389 Video Views·Mar 12, 2025
🔵 Try Epoch Times now: https://ept.ms/3Uu1JA5
This is the 30 minute TV version of Jan Jekielek’s interview with Edward Ring. The longer-form version was released on Epoch TV on February 8, 2025.
🔴 Watch the extended version of this episode: https://ept.ms/Y0208EdwardRing
“The fires themselves are pretty much out. There’s a few smoldering remains, but the trouble has just begun,” says Edward Ring, director of Water and Energy Policy for the California Policy Center. “It’s going to be very hard to get everything rebuilt in Los Angeles.”
In this episode, Edward Ring talks about the recent devastating California wildfires. How did they originate? Why was the devastation so horrific? Could they have been prevented? What is the scope of the damage? And in the aftermath, what should be done?
Edward Ring: “We don't know yet how many people died. They don't know exactly how many homes are destroyed, but it's well over 10,000 homes that have been just burnt to the ground. You can't possibly convey this with enough respect to really grasp just how big this tragedy was for people who have gone through it.”
CHAPTER TITLES
0:00:00 - The Aftermath and Challenges of the California Fires
0:01:21 - Rebuilding Efforts and Permit Streamlining
0:04:54 - Assessing the Scope of Devastation
0:07:19 - Investigating the Causes of the Fires
0:10:18 - The Role of Forest Management and Fire Cycles
0:14:36 - Edward Ring's Perspective on Environmentalism
0:20:11 - Rethinking California's Sustainability Approach
What Edward Ring found on the ground in LA: “I was invited to the President's round table and press conference. So I, you know, kind of had a pretty intimate glimpse of not only what's going on down there, but also the response, at least from the federal government so far. And you know, the first thing I noticed was I couldn't get an Uber from Los Angeles International Airport to Pacific Palisades. It said no service, and that was my first inkling that something was very different. I ended up getting a taxi. I just gave him the address. We started driving, and we got, I guess, to within about five miles of the destination. And we started seeing burned homes here and there along Sunset Boulevard and, you know, in the foothills of West Los Angeles. And then we started seeing Humvees and military police stationed at intersections. And then we came to a checkpoint where there were a whole bunch of soldiers, and they said, you can't go any further. So I presented my identification, and they checked with the Secret Service and said, All right, you can go through, but your driver can't go through. And we ended up getting a motorcycle escort for the driver, and that took us now we go into like the burn scape. I mean, from that point on, everything was burned. And this went for a couple of miles where, you know, on both sides of the road, all you saw was hulks of cars burned out. Hulks, in some cases, melted portions of the car and chimneys, you know, and here and there a tree or a shrub that was just scorched, you know, with no leaves left, just charred branches. So that was, you know, a devastating thing to see.”
About the difficulty of rebuilding burnt down homes in Los Angeles County: “It still takes, on average, about three years to go through the full permit process to build a house in Los Angeles County. So imagine how much more complicated that process is going to be now when not only do you have an avalanche of applications that these agencies are going to receive.”
🔵 Sign up for the American Thought Leaders ALERTS newsletter to stay up-to-date on new episodes, releases, and special events 👉 https://ept.ms/ATLnewsletter
💛 Support us 👉https://donorbox.org/american-thought-leaders
-------------------------------------------------
© All Rights Reserved.
