The Book Club: The Canterbury Tales by Geoffrey Chaucer with Catherine Illingworth | The Book Club

PragerU
799 followers
23 Video Views·Mar 9, 2025
What makes The Canterbury Tales the most popular work of English literature ever? Penned by Geoffrey Chaucer in the 14th century, this medieval collection of stories depicts a diverse group of characters and covers topics ranging from chivalry and deceit to religious corruption. Michael Knowles sits with Catherine Illingworth to discuss what he describes as “the most vulgar, bawdy, downright often disgusting book I’ve ever read.
@MichaelKnowles
SUBSCRIBE today 👉 https://www.prageru.com/series/book-club
Welcome back to the book club. I'm Michael Knowles and this month we will be reading
the most vulgar, bawdy, downright often disgusting book I've ever read.
The Canterbury Tales by Geoffrey Chaucer, the most popular work of English literature ever.
We will be doing that with my dear friend Catherine Illingworth.
Catherine, last time you were here we were reading Dante together.
That's right.
Very similar time period, a little bit earlier, but similar time period to Chaucer.
That's right.
Dante, we were discussing the most elevated, beautiful images that one can possibly imagine,
so much so that as I read the final three cantos, Paradiso, I was crying at my desk.
That's right.
That was not my experience of the Canterbury Tales. I was crying sometimes for different
reasons in laughter at how bawdy this book is. Can you maybe give a brief summary of this story?
I can try after that introduction. This is the story of a group of people who have gathered
together completely by chance because they all want to go on a pilgrimage from the city of
Southwark, outside of London, to Canterbury. They are staying at an inn together and as they
realize that they're all going to be making this journey together, the host, who's the owner of the
inn, invites everybody to help pass the time while they're traveling by telling a story.
Everyone tell two stories on the way there, two stories on the way back,
and we'll see who can tell the best story.
Whoever tells the best, they win a dinner.
Yes, which is he's being a shrewd businessman because he says,
then you'll all come back here and dine here again, and I'll cover the check for one of you.
He's drumming up future business for himself, but that's what's at stake.
The Canterbury Tales is the collection of some of those stories. Chaucer didn't get
around to writing all of them, but the ones he did write, that's what they're doing.
Because this is written in the 14th century, it's not written in modern English. I have here in my
hand a translation from Middle English into New English. I do have the original though here,
just to give you a sense, and I'm going to butcher, not only am I going to butcher the
modern language, I'm going to butcher the Middle English too, but this is what it sounds like.
Okay.
When that April with his shore is sought, The rota march hath person to the rota,
And bathed every vein in swish liqueur, Of which virtue engender'd is the fleur,
When Zephyrus eke with... Okay, you get the point.
I do. You did that. You have to have a lot of fun with Middle English, and I don't think anyone has
had more fun reading a line of Middle English than you have done.
Thank you. What I lacked in precision, I feel I made up for in enthusiasm.
It's the feel that you communicated impeccably.
So it's written now in the 14th century. This is post Dante.
That's right.
There's another figure that follows Dante, who's a big admirer of Dante's,
and who actually gives the Divine Comedy its title, Divine, and that is Boccaccio.
Yes.
And Boccaccio, I had never read the Canterbury Tales before this episode, I admit with shame,
but I had read the Decameron, which as I read this, I thought, wait a second,
this reminds me of an Italian story that has pretty much the same framework.
Exactly. That's a great way to talk about the way the Canterbury Tales is set up and it's framed.
So Dante, the fictional narrative of the Divine Comedy takes place in the year 1300. Dante dies
in 1321, and then Boccaccio is one of the first scholars of Dante, who sort of interprets and
disseminates comments on Dante, and writes, and Boccaccio's main work, the Decameron,
is a group of people who, people are dying right and left of the plague in the city,
and so it's this sort of group of young aristocrats who think, we have to get out of
here, and as we are sort of seeking refuge from this horrible, life-threatening disease,
we're going to tell stories to each other to pass the time. And that is very similar,
people entertaining each other. And even in addition to this framed narrative, Chaucer
also actually just flat out rewrites some of the stories that Boccaccio includes in the Decameron.
