Beijing Acknowledges Weak Domestic Demand, While the Public Says "People Truly Have No Money"

China Truths
61 followers
Welcome to China Truths. In this episode, we will bring you the following story:
Beijing Acknowledges Weak Domestic Demand, While the Public Says "People Truly Have No Money"
Now, let’s dive into the details
#china #chinatruths #chinanews
Welcome to China Truths. In this episode, we will bring you the following story.
Beijing acknowledges weak domestic demand, while the public says people truly have no money.
Now, let's dive into the details.
It's all covered in today's China Truths.
Beijing acknowledges weak domestic demand, while the public says people truly have no money.
Amid an economic downturn in China and persistently weak domestic demand,
even China's state media has acknowledged that the economy faces four significant challenges,
including lackluster domestic demand.
Many voices among the Chinese public assert that people genuinely have no money.
On November 11, China's official newspaper, People's Daily, published a commentary
acknowledging four major challenges facing the current Chinese economy,
increasing pressures to stabilize foreign trade and investments,
weak domestic demand with limited consumer spending ability and intent, difficulties
in stabilizing investments, with private investments needing further stimulation,
and business challenges, including sluggish sales, declining profits, and weakened market expectations.
Additionally, many areas face financial risks,
with some locales struggling with debt restructuring and grassroots financial constraints.
Employment pressure is rising for university graduates and other young groups,
while urban residents' income growth is slowing.
In October, China's CPI rose by 0.3% year-on-year, down from 0.4% in September,
marking the lowest level since June and below the 0.4% rise predicted by Reuters.
Excluding volatile food and fuel prices, core inflation rose by 0.2% in October.
Despite the government's launch of a big policy package in late September to stimulate the
economy, inflation remains close to zero, further indicating weak domestic demand.
On social media, numerous netizens expressed that people now genuinely have no money,
noting several typical phenomena.
First, food retail struggles. Business in food shops is increasingly difficult.
Shopping centers that were once bustling now resemble ghost towns,
sometimes with more staff than customers.
Notably, many stores are frequently listing prime retail spaces for sublease every three
or four months. People's wallets are truly empty, and those with even a little money
are holding on to it tightly, avoiding spending. Rising prices are outpacing wages,
while housing and car loans add immense financial pressure.
With e-commerce also growing, food retail faces particularly tough times.
Second, young people not having children. Many young people are not unwilling but
simply unable to afford to have children. Children are often seen as money guzzlers,
with costs spanning from diapers and formula to school district housing and tutoring classes,
all of which require significant funds.
Amidst pay cuts and a challenging job market, even basic survival is difficult,
making the thought of having children daunting.
This contributes to an aging population and future labor shortages,
a consequence society may be unable to bear.
Third, saving money and reducing consumption. People are now saving money zealously and
lowering their desire to consume. Previously carefree with spending,
they are now budgeting carefully, making thrift a new trend.
Weekend dining out has given way to staying home and watching shows, driven by future uncertainty.
If everyone stops spending, how can the economy grow?
Without economic growth, where will incomes come from?
And without incomes, what will people spend on?
This is a very troubling vicious cycle. These phenomena reflect a range of issues,
from social wealth disparity to structural economic imbalances,
highlighting deep-rooted problems in China's economy.
As ordinary people, it's crucial to bolster personal risk resilience because,
in this country, the only reliable thing is oneself.
The blogger Universe10 recently remarked, where has the public's money gone?
He pointed out that most families, to buy a home, have drained lifelong savings,
putting everything into the real estate market, even using grandparents' pensions to cover down
payments. Yet, many cities are now dotted with unfinished developments comprising over a hundred
buildings, tying up large amounts of capital. Many developers are heavily indebted, with vast
sums bound in real estate, leaving these homeowners effectively penniless, their funds entirely locked
up in property. For years, authorities have been pushing for consumption growth and increased
domestic demand. Why hasn't it materialized? The key is that people's money is tied up in
real estate. Some say real estate is the biggest black hand, which seems to hold some truth.
He continued, there are also many vacant developments that remain unsold. Meanwhile,
people who bought homes often cannot receive them. Mortgage defaults, and even collective defaults,
are becoming more frequent. This is not an abstract idea. It is a real social issue.
Properties in large cities can cost millions, even tens of millions, while in smaller cities,
they may cost hundreds of thousands. As unemployment grows and the wave of layoffs
spreads nationwide, families have invested nearly all their capital into real estate.
Meanwhile, inventories and listings for secondhand properties are surging,
making it difficult to sell properties. The inability to liquidate real estate
is becoming the biggest problem for the public.
