China's local economy is collapsing! Fuyang City in Hangzhou has collapsed and been taken over

CN Under
3 followers
Mar 13, 2025
China's local economy is collapsing! Fuyang City in Hangzhou has collapsed and been taken over.
China's local economy is collapsing. The finances of Hangzhou's Fuyang City have
collapsed and been taken over. Recently, it was reported that the finances of Fuyang City,
Hangzhou, Zhejiang Province, collapsed, and it is now under the trusteeship of Hangzhou.
China's economy continues to decline.
Yunnan Province also announced that all civil servants' salaries in the province will be
suspended. The ex-account, Daniel Fang, posted a message today, 26, stating that Hangzhou's
economy is terrible. Daniel Fang shared an article from a Chinese netizen mentioning that five years
ago, the rent for the EFC office at the Chuangjing Road subway entrance in Hangzhou was 2.8 yuan
per square meter per day, while today, the rent at the Oak Center in the same location is 1.2 yuan.
This office is part of Hangzhou's second iconic CBD in Future Science and Technology City,
close to Alibaba. As for other offices, especially in large parks, many are being
offered rent-free because landlords can save on business fees by renting them out.
Many new companies lack offices, and numerous companies have either closed down or reduced
their office space. The netizen noted that half of his office floor has been vacant for six months.
His office is located in Hangzhou, 100 meters from Yongfu Subway Station and 350 meters from
Alishijie Park. The fact that such a prime location has remained vacant for half a year
shows how bad the economy is. The netizen claimed that to cut costs, he considered laying off
employees. Ultimately, on Monday, he laid off 15 staff from the live broadcasting department,
six from marketing, and retained only one employee for design and customer service.
He lamented that the current economic situation is dire. Daniel Fang also mentioned that various
regions of China have begun laying off investment promotion offices. He speculated that this could
be because there is no money to support these offices or no one is being attracted to them.
He believes this is a sign that China's era of economic prosperity is gone forever.
Additionally, a fiscal expenditure and income chart from Guangwei shows that from January to
July, most regions in China are facing fiscal gaps, further highlighting the worsening economic
situation. Shanghai distributes 500 million yuan in coupons. Netizens say China's economy
is beyond saving. With the National Day holiday approaching, the Shanghai municipal government
announced it will issue consumer vouchers worth 500 million RMB, about 71.22 million USD,
starting Saturday, September 28, to stimulate the service industry. However, Shanghai citizens do
not seem to appreciate it, as the vouchers come with restrictions such as full amount discount
and first-come, first-served. Many netizens believe the government is not being sincere.
Scholars argue that Shanghai's consumer vouchers are akin to discount vouchers. They are not
universally issued and have set consumption thresholds, so their benefits may be limited.
China's economy is weak, and people are generally downgrading their consumption,
even in first-tier cities. On Wednesday, September 25, the Shanghai municipal government
announced it will invest 500 million RMB in municipal funds to issue Happy Shanghai
consumer vouchers to four major service sectors, 3.6 trillion RMB for the catering industry,
90 million RMB for the accommodation industry, 30 million RMB for the film industry, and 20
RMB for sports activities. The first batch of vouchers will be available starting this Saturday.
However, there are thresholds for using the vouchers, such as 50 yuan off for dining
purchases of 300 yuan or more and 300 yuan off for accommodation purchases of 1,200 yuan or more,
resembling department store anniversary discounts. According to official media Liberation Daily on
September 26, these vouchers will be issued in two phases on a first-come, first-served basis
through four different payment and ticketing platforms.
The Taobaoization of consumption vouchers has sparked public outcry in Shanghai.
Shanghai citizens are not optimistic about this measure. Ms. Yang, a Shanghai resident who wished
to remain anonymous, criticized the Shanghai municipal government in an interview with Voice
of America, stating, Taobao has been used too much and has begun to reflect reality.
It is too funny. There is no sincerity at all, and it is impossible to promote consumption.