So why is the work considered so great? Because as we're describing it, and joking,
but I think rightly joking about it, there's a lot of bawdy jokes, some of the stories
have some profundity to them, but some are just kind of wacky, and silly, and farcical, and so
why is it considered so great, and why is it the most popular work of English literature?
That's a great question, and I think that we have an impulse as readers, and this goes back
for centuries, if not millennia, to really value tragedy as the worthy form, the way of treating
serious topics, even like the Shakespearean tragedies are the ones that are the serious
works, and the funny ones are silly. And I think that Chaucer in this work, like many other medieval
writers, and even going back to antiquity, want to resist that impulse that we all have a little bit,
that you can actually contain an extraordinary amount of truth in comedy, and you can treat
things of extreme seriousness and solemnity with jokes. And that pops up in different ways
across different cultures in literature, and in different traditions, but there's just something
about, if you think about British humor, and about the British bearing, it's distinct,
you know, and I think that that is one of the great legacies that Chaucer sort of imprinted on
the literary tradition in the UK, is that you can treat very serious important things with jokes,
and often the most important points he has to make in the tales he tells are encapsulated within the
jokes. Right, and certain tales will be much more serious, and you realize when he's giving
these serious tales that this man is really capable of so many different voices, all of
these sound like different people, because different people are telling them, and he's
extremely learned. Yes, yes, and he wants you to know that. He is making no mistake that he has
read everything, he is very... He's read everything about everything. Yes, and is extremely capable
across multiple languages, classical languages, other contemporary languages, and we should talk
a little bit about Chaucer's life, because it's extraordinary, both in his life itself and how
much we know about it. We have almost 500 records of Chaucer's life, and we have maybe a handful of
Shakespeare's. I mean, we know significantly more about Chaucer than we do about almost any other
writer of his time, and most of the major medieval poets of his age, we don't even have names for
them. They're these anonymous writers of morality plays, and different works of literature that
just aren't attributed to anybody, and that is the case with Chaucer, because he was the son of a
wine merchant who worked in sort of the import-export business, but then made his way from
that merchant class into the aristocracy, and was actually a courtier, and so ran in those circles,
but held all of these positions throughout his life that where he was managing estates for the
essentially, and so because he was working in all of these official government capacities that we
just have records of almost everything he did, at least in a professional basis. So that shows us
that we know that he encountered all kinds of people. If he's managing estates, that means he's
working with workmen, and attorneys, and the field laborers, and then obviously encountering a lot of
religious personnel of his time, and can really sense, because he sort of climbed from a lower
station to a higher one, that everybody else who's also trying to make that turn, and he knows what
the aristocracy values about itself, and the importance that they feel they have for society.