the fires themselves are pretty much out
there's a few smoldering remains but the
trouble has just begun it's going to be
very hard to get everything rebuilt in
Los Angeles Edward ring is director of
water and energy policy for the
California policy Center they don't know
yet how many people died they don't know
exactly how many homes are destroyed but
it's well over 10,000 homes that have
been just burnt to the ground you can't
possibly convey this with enough respect
to really fulfill just how how big this
tragedy was for people who have gone
through it in this episode we do a deep
dive into the California fires how did
they originate could they have been
prevented what is the scope of the
damage and in the aftermath what should
be done I'm an environmentalist but I
think that environmentalism itself has
gotten out of balance it's going too far
this is American thought leaders and I'm
Yan Kell
Edward ring such a pleasure to have you
on American thought leaders yeah thank
you for having me we're pretty much in
the aftermath of these giant fires in
the LA area and tell me if that's
actually correct but like what is the
Big Challenge right now facing the
region well the the fires themselves are
uh you know pretty much out there's a
few uh smoldering remains but you know
the the trouble has just begun I mean
this is the acute catastrophe that we've
seen it's a tragedy can't really Express
in words how bad it must be for the
people that have gone through it but
it's going to be very hard to get
everything rebuilt in in Los Angeles the
amount of uh of Permitting that that you
have to uh get you know in a in a normal
situation let's say where there is uh no
fire and the sewers and the water mains
and the power lines and the gas lines
are all
intact uh you know it still takes on
average about 3 years to go through the
full permit process to build a house in
Los Angeles County so imagine uh how
much uh more complicated that process is
going to be now when not only do you
have an avalanche of applications that
these uh agencies are going to receive
they're going to be uh handling a volume
of requests that's unprecedented but
they're also of course going to be
dealing with all of the things that have
to be managed in the aftermath of a fire
uh all of the debris all of the
Reconstruction of the infrastructure
surrounding these homes so this is this
is a challenge that's just begun and it
it's going to be especially difficult in
in Los Angeles County so surely there's
a way to FastTrack this in this kind of
a you know extreme
scenario well we hope so uh you know the
I think the latest uh that I just saw
was that the mayor mayor bass is
thinking about involving a contractor to
go in uh and and sort of
reconstruct uh blocks of Housing and I'm
not sure you know it's very early we're
just hearing about this and we don't
know exactly what uh she means by that
but that doesn't strike me at first
glance as the most desirable Direction
what ideally should happen uh is if you
have Architects that are certified that
are putting forward plans that are
basically identical to what was
destroyed uh for the replacement home
maybe with some allowances for maybe a
higher ceiling or a slightly uh enlarged
footprint for the home but something
that's substantially the same uh
submitted by a certified architect it
should just it should just be permitted
it should it should sail through all of
the various a gencies that have a have a
hand in these approvals because you're
just replacing what had been there and
what had been there was fine they also
have to uh wave some of the new
requirements you can't have an
affordable home or you can't well
nothing's affordable in California but
you can't get closer to an affordable
home if you have to put in a gas line
and put in uh solar panels on the roof
so all of these new requirements should
either be waved for replacement housing
or minimized we can hope that that
President Trump is going to be able to
apply pressure on the city uh to pursue
solutions that would be faster and
involve you know more diverse assortment
of contractors instead of some kind of
centrally planned solution which seems
to be the direction they're going in but
we have to wait and see Edward give me a
sense of the size and scope of the
devastation well it's it's unbelievable
uh I actually traveled down there on
Friday
I was invited to the president's round
table and press conference so I you know
kind of had a pretty uh intimate glimpse
of uh not only the what what's going on
down there but also the response at
least from the federal government so far
and you know the first thing I noticed
was I couldn't get a a an Uber from Los
Angeles International Airport to Pacific
Palisades it said no service and that
was my first inkling that something was
very different uh I ended up getting a
taxi uh I just gave him the address and
we started driving and we got I guess to
within about 5 miles of the destination
and we started seeing burned homes here
and there along Sunset Boulevard in you
know in the foothills of West Los
Angeles and uh then we started seeing
Humvees and military police uh stationed
at intersections and then we came to a
checkpoint uh where there was a whole
bunch of soldiers and they said you
can't go any further um so so I I
presented my identification and they
