybe the handful who do are actually working
for the Trump regime, people like Peter Navarro, for example, or the current secretaries of the
Treasury and Commerce Departments. But really, the overwhelming impression that markets are
starting to have is that the lunatics are taking over the asylum and that the consequences that
flow from it will be pretty catastrophic. So, Lesley, thank you so much for your time.
That's been a pleasure. Thank you for having me.
Ex-tropical cyclone Alfred has wreaked havoc, leaving a huge personal toll and economic cost
in its wake. Businesses are assessing the damage and insurers will face close scrutiny for how
they handle the thousands of expected claims. Daniel Ziffer has the story.
The damage from ex-tropical cyclone Alfred is still unfolding. In Brisbane,
a tree crashed in front of a shop. That didn't stop the business from reopening.
The bills are piling up, as is the pressure on the insurance industry
to deal with an expected surge of claims. The insurance companies need to do the right thing.
They have a social licence and people expect them to make payments in a speedy and effective way
when they are due. Building inflation has gone up 40% in the last three years and when we think
about the challenge that insurers have, they're trying to anticipate what the cost would be to
rebuild properties in 12 months' time or 18 months' time if the worst happens.
So far, there have been more than 9,000 claims that's expected to rise.
Some analysts expect the insurance bill to exceed $2 billion. The 2022 floods cost $6.4 billion.
We expect a raft of claims that won't just be property damage, it will also be car damage and
we will see a lot of commercial claims around both business interruption and potentially primary
producers impacted in the Brisbane and Lockhear Valleys. More government support is expected to
be announced. Already, there's help for people in 31 local government areas. Eligible workers and
sole traders in South East Queensland and New South Wales who've lost income as a direct result
of ex-tropical cyclone Alfred will be able to access up to 13 weeks of income support.
In Lismore, waters are receding. Businesses here are used to putting things back together.
We've got the helpers here, unloaded everything, brought it back to the office and now they're
going to build the cabinets again. After the floods of 2022, the owner of this accountancy
firm wasn't taking any chances. We just weren't prepared for the amount of water. So we did pack
up, but we just didn't have it high enough. The impact of climate change induced extreme
weather is becoming more common with a massive annual study revealing more people are being
affected. In 2022, we found that four and a half percent of the population reported their home was
severely damaged or destroyed by a weather related event. That's like one in 22 people.
Prompting bigger questions about how prepared we are. Are we taking enough steps to prevent
the adverse consequences of these weather events? If they're going to become more prevalent,
do we need to be doing more to weatherproof our homes and our society more broadly?
As two of Australia's most populous states continue to bear the brunt.
The Australian share market booked its fourth straight week of losses,
ending just shy of recording a technical correction.
The ASX200 and the All Lords both falling 2% by Friday's close. Gemma Dale from NAB Trade
joined me to run through the drama on the markets this week. Gemma, is this a week that investors
would rather forget? Well, we have global headlines and tariff news coming daily. Trump
has been changing his policies quite dramatically on a daily basis and that is absolutely rattling
markets. But when you look at the actual numbers, particularly on the ASX, they're not dreadful,
right? We've seen a 5% pullback over the week in the tech sector. We've seen about a 3% pullback
across the other major sectors, particularly financials. If you look at healthcare and so on,
they're all back about 3%. Materials stronger. So it wasn't read across the screen. There were
some sectors doing okay. Utilities a bit stronger also. So a bit of weakness, but we're post
reporting season. You're starting to see things settle down. And because there's so much clear
political uncertainty and weakness, particularly in the US, I don't think it's very surprising to
see a little pullback this week. I mean, we have been reporting quite a bit about
nearing a technical correction. What's the significance of a correction? Should investors
be worried by that? Yes, so the definition is the market falls by 10%. It's worth noting we were at
all-time highs. So when you're at all-time highs, there is always the potential for you not to make
a new high to come back a little bit. 10%, it's not enormous, right? We see them all the time.
It is very common to see pullbacks of 10% or more in a calendar year or a financial year.
And then the market just picks itself up and just keeps moving forward, right? So when we look at the
US data, a technical correction results in a bear market about one in four times. Most of the time
just sort of picks itself up and then makes new highs again subsequently. So it may get worse,
it may get better. Most of the data suggests it will probably get better from here.
So do you think the sentiment that you're saying is going to have investors buying this dip?
So the buy the dip mentality has been so strong for so long and it's been such a successful
strategy. When you look at the market over the last five years, worth noting five years ago was
the COVID low, so very specific data set. Starting at an absolute low, the S&P 500 is up exactly 100%,
which is extraordinary. So buying the dip all the way through that period, you've done extremely
well. And the ASX is up 40%, which is not as strong, but still buying that particular dip
has played out really nicely for you, particularly if you bought financials, a lot of people did.