I mean, he just, he has seen it all, and that is what enables him to write about this astonishing,
and I would say almost unparalleled, diversity of characters. Right, so let's get into this
diversity of characters, and these stories. I suppose we should begin with the prologue. Yes,
great idea. So the prologue is how it sets up the stage for us, and tells us what we know about
our host, Mr. Harry Bailey, who's one of the few characters who really has a name, and we know about
the pilgrimage journey that they're all taking, and we also get little portraits of every character
that's included, and he includes the funniest details. So on one hand, he does maybe what
anybody would do in that position, where he says, this person holds this job, and therefore they
have these qualities. So there's one, there's a knight, and all of his qualities are knightly,
but then that sort of perfect packaging starts to devolve a little bit, and you think like, all right,
this person of dubious character speaks with a lisp, and maybe is wearing something they shouldn't
be wearing, and has this relative, or this life experience. So he's bringing in a, he's wanting to
paint these people as individual human beings, you know, beyond they're just portraying their
station in life, and that gets more and more complex as he goes along. So you mentioned the
knight. Yes. The knight is the first one up, and he tells the Knight's Tale. Yes, the Knight's
Tale is a great place to begin, because he resists maybe the introduction you gave of the Canterbury
Tales. When I started to read the Knight's Tale, I thought, oh, this is very nice. Yes, what a nice,
a book for nice people, to learn how to be good citizens, and sort of live by a structured code
that will make society better. This is very uplifting. Because the story is about these two
poor guys, they get conquered by Theseus, who runs Athens, and Theseus throws them into prison,
and it's Palamon and Arcite, is that how you pronounce it, Arcite? Arcite. I like Arcite,
it's more exotic. Should I put the... Arcite, you can do it. Arcite! Well, maybe I'll leave
the Middle English. So you've got these two guys, Palamon and Arcite, and they look out the window
of the jail cells, and they see Emily, beautiful Emily, and they fall madly in love with her,
just by the very sight of her. And they have no hope of ever being with her, because they're
locked up in jail forever, but they can look on her. And then they get sprung from the clink,
and that is where things start to go awry. Yes, right. And so now, all of a sudden, you have
two dear friends, who both are not only loyal to each other, but are both very committed to
the chivalric code. And that is, we all kind of have a sense about what chivalry is, you know,
it's when we usually speak about it in terms of, you know, opening a door for a lady, or being
respectful of your elders, those kinds of chivalric gestures. But it also, in medieval
literature, ties in with a much wider set of expectations and rules that govern behavior.
It means you should be brave, you should always be on a quest, you should be loyal to your lord.
And then it's also very much entangled with the sort of courtly love tradition that had been
popular in medieval literature now for a couple hundred years before Chaucer's writing about it.
But it's very much sort of pivots around longing, but longing without satisfaction ever truly being
realized. I mean, Dante, we spoke last time, is just in a state of longing for this entire
very, very long poem, you know, and it's the degree to which he is sort of satisfied at the
end is complicated. And when you have these two knights in the Knight's Tale that are experiencing
this, you know, they see this beautiful woman, and she's picking flowers, which is something that
always seems to happen in medieval literature. It's like men can't deal with the hotness of a
woman picking flowers. I feel seen. I feel understood. Yeah. So when they suddenly have
the barrier to their, you know, being able to pursue Emily is suddenly removed, then it creates
conflict of, wow, how do these structures that govern our lives, this chivalric code, how are
we going to maintain our integrity and our devotion to that while also going after this
object of our desire, which is kind of what we as knights are engineered to do. And when the first of
the two men to be sprung is R.C.Tagg, and he's sprung from the clink. You think he should be
happy, but he's not happy. Right. Because the deal that he struck was, you got to get out of Athens.
As long as you get out of Athens, I'm not going to kill you. Right. But his love is in Athens, so he
goes away, but the only thing he cares about, he doesn't get, so he's miserable. And then Palamon
is stuck in the clink, but at least he gets to look out for a little bit every day and see his
love. So is he better off? Is R.C.Tagg better off? But then Palamon sneaks out of jail. Yes,
by drugging his jailer. Yes. And so we have something that also shows up a lot in medieval
literature, which is a disguise. You know, and so then he finds a way to be near Emily by disguising
himself as a sort of member of her household, and so he can be near to her. But they can't keep
this up for long. They can't keep it up for long. They meet in a field, and then that field turns
into the field of battle. Yes. And Theseus sort of sets it up, and he says, okay, guys, I could
kill you right now, because you both broke the deal. Right, yes. But I'm going to let you hash
it out. And so they amass armies, basically. Right, and Theseus also builds an arena for this.
