Chinese authorities are now cracking down on the out-of-school tutoring industry. A document officially released by Chinese officials on July 24 was titled: "Opinions on Further Reducing the Burden of Assignment and Off-Campus Training on Students in Compulsory Education".
The document requires that no more permits will be issued for subject-based out-of-school training institutions at the compulsory education level across China, i.e. primary and junior high schools; existing training institutions will be registered as non-profit institutions, and online training institutions will have to be approved to operate. Hours of operation for off-campus training institutions are also tightly controlled. The document strictly prohibits training institutions from operating classes on China's national holidays, rest days and winter and summer vacations.
Covering a wide range of stories about or related China and its role in the world.
Have questions? Do you have something to share with us about China? We want to hear from you! Email: [email protected] Facebook www.facebook.com/EyesOnChina.
Copyright @ China Insights 2021. Any illegal reproduction of this content in any form will result in immediate action against the person(s) concerned. Your support allows us to produce more high-quality videos. Consider donating at https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/ChinaInsights
This is not a crackdown on illegal criminal sites, but a classroom where students are studying on weekends.
What is going on here?
Chinese authorities are now cracking down on the out-of-school tutoring industry.
A document officially released by Chinese officials on July 24 was titled
Opinions on Further Reducing the Burden of Assignment and Off-Campus Training on Students in Compulsory Education.
The document requires that no more permits will be issued for subject-based out-of-school training institutions
at the compulsory education level across China, i.e., primary and junior high schools.
Existing training institutions will be registered as non-profit institutions
and online training institutions will have to be approved to operate.
Hours of operation for off-campus training institutions are also tightly controlled.
The document strictly prohibits training institutions from operating classes on China's national holidays, rest days, and winter and summer vacations.
This policy is referred to as the Double Reduction Policy.
This new policy prohibits subject training institutions from going public and raising funds.
Capitalization is strictly forbidden.
So are the hiring of foreign personnel outside of China to conduct training activities.
As a result of the Double Reduction Policy, US-listed Chinese education stocks have taken a crashing plunge.
What is the purpose of the CCP's so-called consolidation of the education sector?
Let's first look at the background of the education sector in China.
In the late 1970s and early 1980s, China reinstated the College Entrance Examination,
a strict household registration system exists in China,
which means there is a huge difference in access to social resources by rural and urban people.
The College Entrance Exams offer a relatively fair path for Chinese people to cross class lines.
Because of the scarcity of similar paths, students were extremely competitive in the exams.
Until the 1990s, school in China largely offered unpaid remedial classes.
But during the 23 years of de facto power of the former Communist Party leader Jiang Zemin,
China's education system changed.
Jiang Zemin pushed Chinese bureaucrats and businessmen at all levels to make a lot of money out of nothing
and created various corrupt ways for them to do so.
In June 1996, the Communist Party proposed a reform of the education system, or industrialization of education,
in which the products of education would be commercialized, marketed, and made for profit.
And in 1998, Jiang's mistress Chen Juli became China's minister of education.
Since then, the industrialization of education has proliferated,
with schools and teachers in China making money under various guises
and tuition fees going through the roof.
Even teachers in Chinese public schools no longer teach properly in class,
but put all their energy into compensated tutoring classes,
deliberately not teaching the key points in class but putting them in the tutorials.
Such practice has been widely known.
The purpose of the tutors is simply to make money.
A popular saying among Chinese parents is
don't let your child lose at the starting line
in order to prepare for the competitive college entrance exams that follow.
According to the latest data from the China Education Association,
more than 75% of K-12 students attended extracurricular tutoring classes in 2016,
and there is evidence that this percentage has been rising.
Since 2003, primary and secondary education in China
has become the second most profitable industry in China after real estate.
2020 saw hundreds of billions of RMB in financing for the education sector.
The double reduction policy, which Chinese authorities introduced in July,
is aimed at reducing the burden on students.
It also reveals that Xi Jinping's administration
wants to dilute the social injustice in education
to quell public discontent caused by the extreme disparity
between the rich and the poor in Chinese society
and thus stabilize the rule of the Communist Party.
However, analysts believe that the current college entrance examination system in China
has not changed,
which means that the injustice and imbalance of educational resources has not changed.
