The Book Club: King Lear by Shakespeare with Douglas Murray | The Book Club

PragerU
799 followers
1 Video View·Mar 9, 2025
Broken families are detrimental to society— it’s been proven throughout history. Douglas Murray and Michael Knowles summarize William Shakespeare’s tragedy, King Lear, and its themes of power, justice, blindness, and chaos played out through the severed relationship between a father and his children.
In our fast-paced world, it’s tough to make reading a priority. At least it used to be. At Thinkr.org, they summarize the key ideas from new and noteworthy nonfiction, giving you access to an entire library of great books in bite-size form. Read or listen to hundreds of titles in a matter of minutes: start your free trial today at https://thinkr.org/.
Subscribe so you never miss a new episode! 📚 👉 https://www.prageru.com/series/book-club/
Welcome back to the Book Club.
I'm Michael Knowles.
This month we will be reading King Lear by William Shakespeare, one of the great plays
ever written.
But before we get into King Lear, in our fast-paced world, it is tough to make reading a priority.
At least, it used to be.
At thinker.org, they summarize the key ideas from new and noteworthy nonfiction, giving
you access to an entire library of great books in bite-sized form.
You can read or listen to hundreds of titles in a matter of minutes, from old classics
like Dale Carnegie's How to Win Friends and Influence People to recent bestsellers
like Jordan Peterson's Twelve Rules for Life.
If you want to challenge your preconceptions, if you want to expand your horizons, if you
want to sound smart at cocktail parties, that's very important, you have to go to thinker.org.
T-H-I-N-K-R dot org.
No E's.
No time for that, folks.
Start a free trial.
Put your mind in motion.
In the meantime, we will delve into King Lear with my guest, Douglas Murray, the international
bestselling author of The Madness of Crowds, of Strange Death of Europe.
These are books, Douglas, that paint, I'm sorry to say, a bleak political picture.
And I felt the only book that paints a bleaker political picture would be King Lear by William
Shakespeare.
So thank you very much for coming on.
It's a great pleasure.
It's true.
King Lear makes my work look like comedy.
This play, we've already done Hamlet, we've done the other greatest play ever written,
and so now we're doing Lear.
You know, at least in Hamlet, there are a few light moments, there are a few moments
of levity, some kind of fun.
King Lear, not so much.
It is all tragedy, all the time.
Yes.
I mean, there are tiny moments of comic alleviation, but they are all themselves bleak.
You know, the fool, famously in Lear, is one of the only characters, becomes the only character
who can tell the truth to the king.
And his truths are not that funny, but are incredibly accurate, hurtful if you're the
king, devastating if you're the playgoer.
It is a play about human beings in extremis.
It's about what we can be pushed to, and what we cannot any longer put up with.
It is one of the greatest and most moving, devastating even, insights into us as human beings.
Before we get into why this is one of the great plays, maybe the great play ever written,
just in, I don't know, a minute or so, can we say what this play's about?
I would say, King Lear, why not to be mean to your daughters?
King Lear, why not to be, why you should pay closer attention to your family and your kingdom?
What happens in the play?
It begins with King dividing his kingdom between his three daughters.
Two of them give speeches of great love and adoration of their father.
The third, the youngest, Cordelia, cannot do this.
And she's cast out from the court as a result.
Simultaneously, we have the subplot of Gloucester, who discovers his own family disaster.
One of his sons, illegitimate son Edmund, claims that the legitimate son, Edgar, is trying to kill him.
Very confusing, by the way.
Very confusing.
Ed, Edgar, Edmund.
But he finds this out, and his legitimate son, who is not trying to kill his father,
also has to flee.
So everybody ends up fleeing.
The king, Lear, finds himself having to flee.
He, having left his throne, finds that there's nowhere in the kingdom for him.
He seeks sanctuary with his daughters, and they end up not giving him sanctuary.
These are the evil daughters.
The evil daughters.
And he ends up maddened, on the heath, losing his mind, accompanied by his fool.
His youngest daughter, Cordelia, returns from exile with her husband to try to take back the kingdom,
is captured, is briefly reunited with her father, is then murdered in prison.
