Scholar: The Age Of Obedient Citizens In China Is Over!

China Truths
61 followers
"US Media: China’s ‘Social Volcano’ Tremors Send Warning Signals to CCP Leadership
Over 100 Shackled, Chained: Torture at Zhengzhou ‘Designated Residence’ Exposed
Legal Battle Over Ownership of Mao Zedong's Secretary Li Rui's Diaries Begins in U.S. Court
China Launches Tit-for-Tat Probe Into Dairy Imports From EU
#china #chinatruths #chinanews"
U.S. media. China's social volcano tremors send warning signals to CCP leadership.
Over 100 shackled, chained, torture a Zhengzhou-designated residence exposed.
Legal battle over ownership of Mao Zedong's secretary Li Rui's diaries begins in U.S. court.
China launches tit-for-tat probe into dairy imports from EU.
U.S. media. China's social volcano tremors send warning signals to CCP leadership.
On August 21, 2024, The Wall Street Journal's Chinese edition published an article titled
China's social volcano trembles, Xi Jinping's vision tested, discussing a deepening pessimism
across Chinese society. The report cited recent surveys spearheaded by Stanford University
economist Scott Rozell, Harvard University sociologist Martin King White, and their
colleagues both in the U.S. and China have pointed to a decline in confidence in the economic
leadership. These surveys reveal significant concerns about the over-reliance on personal
connections, known as guanxi, and a systemic inequality that traditionally favors state-owned
enterprises over private entities, posing major barriers to personal advancement.
Furthermore, many Chinese feel that without significant changes to the system,
no amount of personal effort will suffice to overcome these barriers,
leading to widespread stagnation. This sentiment marks a shift from earlier survey results from
2004, 2009, and 2014, which notably followed Xi Jinping's rise to power in late 2012,
where respondents primarily blamed their lack of progress on personal inadequacies,
such as insufficient diligence or capabilities. However, the 2023 survey contrasts sharply with
these earlier findings, indicating that factors unrelated to individual merit are increasingly
seen as pivotal in determining one's economic status. The authors of the 2023 survey report
note that, although there are no immediate signs of a social volcano eruption, the increasing
tremors are evident and are sending warning signals to the leaders of the Chinese Communist Party.
For instance, the mounting pessimism is prompting private enterprises to withhold
investments and consumers to reduce spending. Economists Rozelle and White have observed that
these trends suggest an erosion in the legitimacy that the CCP leadership has long enjoyed,
derived from decades of continuous economic growth and improved living standards.
This erosion is signaling the unraveling of the implicit social contract between the CCP
and the Chinese populace. As economic growth slows, businesses shrink, and unemployment rates
climb, the realization that the CCP may no longer be able to deliver prosperity is becoming more
widespread. In fact, an increasing number of Chinese are attributing their hardships directly
to systemic failures. Despite the pain caused by the economic slowdown, it remains tolerable for
Some individuals from higher socioeconomic backgrounds are finding themselves downgrading
from business to economy class, or switching from preferred brands to more budget-friendly options.
Moreover, the growing pessimism, combined with ongoing political purges,
is dampening the zeal of government officials at all levels to implement policy changes.
The report said that for Xi Jinping, the most dominant CCP leader in decades,
the changing public sentiment in China has evolved into a form of passive resistance.
This poses a formidable challenge to his initiatives aimed at redirecting the country
back to socialist roots. The CCP Fears the People Like Fearing a Tiger
On Aug. 15, 2024, Dr. Ching Xiaonong, an expert on Chinese issues, wrote a commentary for Radio
Free Asia, stating that the Chinese Communist Party now fears the people like fearing a tiger.
Cheng's analysis highlights the increasingly delicate political atmosphere in China,
where rumors of dissatisfaction with Xi Jinping continue to circulate both within official ranks
and among the general public. Meanwhile, the CCP's anxiety over this growing unrest is becoming more
apparent. The first source of this fear, according to Cheng, lies in the harsh living conditions
faced by the population and the severe social discontent that has arisen. The leadership
is keenly aware of the brewing political storm, akin to the saying a storm is brewing on the
horizon. The second source of the CCP's fear stems from a stark internal reality. Despite
its boasts of overwhelming power, the leadership is fully aware that official statistics are largely
propaganda tools. They fear that their vulnerabilities in technology and economics
could be exposed to the international community. The construction of a Berlin Wall in Beijing's
outskirts highlights the CCP's deep-seated fear. While the Wall has no military value,
it symbolizes the regime's mentality of fearing the people like fearing a tiger.