We have this sort of physical space of the tower that they've been locked in,
and now there's this new, confined to this new physical space of the arena that's been
constructed for this. So this tale is really wanting us to see that we have containers for
what happens in society. We have rules that govern our behavior. We have buildings that
provide spaces for our conflicts. We know how to handle things in this world. And in that conflict,
someone dies. Yes. But first, we have a moment of prayer. We have three different prayers that go to
three different deities. We have one knight that prays for victory, one that prays for
sort of satisfaction and love, and then sweet Emily, who is not really getting a lot of agency
here, she's praying to Diana, and she says, oh, I would love to maintain my virginity, because this
is not great for me. I don't know these people, but if I do have to marry, at least let it be
for love. And so then this big conflict ensues. And then at one point, the war even breaks out in
heaven, and the gods are all in on it. And then you have sort of experienced Saturn, who has seen
these things before and is not squeamish about getting involved in conflict. He sort of opens
the heavens and brings a conclusion to this, which is basically, we have one who is wounded,
and then a victor. But then that victor, suddenly there's an earthquake. So he then falls from his
horse, and then he's actually the one who ends up dying. And so he's able to give permission to
his friend to go and marry Emily. So you have everybody's prayers have kind of been answered,
where he gets to, we have a victor in love, a victor in war, and yet they both are failures
in those counterparts as well. And then Emily also ends up with somebody who actually really
does love her. And so it's kind of, maybe things are satisfied, but it's also just very tragic.
And so it's not the traditional sort of happy ending that we would expect normally from a
romance, because there's a lot of death. Though it is somewhat funny, at least I found it funny,
when you get to the end, Palamon is wounded, and we know that Palamon is going to win, that's
sort of been preordained. But it looks like he's wounded, and then there's Arasite trotting around
on his horse, taking a victory lap, and then he just falls off right on top of his head, and he's
about to die. And that is something that is really jarring when we read medieval texts,
especially of this genre, because all of a sudden there's this wheel of fortune that is constantly
turning. And that shows up in Tale After Tale and Chaucer, that the plot points are not motivated by
rational progressions of events. If you compare the way that stories are told when the novel
emerges as a literary format several centuries later, that really reaches its peak in the
Victorian era and slightly before that, you really are trying to understand what the effects
of our actions are, and how things turn and move forward in rational ways. That is not a priority
yet in literature. And so you can have things like, wow, there's all of this buildup to who's
going to win, but then there's an earthquake, and the wheel of fortune flips, and then here's the
outcome, wow, who knew? And so it makes everything feel a little bit absurd. And so as the reader,
you think, you feel maybe even a little bit tricked, like I was invested in how these actions
were going to lead to consequences, but we don't often get that satisfaction in the romance genre.
And still, this symbol, which is a really central theme throughout the whole book,
this wheel of fortune, I think does describe life in a pretty accurate way. I sometimes think,
these days, people are always citing statistics and data, and I don't think those are real. I
believe in the goddess Fortuna. I think that actually, she will allow me to understand the
world better than this idea that everything is perfectly rational and just constantly progresses
as you predict that it will. That's, you know, what's the old Yiddish line?
There's a lot of strange accents in this episode, but it means...
I'm so glad you're here.
Who would translate for me? What that means is, man plans and God laughs. And that's what happens.
And so we arrive at the end, and it's a nice, pretty tale. Beautiful, maybe.
And then we have the Miller's tale, which is not pretty.
I know you're very eager to get to this, because we're about to maybe fall into a bit of a
crevasse here.
We are. Because what's strange about the Miller's tale, told by the Miller, the guy who just
grounds up the grain, is that it is a kind of a retelling of the Knight's tale.
It's about a woman who is beloved of two men, and she's actually married to another guy.
And so the whole story is about cuckoldry. The word cuckoldry, which in modern days has become
a more popular slur against one's political opponents. But it's one of the oldest slurs
in the English language. The Italians use it all the time. But it's all about cuckoldry, which is
the poor husband, his wife is stepping out on him.
