Desperation in Beijing and Shanghai: People are desperate and lamenting
China Undercover
188 người theo dõi
224 Lượt xem video·18 thg 3, 2025
Desperation in Beijing and Shanghai: People are desperate and lamenting
They are closed down. All closed down. Look, all closed down. You see, there are only two
or three businesses still operating on one floor of the entire mall, and the others are all closed
down. There is basically no one here, which is really scary. The wedding banquet building,
including this hotpot restaurant here, has all closed down. Zui Shen Hai seafood hotpot has
also closed down, and Xianglin Shippu has closed down as well. These stores are quite large,
and the investment is estimated to be more than 1 million. Basically, all the businesses here
have closed down. This mall is an outlet. It was very popular when it first opened,
but now the bankruptcy rate of this mall is basically 60%. As the Chinese New Year approaches,
the prices of domestic air tickets and train tickets have dropped significantly.
Analysts believe that the unemployment wave among Chinese people continues,
and that consumption capacity has dropped significantly, leading to widespread price
reductions. Some mainland netizens lamented that everyone really has no money. Many supermarkets
and shopping malls no longer have the lively New Year atmosphere of previous years,
and even Beijing shopping malls are deserted. Let's talk about related topics today.
Data from multiple online travel booking platforms show that domestic air ticket
prices in China have dropped significantly during the New Year. Wuhan to Ningbo, Tianjin,
and Hangzhou have dropped by more than 50%. Beijing to Haiku, Sanya, and Shanghai have
dropped by more than 60%. Air tickets from Guangzhou to Shanghai and Harbin have dropped by
75% and 74% respectively. Not only in Chongqing, during the New Year, you can buy a bare-air
ticket for 200 yuan from major cities such as Beijing, Shanghai, Guangzhou, and Nanjing.
People who booked tickets in advance refunded their tickets and bought them again,
saving a lot of money. On January 21, netizen Ms. Liu said on social media that she thought the
earlier she bought the tickets, the cheaper they would be. So, she bought tickets from Harbin to
Haiku and Beijing to Haiku a month in advance. Now the price is almost cut in half, and the
flight that cost 2,500 yuan now only costs 1,600 yuan. Ms. Liu calculated that the tickets for her
family of five cost more than 4,000 yuan. So, she called the airline and the ticketing platform to
ask for a refund of the difference, but was rejected. Later, she refunded the ticket according
to the process. Although she paid more than 800 yuan in refund fees, the new ticket was still
cheaper than the previous fare. Have you seen discounted train tickets? During the Spring
Festival travel season, hard seats are 20% off, and hard and soft sleepers are 40% off.
I have been looking at train tickets from Wuhan to Guangzhou recently,
and I found that there is a train with discounted prices every day. High-speed rail also has
bargain-priced tickets at 19% off. On January 23, the high-speed rail ticket from Chongqing to
Huaihua was 19% off and only cost 15 yuan. The ticket price from Chongqing to Guilin was 40%
off, only 121 yuan. Although air tickets and train tickets are being greatly reduced in price,
some people dare not return home to reunite with their families because of a sharp drop in income
or unemployment. I am at the railway station now, but I am not going home for the new year.
Singles are actually too embarrassed to go home for the new year, and I am the same. I have been
wandering outside for 7 or 8 years and have not returned home for the new year. This year is the
same. I am too embarrassed to go back. The whole village is waiting to see you laugh. Why do you
go back? Won't they laugh their heads off? So it is better to stay out here and have more free time.
You can't make money, and you can't find a partner either. This is the most heartbreaking
thing your parents say to you. I believe that parents all over the world say this.
In fact, everyone who wanders outside is happy to go home for the new year,
but they all leave home crying. There is nothing they can do. Now the new year has become a
formality, and the atmosphere of the new year when I was a child is long gone. I don't want
to celebrate the new year more and more. What else do you think there is to celebrate about the new
year, except that I am one year older? China's current economic downturn is becoming increasingly
serious. Consumer demand is weak. Companies are cutting wages and laying off workers on a large
scale. Businesses are closing down, and people are complaining. I really can't afford to live anymore.