And her father comes in at the very end with the body of his daughter, and himself dies of grief.
This is a kingdom in which everything has fallen apart.
The good have to flee.
The insincere are triumphing.
And the center doesn't hold.
To quote Yeats, the whole thing falls apart.
People have to flee.
Lear tries to get hospitality, even, for his remaining court at his daughter's house.
And in the end, because he's not a king, they don't need him anymore.
He can't find the hospitality.
And, of course, by the end, or by halfway through the play,
Lear is staggering around on the heath, mad.
The play really follows this greatest of falls from, not grace, but power.
And throughout it, obviously, the human dynamics change,
but really they change in one direction, which is deterioration.
The challenge almost throughout Lear is whether human suffering in any way leads to enlightenment,
or whether it's just suffering.
And you see, as Lear winds up wandering, he's now lost his army, he's now lost his kingdom, he's broke.
You see him, more or less, as a beggar.
You see Edgar, the good son.
A very bad idea, by the way, to name two sons Ed.
That's very confusing as a general rule.
But the good Edgar, Edgar is walking around.
He pretends to be a beggar.
He plays a beggar because he's fleeing from his father.
His father winds up absolutely, or the Earl of Gloucester winds up completely out of fortune.
And this is a theme that keeps coming up, this wheel of fortune,
this idea that a man is pinned to the wheel of fortune.
And sometimes you go up, sometimes you go down.
And the good not only have to flee, but disguise themselves.
Edgar has to disguise himself as a beggar.
Another nobleman, Kent, disguises himself in order to escort Lear,
by the point at which Lear is otherwise aided only by the jest of the fool, who is still with him.
And this whole idea that in a way the good have to disguise themselves
is the epitome of a kingdom that has fallen into tyranny.
So many things in Lear are things that echo,
that is why people regard it as being a masterpiece it is.
What you do in terrible times, what you do if your family were turning against you,
what you would do if the kingdom turned despotic.
Yeah, and what you do in time itself.
I mean, time itself is a sort of character in the play.
And so, I remember Stella Adler, the great theorist of acting, once said
that you can't use your own personal experiences to play Hamlet.
Unless you're Danish royalty, you have to use your imagination.
But, and of course, I think she's overstating it there.
Here though, I don't need to be a king to realize what time does to people.
That time actually does diminish your power, it diminishes your influence.
So many aged people are cast aside, even if they were once powerful and magnificent.
One of the things I find most moving about the play
is the midnight that comes about halfway through,
where Gloucester, the figure who mirrors the progress of Lear, the decline of Lear,
is at the house of one of the evil daughters of Lear.
She and her husband carry out an act in avenging themselves on somebody they see as,
contrary to their cause, a famously blind Gloucester.
They rip out his eyes.
Yes. The moment this terrible thing happens, an extraordinary thing happens.
A servant in the household of Lear's daughter objects and stands forward
and says to his master something along the lines of,
he says, I've served you, master, many years.
And he says, but greatest service have I never done than now to bid you halt.
Something like that.
He, the first servant, who doesn't even have a name, he's just first servant,
ends up getting into a fight with his master, a physical fight.
He ends up being slain.
Lewis makes an extraordinary observation about this.
At the midnight of the play, this one unnamed character
does perhaps the only thing in the play that is unadulteratedly good.
And there's an observation to follow from that,
which is that this unnamed, unremembered person,
who has, I think, less than six lines all told,
is the person you should wish to be in the play.
In our lives, we don't know what act we're in,
first act of a play or the final act.
It's midnight at this scene in act three,
and the whole play will revolve around it.
But the unnamed servant doesn't know that.
All he knows is that something is happening,
which cannot be allowed to happen.
And the unnamed servant says, oh death, untimely death.
Because he wasn't expecting, he doesn't know what act he's in in his own life.
But he does the right thing.
He does the right thing,
and we don't know if we're in a comedy or a tragedy, or both.
And we don't know how many lines we're going to get.
All we can try to do is to make sure
that we speak the lines we have well,
and do it right.
And hope we don't turn out like these characters do in Lyra.
That's definitely an aspiration.
