Michael Yonan, Associate Professor of Art History, University of Missouri, presents his lecture, "Porcelain As Sculpture: Medium, Materiality, and the Categories of Eighteenth-Century Collecting" on Friday, May 19, 2017. This lecture is part of the symposium Sculpture Collecting and Display, 1600–2000 presented by the Center for the History of Collecting at The Frick Collection on Friday and Saturday, May 19–20, 2017.
This two-day symposium showcased how approaches to collecting and displaying sculpture have varied and changed over the centuries, from the Kunskammer of late Renaissance princes, to the sculpture galleries of the eighteenth century, to garden sculpture ensembles and, finally to the challenges of displaying sculpture in public museums. Renowned art historian Malcolm Baker offered the keynote address, which was followed by a roster of distinguished speakers from Europe and the United States. The symposium was made possible through the support of the Robert H. Smith Family Foundation.
Our next speaker, Michael Yonan, is Associate Professor of Art History at the University of Missouri.
He's the author of,
Empress Maria Teresa and the Politics of Habsburg Imperial Art that was published by Penn State Press in 2011,
and of Cultural Aesthetics of Eighteenth-Century Porcelain, co-edited with Alden Cavanaugh, that appeared in 2010,
as well as numerous articles on the arts in eighteenth-century Central and Northern Europe.
Michael's book, Messerschmitt's Character Heads, Maddening Sculpture in the Writing of Art History, will be published by Routledge this coming summer.
Michael is also the editor of a new book series called, The Material Culture of Art and Design, that is for Bloomsbury Academic,
and he's also the series editor for Ashgate, now Routledge's, Histories of Material Culture and Collecting, 1700-1950,
which I'm pleased to say included one of the center's publications several years ago on British models of collecting and the American response.
This afternoon, Michael will present his thoughts about porcelain as sculpture, meaning, materiality, and the categories of eighteenth-century collecting.
Please give a warm welcome to Michael.
The story of porcelain's beginnings in China, the institutionalization of its production under imperial authority at Jingdezhen,
the role it played in several major early modern global economies, its rise to the ne plus ultra of ceramics in eighteenth-century Europe,
and the complicated history it has had since, all of this regularly attracts the attention of both scholars and the popular viewer.
To summarize its significance, it may be enough to note, following the historian Robert Finley, that porcelain was the first truly global product,
a medium for objects produced not only for specific sites and uses, but for international exchange.
The European discovery of porcelain at Meissen, quote, discovery of porcelain at Meissen,
and the subsequent development of European manufactories, as well as the commercialization of porcelain production at heritage houses like Meissen and Sevres,
are likewise standard components of our history of eighteenth-century collecting.
And furthermore, as the scholarship of Maureen Cassidy Geiger has demonstrated, porcelain was of central importance to international diplomacy in the form of diplomatic gifts.
We may then surmise, from its historical and critical importance, that porcelain's role in the histories of eighteenth-century collecting is securely understood,
and its place in the classificatory systems that structured the arts confirmed.
Yet, I would hesitate to say that.
Well studied though it is, porcelain's significance to eighteenth-century collecting practices is surprisingly complex.
To locate porcelain within a putative history of ceramics, and therefore of the decorative arts, gives the interpreter one view of its importance.
To understand it as part of a broader history of art gives a different one.
The problem arises out of modern art historical classifications, which tend to locate influence within specific media, rather than across them.
And this results in turn from academic specializations that encourage scholars to look carefully at one kind of art, and sometimes less closely at others.
There was a parallel problem in the eighteenth century, in that what defined the boundaries of art, quote, art, was in a state of transformation,
one for which porcelain found itself right in the middle.
Porcelain objects' status as art, or better said, what kind of art porcelain was, was subject to great variation of explanation,
depending on context, the type of object in question, and its heritage.
At the root of the problem is the ontological status of the art object itself.
A big subject indeed, but luckily our focus this afternoon is on collections of sculpture, which helps me narrow it.
In a sense, there is no good reason not to describe a room like the porcelain cabinet at Schloss Charlottenburg in Berlin as a sculptural collection.
It brings together three dimensional objects and arranges them in a carefully conceived display,
the purpose of which is to draw attention to the objects themselves and their aesthetic qualities.
Characteristics that would be largely at home in many other kinds of sculptural collections.
Yet few of us would call this a sculptural collection.
Our hesitation has eighteenth century origins,
and my goal today will be to map out this situation to show how porcelain almost became a high art,
namely sculpture, at an early moment in its European production.
Eighteenth century collections moved closer to transforming porcelain into sculpture than at any time since.
But we shall see that in porcelain's seductive materiality,
lay both its potential to reach that goal and its limitation.
