Fireside Chat Ep. 167 — Science or God: Do You Have To Pick One? | Fireside Chat

PragerU
799 followers
22 Video Views·Mar 11, 2025
We’ve all heard it: “I don't believe in God, I believe in science.” That's fine, but how do you get good and evil from science? And do religious people reject science? Dennis responds.
Hi everybody Dennis Prager here for the final fireside chat of the year for those of you new to the fireside chat every week
And I mean every week we don't miss
I get a chance to just talk to you
About thoughts that I have and then take your own questions
And my sidekick is otto. Usually his head is toward me
There is no rhyme or reason why it's not this week, but there may be a reason this is the area
He most loves to be rubbed
Is that correct otto?
the
dynamism of his response
Is just awe-inspiring
so
What do I talk to you about in the final fireside chat of the year? What a lousy year 2020 was
No, I decided not to actually I do want to say something about that
I did not allow it to be a terrible year in my own life
I decided from the very beginning to live life as normally as possible. I gathered with friends just as frequently
as I have
During normal years
I did not allow lockdowns
to the extent possible and I
I still could go for uh haircuts
I went to what we call a speakeasy
Where during prohibition they had bars open in some way, this is this is like prohibition
writ large
and like nancy pelosi, I went and found
a
Hair salon as it were where I could get a haircut the difference between me and nancy. Pelosi is I
Publicly announced that I was getting a haircut and she told people not to get their hair done
That's a very big difference
Be that as it may, uh, I have been blessed with friends who have the same attitudes
Uh same attitude as I do and i've had a i've had a good year in that regard
But america and the world have had a terrible year. I opposed the worldwide lockdown from the very beginning
I got a lot of mockery and derision for it doesn't matter to me. I'm just noting it
Sometimes the cure so to speak is worse than the disease. This was a perfect example
hundreds of millions of people are approaching
Not just poverty but outright hunger
As a result of the collapse of the world economy
Completely done not by the pandemic completely done by politicians desires
to save every life possible
But they don't save every life possible because so many more people have died
overdosing on drugs or beginning drugs or getting on drugs who had been
sober for years
The number the number of children abused the number of partners and spouses abused has increased dramatically during this time
the number of kids with depression
Has is reaching?
That's a pandemic
Young people's depression is a pandemic
of
teenagers who who were
Just fine and happy go lucky. They're not made to be put into
a solitary confinement for a year
And for no good reason the chances of a 17 year old dying of covid are far less
Than a chance of a 17 year old dying in a car crash
But we allow 17 year olds not just to ride but to drive
So the decisions have been awful never in history have a uh, have entire populations been quarantined
Anyway, just some reflections on the year which was uh,
Fine with me and awful for my beloved society
And for the world, but I want to talk to you
before I take your questions
about this
very famous
Statement. I mean you hear it all the time
Uh about people who don't believe in god or don't believe in religion we believe in science
You get a kick out of that line. What does it mean to believe in science?
Do you mean you believe the truths that science comes up with who doesn't?
If you say religious people do not believe in scientific truths, you're making up nonsense
I'm religious. I know vast numbers of religious jews and christians. They all believe in the truths of science
Yes, it's true. Some people believe god created the world in six 24 hour periods
I happen to not give a hoot whether it's 24 hours or 24 million years
And I make that clear in my bible commentary because the word in hebrew for day can mean a thousand years
It says it in the bible or it could mean 24 hours
So that's not important. But other than that, whom do you know who's religious who doesn't believe in scientific truths?
Do you know any religious person who says gravity doesn't exist?
Or water is not composed of h2o
Or don't go to a doctor if if they if they if they need surgery, I don't know any
I didn't know any
So what does believe in science mean since we all believe in the truths of science and we all go for back surgery
if we need back surgery
What does it mean?
Ah, the answer is people don't know what it means because the truth is it doesn't mean anything else
Do you believe science will lead you to the right decision about good and evil
I don't
science
Tell me how science tells you to be kind
Tell me how science tells you
to save a life
If anything science if you want to follow science, it's just follow the darwinian rule of the survival of the fittest
Do you know if you follow the science you don't keep the elderly and infirm alive?
It's a waste of time and funds that could be spent on healthier people
In nature what happens to the elderly animal and the infirm they're eaten. I saw this in in africa
I've done it. I've been on four safaris
and uh, uh, it was it was revelatory to me when I when I saw
how
uh, the uh, the the weakest of the gazelles
Was simply eaten by the lion the lion would pick out the weakest of the gazelles if you follow science
You let the weak die
Science doesn't tell you to be kind or compassionate or or even build a hospital. It doesn't do any of these things
Follow the science, you know who followed science the nazi. Dr
Mengele, he followed the science and he took human beings and used them as guinea pigs in scientific experiments
this this sadist this butcher this
This diabolical human being he followed science
And so did the german medical association during the holocaust. They they endorsed the experiments on human beings
I don't follow the science to learn anything about life science doesn't give me wisdom science doesn't give me morality
Science doesn't give me compassion
Science has its role exactly. You want to know how to build?