The leadership feels insecure about the capital and aims for a tidy,
tightly controlled Beijing where citizens are too afraid to voice dissent publicly.
On a socioeconomic level, the regime is determined to avoid a surge in low-end
migrant workers entering Beijing, which could affect the city's appearance.
Back in 2017, Beijing was ordered to conduct a clean-up campaign,
expelling tens of thousands of migrant laborers from other provinces.
These low-end migrants primarily hail from Hebei Province, where many rural inhabitants seek to
make a living in the capital. Politically, the government is equally determined to prevent any
recurrence of protest movements like the White Paper Movement. Authorities already maintain
real-time tracking of Beijing residents and travelers arriving by plane or high-speed train
through mobile phone location data. However, monitoring migrant workers entering by minibus
remains a challenge, which is why the Berlin Wall around Beijing is intended to restrict
their entry and ease the burden on the capital's police in terms of social control.
Chinese citizens no longer fear tea invitations. Taiwan's Central News Agency reported on August
1, 2024, that Chinese current affairs commentator Liu Qing observed that Chinese
society is in a state of unrest, with public dissent reaching a level not seen in a decade.
Citizens are no longer as intimidated by tea invitations from state security or the police,
and some have even become quite defiant. However, Liu Qing believes that it will take
time for this social discontent to coalesce into a large-scale mass movement. Liu Qing
observes that since the Sidong Bridge incident in October 2022, pessimism and despair have
increasingly permeated Chinese society over the past year, accompanied by a rise in the
self-debt rate among young people. Nevertheless, most acts of resistance remain isolated incidents,
far from forming a cohesive lone-warrior movement, making large-scale social unrest
unlikely in the near term. Independent scholar Deng Yun, writing on April 30, 2024,
remarked on the 10th anniversary of the CCP's proposal of the overall national security concept.
Over the past decade, the high-pressure measures used to maintain social stability and security
are showing signs of strain, as public dissatisfaction becomes more pronounced.
Recent tragic incidents, including student deaths, highlight this unrest. According to a
credible academic source, the authorities are currently more concerned about social stability
than economic issues, with stability now posing a more critical challenge. If accurate, this
information suggests that the regime is increasingly anxious about maintaining control and senses that
significant social changes may be imminent. Deng concludes that regardless of whether or
how social changes unfold, one certainty remains—the era of expecting the population
to be obedient tools is over. Over 100 shackled, chained, torture at Zhengzhou-designated
residents exposed. Disturbing news has recently surfaced about the Chinese Communist Party's
designated residential surveillance system. On August 21, 2024, the Tsingtao Daily reported
a shocking scandal uncovered during a trial at the Zhengzhou Intermediate People's Court,
held from the 19th to the 20th. This trial involved a healthcare company accused of fraud.
During the proceedings, defense attorneys disclosed that the Zhengzhou Public Security
Bureau had detained multiple individuals for nearly six months under the pretense of
designated residents. These detainees were restrained with handcuffs and leg irons and
confined in groups of about 10 inside rooms at Qingwang Mountain Villa in Zhengzhou,
secured together with thick iron chains. Court testimonies revealed that at least 100 people
were housed in a two-story lodge, with male detainees grouped in rooms, all shackled in
similar fashion. At night, these individuals were linked with iron chains as thick as a pinky
finger, and the rooms lacked beds, having only three mattresses shared by three to four people
each. Detainees expressed that the chaining method rendered bathroom access at night impossible,
leading them to reduce their food and water intake to avoid the need.
Prolonged restraint caused some detainees to suffer from skin abrasions.
Despite claims from authorities of isolation due to the pandemic, nearly all detainees contracted
COVID-19. The conditions for female detainees were particularly harsh, with leg irons causing
ankle injuries. After enduring several days and vocal protests, the leg irons on the women were
eventually removed. Additionally, some defendants recounted being forced by police to crawl on the
floor at the Xingdong Branch Office of the Zhengzhou Public Security Bureau and being
kicked in the chin. They also revealed that the leg irons, after prolonged use, had rusted and
could not be removed when needed, resulting in firefighters being called to cut them off.
