1 Video View·Mar 13, 2025
Activist groups claim a biased criminal justice system has put too many people behind bars. The solution, they say, is to drastically cut the prison population. Even now, some states are using the coronavirus pandemic to double down on granting early release to thousands of prisoners. Rafael Mangual, Deputy Director of Legal Policy at the Manhattan Institute, urges caution: most people are in prison for a good reason.
FOLLOW us!
Facebook: 👉https://www.facebook.com/prageru
Twitter: 👉https://twitter.com/prageru
Instagram: 👉https://instagram.com/prageru/
SUBSCRIBE so you never miss a new video! 👉https://www.prageru.com/join/
To view the script, sources, quiz, visit https://www.prageru.com/video/why-are-so-many-americans-in-prison
Join PragerU's text list to have these videos, free merchandise giveaways and breaking announcements sent directly to your phone! https://optin.mobiniti.com/prageru
Do you shop on Amazon? Click https://smile.amazon.com and a percentage of every Amazon purchase will be donated to PragerU. Same great products. Same low price. Shopping made meaningful.
SHOP!
Love PragerU? Now you can wear PragerU merchandise! Visit our store today! https://shop.prageru.com/
JOIN PragerFORCE!
For Students: http://l.prageru.com/2aozfkP
JOIN our Educators Network! http://l.prageru.com/2aoz2y9
Script:
The U.S. does have a very large prison population—not because too many innocent people are incarcerated, but because too many people commit serious—usually violent—crimes. With rare exceptions, that’s why most people are imprisoned in America. Period. Full stop.
Before presenting the facts, let me add these caveats: It’s unacceptable that any innocent person is behind bars. Punishment must always fit, not exceed, the crime. We should do everything we can to reduce the rates of recidivism—committing more crime after release. And finally, everyone in prison should be treated humanely.
But let’s not fool ourselves that our prisons are full of people who shouldn’t be there. That’s simply not the case.
Let’s start with those convicted of drug offenses, the source of so much of the “mass incarceration” myth. While it’s true that about half of federal prisoners are incarcerated on drug charges, federal inmates constitute only about 12% of the American prison population. Almost nine of every ten prison inmates are in state facilities. And very few of them—less than 15%—are there for drug-related offenses.
Four times that number are behind bars for one of the following serious crimes:
Murder—14%
Rape or sexual assault—13%
Robbery—13%
Aggravated or simple assault—11%
And burglary—9%
In short, violent criminals make up the clear majority of the state prison population. What’s more, drug offenders who do end up in prison don’t actually serve very much time—almost half are released within a year.
The truth is that most criminals probably spend less time in prison than you think—even for the most violent crimes. According to the Bureau of Justice Statistics, almost 40% of released state prisoners served less than a year in prison. Even 20% of murderers and nearly 60% of those convicted of rape or sexual assault served less than five years of their sentences in prison.
What explains the short stays? Answer: plea bargaining.
Most prosecutions never go to court. Instead, a deal is made between the defendant’s attorney and the prosecutor to avoid going to trial. These negotiations often involve the offender agreeing to plead guilty in exchange for a reduced sentence, or dropping or downgrading the most serious charges. As a result, a prisoner’s conviction record often understates the crime that landed him behind bars in the first place.
For example, an armed burglar who, when arrested, was found to be in possession of illegal drugs might go to prison not for his worst crime—the armed burglary, but for a plea-bargained charge of, say, trespass and drug possession. But the media and the activists don’t tell us about this rather important detail. Instead, all we hear about is the poor fellow who’s serving time “for selling a small amount of cocaine.”
This assumes, of course, that the convicted criminal does any time at all. Studies done by the Justice Department show that only about 40% of felony convictions lead to a prison sentence. Yes, many are given probation, sentenced to home confinement, or given credit for time served in pretrial detention. But most of the time, convicted criminals don’t go to prison.