This is some aspect of the play that I think is difficult to read,
which is, it just keeps getting worse.
Even the fool is so sardonic,
it's so biting, it's so brutal.
Perhaps one of the most moving scenes,
aside from Lyra going mad on the heath,
is the scene in which Gloucester, now blind,
is, and there are so many things in this play that have entered the lexicon,
Gloucester, blind, is now actually being guided
by, he doesn't know it, but by his son Edgar,
who is in disguise, leading his blind father.
His blind father wishes to kill himself,
and Edgar leads his father to what he says
is the cliff of Dover Beach.
He's not very subtle about it, Gloucester.
He says, I want you to lead me to the very furthest edge of that cliff
that's very, very high up.
What for? Oh, no reason, I just would like you to take me there.
Edgar realizes his father's going to kill himself.
He decides to effectively pretend to help him, but not.
So that this man, who has fallen all the way,
ends up being misled by his son in disguise
and cannot even kill himself
because his son leads him to what is not an edge.
He just falls forward and is on the ground.
He discovers his son,
and he discovers the truth of what has happened to him.
And the son that has remained loyal to him,
who he has been so cruel to,
albeit because he was misguided by his evil son.
So we lose Gloucester at that point.
Then we lose Gonnel and Regan.
One poisons the other and then kills herself.
Cordelia comes back from France with her husband, the French king,
to try to take back the kingdom.
In any Hollywood production,
which hadn't been bothered by the hand of a genius,
this would be the victorious moment where the kingdom was saved,
but this isn't so.
Cordelia is captured.
She ends up being imprisoned with her father,
who also, again in this thing of the two plots mirroring each other,
who in the madness appears to recognize his true child.
And there's a beautiful, one of the greatest moments of Poitras,
is we two will sing like birds in a cage.
Sing like birds in a cage.
And what he's describing is, we'll just laugh about old times.
He says, we'll talk about court news.
We'll gossip.
And he has this vision of it.
But this doesn't happen.
Cordelia is also then executed.
At the very end, as Lear dies
after cradling the body of his murdered daughter, Cordelia,
with, by the way, again one of the great speeches,
as he howls,
like he did on the heath where he howls in madness and insanity.
But here howls in grief and something more
and dies of a broken heart.
Having realized what has happened.
And then there's this glimmer of hope at the end
when two of the survivors,
including the good son of Gloster,
who's killed the bad son in a duel,
at the very last lines step forward
to be ready to take over the kingdom.
What remains of the kingdom.
Yes.
This final political moment does remind me
that this is a political play.
There's a line, it's not even one of the famous lines,
but it was a line that struck me
as particularly resonant now in our time,
which is, Gloster says this in Act IV,
he says, "'Tis the time's plague
when madmen lead the blind."
Because his son, pretending to be a mad beggar,
is leading him, who's now been blinded.
And it made me think of Kanye West or something.
It made me think that some of the people
who actually might be leading us
seem like they're kind of crazy people.
And we are a blinded civilization.
We don't see what has happened to us.
We don't see where we come from.
We don't see our past.
And it strikes me that what destroys this kingdom
is an act of filial impiety.
These children are being very rough on their parents,
on their fathers.
And vice versa.
It opens up with the father
being very rough on his daughter.
Yes.
Is Shakespeare making a political comment here
about the relationship between the generations?
Relations in almost everything.
Relations with loved ones,
relations with power.
That's one of the overwhelming themes of Lear,
is a reflection on what power does,
how it not just corrupts, but corrodes.
In the world of King Lear,
everybody is potentially mad,
or can be driven mad.
Everybody is a fool.
I mean, Cordelia is a fool at the beginning
for not playing the game in some ways.
Even the good characters.
Gloster is, from the outset,
all sorts of things can be said about him,
but he's not an evil man.
But he does an evil thing
because he's stupid enough
to believe one of his sons
when that son says that the other son
is trying to kill him.
And he believes it.
And as a result,
everything in his own world,
never mind the world of the kingdom,
is torn apart.
It's a world in which anyone can be misled.
Everyone can muck up so badly
they destroy everything
in their family,
in the kingdom.
And everybody can be in disguise.
