Fireside Chat Ep. 160 — Cutting Out Family Over Politics | Fireside Chat

PragerU
800 followers
22 Video Views·Mar 11, 2025
Families are dividing today over politics, and few things upset Dennis Prager more than seeing families destroyed. There's a common thread in these cruel situations; do you know what it is?
0:00 Great To Be With You
0:58 When Cheating And Lying Are Moral
4:20 Cutting Out Family Over Politics
6:38 Why The Left Is A Cult
9:15 What Is The Fruit Of Your Ideology?
11:18 Are Pro-Lifers Only Pro-Birth?
15:30 Imagine If All Conservatives Spoke Out
19:53 Will Conservatism Survive?
23:27 Looked Down Upon For A Big Family
26:37 Dealing With Insecurities
Dennis's column: Thoughts in a Dark Time — https://dennisprager.com/column/thoughts-in-a-dark-time/
Subscribe so you never miss a new Fireside Chat! 👉 https://www.prageru.com/series/fireside-chats/
Okay, everybody hi great to be with you
Isn't that funny for me to say great to be with you?
In what sense am I with you? Well, I really am with you, but i'm not physically with you
But I am with you
Anyway, I analyze everything so forgive me
It's a very strange beginning, but it's the whole thing spontaneous
on behalf of otto
I welcome you
And otto welcomes you on behalf of me
What's he doing? Oh, he's awake
Well, this is a major moment to have a fireside chat
It's a special dog
All right, everybody
So what I do each week and we haven't missed in years now. Wow
is
Offer you some thoughts about life or about current events and then take your questions
So I have an interesting question and an important one
I'm not going to address the whole issue of the american elections being honest not honestly counted
I just want to address one
Interesting moral question
that
Is worth thinking about
Donald trump has been accused by
All of the left democratic party the various newspapers and
And social media and so on for four years of being a white supremacist
a fascist
and a dictator
Right. I mean that's normative
Accusations of donald trump
so if you are
Counting ballots. You're a democrat
In a democratic controlled city and
an area precinct or county
And you have the chance
to to cheat
with regard to the voting count
and you believe
That donald trump is a fascist
And a white supremacist and a dictator
Why wouldn't you cheat?
I would
I admit it
if I were counting votes in any in any country
and
I believed
That a a candidate
That I could stop from winning by cheating
Was a fascist and a white supremacist and a dictator
I would cheat
I mean just there there were times when cheating
Or lying is moral
If I were
Saving a jew I was hiding a jew
in nazi occupied europe
and
The nazis came to the door and said are you hiding a jew I would lie
It would be the right thing to do
Preventing a a fascist white supremacist
Dictator from becoming the leader of a country
Is the right thing to do?
So
I'm, not making any accusation. I am I am only saying
That there is no moral reason why a democratic
operative
In in a voting center wouldn't
Feel morally obligated to cheat. So either
They have been saying these things
Just to uh, just to attack the president
Or they and not really believe it just said it for effect or they really believe it and I and I think they really
Many of them really believe it
so
What's to stop them?
Not not morality
Just a thought
another subject
related to uh, not to the count but related to the
The issue of
How americans are getting along
Right after the 2016 election the new york times
when when
When donald trump was elected president to everybody's shock including my own I might add
There was a front page article in the new york times about a week later
Because in the united states and i'm saying this because a lot of you are outside of the united states
in the united states, we have the
big holiday of thanksgiving
A few weeks after election day
And the article in the new york times noted that thanksgiving was going to be disrupted in many homes
because
A lot of people were not prepared to have a thanksgiving dinner
With a friend or relative who had voted for donald trump
We we don't know of anybody I mean i'm sure it exists, but we don't know of anybody
Where it went the other way around oh you voted for hillary clinton
I won't have thanksgiving dinner with you
I'm laughing because I I simply don't I can't imagine
Somebody saying that i'm not saying it hasn't been said, but I can't imagine it being said
And this has been a crisis for uh for years in the united states
of
of terrible proportions
To the extent and I know about it to
to the extent that
Children, and I don't mean 10 year olds. I mean 25 30 40 year olds
Won't talk to a parent
Who voted for donald trump?