Social classes have been solidified,
and the privileges of the classes have not changed.
Some superficial reforms will not solve China's education problems at this stage.
In addition, China is facing a serious demographic crisis.
In June 2021, China introduced a policy to encourage the birth of three children.
The double reduction policy also aims to encourage childbirth
by reducing the financial burden of raising children,
including the cost of education for Chinese families.
But some Chinese parents say the ban will only increase the financial burden on parents
and worsen inequality.
One parent told Reuters,
I'm surrounded by parents who are actively looking for more one-on-one tutoring
and it doesn't feel like a sudden halt to the tutoring boom.
It's live as usual.
So she won't consider having children again.
She made an analogy.
It's like watching a movie in a theater
and the people in the first row are all standing up
and if you don't stand up, you can't see the movie.
So you have to stand up.
In fact, the Chinese Communist administration
saw the huge benefits of private extracurricular education services long ago.
The double reduction policy now being implemented
is likely to provide a legitimate name for public schools
to share in the profits of previously private schools
and will likely create a new public monopoly.
In the past three months,
at least 13 for-profit elementary schools,
middle schools and one high school
have been taken over by various government agencies
without compensation.
The owners of the schools that have been forced to turn over their schools
say they have no choice.
The number of private elementary schools
has increased tenfold in the past 20 years in mainland China
with an estimated 9.5 million students enrolled in 2019.
According to sources,
private schools are generally better managed than public schools
because they rely on good performance to attract students.
It is expected that more private schools
will be taken over by the government in the future.
Private education in China
focuses more on market demand
and less about controlling the political thinking of students.
This means that private education
has a certain degree of influence
on children's worldview and understanding of the world.
Xie Tian, a professor at the University of South Carolina Aiken School of Business,
said,
Private schools and tutoring services,
including the content they teach,
is something that the CCP does not have strict control over.
Students are able to learn things
that they cannot learn in public schools.
They are not tolerated by the CCP
and now it is tightening up its control,
blocking all of these channels
that could spread the truth about freedom.
If you look at the double reduction policy
in the larger context,
you can see the CCP's intentions better.
In the last six months,
the CCP has taken a series of regulatory actions
in the economic sector,
from internet companies
to the medical beauty industry and infant formula.
Many industries in China are worried,
wondering if the industry they operate in
will be the target of the next crackdown.
U.S.-based scholar Cheng Xiaonong,
who warned the director of the Comprehensive Research Office
of the China Institute for Economic System Reform,
analyzed the industries that have been hit during this period,
and the common denominator
is that they are classified as service industries.
China's out-of-school training industry
not only absorbs the financial resources
of many urban families,
but also occupies the resources of a young workforce.
The Meituan Group,
which operates a food delivery business,
employs 10 million young people in takeout.
When combined with other service industries,
these service industries together
account for a significant amount of the young labor force.
Xi Jinping's administration should see
that the U.S. and China have entered an era
of long-term confrontation.
China needs to maintain its manufacturing sector
in order to break away from its dependence
on the U.S. market to a certain extent,
so that it can persevere in the fight.
Therefore, there is no concern
that the recent regulatory storm
by the Chinese communist authorities
will hit U.S. investors hard.
There is now little interest among young Chinese
in manufacturing jobs.
While huge numbers of Chinese college graduates
are unable to find jobs,
China's manufacturing industry is short of labor.
For example, manufacturing factories
in China's Pearl River Delta
and Yangtze River Delta
are having an increasingly difficult time
finding young workers.
For this analysis,
you can check out our video on June 16.
In all likelihood,
the CCP's economic overhaul
is an attempt to change the propensity
of the younger generation to work,
hoping to squeeze jobs in food delivery,
out-of-school tutoring,
and other service industries,
forcing China's youth
into manufacturing factories.
China's manufacturing sector
is facing triple pressure
from rapidly rising wage costs,
material costs,
and export costs,
making survival increasingly difficult.
This approach helps China's manufacturing factories
to reduce wage costs
and keep China's manufacturing industry alive.
It appears that the CCP
has introduced a double reduction policy
that satisfies multiple objectives.
Can the medicine
concocted within the Communist Party system
cure the diseases that arise from this system?
People who cling to the Communist system
and ideology
seem reluctant to think about this.