For the complete script, visit https://www.prageru.com/video/why-are-so-many-americans-in-prison
our prisons are crowded with people who
shouldn't be there the victims of a
racist justice system this is the
popular progressive narrative but it's
wrong in every respect dangerously wrong
the u.s. does have a very large prison
population not because too many innocent
people are incarcerated but because too
many people commit serious usually
violent crimes with rare exceptions
that's why most people are imprisoned in
America period full stop before
presenting the facts let me add these
caveats it's unacceptable that any
innocent person is behind bars
punishment must always fit not exceed
the crime we should do everything we can
to reduce the rates of recidivism
committing more crime after release and
finally everyone in prison should be
treated humanely but let's not fool
ourselves that our prisons are full of
people who shouldn't be there that's
simply not the case let's start with
those convicted of drug offenses the
source of so much of the mass
incarceration myth while it's true that
about half of federal prisoners are
incarcerated on drug charges federal
inmates constitute only about 12% of the
American prison population almost nine
of every ten prison inmates are in state
facilities and very few of them less
than 15% are there for drug-related
offenses four times that number are
behind bars for one of the following
serious crimes murder 14 percent rape or
sexual assault 13 percent robbery 13
percent aggravated or simple assault 11
percent and burglary nine percent in
short violent criminals make up the
clear majority of the state prison
population what's more drug offenders
who do end up in prison don't actually
serve very much time almost half are
released within a year the truth is that
most criminals probably spend less time
in prison than you think
even for the most violent crimes
according to the Bureau of Justice
Statistics almost 40 percent of released
state prisoners served less than a year
in prison even 20 percent of murderers
and nearly 60 percent of those convicted
of rape or sexual assault served less
than five years in prison
what explains the short stays answer
plea-bargaining most prosecutions never
go to court instead a deal is made
between the defendants attorney and the
prosecutor to avoid going to trial these
negotiations often involve the offender
agreeing to plead guilty in exchange for
a reduced sentence or dropping or
downgrading the most serious charges as
a result a prisoner's conviction record
often understates the crime that landed
him behind bars in the first place for
example an armed burglar who when
arrested was found to be in possession
of illegal drugs might go to prison not
for his worst crime the armed burglary
but for a plea bargain charge of say
trespass and drug possession but the
media and the activists don't tell us
about this rather important detail
instead all we hear about is the poor
fellow who's serving time for selling a
small amount of cocaine this assumes of
course that the convicted criminal does
anytime at all
studies done by the Justice Department
show that only about 40% of felony
convictions lead to a prison sentence
yes many are given probation sentenced
to home confinement or giving credit for
time served in pretrial detention but
most of the time convicted criminals
don't go to prison do we really want
even more criminals out on the street
activists say yes scholars at the
left-leaning Brennan Center have called
for an immediate 40% reduction in the
number of inmates CNN host Van Jones
founder of the hashtag cut 50 initiative
tops that he wants a 50% reduction but
if the activists get their way the cost
would be high and would likely be paid
by the most vulnerable most crimes are
committed by a small fraction of the
population who primarily victimized
their own communities here's an
all-too-common example in the spring of
2019 two men were charged with the
murder of a Chicago woman who was shot
while holding her baby one of the men
charged had nine felony convictions
including four a 2004 second-degree
murder charge
a January 2017 University of Chicago
crime lab study found that on average
someone arrested for a homicide or
shooting in that city had nearly 12
prior arrests almost 20% had more than
20 if we cut prison rolls by 2040 or 50%
it won't be politicians and media
celebrities living in gated communities
who will pay the price it will be the
law-abiding citizens and underserved
neighborhoods struggling to get ahead
who will pay when it comes to debates
about criminal justice policy these
people not criminals should come first
I'm Raphael minghua deputy director of
legal policy at the Manhattan Institute
for Prager University thank you for
watching this video
to keep Prager you videos free please
consider making a tax-deductible
donation