Parents call me up and tell me that their children
Not only don't talk to them. They don't allow them to see
their grandchildren
the children of the children
Because the parent slash grandparent voted for donald trump
and
This is one of the reasons that I believe that
The left not liberals. I always make a distinction. There's a huge distinction between a liberal and a leftist
This is one of the the many reasons I have come to understand that the left is a cult
Because one of the distinguishing characteristics of cults
Is that they frequently sever relations
between the members of the cult and their parents
breaking up
family
ties
is a
very common
thing in cults
and
Breaking parental authority is huge
they
You owe them nothing. You owe the cult everything
And when I was talking about this on my radio show
I
offered this thought
one way of measuring an
ideology secular or religious is
How does it affect?
a person's relationship
With his or her parents
Does it bring parents and children together?
Or does it separate and alienate them from one another so I was thinking about
uh children adult children
who
become christian or become religious jews
and
in in every case that I know
Doesn't mean in every case on earth, but in every case that I know
It actually brought parents and children more together even if the parents did not accept
that religious faith
but
christianity and
the christian faith christianity
orthodox judaism
Would
tend to have you
Try to reconcile with your parents
Because if nothing else both accept the ten commandments
Which has a law the famous law honor your father and mother
There's no such law in leftism
and
That's that's a big difference
So when you measure
or judge
What ideology to adopt?
The consequences of that ideology are very important for you to take into account
Will I be?
A kinder finer human being not just am I taking a great position?
How will it affect me?
Will I be kinder? Will will I be?
more
Desirous of bonds with with the people in my life
Will I I be a a more wonderful honest human being?
Those are very important considerations
and
My experience in life has been that the more left people get
In most kids in most instances the the more the meaner they get
I hate saying this because I wish it weren't true
It's I don't hold again. I don't hold this true for liberals. I don't hold this true for conservatives
But
It seems to be that way
To stop talking to a parent because
They voted
For someone you can't stand
Wow
I know this comes as a shock to a lot of people on the left
But people on the right couldn't stand hillary clinton as much as people on the left couldn't stand donald trump
But they didn't stop talking to their parents or deprive their parents of their grandchildren
If the parent voted for hillary clinton
It's a very important question
What type of person does an ideology produce
Okay, let's go to your questions
and we begin
with
Hi
Hi, my name is rizzi. I'm 20 years old and i'm from new york. I had a question regarding abortion
So recently i've seen the claim going around that people who are pro-life
Aren't actually pro-life they're just pro-birth and don't care about what happened to the baby after it's born
I was wondering how you would respond to that claim
Thank you so much
Well, thank you rizzi
That uh, I uh, I just want you to know that you've seen that claim you're 20 years old
So you've seen that claim going around and I want you to know
That this claim went around when I was 20 years old
it's it is a
Typical left-wing attack on people they differ with
That they're really just scum. That's that's the general left-wing view of people. They don't agree with
I've never quite seen
The proof to that horrible charge
We just want you born and then we don't give a damn about you
It's so preposterous. So here here's a very simple question
I've never seen the data, but i've lived a full and long life
And I can tell you
that
I would love to see the data on who is more likely to adopt
a a child
uh with disabilities
a leftist
or a religious christian
And I would bet my house
and that's
That's a big deal. I love my house and it's the essence of
The uh the savings I have
Uh, but I would bet my house
that a that
Disproportionately
the the pro-life christian
catholic christian
Is more likely to adopt a child with disabilities
Than a pro-choice
leftist
Okay, that's real life. That's not
One of these generalized attacks. I have no problem with generalizations
Providing they're based on reality
so
What they're what they mean I assume is they don't care about when people are born because they're against
a bigger government
But that you could say about people who are have nothing to do with abortion
Their belief is that if you don't want the government to constantly get bigger you don't care about people
Of course, it's often quite the opposite
Because the more the government takes care of people the less people take care of people
That's why americans
Well, first of all conservatives give more charity
than people on the left including liberals
That's just data. You could check that data do conservatives or liberals give more charity
uh in uh
in the volunteer more time
Ask look that look that stuff up
But the what we really have it's clear even clearer than that is americans give more charity and volunteer more time
Uh than europeans do and there's very simple reason
europeans are trained
Because they're they're all trained by the left. They are trained to believe
That the government will take care of the poor and the sick I don't have to take care of the poor and the sick
I don't even have to take care of the poor and sick in my own family. The government will
that's that's
That is why I have a speech on the internet. I gave at the university of wyoming socialism makes you selfish
and you should uh
If I may say that you should watch it
Okay, amy 27 germany hi, mr. Prager i'm an egyptian so I guess it's ami not amy
I'm an egyptian studying in germany. Your wisdom is something I wait to listen to every week. Thank you
My question is what do I do?
