"At what point is renting wasting money? I can't currently buy a home using the Money Guy rule, but renting isn't any cheaper. Do I need to give up living in a HCOL area?"
Bring confidence to your wealth building with simplified strategies from The Money Guy. Learn how to apply financial tactics that go beyond common sense and help you reach your money goals faster. Make your assets do the heavy lifting so you can quit worrying and start living a more fulfilled life.
At what point is renting wasting money?
I can't currently buy a home using the money guy house buying rule,
but renting isn't any cheaper.
Do I need to give up living in a high cost of living area?
This is a good question.
I think there are plenty of people facing this.
What would you say about renting versus buying?
Well, let me answer that last part of the question first.
Do I need to give up living in a high cost of living area?
Maybe.
But in our opinion,
where you live in terms of geography is often less of a financial question
and more of a lifestyle question.
There might be a reason that you live in that high cost of living area.
So it might be that's where your job is,
or that's where your family is,
or that's where you're from,
or whatever the case may be.
So it's going to be difficult to make life choices purely based on financial factors.
However, when you do have those life choices,
there are financial factors that come into play.
Now, I want to set the record straight here,
the financial community has not done this well.
You said,
Hey, when is renting wasting money?
I feel like renting has gotten a bad rap that people act like
if you rent your house, apartment, condo, whatever,
you're just throwing money away,
throwing money away,
throwing money away.
What you don't realize that a lot of time,
the reason that people rent isn't because they want to throw money away.
It's because they want to buy themselves flexibility.
Maybe they're in a situation just like you are Edwin,
where,
Oh man, I don't know that I can commit to this area for a long time.
I don't know that I'm going to be here for five to seven years.
And if that's the case,
all I have to commit to when I rent is the term of that lease.
So if it's a 12 month lease,
I'm just committing to be here for 12 months.
Then I have flexibility to go somewhere else,
do something else just because other people tell you,
Oh, you have to buy a home.
You have to establish roots.
You have to go get a mortgage.
You have to own your property.
Doesn't mean that that's necessarily true for you.
It doesn't mean that it has to be true for you right now in this moment.
Now, Edwin might be an interesting situation because this is what he said.
He said,
you know,
renting is actually just as expensive as owning.
So it's not like I'm saving money per se in rent.
So how should Edwin go about thinking what the right decision for him?
Well, that's what these things intersect in several ways.
I had written down a few quick notes.
First of all,
shelter is not a waste.
Because you got to lay your head down somewhere at night.
I do think rent,
don't overlook the premium that's provided with renting versus owning.
And the fact that you get flexibility,
meaning if you got a better opportunity comes up somewhere else,
guess what?
You get to leave without a lot of trouble.
You also don't have to come up with the capital required to do a down payment.
So those are premiums that you get from renting versus owning.
Now you miss out on potential appreciation as housing goes up.
But I wouldn't even panic about that right now as much
because we just came through a huge run up in values.
You know,
if you think about what happened from 2020 to 2024 on housing values,
they've really accelerated how much the rate of return in that short period of time.
So probably going to take a little bit of a breather
if I had to guess in a lot of markets.
But here's the getting to the Bose question.
I'm going to bring back an oldie but goodie that I haven't talked about in a long time.
It doesn't matter if I go to a theme park,
if I go to a restaurant,
I always ask myself,
what's the cost to fund ratio?
I mean, I haven't talked about that.
Anybody who's been listening since 2006,
you'll be like,
oh my God, I haven't heard him talk about cost to fund.
But I run these mental math numbers in my head saying,
and what I mean by this,
if you're saying what is Brian talking about when he says cost to fund ratio,
is what's the value received for the price paid for something.
Now you have to ask yourself
because you're starting to have these little nudges internally.
If you live in a high cost of living area
and you're not getting a premium or a return or value from that,
and what I mean by that is if you live like,
say San Francisco.
San Francisco has always historically been very expensive,
but I've had a lot of friends that lived in San Francisco
and they worked in technology.
And the reason they did that is because they knew
if they lived there for three to five years,
got the right opportunity with the right tech company,
they could write their ticket for the future
because now that they'd have a premium or a pedigree
that would work for years to come
as they moved around somewhere else in the country,
that opportunity, that foot in the door moment was worth it
to essentially live in this high cost of living area.
Now if you're living in San Francisco
and you're not getting those type of opportunities,
all you're doing is just paying the high price,
but your job and your opportunities for the future
don't reflect that, then yeah, you have to ask yourself,
what's the cost to fund ratio here?
I'm paying a heck of a premium,
but I'm not getting the value.
There's a disconnect for the price paid
versus the value received.
You challenge yourself on that.
Make sure you don't think about this
from just the moment you're in.
I feel like way too many people focus
on just the moment right now.
What are you setting yourself up for five years,
seven years down the road?
And if you can't come up with a definitive answer on that,
then yeah, maybe you don't need to be living
in that high cost of living area and you need to adapt.
Because really, you guys have heard us talk about this.
Money is simple in some basic forms,
meaning that if you can't find margin in your life
to afford your life,
there's really only two options.
You either make more income or you cut expenses.
It's that simple.
I hate to bring it down
because there's a lot of nuances and facets
that come into that,
but that's going to help you
bring down a complex situation to the simple elements.
Am I getting the cost of fund ratio
for paying this high cost?