She also expressed concern that the Shanghai municipal government
might use taxpayers' money to frivolously subsidize businesses in disguise.
Chinese social media platform Weibo also reflected doubts. Shanghai netizen
HappyMiracle09 criticized the government for saying,
If you're reluctant to issue it, then don't. You want to stimulate people's consumption
but are unwilling to release it. Another Shanghai netizen, KidsMomDod,
complained that cash is more useful than consumption coupons, writing,
Give out money. Brother, you always want to get the biggest return with the least expenditure.
You're being foolish. A third Shanghai netizen,
WandoDuoDuo, questioned the goodwill of the Shanghai municipal government, asking,
Why are they always secretive about issuing them, announcing subsidies without telling you where
to get them? Even people from other provinces and cities criticized the Shanghai municipal
government's so-called people-friendly policies. A Weibo user named HeyCurryGuySan from Guangdong
wrote, The local government, Shanghai, did it on its own. They wanted to stimulate
consumption but didn't have much money, fearing they would offend other regions
and the central government. A Shanghai resident noted,
The Chinese economy is declining daily, and these consumer stimulus packages from the government
can only slow the collapse of the domestic economy. They cannot save it. This is because
people are facing a wave of unemployment and bankruptcy and no longer have a source of income.
People want to improve their spending power, rather than increase consumption.
Wusechi, director of the Taiwan Think Tank Center for Chinese Studies in Taipei,
stated that Shanghai's issuance of discount-type consumer coupons aims to boost the economy in
specific areas through targeted consumption, but the benefits may be extremely limited.
The vouchers adopt a first-come, first-served model rather than a universal issuance,
locking in those with spending power to achieve immediate digital performance,
which aligns with the short-term operational inertia of the CCP's rule. However, setting a
consumption threshold may lead to low public acceptance. Furthermore, he said Shanghai's
consumption is anchored in the life and entertainment industry. The intended model is,
people consume first, stores offer discounts, and then vouchers are used to receive government
subsidies. However, unscrupulous stores might increase prices before offering discounts to
maintain higher profits. If such situations arise, consumers will be disadvantaged and won't enjoy
any real benefits. Whether stores that offer discounts will ultimately receive government
subsidies is also uncertain. Wusechi told VOA,
Chinese people do not want to increase consumption now. They want to improve their
consumption capacity. This is a completely different concept. This consumption voucher
policy may be like a stone thrown into water, having no effect. China's current structural
problems are very serious, and consumption cannot be resolved merely by consumption.
Wusechi remarked that Shanghai, as a leading international city with many leading industries,
relying on consumption vouchers to stimulate the economy, indicates that its status as China's
economic leader has been shaken, suggesting that the economies of other Chinese cities may be worse.
Consumption vouchers boost consumption, but the effect is only short-lived.
Shanghai issued a total of 1 billion RMB in consumption vouchers as early as August 2022.
At that time, the city was severely affected by the pandemic,
prompting the Shanghai municipal government to issue electronic consumption vouchers
through online registration and lottery to promote spending.
Regarding the consumption voucher initiative, Lai Rongwei, assistant professor at Longhua
University of Science and Technology in Taoyuan, northern Taiwan, believes it can only promote
short-term consumption and cannot reverse the long-term structural decline of China's economy.
He stated that Shanghai's consumption vouchers have many restrictions,
with effects akin to a department store anniversary celebration, which has limited
appeal. Moreover, Chinese consumers are now saving more and spending less.
Under the trend of consumption downgrading, the first cuts are usually made to unnecessary
entertainment expenses. Thus, few people are likely to spend an extra 250 yuan for a 50 yuan discount.
Lai Rongwei told VOA,
Once the consumption vouchers are used up, people will not consume. The effect is short-lived.
It merely rejuvenates the economic situation for a while,
treating the symptoms, but not the root cause.