If both my professors and other students in class are always very aggressive in attacking
Conservatism slash capitalism
I feel like giving up and just keep my views to myself because the aggression escalates very quickly and I feel alone in the fight
First of all, let me just say
That if you're an egyptian living in germany, obviously your two primary languages are arabic and german
It's pretty good english
I gotta say that that's uh, I mean, I hope I meet you once
or even twice
So, well, let's see, what do I do about uh, they uh, they escalate uh the aggression
You feel like giving up
So i've been thinking about this a lot because i've been getting this question for years
If I speak up, I again I may lose my family like I just described earlier
I may lose friends. I may be
You know
removed from everybody's facebook page
I may be attacked on social media
I may even get fired from my job. I may get a lower grade in college
I am aware of all of that
Because the left is mean and that's that's true
We don't do that to them
so
Here is a thought
70 million americans voted for donald trump
70 million americans essentially
Uh, or whatever the the number would be but half of america voted
Conservative voted republican
Imagine if they all spoke out
Imagine if 70 million americans just decided
I don't care about what will be done to me on social media
Or by friends who really don't like me apparently
But I am no longer willing to hide what I stand for
The country this country would change radically
for the better
Because they believe correctly that if they bully
conservatives enough
They will force them to shut up
I receive letters because i'm involved in music. I receive letters from members of orchestras in the united states
And they they tell me that they they just can't say anything
uh for fear of
if they you know, they may get thrown off the orchestra, but
their bigger fear is just being
Ostracized by their colleagues, which is a bad thing in an orchestra
You you need each other very much in an orchestra
but I I know how prevalent this is and
We need a campaign to get people to speak up
if if one tenth
Of those who voted for donald trump came out of the closet
It would be very dramatic
seven million americans
Just saying I I will no longer
Be bullied by left-wing totalitarians
So I would say to you ami that's right
You're not the only one in germany who thinks like you do
There aren't many
But you're they're not non-existent either
so
Good luck. It's easier for me to advise than for you to do. I fully acknowledge that
But that's my advice
Rui
60 bellum para brazil
Mr. Prager, i'm a brazilian fan of yours
Thank you
Obrigado
My question is do you really and really is capitalized?
Think multi-millennial judeo-christian western civilization has any chance to survive 50 more years. I don't
capitalize d-o-n-postrophe-t
Unfortunately, it's doomed to perish by 2050
well
So let me tell you as the judeo part of the judeo-christian and i'm a big believer in judeo-christian values
That uh, they're
One guy who wrote one author wrote a book about the jews
And he called them the ever dying people
Jews are always dying out and by golly, they're still here
This is not going to die out
It's inconceivable you think
By 2050 every christian is going to end up being a secular leftist. I'll tell you an interesting thing. It is growing
It's growing in africa
I expect an african pope
In the not too distant future
I uh, I see both protestantism and catholicism
Having a renaissance in africa
so
Uh, the west is has decided to die
That's it's it's it. They don't have children
They get married much less. They they have far fewer children. It's all because of secularism
Religious people have children
The secular, uh are preoccupied with the climate change
and
So they'll uh, they'll reduce carbon emissions
And no longer have a western civilization
I the we live in the in the realm of the absurd
So, uh, I would not make the prediction that you did
But I will say religious people have to know how to make the case for religion and very few do
For most religious people religion is a habit
not an intellectual
conviction
and
I I blame religious people
As much as I blame the anti-religious no, it's 50 50
For the decline in judaism and christianity because it has been rendered habit
rather than
an intellectual
moral
powerhouse that it is
So I guess this is a good chance for me to tell you
You want to know this?
in depth, please read
My two volumes third volume is coming out next year
Of my commentary called the rational bible. It is completely reason-based
It explains the most important text to judaism and christianity the first five books of the bible
Everything else is based on on those five books
It's called the rational bible
Genesis and exodus are out
Deuteronomy is coming out next year
Even if you're an atheist you you owe it to the west and you owe it to yourself
to see what an intellectual explanation
of those books
consists of
All right, amanda 38 st. John indiana. Hello dennis. My husband and I have eight children
Eight boys to be precise
That is mind
blowing
Eight boys amanda, so like do you like escape to girlfriends?