Everybody can lie,
mislead, and be misled.
The people with power
aren't necessarily the people
who deserve to have power
or know what to do with it.
I mean, Goneril and Rhaegan,
the two evil daughters of Lear,
clearly, with their husbands,
want power but have no idea
of what they will do with it
and end up just corrupting
and corroding the kingdom further.
And Lear, who thinks he knows
what he'll do in retirement,
has no idea of what happens
to a king divested
of the garments of power.
And pride seems to displace
their reason from the very outset.
The very first scene is this
perfect embodiment of pride.
He says, I'm going to divvy up my kingdom.
Now flatter me.
And when you flatter me, I'll give you this.
And maybe one of the most famous scenes
is in Act 3 when Lear
cries out and says,
Blow winds and crack your cheeks.
Rage, blow.
You cataracts and hurricanes
spout till you have drenched
our steeples, drowned the cocks.
Goes on and on.
He's crying out at nature itself.
Yes, that's
one of the scenes that the actors who play
Lear are always judged by and love.
It's a great...
It's a great moment. Some ham
actors can somewhat
overdo the scene.
Once or twice, I think.
No, not.
Yes, this is Lear, an extremist
on the heath
becoming mad.
And it's
one of the most pitiful things in the play
is
watching
a man who had sense
losing his mind.
And it's terrifying. I mean, this is one of the things
which I think causes the play to continue
to be so
important is that
we recognize
elements of it in our own lives.
Lives of those around us.
Lear ends up completely
losing his sense of his self.
He has
to ask himself
who he is.
A number of characters do this. Edgar, the good son.
Edgar, I am nothing. I am not Edgar.
What is Edgar? What am I?
It's like so much
of Shakespeare.
Certain lines resonate
as if they were written yesterday
because they
tell us something
we had intuited but haven't said
about, for instance,
the dissolving of character,
the dissolving of a mind,
the falling apart of a mind.
And then the reflection on
what you or we
should or can
do in those circumstances.
Lear howling into
the hurricane
is the howl of humanity
in the situation
we find ourselves in,
a beleaguering world,
the point of which has not been adequately
explained to us.
And you can
howl at the wind
and
you can lose everything in it.
The heath
is obviously, among
much else, a sort of metaphor
that Shakespeare
uses, a place in
which people lose themselves and find
themselves. And this crucial
thing, again, of this, do we
learn anything from suffering?
Is it pointless?
There's no way in which Lear can
be returned to his throne. It cannot happen
that way. He cries out, not just against
the wind, he cries out against his two evil daughters.
I'm going to get you.
Basically, I'll avenge myself.
You're not going to see the things that I'm going to do to you.
And it's pathetic, because you look at it
and you say, of course he can't.
Even if he could, even if there were
the political advantages that would
allow him to, he's lost his senses.
He's actually a senile old man.
And he talks about this relationship of age.
He says, my daughters flattered me.
They said that I had white whiskers
when they were still black.
Flattering me as though I had the wisdom of age
before I did. Don't we all
do that? And then when he does
have these white whiskers, what do we do?
He's cast aside.
When he threatens revenge,
he's an incredibly familiar figure.
We can recognize a part of it
in ourselves in our less inglorious
moments, or less glorious moments.
We can recognize it in others.
The idea, for instance,
that with enough
determination,
rage, vengeance,
violence,
much more, you might
change the course of things
is to some extent
a maddening idea.
It literally
deranges Lear.
Not just a mad idea, but a maddening idea.
It makes you go crazy.
Yes, and
who hasn't seen somebody do a bit
of that? Revenge I will have
on this person for the slight, I believe.
It also
comes back to this
thing, which actually it's in Hamlet as well.
It's in many of the great
tragedies, which is the question of whether
the thing done, a terrible
thing done can ever be undone.
Well, you see this at the very end,
shockingly, one of the few moments of redemption
you see in the whole play. Edmund
at the very end, this bastard, awful
evil son, even
he, as he's dying, tries
to do a good thing. He says,
gosh, sorry, I put this hit out on Cordelia.
She's going to go be killed in prison.
Maybe go try to save her.
