The Committee on Energy and Commerce is the oldest standing legislative committee (established 1795) in the U.S. House of Representatives and is vested with the broadest jurisdiction of any congressional authorizing committee. The Energy and Commerce Committee is at the forefront of all issues and policies powering America’s economy, including our global competitive edge in energy, technology, and health care. The committee is led by E&C Chairman Brett Guthrie (KY-02) and E&C Ranking Member Frank Pallone (NJ-06). The Subcommittee on Commerce, Manufacturing, and Trade is led by Chairman Gus Bilirakis (FL-12) and Ranking Member Jan Schakowsky (IL-09).
Good morning, everyone, and thank you to our witnesses for being
here. We really do appreciate it very much. I'm really excited to
hold this hearing today on the evolving landscape of name, image,
likeness, uh, commonly known as NIL and its impact on college athletes.
In just a few years, college athletics has fundamentally reshaped
the lives of student athletes who can now benefit from their NIL.
Before 2021, athletes were barred from profiting off of their own
NIL, but in response to legal challenges in the Supreme Court decision,
the NCAA ended those restrictions. Finally, giving our student athletes
their much deserved ability to earn compensation for their brand
and their God-given talent. However, However,
the absence of a preemptive uniform standard has led to the wild
west. Most would agree with that. Uh, a wild west environment where
sadly our student athletes are put in vulnerable positions where
they can easily be exploited by those who do not have their best
interests in mind. I've heard awful stories of student athletes signing
deals without having been given full explanations for how their deal
would impact their long-term finances and livelihood.
This lack of structure has also allowed NIL collectives or often
affiliated with universities but operating independently to turn
NIL into a pay for play system.
Instead of being used for legitimate business purposes, and I deals
are frequently given out as recruiting inducements, with little transparency,
oversight. We have to fix that, folks. I'm also concerned about the
transfer portal. All of us want to make sure student athletes have
the freedom to make the best collegiate and educational decisions,
after all, that's why they go to college to get a good education,
but educational decisions for themselves and for their future.
But this current system is not workable as athletes are entering
the portal at an unprecedented rate,
sometimes multiple times in their careers with a hope, but not a
guaranteed
for something better. I'm sure we have all heard the stories of student
athletes being encouraged to transfer schools based on promises of
NIL money. That never materializes.
Others transfer expecting better playing time.
Only to find themselves in a worse
situation. This revolving door system has created instability for
both athletes in the programs they leave behind. With many student
athletes ending up without a clear academic or athletic path.
We often focus on NIL on the business side of college athletics.
But we must remember that these are still student athletes. Young
men and women who are supposed to be receiving an education that
prepares them for a life
beyond sports. Yet, too many are making life altering financial and
academic decisions without the proper guidance.
Some are signing in IL deals without understanding tax and legal
implications and you can't blame them. These most of these, while
they're 18 year olds in some cases, uh, but some are even younger,
uh, so, uh, they're gonna need some guidance, folks. Others are transferring
from school to school without receiving the academic support they
need to graduate. If we are serious about protecting student athletes,
and I hope we are. We need to ensure that they have the resources
and education necessary to navigate this new era successfully.
That's why I'm so glad to have Emily and Anthony with us here today.
Thank you for sharing your stories. We really appreciate a student
athletes, and how you were able to traverse this complex environment.
It gives us all student athletes the chance, gives all the student
athletes a chance to learn and better themselves. That brings me
to a point I really want to drive home. We are working on this issue,
not to put one school over another, although I am. A Florida gator,
and I'd like to see the national championship, or another national
championship sometime soon. Uh, but again, not one school over another,
OK? We've got to protect the small schools as well, OK? We have division
one, but we have to look out for the medium size and small schools
as well. So now we're doing this for the student athletes, and that's
what we're doing it for. We must protect these student athletes folks.
We have a responsibility to do so. Uh, unfortunately, they haven't
been protected in the past, so Congress has to intervene with the
preemption, in my opinion. So, we, I'll say it again. We are doing
this for the student athletes, for the young men and women who advance
to college so they can continue playing the sport they love and use
that experience to help them succeed throughout their lives.
It could be a wonderful experience. So it is crucial.
It is crucial we establish a preemptive
standard, as I said, that protects student athletes, but also doesn't
endanger the many sports programs that we don't see on ESPN or that
bring in billions of dollars. I know I'm over, aren't I? Yeah, well,
let me just finish uh here, uh, and I'll give you the opportunity,
uh, ranking member to go over if you, if you'd like. Again, uh, folks,
We must protect the student athletes, um, and, and we must protect
the Olympic sports and the sports, the non-revenue sports as well.
So, this is too important of an issue to get wrong. I think you know
that. So I look forward to a thoughtful discussion and working towards
solutions that support both student athletes and the long-term future
of college sports. With that, are you back