checked with the Secret Service and said
all right you can go through but your
driver can't go through and and we ended
up getting a motorcycle escort for the
driver and that took us now we go into
like the burn scape I mean from that
point on everything was burned uh and
this went for a couple of Miles where
you know on both sides of the road all
you saw was hulks of cars burned out
hulks in some cases melted uh portions
of the car uh in chimneys you know and
and here and there a a tree or a shrub
that was just scorched you know with no
leaves left um just charred branches so
that that was you know a devastating
thing to see it sounds a little bit try
you can't possibly you know convey this
with enough respect uh to to Really
fulfill just how how big this tragedy
was for people who have gone through it
you know they don't know yet how many
people died they don't know exactly how
many homes are destroyed but it's
thousands it's well over 10,000 homes
that have been just burnt to the
ground at this point given everything
you
know how would you characterize the
cause of the fire or the
causes well the cause of the fire you
know there's the the spark that started
the fire and I don't think they're
certain uh there's already lawsuits
being filed saying that it was caused by
a power line uh you know when you get
Santa Ana winds blowing at 50 to 100
miles an hour which by the way is not a
unique event that happens in Los Angeles
periodically almost every year there's
santaana winds that are very strong uh
wind coming from
Inland uh and some years they're more
severe than others this was a bad year
but there were bad years a 100 years ago
uh but you're blowing the trees around
so even if you've trimmed very
responsibly you can still have a tree
that's going to get knocked over by the
wind and it's going to hit the power
line and what really should be done is
those power lines should be put
underground in any fire prone
neighborhood but that that's one of the
possible causes you know 50% of the
reported fires in Los Angeles according
to members of the fire department uh
apparently are caused by homeless
encampments where they you know it's
January uh they they're trying to St
stay warm and they they'll they'll uh
set up camps and in the canyons in the
vacant lots and so forth uh so that's
another potential cause uh and then
there could be some accident accidents
cause fires arson causes fires there's
policies that could be changed and might
largely eliminate that potential cause
of fires as well as solve a lot of other
problems like helping these people uh
get their lives back um but ultimately
you're you're still going to have fires
and
the question then is you know how how
can you mitigate the fuel that these
fires consume so they won't be as severe
and and then when they do start how do
you how do you fight them I think the
the bigger issue is how do you mitigate
the fuel you know back a hundred years
ago they used to graze U sheep in the
Santa Monica Mountains and and there
there would be fires that would
inevitably blow through there but they
wouldn't be as severe Edward we're going
to take a quick break and we'll be right
back
and we're back with Edward ring director
of water and energy policy for the
California policy Center well so so let
me speak to this uh you know in another
lifetime I was a biologist I went to uh
my graduate work I did at a school uh
that was known for its Forestry
Department and I've taken classes uh
talking about this so you know most
areas have a fire cycle um and over some
period of time few hundred years perhaps
an entire area will burn uh however if
you kind of stop that fire cycle in some
way the brush will build up and you can
get these super fires if you're not
actually managing the forest I mean this
is kind of from forestry 101 how does
that fit into this equation that
equation applies very obviously with our
you know our Conifer
forests uh it because there you have
marketable Timber and you can the price
private sector could simply responsively
responsibly log those forests and you
would have a lot less uh of these super
fires because they would be going in
there and doing the thinning uh you
either have to thin the forests or you
have to let them burn you can't if you
do neither exactly what you described is
what happens uh you know a lot of these
property owners and you can see this
it's coming to light now because there's
more attention being paid on it but for
years you know they've been clamoring
for the right to go into those Canyons
adjacent to their homes and clear out
the dead brush or at least to get the
county to do it but what happens is most
of the money uh public money that would
go to brush clearing and and private
money if you're trying to acquire the
permits it all goes to either uh the the
process you know the application process
or or litigation uh there's a lot of
environmentalist litigation to stop some
of this and there's regulations like you
know the California air resources board
it's very hard to get a burn permit
through the California air resources
board which is very ironic when you
think about the amount of you know filth
that got you know belched up into the
air from these fires uh you know if you
do these small fires do small prescribed
Burns you do grazing you do mechanical
thinning uh you can bring the fuel load