Shanghai's issuance of consumption vouchers may aim to show the world that China's economy
is not as bleak as outside assessments suggest, but Lai Rongwei believes that this move has
exposed the severity of China's economic situation. Like government actions at all levels,
it has stopped hiding and begun to actively address economic challenges.
However, he cautions that the Shanghai consumption vouchers are merely a short-term
stimulus policy in response to the National Day holiday and are limited to Shanghai,
meaning they are unlikely to stimulate significant enthusiasm for consumption.
When the CCP finally lifted the zero COVID epidemic prevention measures
and allowed Chinese citizens to travel abroad, many countries' tourism industries had high hopes.
However, as China's economic situation continues to worsen,
more and more small and middle-class citizens are tightening their purse strings when traveling,
and some are choosing not to travel or to travel less.
Last year, 87 million Chinese citizens traveled abroad, a 40 percent decrease from 2019 before
the pandemic. Only 3.5 million Chinese tourists visited Thailand, about one-third of the nearly
11 million in 2019. According to tourism data from the United Nations, Chinese tourists spent
24 percent less last year compared to 2019, while American tourists spent 14 percent more.
Mr. Liu, a Thai tourism operator, said that the number of mainland Chinese tour groups
coming to Thailand is at least half of what it used to be, and their spending power has
significantly decreased. Mr. Liu, a Thai travel agent, even the tour guide from the group I led
today had a hoarse voice. Even the popular parachute activity, which used to be a must,
wasn't taken by anyone. It's quite common now. People are just reluctant to spend money.
Mr. Liu mentioned that many Chinese tourists now have a just-visiting mentality,
holding onto their wallets tightly and trying not to spend money. Mr. Liu added that many Chinese
who travel to Thailand are now middle- and low-income individuals. In order to attract
business, Chinese travel agencies are competing fiercely, with some even offering a seven-day
luxury tour of Thailand for only 555 yuan. Mr. Liu, if customers don't buy anything,
the travel agency loses money. If they don't participate in activities,
the tour guide loses money. So, it's common for customers to be pressured into shopping,
scolded, or even beaten. This downgrade in consumption is very evident.
A tourist from Wuhan told Mr. Liu that before the pandemic, his small shop earned 10,000 to
20,000 yuan per month. Now, it's hard enough just to keep the shop running. He also showed Mr. Liu
a video of Hanjing Street, a famous commercial street in Wuhan that he personally recorded.
Mr. Liu, it used to be crowded and bustling. Now, only a few shops remain open and the rest
are closed. Clothing stores are the first to go. Some restaurants survive because people still need
to eat. But for tourist goods, small accessories, souvenirs, etc., it's over. People don't buy them
unless they have to. Mr. Tan from Fuzhou, Fujian said that the local standard of living can only
be described as resembling the Great Depression. Nothing is going well and the tourism industry
is naturally suffering. Even 13th Street, the most lively street in Fuzhou, has seen most
stores closed down. Mr. Tan from Fuzhou, tourism is nearly stagnant. There are some domestic
travelers but far fewer are traveling abroad. I hardly hear of anyone going abroad to play these
days. Mr. Wu from Guangzhou, the overall decline in consumption is quite obvious. I drove back to
my hometown on August 13th and found that there were noticeably fewer cars and people on the
Beijing Zhuhai Expressway, even in the rest areas. I travel this route often and there are never this
few people, even on weekdays. Mr. Liu said that because of the economic downturn, many middle
class people from mainland China have come to Thailand and more are continuing to arrive.
Mr. Liu, many residential areas, especially middle and high-end ones, are filled with Chinese people.
It feels like I'm still in China. The economy is the main reason. The second reason is that
many people in China woke up because of the pandemic. You can now see that many people
realize they are being taken advantage of. Douyin videos are being forwarded to friends on WeChat.
What is China's national dish? Leeks. We are the national dish. Why leeks? Because leeks can be
harvested over and over again without complaints. Mr. Liu said that those Chinese who are woke and
have the means are trying to leave, while those without the means can't leave even if they want to.
