PragerU v. YouTube | 5 Minute Videos

PragerU
799 followers
11 Video Views·Mar 12, 2025
Flashback to our video from 2019 on the PragerU vs. YouTube lawsuit which is now more relevant than ever since a federal judge ruled that Google holds a monopoly for online search engines and text-based advertising markets.
📲 Download the FREE PragerU app: https://prageru.onelink.me/3bas/vgyxvm79
the most important lawsuit in America
right now and perhaps the Free World is
Prager University versus
YouTube you might consider this a
grandiose statement especially since I'm
the lead attorney for Prager U I assure
you it's not that's because this case is
about the most fundamental Freedom
Americans have freedom of speech as
enunciated in the First Amendment to the
United States
Constitution all our freedom the very
concept of Freedom Springs from this
right lose it and we're no longer free
not as individuals and not as a nation
I'm not willing to accept that Prager
you doesn't accept that and you
shouldn't either okay so how did we get
into this situation a little background
Prager use what is called a 501c3 a
nonprofit educational Media Company it's
known primarily for its 5minute videos
in 16 viewers began to notice that
certain prageru videos were no longer
available YouTube had placed them on its
restricted list which prevents the
videos from playing on computers using
content filters to screen out violence
and pornography Prager you assumed this
was simply a case of bad algorithms but
YouTube said no each restricted video
had been reviewed by a walking talking
human the list included such diverse
titles as are the police racist by
Heather McDonald Israel's legal founding
by Alan dtz and even a video on the Ten
Commandments by Dennis Prager YouTube
deemed each one unsuitable for young
people treating these videos the same as
they would say for ones containing
pornography or excessive violence keep
in mind this is Prager you were talking
about as Main Street as you can get and
that ultimately turns out to be the
issue Prager use center right content of
their videos by the way have no
political theme at all offends YouTube
sensibilities in other words the videos
aren't being restricted to protect young
people from inappropriate content
they're being restricted to protect
young people from ideas YouTube
disagrees with we didn't want to sue we
tried to reach an accommodation but when
YouTube wouldn't take the offending
videos off their restricted list there
are now 100 on that list we had no other
op
option YouTube was infringing on our
right to free speech we filed in federal
court in late 2017 and thereafter in
California State
Court wait a second you might say
YouTube which is owned by Google is a
private company can't they do anything
they want the answer is yes and no yes
if they are a publisher no if they are a
public forum so what's the difference
this gets right to the nub of the matter
a publisher chooses the content that
resides on its site the New York Times
is a perfect example you can't write a
story and just expect the New York Times
to publish it the times chooses what
appears on its Pages or website and if
they publish a story that contains a
malicious lie or violates copyright law
they can be sued Prager youu is also a
publisher it decides what material gets
placed on its website most sites are
publishers in contrast a public forum
which can be a physical location like
the classic Town Square or a shopping
mall or a virtual location like a
website is a place that must allow
individuals and organizations to
exercise their free speech rights
YouTube is an example of a public forum
in fact YouTube describes itself as a
public forum you make a video YouTube
hosts it and anyone with an internet
connection can watch it Facebook is also
a public forum and so is Twitter
here's why this is so important a public
forum under Section 230 of the
communications decency act aot
co-sponsored by Democrats and
Republicans and passed by Congress in
1996 is not subject to liability for
Content placed on its site if someone
posts a video about how to build a bomb
or writes a threatening comment the
public forum website cannot be held
legally responsible for that content
that's a good thing it gives YouTube
yoube and other public forums the chance
to host a wide variety of material from
nature videos to political diet tribes
without fear of being sued and it worked
and then it didn't a few years ago the
social media Giants Google Facebook
YouTube and Twitter started to behave
not like public forums but like
Publishers they stopped following
section 230 which specifically requires
that these websites promote a true
diversity of political discourse and
began to judge content by their own
political and social criteria in other
words the social media Giants wanted
both ways they want the protections of a
public forum and the editorial control
of a publisher we're fine if they're a
publisher and we're fine if they're a
public forum they just can't be both if
we win our legal action YouTube will
have to return to the way things were
when they started that's freedom but if
we lose YouTube gets to act as a
publisher while pretending to be a
public forum that would mean much less
freedom and then eventually no freedom
because the most powerful internet sites
on Earth will determine what you see and
what you don't I'm Eric George managing
partner Brown George Ross for Prager
University