A a vaccine or an atom bomb
Science is your vehicle
But it doesn't tell you when to use the atom bomb. It only tells you how to build one
so, uh, I don't trust people who just believe in science because I don't I don't trust your your
Understanding of good and evil. Where do you get it from?
Science science doesn't teach you that
So just thought i'd
Offer that as a thought we believe in science
What does that even mean? And by the way, the people who say it don't even mean it they really believe in science
thousands of scientists said it was
unhealthy to demonstrate
During during the pandemic right unhealthy too many people congregating together
But then they started demonstrating in the thousands against racism or alleged racism
And then they said oh that's healthy
That's right. Look it up thousands of scientists said. Oh, no
There's there are health benefits
to demonstrating against racism
so
People who say believe in science what they really mean is they believe in the scientists they agree with
That's all they mean
The best example is hydroxychloroquine
Many scientists believe that this would have saved a hundred thousand lives in america and probably
Hundreds of thousands all over the world if used early enough when a person is positive for covid hydroxychloroquine and zinc
Many I mean truly a lot of scientists
Are pro hydroxychloroquine?
And there's no danger to it
Essentially the thing has been around over a half a century millions of people have taken it constantly
It's as safe as drug as exists
So which science do you believe the scientists that say yes?
You can save massive numbers of lives if you in fact take it early
Or those who say oh, no, don't take it. The uh, the fda doesn't approve its use in early stages of covid
So you're not following the science if you're against hydroxychloroquine
You're following the scientists you agree with
I follow the science and I take hydroxychloroquine and zinc and and ivermectin too
So you're fooling yourself if you say follow the science
It means follow the scientists you agree with do you follow the scientists who say that men give birth?
Is that science?
Tell me is that science men give birth. Is that a scientifically accurate statement?
Of course not, you know many scientists now say men give birth
All who are woke
They don't follow science. They follow woketude
so
some thoughts on
follow the science
All right. Let's go to your uh, let's go to your questions here
and we begin with
Hi, my name is azalea. I'm 17 and i'm from chicago, illinois. My question is reflecting upon this year
Dennis, do you have any advice that you learned in 2020 that we should bring into this new year?
Oh boy
Well, ironically, I just uh actually addressed some of them i'll give you one immediately one one immediately
You have a choice in life
Is the purpose of life to live?
Or is the purpose of life to live fully?
That's that's the question
an animal's life
The purpose of an animal's life is to live
They have no interest in living fully
They don't have such a concept
We do
We're not animals
So the people who have spent the year afraid and hidden from life
And not been with friends and not had a thanksgiving or a christmas with with family or friends
I'm, not talking about the highly vulnerable. That's a completely separate issue. I fully understand it
But for the vast majority of people, do you know i'm not a big fan
I never even when I was in high school. I wasn't a big fan of big parties
I like to talk to people
You know one-on-one and you know have fun with a bunch of people that I knew but it doesn't matter
I'm, only mentioning this
I am such a big fan of kids having parties
Because they're saying to society. Hello. We're 21 years old. We want to live
We don't want to hide from life on the unbelievably slim chance that we'll die
The chance of a 21 year old dying of covid is so minuscule as to be pointless to even talk about
so
one of the biggest lessons must be
That you live life. I'll give you an example because you know the motto another great motto is better safe than sorry
For years i'll tell you how many years about 25
I've been broadcasting 35. So maybe 35 years. So I would often mention or occasionally mention
Oh, i'm going to israel for a visit because I get very inspired going to israel. I've been there about 25 times
And people would call up and say, you know, then it's boy would I love to visit the holy land? We'll see israel
But i'm waiting till it's safe
And I always used to say to people I just came back
It's safe. It's not perfectly safe
But the chance that you'll be blown up by a by an arab terrorist
Is very very small. In fact, I feel safer in israel than in parts of manhattan
Which is true, by the way
That's that's not an exaggeration
Or parts of philadelphia
that was for my younger son's sake and uh
You know wherever it might be
And so people who said oh i'll go to israel when it's safe never went
In the meantime, I go I take a trip of people of my listeners to israel
every two years
and
500 come with me
And it for most of them. It is the most wonderful trip of their life
And then they go back and go. Thank god. I wasn't paralyzed by fear. That's the big lesson
From the year don't be paralyzed by fear
Which means don't let the press don't let the media
Who are utterly and totally irresponsible? There's no redeeming factor to the mainstream media
Don't let them lead you by the nose
And in this case frighten you
They I don't know
Why they have such an agenda of fear, but they do
And virtually every country in the world followed the media except sweden
And even sweden finally sort of buckled sort of not fully
so yes
I I often mention that
You know what god tells the human being what god tells people the most in the bible do not fear
Okay
Jennifer 20 roswell, georgia. Why should men not wear dresses?
