The Framers of the United States Constitution wanted to give more power to the people and less power to the government. This was a radical new idea, and it started with the legislative branch: the House of Representatives and the Senate. John Yoo, Professor of Law at the University of California, Berkeley, explains.
#constitution #prageru #government
SUBSCRIBE 👉 https://www.prageru.com/join
Script:
“We the People of the United States.”
These are the words that open the American Constitution. We take them for granted now, but at the time they were written they were earth-shattering. If you think that sounds like an exaggeration, consider this:
No government had ever come into existence based on a document written for the people and approved by them.
It makes perfect sense, then that the most immediate and accountable branch of the government, the legislature, would be the first item on the Constitution’s agenda.
This is Article I.
It’s divided into ten sections.
Section 1 creates a bicameral legislature; that is, a legislature made up of two separate entities: a House of Representatives and a Senate. Thus, the theme of the Constitution is immediately suggested: this is going to be a government in which power is both limited and shared.
Section 2 describes how members of the House of Representatives are to be chosen. To run for office, you must be a citizen, reside in the state you’re representing and be at least 25 years of age.
It’s easy to miss, but at the time this was another startling feature of the Constitution: almost anyone could be a candidate for Congress. The citizen politician is an American innovation.
Section 2 also describes who could vote and how many people it takes to make up a Congressional district.
This “shall be determined by adding to the whole Number of free Persons…and…three fifths of all other Persons.”
This last phrase refers, of course, to slaves. It should be noted that the word “slave” does not occur in the Constitution. The Framers kept it out for two reasons. One, they recognized it would not play well in a document that was all about freedom. Two, they believed that slavery would fade away with time.
But it did exist in the Framers here and now, so it had to be dealt with.
The Northern abolitionists—those who were for abolishing slavery—didn’t think slaves should be counted at all. Why? Because if slaves were counted, the population of the Southern slave states would be increased, and consequently the political influence of the anti-slavery North would be decreased.
Of course, the Southern states wanted their slaves counted as five-fifths, that is, as whole persons so that the population of the slave states would be greater and give the South more power in the House of Representatives.
The three-fifths compromise came after much fierce debate. Neither side was fully satisfied. But the country stayed united and got a constitution—no small feat.
Section 3 concerns the second legislative body, the Senate. Whereas members of the House of Representatives are elected by the people directly and serve two-year terms, senators are to serve six-year terms and are chosen by each state government.
Populous states would have more representatives than less populous ones, but every state would have the same number of senators—two. This gave the states an equal share of legislative power. The minimum age requirement to be a Senator was set at 30.
Sections 4, 5, and 6 establish the basic operating rules: when Congress shall meet, what constitutes a quorum, what to do with disorderly members, and so on.
Section 7 sets out the process for enacting legislation. A bill must receive the consent of both the House and the Senate to become a law. The President is also involved in this process. He can veto legislation. His veto, however, can be overridden by a two-thirds vote by both houses of Congress.
Passing laws—which by definition are restrictions on freedom—is not meant to be easy. It’s meant—unless there is overwhelming support—to be hard.
Section 8 lists the legislature’s many responsibilities such as establishing and equipping the Armed Forces, coining money, and regulating interstate commerce. Perhaps the most important of these responsibilities is articulated in the Taxing and Spending Clause, which allows Congress to collect taxes and to spend for the national defense and general welfare.
For the full script, visit: https://www.prageru.com/video/the-constitution-the-limited-powers-of-congress
we the people of the united states
these are the words that open the
american constitution
we take them for granted now but the
time they were written they were earth
shattering
if you think that sounds like an
exaggeration consider this no government
had ever come into existence based on a
document written for the people and
approved by them
it makes perfect sense then that the
most immediate and accountable branch of
the government the legislature would be
the first item on the constitution's
agenda
this is article one
it's divided into ten sections
section one creates a bicameral
legislature that is a legislature made
up of two separate entities a house of
representatives and a senate
thus the theme of the constitution is
immediately suggested this is going to
be a government in which power is both
limited and shared
section 2 describes how members of the
house of representatives are to be
chosen
to run for office you must be a citizen
reside in the state you're representing
and be at least 25 years of age
it's easy to miss but at the time this
was another startling feature of the
constitution
almost anyone could be a candidate for
congress
the citizen politician is an american
innovation
section 2 also describes who could vote
and how many people it takes to make up
a congressional district
this
shall be determined by adding to the
whole number of free persons and
three-fifths of all other persons
this last phrase refers of course to
slaves
it should be noted that the word slave
does not occur in the constitution
the framers kept it out for two reasons
one they recognized it would not play
well in a document that was all about
freedom
two
they believed that slavery would fade
away with time
but it did exist in the framers here and
now so it had to be dealt with
the northern abolitionists those who
were for abolishing slavery didn't think
slaves should be counted at all
why
because the slaves were counted the
population of the southern slave states
would be increased and consequently the
political influence of the anti-slavery
north would be decreased
of course the southern states wanted
their slaves counted as five-fifths that
is as whole persons so that the
population of the slave states would be
greater
and give the south more power in the
house of representatives
the three-fifths compromise came after
much fierce debate
neither side was fully satisfied
but the country stayed united and got a
constitution
no small feat
section three concerns the second
legislative body the senate
whereas members of the house of
representatives are elected by the
people directly and serve two-year terms
senators are to serve six-year terms and
are chosen by each state government
populist states would have more
representatives and less populous ones
but every state would have the same
number of senators too
this gave the states an equal share of
legislative power
the minimum age requirement to be a
senator was set at 30.
sections 4 5 and 6 establish the basic
operating rules when congress shall meet
what constitutes a quorum what to do
with disorderly members and so on
section 7 sets out the process for
enacting legislation a bill must receive
the consent of both the house and the
senate to become a law
the president is also involved in this
process he can veto legislation his veto
however can be overridden by a
two-thirds vote by both houses of
congress
passing laws which by definition are
restrictions on freedom is not meant to
be easy it's meant unless there's
overwhelming support to be hard section
8 lists the legislature's many
responsibilities such as establishing
and equipping the armed forces coining
money and regulating interstate commerce
perhaps the most important of these
responsibilities is articulated in the
taxing and spending clause which allows
congress to collect taxes and to spend
for the national defense and general
welfare
sections nine and ten almost as a
counterweight to section eight conclude
with a list of government restrictions
no one can be convicted of a crime
without a trial
laws can't be made retroactive and
habeas corpus the right to see a judge
if you are arrested by the police can't
be suspended except in case of invasion
or rebellion or when the public safety
requires it
the framers understood the need for a
strong central authority but they also
knew well that such authority without
clear checks and balances
could and probably would become despotic
a government of limited powers could not
easily threaten our foundational rights
of speech assembly worship and
self-defense
it was a grand experiment and like any
experiment nobody knew if it would work
but it did
i'm john yu professor of law at the
university of california berkeley for
prager university
thank you for watching this video
to keep prageru videos free please
consider making a tax-deductible
donation