Designated Residential Surveillance is the CCP's private prison. Gao Jisheng, a Chinese
human rights lawyer, criticized the term Designated Residential Surveillance in democratic
China, clarifying that it is not recognized within the CCP's legal framework but is easily confused
with the residential surveillance of China's misleading criminal procedure law. This confusion
is exploited by authorities to manipulate public perception. Gao shared his own harrowing experiences
under this system before his transfer to a state-registered prison, enduring over four years
of what he describes as a nightmarish and surreal ordeal that feels like it occurred in another
lifetime. He detailed how the entire system is engineered to prey on the most sensitive and
vulnerable aspects of human nature, involving torture, relentless psychological torment,
and deliberate isolation from the outside world. He described being kept in a damp,
unventilated basement, facing extreme temperatures and continuous harassment by guards.
This severe treatment, which he termed the devil's management method, is widely used across China,
reflecting a new depth of depravity under the guise of legality. Gao remarked that Designated
Residential Surveillance is a new facade for evil that has emerged in recent years,
a new level of depravity. The Communist Party has a unique ability that catches the world's
attention—its shamelessness, shamelessness that is fully conscious and yet entirely unapologetic.
In the face of such audacity, any words or language seem utterly powerless.
China's Designated Residential Surveillance system described as hellish, linked to multiple deaths.
On July 20, the Southern Weekend newspaper published an investigative report titled
Multiple deaths under Designated Residential Surveillance, a system in dispute of existence.
The article exposes the harsh realities within China's Designated Residential Surveillance
DRS system, where it has been misused as a tool for torture, resulting in multiple fatalities.
Highlighting specific cases, the report notes the death of a 34-year-old
just 13 days into DRS, along with other unexplained deaths including a tech company
executive from Inner Mongolia and a theft suspect from Hubei. Eyewitnesses described
severe torture and grueling interrogation sessions lasting up to 16 hours daily.
Their diet was restricted to a small bun, only slightly larger than an egg, and bathroom access
was limited to three times daily, with stringent time constraints of 30 seconds for urination and
60 seconds for defecation, with harsh penalties for any infractions.
A 2021 report by the human rights organization Safeguard Defenders titled Locked Up Inside
China's RSDL Secret Jails labels the DRS a legal cover for what are essentially black prisons.
These facilities operate with minimal judicial oversight,
greatly increasing the risk of abuse and torture. The DRS system, established in 2013,
has been used to detain numerous human rights activists and lawyers in secret locations,
subjecting them to brutal torture techniques. Chen Guangcheng, an exiled Chinese human rights
advocate, condemned these practices on July 22 via a tweet on Xplatform. He talked about the
legitimization of arbitrary detention under Article 73 of the Criminal Procedure Law,
questioning whether such provisions alter the inherently cruel nature of these detention
centers. Chen emphasized that as long as the communist regime remains in power,
it will persistently devise oppressive measures against the populace.
Legal battle over ownership of Mao Zedong's secretary Li Rui's diaries begins in U.S. court.
On August 19, a significant trial commenced in a California court over the ownership of
diaries belonging to Li Rui, the former secretary to Mao Zedong, leader of the CCP.
Li Nanyang, Li Rui's daughter, appeared in court to testify, amid allegations that the defendant,
Li Rui's widow Zhang Yujian, was merely acting as a proxy for the CCP. The proceedings,
taking place at the Northern District of California Federal District Court in Oakland,
are expected to span two weeks. Li Nanyang, during her testimony on August 20,
recalled advising her father against placing hope in Xi Jinping concerning historical truths,
after which he agreed to have his diaries preserved at Stanford University in the
United States. This marks the third lawsuit concerning the ownership of Li Rui's diaries.