down
now having said that you we have to
acknowledge that you know unless you
just stripped the Canyons be which
nobody thinks is a good idea uh there's
going to be Fuel and there's going to be
fires uh it's just the Sant anas are
going to blow there's going to be
vegetation in these pretty dry CL you
know it's it's an arid climate uh
certain times of year you're going to
have severe fire danger uh but th those
fires would not be as severe as the ones
that we just experienced because they
would have cut the fuel load by you know
a half or by 2third and there just
wouldn't have been enough to burn and
they still would have been healthy lands
escapes which I think escapes a lot of
the I think a lot of the
environmentalists who look at this have
a a biased point of view and one of the
things that we really really need to do
is have alternative Land Management uh
uh plans uh proposed to uh to offer
another way to manage these Canyons what
we're up against is technology if you
can detect a genomic variant in a lizard
for example you can say that lizard is
endangered because that genomic variant
only exists in Cold Water Canyon in Los
Angeles County right it's the same
analogy applies to things like posos the
persistent chemicals in water we now
have the ability to measure posos down
to parts per trillion and so all of a
sudden we have to screen to the parts
per trillion because we've developed the
technology to measure the parts per
trillion so we're we're in this race
with technology where the
environmentalist Community is taking
advantage and I don't mean that in a
cynical way I'm just saying they're
they're using technology to identify you
know subspecies and sub subspecies
genetically and they're using it to
identify chemicals at a parts per
trillion level and regulating on that
basis and you you there's no end to that
I mean at some point we have to step
back and we need other experts to get in
involved with with these analyses to say
you know that's going too far that
that's beyond what is uh an appropriate
balance between what we need for the
environment and what we need for public
health and and what we can afford and
what's actually actually necessary and
reasonable you you have done quite a bit
of thinking about what is good for the
environment and your work and actually I
want to take this opportunity for you
just to tell us about your background
um and when you say the environment you
yourself aren't an environmentalist I
guess by that token uh please explain uh
I think that the environmentalist
movement is absolutely vital you know
and and in California we got lead out of
gasoline uh you know in the 1960s and 7s
you couldn't even see the hills five
miles away in Los Angeles or the Santa
Clara Valley uh and those kinds of
advances were absolutely necessary you
know they were about to fill in the San
Francisco Bay uh in the 1960s there are
cities on the bay Redwood Shores Foster
City it's all landfill and they they
were going to go ahead and fill it up
you know and and I'm glad they didn't
you know so those kinds of things are
very
important the California condor was was
saved and and that that they were down
to like 25 Birds something like that and
they took them all into captivity did a
captive breeding program and they
finally started releasing them again
they they spent millions and millions of
dollars doing that and I'm glad they did
you know we got about 500 of them now
flying around in the wild they're the
they're the most beautiful Majestic
Birds but we have to acknowledge that at
some point you know like let's take
mountain lions we mountain lions were
endangered in California they were down
to six I think around 600 of them they
estimate now that the counts are well
over 6,000 6 7,000 mountain lions
roaming around do we need Mountain
liines in every single uh habitat where
they can Thrive do we need them in the
suburbs of Pasadena or or the you know
the the Santa Monica Mountains in B air
Beverly Hills Pacific Palisades I me
where where do you say all right
mountain lions and I you know I love
mountain lions they're they're beautiful
you know it's an emotional thing it's a
very emotional argument when somebody
says you know we've got to protect these
Mountain lines and you look at the
photographs of these animals you know
yeah I'm an environmentalist but I think
that environmentalism itself has gotten
out of balance it's going going too far
and and I think it's being dominated a
lot by special interests nowadays what
else needs to happen to move forward now
to try to answer your question in detail
it it's an overwhelming list of things
that California does that nobody else
does or you know maybe Massachusetts
does and New York does but you know you
go to Texas you want a building permit I
was talking to a controller for a land
developer in Califor in Texas a few
years ago and he said yeah we had to pay
U our our building permit was
$2,500 and we were astonished you know
CU in California it's anywhere from 50
to 100 or even over
$100,000 and and we said $2,500 per home
and he goes no no no that was for the
whole
subdivision you know and they and they
can put their plans forward in Texas and
and get approval in weeks sometimes days
and in California it can take decades it
can literally take decades to build a
subdivision in California you you you're