And in the case of the Miller's tale, this woman, Alison, wants to sleep with her young lover,
Nicholas. But her husband, John, he's around, he's kind of a jealous guy. And so they got to
figure out exactly the right time to do it. And then there's this other clerk over at the church,
Absalom. And he also wants Alison. And Alison, she doesn't like Absalom. Out of sight, out of
mind is a point that Chaucer makes. And this young guy, Nicholas, he's living with them,
actually. He's sort of renting a room from them. And so how do they arrange to have their escapade?
It's all trickery and deceit that depends on these characters being the most gullible people
who have ever lived. We talked about in The Knight's Tale about how there is a sort of
standard of perfection, that this is nothing like real life because this is not how people actually
behave and this is not what governs human decisions. But things are just as unbelievable
and outrageous in The Miller's Tale. This is a really important point because I think there's
an inclination in our modern age to say anything that looks up to an ideal, that's absurd. Give me
a break. Be real. Be real. But anything that is base and cynical and scatological, we say,
that's what life really is like. But no, it isn't. No, it isn't. Exactly. Yes. Isn't there some
middle ground perhaps here? Sometimes it's one and sometimes it's the other. Because it's so
tempting. Because the way that Chaucer puts these three tales in succession, we have the prologue
setting things up, then The Knight's Tale, which is like, we are Athens. Things are structured.
After that, you have this, I'll tell you a tale about two guys interested in the same gal.
And The Miller also is, we learn, he is so drunk he cannot sit on his horse.
And he's described as this big brawny guy who could tear a door off his hinges if he wanted
to. And so he's as much of a caricature as The Knight is. So he comes in with this premise of
saying, all right, I'm going to be real with you. And he even says, I can't handle this Knight's
Tale stuff. This is too much for me. And so it's what, as you said, it's tempting us to think,
all right, now we're going to get the real. What is it really like when two men are in love with
the same woman? But then it's not like this. I'll tell you what it's like when two men are in love
with the same woman. So Nicholas and Alison figure out how to have their little rendezvous.
They take care of John, basically by telling him that Nicholas says, I've had this vision from God
has told me there's going to be another flood. You've got to go get some provisions and we're
going to have little boats and you've got to basically get out of my way because in a few
days it's all going to end. But you, me and your wife, we're going to make it. But you've got to
go away so I can sleep with your wife. And so they take care of the carpenter and Nicholas and
Alison are having fun and Absalom comes up and he says, please, I want to kiss. Give me a kiss.
She goes, go away. I don't want to talk to you. He goes, no, please give me a kiss. And so she
says, okay, fine. Come on over here. You can get a kiss. Absalom started wiping his mouth dry.
Dark was the night as pitch as black as coal. And at the window out, she put her whole and
Absalom so fortune framed the farce, put up his mouth and kissed her naked arse most savorously
before he knew of this. And back he started. Something was amiss. He knew quite well a woman
has no beard, yet something rough and hairy had appeared. What have I done? He said, can that be
you? Teehee, she cried and clapped the window too. And then not to be outdone, he decides,
she says, I'm sorry. I didn't mean to do that. You can come back. You can get a kiss now.
And so Nicholas decides he's going to have fun too. And so he's the lover and he's going to stick
his derriere out there. And so Absalom was ready. He's all set to make a launch.
Speak pretty bird. I know not where thou art. This Nicholas at once let fly a fart
as loud as if it were a thunder clap. He was near blinded by the blast. Poor chap.
Indeed, poor chap. That is the most disgusting thing I've ever said in public, certainly on
camera. But I do feel it is necessary to understand just how gross this story gets.
Yes. Yes. I think that that is, there is a kind of anatomical specificity that we are not making.