The Chinese new year is approaching. However, in contrast to the bustling atmosphere of preparing
for the traditional new year as in previous years, mainland China is currently gloomy and somber,
with cries of closures, bankruptcies, and unemployment spreading everywhere.
Foreign investors in Beijing, Shanghai, Guangzhou, and Shenzhen are fleeing. The wave of unemployment
is spreading to major cities at a dizzying speed. According to official statistics,
both Beijing and Shanghai experienced a sharp decline in consumption in November.
Beijing's total retail sales of consumer goods fell by 14.1% year-on-year in November,
and Shanghai's fell by 13.5% year-on-year, while the national total grew by 3% year-on-year during
the same period. In addition to Beijing and Shanghai, Guangzhou's retail sales in November
also fell by 1.6% year-on-year, and as of the time of this article's publication,
Shenzhen's data has not yet been released. In the past, there was a saying that economic
downward pressure would not affect Beijing and Shanghai, because Beijing and Shanghai
would absorb national resources, so Beijing and Shanghai will always rise. But now, on the
contrary, everything is falling apart here. As first-tier cities among first-tier cities in
China, will the current consumption status of Beijing and Shanghai become a national forward-
or are there special factors behind them? Behind the decline in consumption in Beijing
and Shanghai, I believe there are at least several important reasons. Asset shrinkage,
employment fluctuations, differences in consumption structure, and higher household
leverage ratios. The big impact of declining personal wealth. The widely discussed consumption
downgrade is not merely a simple impact of income changes. Compared to income changes,
the wealth perspective brought about by asset price fluctuations has a greater impact on a
person's consumption. Let's take Beijing and Shanghai as examples. The market value of a
very ordinary house in Beijing and Shanghai easily exceeds 5 million, while in other second-
tier cities, it may only be 1 million. Over the past few years, we have clearly seen that both
first-tier cities such as Beijing and Shanghai and other second- and third-tier cities have
experienced a sharp drop in housing prices. The decline in Beijing and Shanghai is not smaller.
If the decline in each city is the same, for instance, a 30% drop, the absolute value of the
average total price of real estate in Beijing and Shanghai, 5 million, shrinks by 1.5 million,
while the absolute value of the average total price of real estate in other cities,
1 million market value, shrinks by only 300,000. Such asset shrinkage has a huge
impact on consumer psychology. It is also necessary to emphasize a cruel reality.
Although many new Beijingers or new Shanghainese often claim how inspiring and hard-working they
are, most of them have not made much money from work in cities like Beijing and Shanghai.
Instead, they gritted their teeth, bought a house, and benefited from rising prices. In the end,
they mistook the dividends of the times for their own ability. This is obviously an illusion.
However, it is undeniable that many people's satisfaction and consumption potential
were based on the previous housing price increase. When the domestic real estate market was booming,
even while traveling abroad, many Chinese people would feel happy when they learned that local
housing prices were very low. Now that house prices have dropped dramatically and they cannot
sell their houses, their most valuable assets are gradually losing value. Confronted with this shock,
they cannot believe it, and their spending budgets have also started to drop dramatically.
The impact of employment fluctuations, greater widespread layoffs, and unemployment. Previously,
hot cities such as Beijing and Shanghai gathered a large number of high-income occupations.
When the economic cycle was upward, these industries were booming and helped the cities
attract countless talents from all over the country. Now, as these industries begin to decline,
they naturally cut salaries and lay off workers, leading to widespread unemployment. This situation
has led to an exodus of foreign populations and migrant workers from Beijing and Shanghai,
along with a decline in consumption power. We can clearly observe that over the past few years,
industries with strong wealth-making capabilities, such as real estate, finance, education, and
training, and the internet, have successively encountered financial difficulties due to
objective market laws or strict regulatory measures. In addition, unless you are a wealthy native,
life in first-tier cities is not easy. For most young people, first-tier cities are either
roll or leave, because the cost of living here is much higher than in other cities.