I think at this point in time, there is a lot of uncertainty and it's also worth noting,
particularly in the US, share prices are still not cheap. Tesla, which has fallen 50% from its
So we're not talking a cheap market necessarily. You may want to buy the dip,
but there may be more dips to come. It's hard to say.
And you mentioned Tesla there. When we look at the magnificent seven tech stocks,
they have been the outperformers and Australia's big superannuation funds
have quite a large holding, many in that mag seven contingent. What's the risk here,
given that they've seen the brunt of the selling?
So this is really difficult for super funds and any large asset manager. You're generally
benchmarked to these global benchmarks and the All Country World Index, which is developed markets
and emerging, so it's not just exclusively developed markets, is 74% US, or it was at
the end of December. It's astonishing, 26% the rest of the world, 74% US.
So you have to be in it, right?
You've got to be in it. And of that, nearly 40% was the mag seven. So it's quite extraordinary
how concentrated global markets as a benchmark have been. And as an asset manager, you kind of
have to be there. So yes, you're going to wear some pain, but you also had all the run up.
So that's all right.
So just ride it out.
It's a challenge. Asset managers should be making active decisions and may have taken
some risk off the table prior to this pullback. But you've got to be watching really what your
investment manager is doing to have a feel for what the impact is going to be on your portfolio.
Gemma Dale, thanks so much.
Thank you for having me.
Prefabricated housing is cheap, fast and effective, but it makes up just a fraction of total dwelling stock.
Experts have increasingly pointed to it as a possible solution to help ease Australia's
housing crisis. But despite proving successful overseas, finance for modular homes is still
a problem. Here's Rachel Clayton again.
In a high-tech factory, a robotic arm swings into action to cut, nail and shape the wall of a house.
Most of our manufacturing members are producing homes in 12 weeks
compared to traditional constructions taking around 18 months.
Prefabricated homes built on a production line have been lauded as a cheap and fast
solution to Australia's need for housing for decades.
The new modular home is built totally in a factory and then transported to the site.
Yet the industry makes up just 8% of all construction.
Our industry is at capacity currently building conventionally. So the prefab industry is an
enabler for the construction sector to help to get back to productivity and profitability.
Across the country, states and territories have poured money into prefab to quickly boost
supply of social housing with projects ranging from a few dozen homes to a few hundred.
This row of modules is a deconstructed apartment building being made in Melbourne
and bound for Queensland.
So this is the kitchen living module and this will go to site, fully finish,
all the appliances installed and then when it goes to site,
the next module that gets installed next to it will have the bathroom and the bedrooms.
In 2024, the federal government announced a $900 million productivity fund for states
and territories to reduce red tape and launched a voluntary certification scheme to simplify
prefab home approvals.
If you had a three module home, which would be a small average home,
there's 15 days and you've got it built ready to go.
But cost, regulation, financing and even public perception remain key barriers.
This firm in Victoria supplies regional and rural worker accommodation.
In here we've got a laundry letting into the garage.
The reason we've done a single garage is because you can't do a double garage in a modular build.
You can't do a double? Why's that?
Double garage has to be a minimum five and a half metres wide,
which once you add the walls, it's too wide to be moved on the road.
There is a perception around modular building that they are a lower cost,
cheaper option. So people come looking at a modular thinking that price is going to be the
selling factor, but we have to build to the same standard as any building
and therefore there is no cost saving over traditional building.
Australia's Productivity Commission says the industry must grow if it's going to succeed.
We've faced some particular challenges in adoption in Australia.
One is scale and because it is essentially manufacturing process,
it works better when you have large levels of throughput.
The public need to come on board too.
I think people are not used to thinking about prefabrication.
They might not think it's as good a quality.
Getting finance has also been an issue, but that's shifting with Commonwealth Bank becoming
the first of the big four to offer a standard contract for prefabricated homes,
offering up to 80% of the total contract price before the home is on site.
Given the time frame is so much shorter, actually we believe that we can actually
manage that risk because we are only holding that risk for a very short period of time.
All of these issues are not new. They were discussed in detail
in a 150-page report for a federal government task force 51 years ago.
One leading construction expert says it proves a decades-long lack of leadership.
The way the National Construction Code is actually played out,
it's almost a different version in every state. One of the downsides of getting this wrong...
Without a national way forward, he says the industry will produce poor products.
The trouble is when one of these people fail, and there's been many of them,
cleaning up is a huge challenge. It hurts the supply chain and it hurts the consumers,
and it'll certainly hurt the brand of this type of construction, which has got lots of potential.
Potential that could provide a solution to Australia's housing crisis.