He's implying nothing. He's leaving nothing to the imagination here. He's going to tell us
exactly which body parts we're dealing with and tells us in the beginning to this, you may want
to skip this to save your dignity, which you chose not to do here today for the benefit of
your viewership. For the benefit? I don't know. Speaking of the sort of funny way that human
beings work, you then get to one of the most famous tales in the Canterbury Tales, which is
the Wife of Bath story. Yes. Yes. And she is probably the most famous, I would say, along
with maybe the Pardoner, the most famous character that Chaucer invents. And she becomes, has sort of
a, takes on a personality. It's like this fictional character that people all recognized in Chaucer's
time. People loved the Wife of Bath. And so what we learn about her, her portrait, is that she's
been married five times. She's been with many people, even outside of that. She works in the
sort of textile trade, which is the most lucrative business to be in in this time period. But she
also, the fact that she's had five husbands, means that she's gotten very good at marrying old guys
and then inheriting their wealth. And so she's created quite a position for herself in society,
in spite of the fact that she is breaking every rule that we, especially when we look back at the
Middle Ages, think mattered then. Right. You know, and so, because she is not sorry or apologetic
about anything. She's a nasty woman. Yes. She, never heard anyone say that about the Wife of
Bath, but sure. Yes, she is. She is who she is without any shame at all. And people love her
for it. You know, which is funny because she is really breaking all of these conventions,
and yet something about her is just so appealing, you know, their confidence with it. You know,
and then the tale that she tells us, you know, because we're learning all the things we've
talked about so far. Marriage is a pretty big topic, you know, because it's, again,
one of those things that gives structure to society. It relates to love and longing,
which is related to the chivalric motivation. And it's a confounding issue. I mean,
specifically for her, she talks about all her husbands, and she says, oh, this really nice guy,
yeah, I took him for all he was worth. And this other wonderful, kind, gentle man, oh yeah,
I was a devil to him. I just ruined his life. And, you know, the only one I really liked was
the guy who just viciously beat me. Yes. Right. Yes, exactly. And it's a, so she's been through
a lot and put other people through a lot, you know, in this sort of, as this marriage convention
has sort of ruled her, the happenings of her life. So when we get to hear her tale, I mean,
and this is something that's so interesting about reading the Canterbury Tales, we could spend
our whole time today talking about the way that this is structured, because you're constantly
going back from portrait of the storyteller to the story that they tell. And, you know,
those are equal fictions. And so you're always, the voice is always changing. You know, when we
read Dante, you have one person who's conversing with hundreds of people as he's on a linear
trajectory to go one place. Here, the mic is being passed constantly, and they even steal it from
each other, like the characters are interacting. And so that's why the Canterbury Tales kind of
resists a, what is Chaucer saying? You know, it's really hard to get there. But one of the things
that the Wife of Bath is saying, because her tale is basically, just to summarize it, the story of
a knight who rapes a young maiden, which is a crime punishable by death. And then the queen,
who is supposed to sentence him, says, all right, I will give you an opportunity to survive. And
you have exactly one year to tell me what women want. So then he goes around looking for this
answer. And finally, there's this kind of old, ugly hag of a woman who, by the 11th hour,
can tell him, she says, I can tell you the answer that will save your life, but you're going to owe
me something. And he's like, okay, great. Whatever you want. He's on the line.
Exactly. So she says that what women want is sovereignty over their husbands. So he says,
great. Tells the queen, she's like, you got it. And then, so he's free. And then he then has to
marry the old hag. And so she then tells him that he, she sort of gives him a choice, because it's
their wedding night, and he takes off her veil, and she's this like old, terrible creature that
he does not want to be married to. And she goes, okay, I will transform myself to be young and
beautiful forever, but I will cheat on you. Or I can be faithful to you, but I'm going to look like
this. And so he turns to her and he says, well, why don't you choose? And she just, he just
answered that exactly right, because what he has done is given her sovereignty over him. And so
then to sort of reward him for this correct answer, this gift of sovereignty, she says,
you get both. I'll be beautiful forever, and I will be faithful to you.
So the old hag, who then becomes this hot young lady, and the queen, are they right?
Is that what women want? I can't answer. I don't know, but you're a woman.
