Understanding Why High-ranking CCP Military Officials Are Frequently Purged | China Truths

China Truths
61 followers
Welcome to China Truths. In this episode, we will bring you the following stories:
Zhang Youxia Leads Military Purge: Fourth Plenary Session Showdown
Understanding Why High-ranking CCP Military Officials Are Frequently Purged
Now, let’s dive into the details
00:00 - Introduction
00:23 - Zhang Youxia Leads Military Purge: Fourth Plenary Session Showdown
04:20 - Understanding Why High-ranking CCP Military Officials Are Frequently Purged
#china #chinatruths #chinanews
Welcome to China Truths. In this episode, we will bring you the following stories.
Zhang Youxia Leads Military Purge, 4th Plenary Session Showdown
Understanding Why High-Ranking CCP Military Officials Are Frequently Purged
Now, let's dive into the details. It's all covered in today's China Truths.
Zhang Youxia Leads Military Purge, 4th Plenary Session Showdown
Power struggles within the CCP are often most intense when involving the military.
On Nov. 28, China's Ministry of Defense announced that Miao Hua, a member of the
CCP Central Military Commission, CMC, and director of the Political Work Department,
is under investigation for serious violations of discipline. Reliable sources also report
that Wang Chunning, commander of the People's Armed Police Force, PAP, has been detained.
Military experts believe Zhang Youxia is behind the purge,
targeting key allies of Chinese leader Xi Jinping to undermine his military control,
rebuild the CMC, and potentially force Xi to step down during the CCP's 24th plenary session.
Independent producer Li Jun stated that Miao Hua has been detained by the CMC's Discipline
Inspection Commission. Additional reliable reports suggest that Wang Chunning has also
been arrested. If true, this signals that Xi Jinping may have lost his grip on military power.
Miao Hua, a native of Fuzhou, served in Xi's close ally unit, the 31st Army, for 30-40 years
before moving to the Navy, making him one of Xi's most loyal supporters. Defense Minister Dong Jun,
with a naval background, is reportedly connected to Miao Hua, who may have recommended him.
The situation surrounding Wang Chunning is also unusual.
During a nationwide police videoconference on Nov. 21, PAP political commissar Zhang Hongbin
sat to the left of public security minister Wang Xiaohong, a position traditionally occupied by
Wang Chunning. Wang Chunning, as commander of the 12th Army, worked with Miao Hua,
who was then the political commissar. During Xi Jinping's tenure as Zhejiang
Provincial Party secretary, Wang served in the 1st Group Army under the Nanjing Military Region,
developing ties with Xi. After significant promotions, including commander of the Beijing
Garrison District and later PAP commander, Wang became a key figure in Xi's inner circle.
Former PLA Navy Lieutenant Commander Yao Cheng revealed that Miao Hua's role as CMC member was
critical, overseeing personnel across all military branches. However, Xi's promotion of a deputy
political work chief effectively sidelined Miao, signaling an impending downfall.
Yao emphasized that Zhang Youxia's purge aims to neutralize Xi's military proxies,
particularly those from the 31st Army, which includes loyalists like Miao Hua and Wang Chunning.
This maneuver is seen as essential for resolving the issue of Xi's military control.
Veteran journalist Guo Jun explained that PAP reforms initiated in 2017 gave command authority
to the CMC, severing ties with the Political and Legal Affairs Commission. This restructuring
turned the PAP into a military force, potentially for urban combat and Taiwan unification scenarios.
However, internal discord and deteriorating domestic security have raised doubts about
China's capacity to execute external campaigns, let alone unification efforts.
With the CMC paralyzed and purges targeting Xi's allies,
insiders believe the Fourth Plenary Session could force Xi into a ceremonial role,
retaining the title of state president but removing him from real power.
This would allow a restructured CMC to regain functionality and address dissatisfaction
within the military. The military power struggle reflects deeper systemic issues within the CCP.
