8 Video Views·Mar 12, 2025 #constitution #prageru #history Winning the War of Independence brought a new challenge to the American people: what sort of government should they choose for their new nation? Robert George, Professor of Jurisprudence at Princeton University, explores the problems the founders faced at this pivotal moment in history.
#constitution #prageru #history
SUBSCRIBE 👉 https://www.prageru.com/join/
📲 Take PragerU videos with you everywhere you go. Download our free mobile app!
Download for Apple iOS ➡ https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/prage...
Download for Android ➡ https://play.google.com/store/apps/de...
Script:
Against all odds, the Americans won their War of Independence.
But their success brought a new challenge—no less daunting. What sort of government should they choose for themselves?
How could they ensure that the tyranny of the English king George III would not be replaced by a homegrown tyranny?
One possibility was to establish an American monarchy with a better king. That was tempting for some, especially because they had a superb person for the job—General George Washington.
To his legion of admirers, the fact that he did not want to be king made him an even more attractive candidate.
The other possibility was to establish a republic, a government of and by the people and their representatives.
But this solution came with a big problem. Historically, republics like those in ancient Greece and Rome had always failed. And, when they failed, they were usually replaced by the very worst—most oppressive—forms of tyranny.
Might there be a way to make republicanism work—and last? To structure a constitution that would protect the new American republic from the social and political pathologies that had destroyed republics throughout history?
America’s Founding Fathers—men like Washington, Thomas Jefferson, Benjamin Franklin, John Adams, Alexander Hamilton, and James Madison—believed they had answers.
They had risked everything when they declared their independence from England; they were willing to risk everything again to create a new, different, and better type of republic.
The key, they all agreed, was to establish structural limits on power—the power of anyone, and any institution, exercising governmental authority.
In the summer of 1787, in one of the most creative acts in human history, these men (minus Jefferson and Adams who were serving the country abroad) fashioned a national government divided into three separate parts or branches—the legislative (Congress), the executive (the president), and the judicial (the courts). Congress would make laws, the executive would execute the laws and the courts would settle disputes arising under the Constitution and laws of the United States.
Dividing power would prevent power being concentrated in any one branch—the concept of checks and balances. Moreover, the central government would be limited to the powers specifically delegated to it, having no powers beyond those enumerated.
Where then would most of the powers of government reside? The answer was with the states.
This was not, as some wrongly suppose, done to protect slavery. Rather, it was done out of the commonsense belief that those public officials nearer to the people would naturally be more responsive and accountable to the people.
Just to make sure nobody missed the point, after attaching a Bill of Rights to the Constitution, the Founders enshrined this principle in the Tenth Amendment.
“The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the states, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.”
In short, whatever the Constitution does not specifically delegate to the national government belongs to the states and the people.
But the power of the states was also limited by constitutional prohibitions in certain areas, either because power in those areas had been delegated exclusively to the national government—such as the power to enter into treaties with other nations—or because the Framers did not want government at any level to have certain powers—such as the power to confer titles of nobility, something incompatible with republicanism.
For the full script, visit: https://www.prageru.com/video/the-constitution-why-a-republic
against all odds the americans won their
war of independence
but their success brought a new
challenge no less daunting
what sort of government should they
choose for themselves
how could they ensure that the tyranny
of the english king george iii
would not be replaced by a homegrown
tyranny
one possibility was to establish an
american monarchy with a better king
that was tempting for some especially
because they had a superb person for the
job general george washington
to his legion of admirers the fact that
he did not want to be king
made him an even more attractive
candidate
the other possibility was to establish a
republic
a government of and by the people and
their representatives
but this solution came with a big
problem
historically republics like those in
ancient greece and rome had always
failed
and when they failed they were usually
replaced by the very worst most
oppressive forms of tyranny
might there be a way to make
republicanism work and last
to structure a constitution that would
protect the new american republic from
the social and political pathologies
that had destroyed republics throughout
history
america's founding fathers men like
washington thomas jefferson benjamin
franklin john adams alexander hamilton
and james madison believed they had
answers
they had risked everything when they
declared their independence from england
they were willing to risk everything
again
to create a new different and better
type of republic
the key they all agreed was to establish
structural limits on power the power of
anyone and any institution exercising
governmental authority
in the summer of 1787 in one of the most
creative acts in human history
these men minus jefferson and adams who
were serving the country abroad
fashioned a national government divided
into three separate parts or branches
the legislative congress
the executive the president and the
judicial the courts
congress would make the laws
the executive would execute the laws and
the courts would settle disputes arising
under the constitution and laws of the
united states
dividing power would prevent power being
concentrated in any one branch the
concept of checks and balances
moreover the central government would be
limited to the powers specifically
delegated to it having no powers beyond
those
enumerated where then would most of the
powers of government reside
the answer was with the states
this was not a some wrongly supposed
done to protect slavery
rather it was done out of the common
sense belief that those public officials
nearer to the people would naturally be
more responsive and accountable to the
people
just to make sure nobody missed the
point
after attaching a bill of rights to the
constitution the founders enshrined this
principle in the tenth amendment
the powers not delegated to the united
states by the constitution nor
prohibited by it to the states are
reserved to the states respectively or
to the people
in short whatever the constitution does
not specifically delegate to the
national government belongs to the
states and the people
but the power of the states was also
limited by constitutional prohibitions
in certain areas either because power in
those areas had been delegated
exclusively to the national government
such as the power to enter into treaties
with other nations
or because the framers did not want
government at any level to have certain
powers such as the power to confer
titles of nobility something
incompatible with republicanism
still
as much care as the framers took to
constrain government power federal and
state
they knew their efforts would fail
unless one more component was present
citizens imbued with the spirit of
republicanism
people who understood the principles of
their constitution who valued
self-government and who would be willing
to do the work necessary for its
maintenance
citizens who would not yield to
demagogues who promised prosperity
security or anything else at the price
of liberty
james madison had this in mind when he
said that only a well-instructed people
could be permanently a free people
by a well-instructed people madison
meant above all a people well educated
about our constitutional liberties and
responsibilities
when at the conclusion of the
constitutional convention a woman asked
benjamin franklin what kind of
government he and the others had
proposed for the nation
he famously responded a republic madam
if you can keep it
the wise old philadelphia polymath had
history in mind in giving that answer
he knew that he and his colleagues at
the convention had supplied only the
mechanics of what was needed for a
republic to long endure
the rest could only be supplied by we
the people
understanding and fulfilling our duties
as citizens
that's why studying the constitution is
essential
how can we fulfill our duties as
citizens if we don't understand the
document on which that citizenship is
based
i'm robert george professor of
jurisprudence and director of the james
madison program at princeton university
for prager university
thank you for watching this video
to keep prageru videos free please
consider making a tax-deductible
donation