Let us begin by talking a little bit about materiality.
Materiality is not, as so much art historical writing assumes, synonymous with medium.
One component of a work of art's materiality is, in fact, its medium.
It matters enormously whether a painting is made of oil, tempera, or acrylics,
and the possibilities that each medium allows, as well as the limits that it proscribes,
are an essential component of that work of art,
and ideally should play a role in the scholarly interpretation of it.
But once a work of art is made, its medium becomes incorporated into the broader materiality of its culture,
which is better described as how medium creates the status of the artwork as a thing
that interacts with other things to form a specific material world.
This material world is forever in flux, changing over time,
and within a material world, different materialities interrelate,
carry meanings, clash with each other,
or otherwise inflect how individuals understand how the world functions.
Imagining how an object fits within the philosophical, ethical, perceptual,
and economic structures of a given moment is one way to understand its materiality,
which produces a much broader and, to my mind, more exciting way of talking about an object.
Probably in your mind at this moment is the question of how we designate something as a thing.
This is a major philosophical question that I will not attempt to solve in a simple paper,
but let me say with great circularity that we know a thing is a thing because we encounter its materiality.
Its special, seductively shiny materiality was, of course,
one component of what made porcelain so desirable among 18th century collectors.
It is also, paradoxically, what made porcelain difficult to understand as sculpture,
even when porcelain was used for figural modeling
that directly mimicked the dynamics of viewing small-scale sculptures.
We shall come to that in a moment,
but nowhere do we encounter this confusion about porcelain's materiality more
than in the earliest court attempts to collect and display it.
We can see this clearly in the most famous porcelain sculptural display of the early 18th century,
albeit one that did not survive for long,
and we know it today through preparatory drawings, which I will show you,
namely the porcelain collections put on display at the Japanisches Palais in Dresden
under the supervision of the Polish-Saxon elector, King Augustus the Strong,
whose place in the history of European porcelain is, of course, very secure.
Augustus was so fascinated by Asiatic porcelains
that he pushed local philosopher-artisans,
Walter Ehrenfried von Tschirnhaus and Johann Friedrich Boettger,
to create porcelain in Dresden,
leading to the development, eventually, of the Meissen Manufactory.
And, of course, Augustus amassed staggering amounts of porcelain,
both Asiatic and European in origin,
numbering into the tens of thousands of individual objects.
Just as a slight aside,
there may be a direct connection between this famous collection of porcelain in Dresden
and the Prussian one that I showed you a moment ago.
Scholars have proposed that Augustus only became interested in creating
such an enormous display for his porcelain collection
after visiting Berlin in 1709,
to which he traveled to form an alliance with Prussia and Denmark against Sweden.
During that trip, he certainly visited Charlottenburg
and may have had this room in mind
when overseeing the designs for the displays at the Apponishus Palais.
The building was not a palace in the usual sense.
It was not a courtly residence,
but instead a gigantic show space
to be used in receptions, ceremonies, and diplomatic visits.
The building's history has been well studied.
I would mention recent scholarship by Cordula Bischoff,
Ulrich Pitsch, and Samuel Wittwar,
for the knowledge they have imparted to our understanding of its genesis and function.
Today, I shall emphasize two aspects of its interior arrangement and design.
The first concerns the way in which the display of the royal porcelain collection was conceived.
The second is the range of objects on view
and how they might be classified as sculpture, decorative arts, or something else.
Although the documentary record for the Apponishus Palais is rich,
our understanding of exactly how porcelains were displayed in its interior
is imperfect, as they were dismantled around 1770.
We know something of its possible arrangement
from a series of drawings for the interior
produced by a group of Saxon court architects,
each of which grappled with issues of how to present
the Elector's porcelain collection in a most appealing manner.
The first drawings come from the studio of Matthäus Daniel Perpelmann,
well known as the architect of the Zwinger Palace,
but also put into service to outfit the Apponishus Palais.
In one of several drawings for the project,
in this case showing a display of porcelain object in the palace's upper story
and dating from around 1730,
we find something remarkably close to the example from Charlottenburg.
Ornate shelves and pedestals are arranged across the surface of the wall.
Resting upon them are porcelain vases, terrines, and some small animal figurines.
Also sketched into the design are Asiatic pagodes,
these smiling Buddha-like figures,
smirking masks, candle sconces, and tendrils of purely ornamental filigree.
These function to incorporate the objects displayed
into a rich and fantastic Asiatic theme.
In this respect, Perpelmann modifies the well-known wall display templates
provided by Daniel Marot in his highly influential Nouvelle Cheminée of 1712,
which were extremely influential in guiding the display of porcelain
and other precious objects in noble interiors,
and particularly so in Germany.
