Is School Slowly Destroying Your Brain?

EDUCATION AROUND THE WORLD
32 followers
Comments are disabled for this video.
This episode is sponsored by KiwiCo.
Dear school, today I want to talk about something that on the surface may seem trivial,
but it's actually a huge deal, and that is school start times.
Because when I tell you that you might not only be severely impacting your students' mental capacity and intelligence,
both in the moment and the future, but also impacting their physical and mental health, I'm not exaggerating.
Let me put it bluntly, school needs to start later, at least for high school and university age students.
And I don't mean later as in later in the year, I mean later as in not so freaking early in the morning.
But to understand why, we first have to understand sleep.
Before a baby is even born, and up to around the first year of its life, infants spend much of their time in REM sleep,
otherwise known as rapid eye movement.
This is a stage we dream in, and it's during this REM sleep that babies are building up huge amounts of neural networks and connections in their brain.
But soon after this time period, there's a sharp decline in REM sleep and an exponential rise in deep non-REM sleep that continues to rise until around puberty.
And this non-REM sleep is actually responsible for fine-tuning our brains.
Instead of building up more and more neurons and connections, it actually prunes and makes the brain more efficient and effective.
It's basically taking the mold that early life created and sculpting it based on your life experiences and interactions.
And studies have shown that this non-REM sleep is linked to the development of critical thinking, reasoning, and cognitive skills.
Now, some of you might be screaming,
REASONING SKILLS? CRITICAL THINKING? IN TEENS?
And you'd be right in noticing that teens aren't exactly known for these things.
But ironically, the development of the brain during this non-REM increase happens from back to front.
Literally, the back of the brain, which manages visual and spatial perception, develops first,
and this growth eventually makes its way to the front of the brain or the frontal lobe last,
which finally enables critical and rational thought.
This is why it sometimes feels that kids' brains aren't exactly working or keeping up with the rest of their development.
The thing is, when non-REM is minimized or removed, things can go really wrong.
In studies of mice and cats deprived of sleep, the brain development is stopped.
In fact, many psychiatric disorders like schizophrenia, bipolar, and major depression are considered disorders of abnormal development.
Studies on schizophrenia in particular have shown that there is a two- to three-fold reduction in non-REM sleep in teenagers that suffer from it.
To top it all off, teens actually need more sleep than their adult counterparts.
So if they're not getting enough hours of sleep, then they aren't going to be getting the optimal amount of non-REM sleep, which can hamper development.
Now, I know what you're asking, how does this correlate to the time that schools start?
Can't teens just go to bed early like the rest of us and get a long enough sleep?
And if not, what time should school be starting at?
Before we get to that answer, I want to quickly thank today's sponsor, KiwiCo.
No word of a lie, KiwiCo is one of our favorite companies defining the future of play and learning at home.
Every month, they release a crate that's designed by experts and tested by kids that teaches about science, technology, engineering, art, and math through hands-on learning.
They're truly awesome to experience, even as an adult, because they make crates for all different ages through eight different subscription lines.
I, of course, love the Maker Crate, which is designed for ages 14 to 104+, but all of them are amazing and I've had a great time playing with so many of them with my niece and nephew.
Each box comes with all the supplies you'll need for that month's unique project, so there's no need to run out to the store or get extra supplies.
It's a blast every single time. Get it? A blast?
Use KiwiCo.com to get your first month free, which also helps our show.
I mean, bam! What more can you ask for? Learning and supporting science creators.
Again, that's KiwiCo.com for your first month free.
Now, back to some sleepy science.
So why does the specific time matter so much? Isn't it more relevant how much sleep kids are getting?
Yes and no.
The first thing you need to know is that as kids move into puberty, their circadian rhythm completely shifts.
Our circadian rhythm is the name given to our internal clock that controls your body's sleep-wake cycle.
In other words, it helps define when you feel tired and want to sleep versus when you feel at your most alert.
This rhythm is, of course, different for everyone.
We all have our unique chronotype, which is why some people are considered early birds and others are night owls.
But in general, adults share a propensity to wake and sleep at roughly the same time.
The thing is, one of the biggest factors defining our circadian rhythm is our age.