So this is a very important question actually
And i'll answer with a question and then i'll answer with an answer
Why should people not go around naked?
It's a very serious question
Why should people wear any clothing forget male female? Why shouldn't people I want you to answer in your mind right now?
Why shouldn't people walk around naked?
Obviously if it's if it's not, uh, if it's too cold, they can't
But in in the summer anywhere and in temperate climates
Anywhere anytime
So it's an interesting question, isn't it? Why shouldn't people walk around naked do you know that san francisco had a debate about this
They had a bill
To uh rescind the prohibition of walking around naked and by one vote
It uh, the the bill did not pass by one vote
They still said that you can't walk around fully naked in in san francisco. And by the way, the reasoning was it isn't sanitary
Naked people will sit on benches
And it's not sanitary which is nonsense. Obviously how many people sit on benches naked?
There aren't that many benches in cities to begin with
but uh, they they couldn't admit
That they really did believe there might be a deeper reason which gets me to the male and female in a moment
The reason that we don't want people to walk with their genitals exposed. That's that's what the issue is primarily with regard to nudity
Is because and people don't even know why
it's because
we have
a deep tradition called judeo-christian
That says humans are not animals animals have their genitalia exposed humans do not
One of the biggest difference between the differences between humans and animals is clothing
Animals don't wear clothing and and they're not self-conscious about
They're being naked that that's just the way it is and nor are we self-conscious about animals being naked
so
The deepest reason for not for for objecting and not allowing people to walk around naked
Is that there are certain things that are intrinsic to being human
That we want to preserve
And that comes ultimately from a judeo-christian outlook
Pre-judeo-christian outlook a lot of societies people did walk around naked
The bible says the same thing about men and women
There is a biblical law men cannot wear women's clothing and there's another law that women cannot wear men's clothing
And that is to preserve the distinction between male and female which is fundamental to civilization
Blurring the distinction between male and female
Uh, this has nothing to do with the transgender the transgender are not blurring the distinction
If if a woman says I am a man
And she then dresses like a man
takes a man's name
Looks like a man then it's a non-issue. There's no blurring of the male female distinction, but when a man
wears a dress
That is a deliberate blurring of the male female distinction
And then you have an unraveling of the basic
fundamental order of civilization, I know
This is not the way people think because people don't think about the the consequences
Of ending the judeo-christian tradition
I've devoted my life to one overriding theme
And that is the bad consequences of secularism
Secularism is great for government, but it's not great for life
What's our timing?
Oh good, really
Well, it's the second time in a row. I think your clock is off my inner clock
Rodrigo what do you think?
Oh, really the time of year what when clocks break
Yeah, oh the inner clocks break that's interesting
All right, dominic 23, new jersey. Hi dominic, new jersey. How do you know when you find your purpose here on earth?
It's a very very important question
So I have a few ways of approaching that
Well to be precise, you know when you know it
When you know it and I know this is almost a sort of a it seems like an evasive answer
But it's like there's a very famous story about a supreme court justice on a pornography case
And he was asked to define pornography and he said I can't define pornography
But I know it when I see it
And as it was a good it was a good answer. I mean it is difficult to define pornography
uh, and you know it when you see it and likewise
when you when you've
When you have a sense of purpose, you know it
It it comes but I I would like to offer you a a more helpful answer perhaps
through through most of of history
People were given a purpose
Rather than looking for one
so for example
For the vast majority of people in in history
Getting married and making a family was a built-in
huge purpose of life
That's another thing secular society has killed
We are we are fewer people in than any time in american history or for that matter japanese history
Are getting married
It's because of the death of religion for many people both in japan and the united states
And so when you don't believe that there is purpose in getting married and making a family
You you're really on the big big quest for purpose
So what people have done is they have made career purpose
There are very few careers that truly fulfill
That hole in you that wants purpose
I uh, I think I could tell the story of my my trainer. She's uh,
She's either 30 or just about to turn 30
So i've known her for years because i've been training with her for years
And I know her before she got married. I know her after she got married and I now know her after she has a baby
And she was very committed. That's why I have her as a trainer. She's a terrific trainer
And she got great deal of satisfaction from being a trainer
And then all of a sudden she had a husband
and a child
And now she tells me
She finds it very hard to leave the child
It's very tough
Somehow or other and i'm i'm i'm not
Knocking at all profession
It could be a big deal in a person's life
but compared for most people
To making a home and making make raising a child
Unless you are in a very very
powerfully
fulfilling
work
and that exists
then
It's it's a toughie
For the vast majority of people the purpose was given
Get married
make a family
Then you need a job. You need income to support the family
So what so most of the time through history it was the man of the family who made the money
And what he felt was wow, it doesn't matter that i'm selling tires
I don't get that much meaning from selling tires, but I get an immense amount of meaning
From making money from selling tires to support a family
So then almost anything you do
Becomes meaningful because the money that you've earned goes to supporting a family
I dare say that
Selling tires and making an income and supporting a family
Is a hell of a lot more meaningful than teaching gender studies
At the kaduka state college. I made up the name of the college because I didn't want to offend any given college
so
This is a real problem
This purpose issue and so did religion the other thing that would gave people deep purpose was religion
And you know to go to church each week to go to synagogue each week
To to have the lord's day in christianity to have the sabbath in judaism
Where you you convene with with?