You are living in testosterone city. That is mind-blowing
I wonder how many people have had eight boys or eight girls
We love having a big family and feel it is a blessing from god that he has entrusted us with so many children
It is a blessing
However, when we go anywhere strangers look at us like we have two heads
Now that is interesting
I'm going to talk about that in a moment. We get all sorts of questions and comments some are nice, but most are not
that I I I have to say i'm
I'm a little uh surprised
Why would someone make a not nice first of all to make a not nice comment to a stranger?
takes a particularly ugly human being but uh
But a not nice comment over having eight children
Women are act shocked that I would choose to give birth eight times and be a homemaker
It was not that long ago in america. So it must be then I guess women making these comments. I believe that I can't imagine a
Man making a comment to a family. Oh, I can't believe you're doing that
Uh, which is one of the reasons by the way that i've never bought the idiocy that women are superior to men
Both sexes have wonderful human beings and both sexes have disgusting human beings and that's the way it is
It was not that long ago in america that large families were the norm
When do you think that changed and why are large families now looked on as strange? Thanks for your thoughts. I love listening to you
It changed, uh in after the 50s
As america went secular left
It's a combination of secularism and leftism
and the
You represent what they loathe
a family-based life
You see if you were the ceo
of a um
I don't know a fashion design firm
Whoa
That is a big deal
But that you are raising eight human beings
To be good citizens good human beings
Oh, that's what a waste of a life you understand how perverse it is
Now you should really get a life if you're a young woman major in gender studies
Then you will really have an important life
whereas having kids having a husband and kids
What a waste
That's how sick it's become. It's all inverted. It's truly inverted leftism is a form of moral chaos
Ben 19, westminster, colorado. Mr. Prager and the world's most famous dog. Otto
Yeah
Otto's immediate response to hearing his name
Must move you
I would like to begin by saying your fireside chats have brought a lot of joy and wisdom into my life. Excellent
I am currently reading your book. Think a second time
And I recently ordered happiness is a serious problem. Thank you on both
Think a second time is 44 essays on 44 subjects
It's a it's the perfect
Introduction to my thoughts on a lot of subjects
Think the second time I was curious if you talk about insecurities in that book the book on happiness
I was also wondering if you could give a short answer on how you personally deal with insecurities
Thank you, and god bless all those at prager you. Thank you. God has blessed all those at prager you
I think they feel it. Isn't that right to say?
It's a very good question. I don't address the issue of insecurities in the happiness book
And you have prompted me
To raise that issue on my happiness hour
So I could talk it over
With people who call in from the millions of listeners
I've gotten a lot of wisdom massive wisdom
from my listeners
So I will I will raise that issue
Everyone on earth has insecurities
everyone
and part of the
Antidote, I suspect is the great famous idea know thyself
See it. I I knew at a very early age what I wasn't good at and probably would never be good at
And what I did was concentrate
On what I was good at
And I
I simply allowed
And i'm not saying this is a perfect answer
At all to your question
But i'm i'm referencing my own life because that's the life I know best
and
What what I would do is
By excelling in certain areas the areas where I wasn't
Excellent or felt insecure in
Became less important
You everyone needs an area to feel good about themselves in and and by the way
I I believe that there are two things that allow that you earn it
That's the biggest but also you you may have it built in you if you
if if you uh are
You know endowed with perfect pitch i'll use a musical example, you know, it's a gift
There you know, you can give 50 kids piano lessons
And you know three of them
are gifted pianists
47 or not
But they could still learn to play the piano nicely but very few are gifted but the gifted
the the
I know musicians so a lot of them are very secure in their music, but not necessarily as secure socially
You know
They would feel very funny getting up in front of a group and giving a speech
I would have the opposite. I I
I find talking to groups effortless
uh, and
I on the other hand
I I knew at an early age. I I was never going to be a good instrumentalist. That's why I learned to conduct because
That was my way of playing an instrument the orchestra
I think focusing on on what you can do. Well will help you
And
Know this will also help
Everybody has insecurities
that
comes
With the deal when you're born
So, I hope all of this was thought-provoking
Thanks for being with me. I'm dennis prager
This is otto. I'll see you next week
Thank you for watching this video to help keep prager you videos free
Please consider making a tax-deductible donation
You