Without better job opportunities, they have no reason to continue paying the high costs of
staying in such places. As the population decreases, consumption naturally declines.
The previous hustle and bustle gradually fades, replaced by a gloomy and deserted scene,
as more people leave Beijing and Shanghai each day.
Differences in Consumption Structure Looking at the national consumption data
from November 2024, one clear feature emerges. Optional consumption has dropped sharply,
with the largest decline seen in cosmetics, which fell 26.4% year-on-year in November 2023.
Meanwhile, essential consumption related to basic life needs has remained relatively stable.
Notably, household appliance consumption grew by 22% year-on-year, driven by government subsidies
for replacing old appliances with new ones. This demonstrates that subsidized consumption
has an immediate effect. In the future, we can expect more such subsidies, which is worth
anticipating. In the past, first-tier cities were at the forefront of consumption upgrades
in the country. Consequently, the proportion of optional consumption by residents in first-tier
cities is much higher than in other regions. This also results in a greater potential for
consumption decline in first-tier cities compared to other areas. Thus, it is not that people in
other regions do not want to save money, but rather that consumers in these areas have hardly
experienced substantial consumption upgrades. Consumption here is largely focused on meeting
basic needs like food and clothing, making it genuinely difficult to save money. Residents
have a higher leverage ratio. The housing price-to-income ratio in first-tier cities
is much higher than in other cities. In other words, even though income in first-tier cities
is higher, the increase is far less than the increase in housing prices. This is the effect
of leverage. It also means that people of the same age and industry who have bought houses in
first-tier cities generally face much greater financial pressure than those in other cities.
Due to this financial pressure, the marriage rate and fertility rate in first-tier cities are also
much lower than in other cities. In smaller cities, due to less developed modern financial concepts
and relatively low total housing prices, ordinary people do not use leverage to the extreme when
buying houses. In cities with high housing prices like Beijing and Shanghai, purchasing a very
ordinary house may require a loan of several million yuan, putting residents under significant
leverage pressure. From the data, we can observe that once the resident leverage ratio exceeds a
certain critical value, the higher the resident leverage ratio, the slower the consumption growth
rate. The two figures exhibit a very obvious negative correlation. Facts and data show that in
an economic downturn, there is no place that is an absolutely safe fortress. The belief that Beijing
and Shanghai will always rise might just be some people's self-consolation, much like the notion
that rigid demand is immune to price drops. Such brainwashing judgments have no reference value,
only emotional value. Additionally, the decline in consumption indicates that residents' financial
pressures have begun to affect their actual quality of life. Forget about housing prices,
which is really a non-nutritive topic, because when difficulties arise, bricks cannot be eaten
as food. The next focus for ordinary people like us should be on securing work and income for
ourselves or our families in the coming year. It is no exaggeration to say that any company
that can pay wages on time and in full now is a good company. After Beijing and Shanghai,
whether other hot cities and more second- and third-tier cities will experience similar
consumption declines remains to be observed. However, weak consumption is not just a short-term
issue, but a long-term structural problem. We have always prioritized investment and production
while neglecting the importance of consumption. Some even consider consumption, eating, drinking,
and having fun as detrimental to hard work. This understanding is entirely wrong.
Regarding the pressure of deflation and the value of consumption, I previously shared a post on my
aimed at helping readers overcome inflation anxiety and protect their finances by presenting
facts and logical reasoning. In short, consumption is the core driving force of sustainable economic
growth. Without sufficient effective demand, production becomes meaningless and inefficient.
Once the decline in consumption becomes a trend, it easily leads to a vicious cycle.
A decline in consumption causes manufacturers to incur losses or reduce production,
leading to upstream and downstream industrial chain wage cuts or layoffs.
Then, those whose wages are cut or who lose their jobs further reduce consumption due to reduced
income. Furthermore, as 2025 approaches, with the prospect of Trump taking office,
we can be almost certain that international trade protectionism will rise again,
new trade frictions will emerge, and external demand will become unstable. China's economy
will enter 2025 with significant challenges, and we will wait and see what happens next.