you're litigating and you're jumping
through hoops perpetually and and
spending for if it's a big let's say
it's a subdivision with you know 600
homes you you you're you will spend
decades and you will spend hundreds of
millions of dollars trying to get
approval to build it you know the list
is overwhelming the the California
environmental equality Act is probably
the one that everybody talks about the
most and in 19 197 when that was passed
it was the first of its kind in the
nation and all it all it said was put
together a statement when you apply for
a building if you have an impact on the
environment describe what it is and
describe what you're going to do about
it and and people would turn in two or
three page documents you know it was it
was reasonable uh precautions that
people had to take now California
environmental equality act requires
documents that can be you know
volumes and they have to go through a
lead agency I have a flowchart I posted
uh showing the the process and it you
know there's sometimes there's more than
one lead or so-called responsible agency
but you know you have to get that thing
through uh the California air uh
resources board you have you have to get
it through the coastal commission if
it's within five miles of the coast
you've got to go through like the
responsible agency may be the county so
you've got to go there uh and and and
you you have all these agencies that
that have to sign off on it and at every
stage in the process any third-party
attorney not somebody with standing in
the community who maybe they don't want
a subdivision on the hillside next to
their home you know that that person
would have standing no it can be anybody
there there there are law firms in other
states that you know just fly into
California because it's such a positive
and this is goes back to crony
environmentalism it's it's a business
model if you heard of Sue and settle uh
during the Obama Administration that
really got out of control where uh
environmentalist groups would would sue
a uh the Environmental Protection Agency
over some alleged misconduct that's
going on on a piece of land or with a
manufacturing plant or whatever and the
EPA would immediately settle and and
give them a $100 million do you know the
it's a business model and we've got to
streamline the process to rebuild and
we've got to start managing our forests
and our wildlands in a way that is going
to reduce the fuel load and and we need
to invest in Practical water uh and
energy infrastructure in the state
instead of all of these heavily
subsidized uh
experiments um Edward this has been an
absolutely fascinating discussion for me
I've learned a ton any final thoughts as
we finish California is a state where
the they equate sustainability with
scarcity you know they want to ration
water they want to get our water water
consumption down even further uh they
want to be super energy efficient and
you know and there's nothing wrong with
either of those things there nothing
wrong with conver conservation and
efficiency but it it goes too far and
then it becomes a economic drain and
there's there is a model for our state
which would instead of instead of
recognizing scarcity as our only path to
sustainability let's look for ways to
sustainably create abundance and let's
be realistic about what the rest of the
world is willing to do because if
California wants to set an example to
the world it's got to be an example that
people are going to follow so that would
be for example let's not close down all
of our natural gas power plants let's
instead retrofit them to use the
absolute state-of-the-art combined cycle
Technologies where we can get you know
70 plus percent efficiency in terms of
the natural gas going into the
generating plant and the electricity
coming out because a lot of these plants
especially the peers that they made to
turn on and off to to for renewable
energy you know they're only 30%
efficient so you could like double or or
more the efficiency of these plants if
they're trying to develop more energy
for the grid let's say in
Jakarta they're not going to install a
bunch of solar panels and batteries
because it costs too much and it takes
up too much space but they would
retrofit their natural gas power plant
so those are those kinds of choices are
choices that Californians should be
making if they want to set an example
for the world and if we're not doing
this to set an example for the world
it's irrelevant we're only 1% of the
world's energy consumption here in
California so whatever we do to our own
population in terms of being on the
bleeding edge and making everyone pay
you know so much more for all of our
necessities and creating all this
scarcity isn't going to change the world
it's just going to make us poorer so so
we have to think about what kind of
solutions things like Advanced hybrids
instead of all EV things that people in
the rest of the world are going to want
to emulate that's where we should be
focusing our investment and our
Innovation uh and and I I'm hoping that
Californians and are going to sort of
realign behind an abundance agenda
instead of a scarcity agenda well Edward
ring it's such a pleasure to have had
you on well thank you very much thank
you all for joining Edward ringing me on
this episode of American thought leaders
I'm your host Yan Kell
[Music]