2 Video Views·Mar 12, 2025
SUBSCRIBE 👉 https://www.prageru.com/join
Unlike any governing document in history, the U.S. Constitution inscribed liberty and individual rights into law. But how could America espouse freedom at its founding and also permit slavery? Robert George, Professor of Jurisprudence at Princeton University, examines this moral conundrum.
Script:
“We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights, that among these are life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness.”
These, of course, are stirring words from America’s Declaration of Independence. They are the foundation of America’s commitment to civil liberty. We accept them as a given now, but only because we know America’s history.
At the time, they presented a serious challenge to the founders of the nation:
Could they create a governing structure that would match the high moral standards they had set for themselves?
Their first attempt did not go well.
The Articles of Confederation, the document that governed the country through the Revolutionary War and for a few years after, was such a miserable failure that many in England (and America) thought the new nation would soon collapse and return, hat in hand, to the mother country.
The Americans’ wariness of central power was understandable. Americans had fought and died to win freedom from an oppressive government. They weren’t about to give away that hard-won freedom to a new government of their own making.
The Articles allowed for no central authority to speak of. There was no chief executive; no effective way to impose or collect taxes; no provision for the national defense. All the power belonged to the individual states. And since the states disagreed on so many issues, almost nothing got done.
The Constitutional Convention of 1787 brilliantly solved this problem. It installed a system of checks and balances within the federal government and divided power between the federal government and the states. It did so while still preserving basic civil liberties.
Only a few years later, the founders would buttress these liberties with a Bill of Rights specifically protecting the free exercise of religion and the freedoms of speech, press, and assembly among other rights in the Constitution. This step, too, was taken to bring the country closer to the vision of the Declaration.
But, here, of course, the founders faced a moral challenge: how could America espouse freedom and also permit slavery?
Many of the founders, including Thomas Jefferson, the principal drafter of the Declaration, and George Washington, who presided at the Constitutional Convention, were slaveholders.
This fact leads some people to condemn America’s origins. The truth is that great men—and they were great—like Washington and Jefferson violated their own ideals in holding slaves while proclaiming equality and liberty.
They knew that slavery was an evil. Jefferson, speaking of slavery, declared that “I tremble for my country when I reflect that God is just; that his justice cannot sleep forever…” Washington, upon his death, freed his slaves and made financial provisions for them in his will.
For the full script, visit: https://l.prageru.com/3AZI1BG
we hold these truths to be self-evident
that all men are created equal
that they are endowed by their creator
with certain unalienable rights that
among these are life liberty and the
pursuit of happiness
these of course are stirring words from
America's Declaration of Independence
they are the foundation of America's
commitment to civil liberty
we accept them as a given now but only
because we know America's history
at the time they presented a serious
challenge to the founders of our nation
could they create a governing structure
that would match the Heim World
standards they had set for themselves
their first attempt did not go well
the Articles of Confederation the
document that governed the country
through the Revolutionary War and for a
few years after was such a miserable
failure that many in England and America
thought the new nation would soon
collapse and return had in hand to the
mother country
the Americans wariness of central power
was understandable
Americans had fought and died to win
freedom from an oppressive government
they weren't about to give away that
hard-won freedom to a new government of
their own making
the Articles allowed for no Central
authority to speak of
there was no chief executive no
effective way to impose or collect taxes
no provision for the National Defense
all the power belonged to the individual
states
and since the states disagreed on so
many issues almost nothing got done
the Constitutional Convention of 1787
brilliantly solved this problem
it installed a system of checks and
balances within the federal government
and divided power between the federal
government and the states
it did so while still preserving basic
civil liberties
only a few years later the founders
would buttress these liberties with a
Bill of Rights specifically protecting
the free exercise of religion and the
freedoms of speech press and assembly
among other rights in the Constitution
this step two was taken to bring the
country closer to the vision of the
Declaration
but here of course the founders faced a
moral challenge
how could America espouse freedom and
also permit slavery
many of the founders including Thomas
Jefferson the principal drafter of the
Declaration and George Washington who
presided at the Constitutional
Convention were slaveholders
this fact leads some people to condemn
America's Origins
the truth is that great men and they
were great like Washington and Jefferson
violated their own ideals in holding
slaves while proclaiming equality and
Liberty
they knew that slavery was an evil
Jefferson speaking of slavery declared
that I tremble for my country when I
reflected God as just
that his Justice cannot sleep forever
Washington upon his death free to slaves
and made Financial provision for them in
his will
but we do not celebrate these and the
other Founders for their personal moral
failures
we celebrate them for their unique moral
achievements for the revolution they
bravely fought and for the great
principles they fought for the equality
of all human beings and a society rooted
in Liberty the principles of the
Declaration and the Constitution
to judge these documents as corrupt
because imperfect men wrote them is to
say the least foolish
it takes no account of historic context
namely that virtually every society in
history and everywhere on Earth practice
slavery it disregards the obvious truths
that human beings are flawed creatures
and it elevates our current moral
position to a level we haven't earned
do we really think we are better and
wiser than Washington Franklin Jefferson
Adams Hamilton Madison and the other
founders
the simple truth is that the Declaration
the Constitution and Bill of Rights are
among the most moral documents and
principles ever conceived
they speak the truth about human nature
human rights and human dignity
it was for the sake of and indeed in the
name of the principles of the
Declaration and the Constitution that
Americans ended slavery
paying an enormous price in Blood and
treasure in a cataclysmic Civil War
it was for the sake of and in the name
of these principles that great if also
personally flawed leaders like Martin
Luther King struggled to end the regime
of segregation and Jim Crow that was the
legacy of slavery
King like Frederick Douglass before him
did not reject America's founding
principles
quite the opposite
the Constitution for these men was a
promise of liberty and justice for all
a promise that they quite rightly
insisted that our nation honor
America's problem is not its principles
they are just and good and true
when we as a people have gone wrong
our error has not been in excess of zeal
for our nation's founding principles
rather it has been precisely because we
have at times Dishonored and failed to
live up to them
but never have we had and never will we
have anything to regret when we hold
fast to the principles in our founding
documents I'm Robert George professor of
jurisprudence and director of the James
Madison program at Princeton University
for Prager University
thank you for watching this video to
keep prageru videos free please consider
making a tax deductible donation