The initial conflict began a month after Li Rui's death, when Zhang Yujian,
claiming ownership, demanded the return of the diaries from Stanford University,
where they were being kept. In April 2019, Zhang filed the first lawsuit in Beijing's
District Court against Li Nanyang, accusing her of unauthorized handling of Li Rui's diaries
and other personal documents. However, on June 25 of that year, the day the Beijing
Shijing District Court heard the Zhang Yujian vs. Li Nanyang case, Zhang issued a personal
statement. Firstly, I declare that suing Li Nanyang is not my personal wish. Secondly,
there is in fact no dispute between me and Li Nanyang over Li Rui's estate. I lived with Li
Rui for 40 years, and I never disagreed with his arrangements for his affairs,
including the belongings he gave to others, including his daughter. Thirdly, I am nearly
90 years old this year, with long-term illnesses. Li Rui had just passed away, and I had not yet
come to terms with it mentally. I am simply unable to cope with all kinds of rumors and
questions from society. I wish to spend my remaining years quietly and hope that no one
will bother me with this lawsuit again. This statement received significant attention on
Chinese social media, sparking discussions about the pressures she faced from external forces,
possibly the CCP. Li Nanyang has maintained that her actions were in compliance with her father's
last wishes, supporting her claims with videos and recordings of Li Rui expressing his desire
for his writings to be archived at Stanford University's Hoover Institution. Despite her
efforts, the Beijing Xicheng District Court ruled in November 2019 that the diaries belonged to
Zhang, ordering their return from Stanford within 30 days. Following the ruling, the Hoover
Institution filed a countersuit in the United States, asserting that the diaries and other
documents had been rightfully donated to them by Li Nanyang, with Li Rui's authorization.
The dispute has expanded to include accusations of conspiracy to steal what has been referred to
as a national treasure, involving significant legal interventions likely backed by the CCP,
according to observers. Perry Link, a renowned American sinologist, has voiced his belief that
the CCP is orchestrating Zhang's legal actions due to her lack of financial resources to sustain
such international lawsuits. The legal battles over Li Rui's diaries are seen not just as a
family inheritance issue but as a deliberate attempt by the CCP to control historical
narratives. Li Rui's extensive writings, which provide insights into significant CCP decisions
and internal dynamics, are viewed as potentially damaging if made public.
Born in 1917, Li Rui, in his youth, enthusiastically participated in the
revolution that led to the Communist Party's seizure of power. In the mid-1950s, he was
appointed as one of Mao Zedong's personal secretaries, though his tenure was short.
Li Rui was purged three times in total, exiled, and imprisoned for 20 years. In 1979, he was
rehabilitated and briefly held the position of deputy director of the CCP's organization department,
responsible for selecting senior CCP officials. In his later years, he became an outspoken critic
of the Communist Party, calling for political system reform and constitutional democracy,
and was recognized as a liberal within the party. Li Rui's dozens of diaries, letters,
work notes, and meeting records span 83 years, totaling about 10 million words.
These materials provide a glimpse into the inner workings of the CCP.
On June 4, 1989, the world was shocked by the Tiananmen Square Massacre.
Li Rui wrote in his diary, disturbed all day, wanting to cry bitterly.
It is done. How to face the world, how to thank the world?
On January 9, 2010, he mentioned Mao Zedong in his diary. He wrote, Mao's actions completely
contradicted the universal values of freedom, democracy, scientific progress, and the rule
of law. He also mentioned Xi Jinping, the current highest leader of the CCP, several times in his
diaries. In 2018, when China attempted to remove the term limits for the head of state,
he cited a foreign media report titled Democracy is Dead. Li Rui's words and actions angered the
CCP authorities, and his writings were subject to censorship, his books banned in China.
China launches tit-for-tat probe into dairy imports from EU
On August 21, China announced an anti-dumping investigation into EU dairy imports,
escalating trade tensions following the EU's proposed tariffs on Chinese electric vehicles.
The probe targets various cheeses, milk and cream products and was initiated after formal requests
from two state-backed dairy associations. China's investigation will focus on 20
subsidy programs across eight EU countries. The European Commission acknowledged the
investigation and pledged to monitor the process closely while ensuring WTO compliance.
This development follows the EU's plan to impose tariffs of up to 36.6% on Chinese EVs,
citing unfair subsidies. Experts view China's probe as a strategic move to counter the EU's
scrutiny of its electric vehicle sector, which Beijing heavily supports. The situation raises
concerns about a potential trade war, with EU diplomat Josep Borrell warning that it may become
unavoidable. This trade investigation into EU dairy products is part of a series of probes by
Beijing, which also includes inquiries into EU pork and French cognac, signaling a deepening
rift in trade relations between China and the European Union. Don't forget to leave a comment
in the section below to share your opinions on today's topic with us. Make sure to like
and subscribe to see more interesting topics from China Truths.