Young kids before puberty not only need the most sleep, but tend to have a really early schedule.
They become sleepy early in the evening and wake up earlier than adults, typically.
But as we hit puberty, the timing is shifted forward, past even their parents by as much as two to four hours,
meaning we want to stay up much later.
And this change is seen across all adolescents, regardless of culture or geography.
Where a nine-year-old will typically fall asleep around 9 p.m.,
by the age of 16, that's actually off in the hour of peak wakefulness.
Asking a teenager to go to bed at 10 p.m. is like asking an adult to go to sleep at 7 p.m.
In the same vein, waking up at 7 a.m. for a teen is the same as waking up around 4 a.m. for an adult.
And I'm pretty sure all of us don't want to be seen at 4 a.m., let alone have to use our brains at 4 a.m.
A lot of parents believe that teens are making a conscious decision to stay up later
and that if they just went to bed earlier, they wouldn't be so tired.
But the truth is, even if they do go to bed earlier,
chances are they'll just be lying in bed awake until their body naturally winds down.
But not embracing this biological timing, on top of the fact that teens need more sleep to begin with,
risks developmental brain abnormalities and mental illness, and we have experimental evidence to show it.
Later start times increase class attendance, reduce behavioral and psychological problems,
and decrease substance and alcohol abuse.
Longer sleep is directly correlated to better grades in teens across the board and higher IQs.
And studies on identical twins show that by the age of 10,
the twin with the longer sleep pattern has superior intellectual abilities
with more expansive vocabulary too.
And schools that have tested later start times have seen a huge shift.
A school in Minnesota that changed from a 7.25 a.m. start to 8.30 a.m.
while math SAT scores went up by over 50.
And while we've talked about the importance of non-REM quality sleep in young adults,
that's not to say REM sleep isn't also really important.
Studies in the 1960s that deprived young adults of REM
found that by the third day of extreme deprivation,
participants started to exhibit signs of psychosis.
They were anxious, moody, and started to hallucinate and became paranoid.
REM also becomes longer and more prominent in the later parts of your sleep,
meaning if you cut your sleep short,
you're disproportionately impacting the amount of REM you're getting.
Life expectancy has also been shown to increase with later start times.
So the number one cause of death in teens is road traffic accidents,
which have been linked directly to sleep deprivation.
When one county in Wyoming changed their start time from 7.25 a.m. to 8.55 a.m.,
they saw a 70% decrease in traffic accidents in the affected age group.
So why do circadian rhythms stray so far in adolescents?
The prevailing socio-evolutionary theory right now is that it allows
teens and young adults to start gaining their independence from their parents,
but in small increments.
For several hours a day, kids can operate on their own
or with their peer group away from adults,
but it's not a full removal from parental supervision.
During this stage, they get to practice becoming their own individual.
The truth is, only a century ago in America,
most schools started around 9 a.m. and 95% of students woke up without an alarm.
Now in the U.S., 80% of schools begin before 8.15 a.m.
and 50% of those start before 7.20 a.m.
Not to mention the increasing impact of TVs, computers, and phones in the bedroom.
It's no wonder kids are more tired than ever.
At the end of the day, the evidence is overwhelming
that later start times around 9 a.m. or so are not only preferred by students,
but lead to improvements in basically every single metric
we're measuring their progress by in school.
In the words of Dr. Walker, who wrote the book Why We Sleep,
which was the primary source for this episode,
we're too often focused on what sleep is taking away from our teenagers
without stopping to think about what it may be adding.
I hope we can change.
I hope we can break the parent-to-child transmission of sleep neglect
and remove what the exhausted, fatigued brains of our youth are so painfully starved of.
When sleep is abundant, minds flourish.
When it's deficient, they don't.
I hope this video has been informative and useful,
especially if you are a parent or a teacher or someone who manages a school.
And if you're a student, send this to your teachers right now.
Send this to your administrators and let them know.
It's not a joke.
Sleep is a huge part of our lives
and so important for our intellectual capacities and our physical health.
And they would do well to think about that when they start your school.
Thanks again for watching.
Make sure you like the video.
Subscribe if you want more.
And we'll see you next time for some more science.
Peace.