Perpelmann's display positions the porcelain objects in it
as components of the interior architecture,
as largely fixed entities within its design.
In a sense, then, porcelain here asserts its presence
through its purely formal qualities,
alongside whatever wisps of narrative might be implied
through the figural elements.
The point is to see porcelain as part of a whole.
Whether we can call this a display of sculpture, however,
is not so clear, although one might note
that it operates here more like architectural sculpture,
and that it adorns a space as part of a decorative program.
Insofar as architectural sculpture might be conceived
as a sculptural collection,
so too might that designation apply for this room.
And insofar as the porcelain objects meant here
are primarily meant here to be seen,
and seen within a decorative patterning,
they might come closer to sculpture
than they otherwise would.
The sharp-eyed among you might have noticed
that Perpelmann's design is somewhat old-fashioned for 1730,
in case you're into that.
And apparently, that is also how it looked to Augustus the Strong,
since the Elector King brought in a second architect
to offer an alternative conception of the palace's displays.
This was the French-born Zacharias Langlune,
active in Dresden,
who produced a series of drawings for the palace's interior
around 1735.
Not only do these designs arrange the porcelain objects
in the palace entirely differently,
updating them in a way understood as the French manner,
they imply a different conception
of the porcelain object as a material entity.
Here is one of Langlune's drawings
for a room on the palace's ground floor.
Of course, we should remember that,
as with many 18th century architectural drawings,
this one represents several options
for potential building.
It is not a view of any actual segment of wall.
I show it here to provide insight
into the concept behind porcelain's display,
as Langlune understood it.
In it, we find once again porcelain arranged
in patterns on the wall's surface
and also on pedestals, as in Perpelmann's drawings.
But something important has changed.
The balance between wall ornament
and porcelain object has been rethought,
with the porcelains given greater presence and emphasis.
Indeed, they become the primary decoration of the wall,
not simply one component among many decorative elements.
The result is that individual objects
are easier to apprehend as discrete pieces.
The result is also to let each object speak,
if one can say that, more directly for itself.
We also know from a memorandum
written by Langlune around this time
that there were practical considerations
behind this structure of display.
In it, he remarks that the advantage
of displaying porcelains like this
is that it enabled the objects to be moved around,
removed from their place on the wall and held,
and more broadly, to allow new objects
to be switched in for others
according to the patron's wishes.
The flexibility of display also reveals Langlune's
understanding of Augustus' collecting practices,
since it indicates that the collection as a whole
could be improved as new
and presumably better quality porcelain pieces were acquired.
The porcelain as individual objects
are not fixed constituent parts of the room,
but rather are individual pieces
with their own independence.
They operate more like a collection
and less like the architectural elements of the wall.
Here I brought in an additional drawing
just to show you the two conceptions.
With that in mind,
we can think a little bit about
whether portability brings these objects
closer to sculpture.
I would suggest that transferability
works against the idea
that this was a sculptural collection
in the conventional sense.
Of course, much sculpture is portable,
and small-scale sculpture,
particularly bronzes like the ones we just saw,
need not be understood as permanently affixed
to any particular site,
but rather as movable elements
of a collector's holdings.
But the idea of porcelain objects
being interchangeable
and detached from the wall
and held in the hand,
and at least theoretically,
if not actually used,
and that's an issue with porcelain
and displays like this,
is that they were often not used as plates,
but the theoretical idea,
the sort of possibility that they could be,
is there.
All of those combine to work against the idea
that this was conceived as a sculptural display.
It's a slippery point,
but the question of porcelain status
clearly concerned Long Lun,
who argued that the object's portability
worked against the collection
being appreciated as art.
The display needed to be handled,
he said, with great care,
lest it take on,
and excuse my French,
that it would look too much
like a richly outfitted store.
This comment tries to deflect
the criticism that collecting porcelain
was a purely commercial endeavor,
and its display needed to avoid
easy conflation with
to use Barbara Maria Stafford's
wonderful phrase,
gaping at heaped up goods.
Long Lun's comment
might surprise those of us
accustomed to thinking about
porcelain's economic importance
to Dresden,
which is emphasized heavily in the literature.
But in it,
and the designs for the Ipanishos Palais,
I think we can locate Long Lun's worry
that many viewers would not understand
porcelain as art.
Another place where this tension arises
is in the four sculptural roundels
he proposed to decorate
the palace's grand gallery.
These were to represent
allegorical figures of painting,
sculpture, geometry, and chemistry.
Porcelain combines all of these,
since mastery of each
is required in order to produce
a porcelain object.