I would say there's something floating under the surface here, which is that what we're trying to
get is possibly a picture of mutual submission, because that is what at the end, and that's what
really is a great successful partnership, is two people who are not so much like alternating who
gets to rule over who in which moment, but two people who have enough mutual respect that they
can actually honor one another's wishes and come to productive solutions. And maybe the wife of
Bath is touching on that a little bit at the end of her story, that he grants her her will, and then
he turns around and gives him what he wants. And so there's weirdly, I mean, because this man also
is a rapist, which is the way, I mean, he is. You forget that as you read the story.
Yes, and it's the whole context of this story is horrifying. And so he, is he being transformed
into suddenly a virtuous person who has all of this respect for women? You know, is that what
is happening here? It seems to be. He does undergo this transformation, you know, and
sort of being molded by this woman who has kind of magical powers.
Right. And so the most magical power of all in the entire book is the power of speech, right?
Yes.
This is what comes when you just, you're really dazzled when you watch Chaucer's amazing
facility with speech. He can speak as anybody about anything in any tone or register. It's
amazing. And by the end of the book, well, it's unfinished, so the end of what we've got of the
book, you get a story about speech. That's right. Yes, this is not a popular
tale from within this text. I'm glad we have the chance to give it a little spotlight today.
It's called the Nun's Priest's Tale. And this, the nun's priest is somebody that is referenced as
being part of the party that's accompanying this nun in the general prologue. But unlike most of
the speakers, he doesn't have a really distinct portrait. So we don't know a lot about who's
telling us this story. But he launches, Chaucer takes us launching into this sort of like a
medievalist called them beasts. It's like an animal fable, a beast fable. You've ever heard
of like a medieval bestiary? I think that the people in the Middle Ages really looked to
animals both in artwork, and you've probably seen pictures of medieval marginalia, like silly
rabbits and things like that. Animals add a sort of an underpinning of immutable nature.
I mean that in sort of a natural law sense, because animal nature seems to be a lot more static than
human nature. You know, that like kinds of people don't always behave as their kind,
but kinds of animals generally do. Right. Animals don't have a rational soul and will,
so they're not constantly evolving and growing. A rabbit's a rabbit.
Right, exactly. And you know, if you have this sort of this Aristotelian hierarchy of the souls,
you have your vegetable soul, an animal soul, and an intellectual soul. And so this is the
sort of, it has a will, animals have a will, but they don't have language essentially.
So animals provide a sense of stability, narrative and stability of significance, I guess,
that allow us to question whether the things that happen are happening as a consequence of
natural law or just of this wheel of fortune fate circumstance that we were kind of talking
about earlier. So this is a story that is, it's a barnyard tale of this rooster named Chanticleer.
And he is kind of wooing his wife, who is also one of his sisters, because that's how it works
if you're in the chicken family. Fair enough. Yes. So there's all these hens, but he has this
moment of wooing. And he's a sophisticated and educated rooster. And so he is sort of quoting,
translating things from Latin for her as he speaks. But he has a couple moments of mistranslation
in the beginning where he is so confident in his learning that we don't really pay much attention
to it unless you sit there and realize everything that he's saying is not really from these original
Latin source texts. He's saying that women are the best thing that ever happened to men, but
that's not what his source texts are saying. So he's a little bit unreliable. But the big action
of this is a fox breaks into the farmyard. And so there's a moment where Chanticleer,
the rooster, finds himself in the mouth of the fox. And as the fox is sprinting across this
barnyard, all the animals are just scattered everywhere. And Chaucer compares this to
the scene at the fall of Troy, that this is so dramatic and such a big event happening that
it's exactly like the poor women who know that society is over and the greatest tragedy in all
of literature. It's just a hen house that's being invaded by a fox. Yes. Which is so silly to think
about these hens having anything to do with Troy until he adds a couple of details that say that
the woman who actually owns this farm is this poor widow, so she has no income other than
this farm. And it's her entire survival depends on them. So the fact that her rooster is in the
mouth of a fox is actually kind of life-threatening for this woman. And so it adds this level of
seriousness that's very, very off to the side of the scene while this silly barnyard
scene is unfolding. Right. But the rooster is able to save himself by tricking the fox
into speaking. And as he tricks him into speaking, he opens his mouth to talk and that's
what makes the he drops the rooster to the ground and the rooster can then escape. And in fact,
the fox only was able to get the rooster by tricking the rooster into speaking. Yes. By saying,
oh Chanticleer, please sing out one of those beautiful songs. Yeah, me, I used to love it
when your dad would sing. So please just sing out this beautiful song. And as the rooster goes to
sing, he stretches out his neck and the fox can chomp down on the neck, drag him off to the woods.