Zhang Youxia's actions, though driven by self-preservation and aligning with discontented
military officers, could lead to dramatic political shifts. Regardless of CCP dynamics,
peace and stability remain crucial for China and the region.
Understanding Why High-Ranking CCP Military Officials Are Frequently Purged
Over the past two years, the CCP has quietly launched its largest purge of
senior military leaders in recent years, removing at least 16 top-level military officials.
Among them, former Defense Minister Li Shangfu is one of the highest-ranking military leaders
to be dismissed since 2017. The purges have mainly targeted the rocket force and equipment
departments, but the Navy has also come under scrutiny. At least five of the dismissed officials
were associated with the rocket force, which was reorganized by Xi Jinping in 2015, and at least
two were from the equipment department responsible for the armed forces' procurement and armament.
The latest development came on Thursday, November 28, with the announcement that Miao Hua,
a Central Military Commission, CMC, member and head of its political work department,
is under investigation. On Wednesday, the Financial Times reported that Admiral Dong Jun,
the Minister of Defense, is also being investigated, though Chinese authorities have
denied this. Why is the CCP purging its top military leaders? What is Xi Jinping's relationship
with the military, and what is the extent of corruption within the ranks? Unlike other
administrative departments of the CCP, the military does not disclose corruption investigations,
making it challenging to gauge the scale of the purges. However, announcements of dismissals
provide some clues. In June, Li Shangfu and another former Defense Minister, Wei Fenghe,
were expelled from the party for corruption. Both were accused of bribery and polluting the
political environment in the military's equipment procurement sector. The role of Defense Minister
is primarily administrative, focused on military diplomacy with other nations, rather than
commanding armed forces directly. The CMC's Anti-Corruption Task Force handles corruption
investigations in the military and reports directly to the CMC, which is chaired by Xi Jinping.
Besides Xi, two vice chairpersons and three other members manage military operations,
political work, and discipline within the commission. According to the Asia Society
Policy Institute, this small group forms the core of the CCP's military strategy and oversight.
The CMC controls the armed forces, including strategic planning, auditing, and political
education, acting as a party institution that directly commands the military. Investigations
into top officials are opaque, with only broad accusations announced after they conclude.
For example, the charges against the two former Defense Ministers were termed
serious violations of discipline and law, a common CCP euphemism for corruption.
Observers often rely on sub-language shifts in official announcements to infer the severity
and specifics of accusations. Due to CCP efforts to avoid damaging its image or disclosing
vulnerabilities, much of what is known about military purges comes from foreign intelligence
sources and independent Chinese whistleblowers. Earlier this month, former Navy Lt. Col. Yao Cheng
and commentator Kai Shinkoen alleged on social media that Miao Hua was under investigation.
Kai also speculated that many senior officers promoted by Miao, including Admiral Dong Jun,
might be implicated, signaling another wave of purges. Corruption has raised questions about
the military's combat effectiveness and the return on its massive investments in weapons.
From aircraft carriers to hypersonic missiles, converting these assets into operational
capabilities remains an issue, compounded by scandalous revelations about the military's state.
Bloomberg reported severe corruption in the rocket force and China's broader defense industry,
citing U.S. officials who believe that such issues may deter Xi from launching
major military actions in the near future. Examples of corruption include diluted missile
fuel and defective missile silo covers in the western regions. During his first term as CCP
general secretary, Xi Jinping became known for his anti-corruption campaign, which toppled
political rivals and disciplined thousands of party officials. However, even after over a
decade of these campaigns, systemic corruption remains entrenched, as kickbacks and bribery
have been standard practices in the military for decades. Lyle Morris, a researcher at the Asia
Society Policy Institute, noted that the extensive leadership reshuffle within the PLA
and state-owned military enterprises indicates deep-seated anxiety and distrust between Xi
and the military. Corruption in the PLA is not just about a few bad apples.
It is, to a large extent, how the PLA has conducted business, Morris wrote.
Even with Xi's centralized authority, eradicating entrenched factions remains a challenge,
he said.