Co-religionists
Hopefully have have a meal with them
And pray with them study with them
These are huge
I I devote mass amounts of time to to
My my bible commentary. It's very hard work. It's the hardest project i've ever embarked on
But it's immensely rewarding
Because I believe in it
So when you knock out religion and you knock out family knock out marriage and children
What what is your purpose going to be?
ceo
Of of some tech company wow, you know what that's not that much
CEOs are replaceable
No matter how good a ceo you are. You're ultimately replaceable
But nobody could replace mommy. Nobody could replace daddy. Nobody could replace a best friend
That's that's the thing
Okay
Allentown pennsylvania, look at that
matt 37
Dennis love your show and the puppies now. That's interesting did not isolate otto
And he is not hurt
I just I just looked over and see if he was all insulted. Somebody should mention even hintingly at otto
I mean at at snoopy. He he loves snoopy
I'm, not sure. He wants to share the spotlight
Question considering you were a democrat in the past, but now a conservative
What is your position on the argument that the democrats and republicans switched platforms at some point in our history?
Thank you for doing what you do. Thank you matt
Well, here's the interesting thing. It's funny considering you were a democrat in the past, but now a conservative
So I have a real big surprise for you
There is only one
thing I can think of
That I have changed my mind on
Going from the democratic party the through the republican party going from liberal to conservative
Literally only one and that is the size of government
I I realized and that's a big one, by the way
America was founded to have a very small government so that people have as much freedom and responsibility as possible
That is the unique thing every other society in history had big governments kings
emperors
Religious people and theocracies
Only america was founded to have small government
But otherwise there is not one value that I have rejected from my liberal democrat
past
That and i'm called a conservative
I'm, so in other words, I didn't change my values the left the liberals change their values
Because they don't realize that the left is their enemy. The enemy of liberalism is not conservatism
The enemy of liberalism is leftism
How many examples you want liberals believe in free speech leftists don't?
liberals believe in racial integration
leftists believe in racial segregation
Colleges have black dorms
Liberals hated black dorms. The only people who were pro pro black dorms are the ku klux klan and leftists
dorms based on race
Is called segregation
That was the dirtiest word for liberals when I grew up. It's still a dirty word in my opinion
I want complete racial integration
Liberals knew capitalism is the only way to raise people from poverty the left hates capitalism
So I haven't changed
liberals did
Because they now accept the left as part of their own ideology
Kudsiya 21 st. Louis. My name is kudsiya
I gathered that I am from afghanistan living in st. Louis, Missouri
When learning about the holocaust in grade school, it always bothered me how such evil could happen
I look at the hate that has spread through america today and it makes me question where the future is headed
My question to you is how did nazism happen and what role did propaganda and illiteracy play in it?
Truly admire
What you do. Thank you
well
It is scary actually
The only way the holocaust could have happened i've written this for all of my life is based on lies lies are the root of evil
Money is not the root of evil
Appetites are not the root of evil lies are the root of evil not not that
The others don't cause problems
But you can't have mass evil without lies
The lie that blacks were inferior allowed slavery the lie that jews were inferior allowed the holocaust
And yes when that when the mass media lie
You are your country is in trouble and I believe the mass media in america lie
And uh, we are in trouble. That's why they suppress
people like me and others
because the left
For whom truth has never been a value liberals value truth
conservatives value truth
But uh truth is not a left-wing value and never has been that's why they are willing to shut down
all dissenting voices at college at high school
At your place of work and on the internet
because
It's easy to punctualize
If we are allowed to expose them
But they don't want us to do so
So it is a scary time
And that's uh, that's a sad fact
But i'm not scared because I don't walk around scared
That's one of the things I mentioned about one of the great lessons of 2020
So I wish you from the bottom of my heart a happy
and healthy new year
And I will be with you
God willing
All year like this past one
So on behalf of otto
And megan and rodrigo and nathan and the folks at prager u
Have a happy year
Thank you for watching this video to help keep prager u videos free. Please consider making a tax-deductible donation