Obviously it doesn't work, and Lear comes back in with
Cordelia, but even he is, as the darkness
is closing in, he says,
let me try to do one good thing at least.
Yes, it's obviously too late for him
and it's too late for Cordelia.
But these
are another of the glimpses you get in the play.
These little signs
that Shakespeare gives you, that
it is possible, even
at that moment, to try
to redeem something.
And
it's
one of the most profound aspects of the play
this, that this
extraordinary, bleak
landscape in which
all of the characters find themselves,
nevertheless, even the worst of the characters
could, if they had wanted to,
redeem something.
They just
repeatedly choose not to
and suffer the consequences
of it. I mean, at the very
end of the play, at the end of Act 5,
Lear is holding his
daughter's body. He comes to his
senses again, like Gloucester.
Just before the end
there is a moment of
recognition in which
he learns everything
that he could have learned in the rest of his
life and didn't.
He has this pitiful
speech. He says
he's testing her.
He thinks maybe there is
breath in her body
and
as if he could wish her back to life
and he says at the end
he says, no life
why should a dog, a horse
a rat have life
thou no breath at all
and then he starts
to dream that her lips
are moving and his last words
he says, look on her, look
her lips, look there, look there
and eyes
and
it's
certainly done well in the theater
and it's quite hard to do that scene badly
but done well, it's one of the most
moving scenes in theater
that he
finally, cradling his daughter's body
finds out the thing
he should have known at the beginning. He should have
known who to love, who to trust
he should have known among
much else the potential costs
and the consequences of the
game he set in motion
he should have understood the world
he was in more accurately
and we, the viewer
the audience, the reader
obviously have the
opportunity to judge Lear
as every
character in the play, we have the opportunity
to judge, but the real question we have
at the end
as the smoke
starts ever so slightly
to clear
is whether we would have
done any better
in the circumstances
that the characters find themselves in
I think by the way, I think that's one
of the reasons why this
play has endured and has
spoken to people because of course
in some societies
America you might say is one of them
there is a narrative
that everything
can come right
never too late
Alan Bloom once
described a form of American nihilism
which he said is nihilism with a happy ending
things don't just work out
by some cosmic
fluke
they can always become better
or worse, made more maddening
or more sane
by the actions of the people in it
in the society, in the play
people have given
accounts across the centuries of
finding in Lear this
reflection of their own lives
of their own situation
the reflection that doesn't just
fall out better by chance
it all relies
on the actions of
absolutely every individual
on the stage
and you mention in Lear's final lines
talking about Cordelia's lips
and you'll recall
when he is waking up
he's sort of asleep, he's in a stupor
what wakes him up? Cordelia's lips
kisses from Cordelia's lips
she says, my lips will be your medicine
lips, which seems to me
obviously it's an image
and it's a commentary on
speech and on language
on what lips do
how we can hopefully learn these lessons before that very last moment
that's right
the lips got her and indeed him
into the position
at the very beginning
and also have this
curing potential
yes, you're right
a lot of things in the play come around like that
disguises
that turn out to reveal
truths
madmen who turn out
to be the only people who are sane
fools who are the only ones who can speak
the truth
the whole world thrown upside down
but
by being turned
and thrown upside down and jumbled
is somehow made
more clear
I think that's a good pitch by the way for the play
that in seeing these truths
these parallels to our human nature
and to our own lives
we can hopefully avoid
the maddening
lies
that will destroy our kingdom and our lives
until at the very last second we find out
it's too late
or you could just read these things
and try to understand those truths
while you're still moving and still breathing
Douglas, we could talk about this play
for another 30 hours probably
and perhaps we'll have to do that
next time you're in the States
Douglas Murray, you should of course
go out and read Strange Death of Europe
you should read Madness of Crowds
those can be the two books right after
you read King Lear
thank you so much for being here
it's been a great pleasure
mine as well, I'm Michael Knowles, this is The Book Club
we'll see you next time
Thank you so much for watching this episode of The Book Club
on PragerU
PragerU is a 501c3 non-profit organization
so we rely on donations
from viewers like you
to keep this content on the air
please consider making a tax-deductible
contribution today
to help keep this content coming
thank you very much