And so you see the same tool here and the rooster goes up in a tree. Yes, right. And then the fox,
what does the fox say? The fox says, hey, sorry about that. I don't know what came over me.
I'm not usually like this. You want to come down maybe? And the rooster says to invoke a beautiful
line from George W. Bush, basically fool me once, shame on you, fool me twice. The point is you're
not going to fool me again. It's a loose translation. Yes, yes. That's a perfect description of this
response. So what we have really unfolding here is that rhetoric is where all the power lies. You
know, it's when people traditionally think about speech, there's rhetoric sort of gets thrown into
this like, I don't know about rhetoric. Rhetoric is how you manipulate and how you lie and you can
make people do things they don't want to do and create false impressions of reality. If you're a
great rhetorician, it kind of means you're up to mischief and a trickster. But then there's these
other kinds of speech that are performative, like the most famous example, I guess, would be like a
wedding vow that when you say, you know, do you take this woman, you know, it's the I do's actually
like enact the sacrament of marriage. And so that speech can actually work in that way. But I think
that what some scholars that I admire who work on this have made the observation that this tale is
kind of, and the Canterbury tales as a whole, are kind of telling us that all speech is action.
You know, that it is even the rhetoric kind is leading, it's changing reality. It has consequences
and it leads people to, you know, their rise and fall all the time. And so speech is really what
humanity is turning around. It's not just idle chatter. And it's easy to think of these people
are just passing the time and playing a game for a dinner, but it's not just idle chatter.
Exactly. It's actually from the silliest, most vulgar tale to the most serious religious tale.
And there are many tales we didn't have time to get to. They're doing something, they're taking
us on a journey, could be taking us on a pilgrimage. Right. Yes, exactly. And that pilgrimage is,
you know, so critical to keep in mind because after the introduction, they only mentioned
pilgrimage one more time in this whole story. But it's there all the time. And you have this,
they're going to see the relics of the martyred Thomas Beckett. And Canterbury is so critical
because he was martyred in the cathedral, you know, where his relics are actually enshrined now.
And so it's that sort of darkness and holiness and somberness really undergirds this whole thing.
And so even though we are making jokes and, you know, talking about things that people
wouldn't maybe normally talk about on a pilgrimage, that this is all part of
human life as we strive for those things that are sanctifying, that are reliable,
these things that order society in ways that are reliable, gives structure. There's this
prime mover who is allowing us to live in a way that sort of gives structure to interior life,
what we think about within ourselves, and then gives structure to the principles that govern
society. And sometimes it's left unfinished. It is. Sometimes the wheel of fortune spins such that
you don't get to finish. And we can ponder that on our own pilgrimages with all of the bodiness and
all of the seriousness and all of the holiness and all of the chicanery and all of the things that
are part of the human comedy, absolutely. Catherine, marvelous as always to have you with
us. I look forward to the next time you're back. Until then, I'm Michael Knowles. This is The Book
Club. Thank you so much for watching this episode of The Book Club on PragerU. PragerU is a 501c3
nonprofit organization, so we rely on donations from viewers like you to keep this content on
the air. Please consider making a tax-deductible contribution today to help keep this content
coming. Thank you very much.
