2024's Biggest Breakthroughs in Physics

Universe Unveiled
2 followers
Dark energy is one of the biggest mysteries in physics. It dominates the universe,
making up 68% of its contents and pushing matter apart with its repulsive force.
We often say dark energy because cosmologists are kind of in the dark. We really don't know
what it is. About a hundred years ago, Einstein added a variable to his equations of general
relativity to represent the energy infused in space itself. He called it lambda, or the
In 1998, teams led by Adam Ries, Saul Perlmutter, and Brian Schmidt confirmed the presence of dark
energy, winning them a Nobel Prize in 2011. The discovery matched Einstein's hypothesis
about an accelerating universe and a cosmological constant. But in April 2024,
data from a new telescope instrument produced the biggest map of the cosmos yet.
The results throw the cosmological constant into question,
suggesting that dark energy might be changing.
That would not be what a cosmological constant would have been predicting.
This opens the floodgates for new theories. To understand what the cosmological constant
is, we have to sort of start at the beginning, which is the Big Bang. There's this initial
kick of energy, and the universe starts expanding outwards. The dominant force is,
generally speaking, gravity. We would expect that because it's filled with matter and dark
matter, the universe would eventually slow down because of this attractive force due to gravity.
But not only is it not slowing down, it's accelerating. That's akin to me on Earth
throwing up a tennis ball, expecting it to come back down due to gravity, and it doesn't. It
keeps going up, and it's accelerating upwards. The simplest explanation for this acceleration
is Einstein's cosmological constant, an unchanging dark energy that permeates empty space.
The universe is expanding. We're essentially getting more and more
empty space between galaxies, and consequently more and more dark energy.
This hypothesis is the basis of Lambda CDM, cosmologists' current model of the universe.
Physicists and cosmologists are between a rock and a hard place.
Ninety-five percent of the energy and matter in that model we cannot fully explain.
There are many physicists who would be very eager to see deviations from the predictions made by
that model, which would indicate some new kind of physics that could lead us to insights about
dark energy and dark matter. In 2021, the dark energy spectroscopic
instrument, known as DESI, kicked off a five-year effort to measure the positions
and velocities of 40 million galaxies. The goal of DESI is to build the largest
3D map of the universe that we've ever achieved. If you want to measure and understand dark energy,
you want to look at the universe at its largest size. DESI has 5,000 optical fibers that allows
the instrument to collect 5,000 galaxies at a time.
As DESI's fibers collect light from galaxies, a spectrograph splits the light into its individual
wavelengths. This reveals how quickly a galaxy is moving away from Earth, which the researchers
use to infer its distance. But to measure the expansion rate of the universe, DESI scientists
turn to baryon acoustic oscillations, or BAOs, the leftover imprints of pressure waves from the
Big Bang. Each of these unique features is imprinted on the universe like a ripple frozen
onto a pond. And the only thing that changes its size is the expansion of the universe.
So with DESI, by measuring this 3D map of the universe over time, we can actually see how BAO
has evolved over time, and therefore the impact of dark energy on that expansion.
In April 2024, an international collaboration of more than 500 scientists published a rigorous
analysis of the data from DESI's first year of observations. The results revealed something
startling. If dark energy were the cosmological constant, galaxies would appear to be accelerating
apart at an unchanging rate. But DESI showed that in the universe's most recent history,
many galaxies appeared closer together than expected,
suggesting that dark energy is weakening over time.
This is not at all what we were thinking that we would be obtaining with this first year result. So
that was an amazing surprise. The DESI data reveals the expansion rate of the universe
by measuring the size of the BAO feature as a function of time. If dark energy is the cosmological
constant, the rate should hold steady at a value of one. That's where we started to see
hints of a possible deviation from lambda Cdm. To claim a discovery, physicists must prove a 5
sigma level of confidence, about a one in a million probability that the findings are a result
of random chance. When the DESI scientists pooled their data with other sets of astronomical
observations, they achieved a probability of 3.5 sigma, about a one in 300 chance that it's a
statistical fluke. We're not there yet. There's a serious hint and that's why we're so excited
about it and we want to continue taking data. If we confirm that dark energy is varying with time,
then it just is not compatible with lambda Cdm. If some theorist comes along and can explain
the observations, this is a Nobel Prize. It's a very tall task, but perhaps someone out there
is up to it. Imagine a phase of matter that's at once a solid and a liquid. Like a solid, it has a
rigid spatially ordered structure, but it flows like a superfluid, entirely without friction.
This is a super solid. Since the 1950s, condensed matter physicists have debated whether this exotic
phase of matter exists. But this year, scientists at the University of Innsbruck in Austria created
a super solid in the lab for the first time. A super solid state of matter is one of these
unique situations in which you can really see directly the impact of quantum mechanics
on measurable properties of a system. The results may help explain how matter behaves in some of the
most extreme conditions in the universe. In 1937, scientists cooled liquid helium-4 to just above
absolute zero. They observed a new phase of matter, the superfluid, which flows like a fluid
with zero viscosity. Here you see the liquid passing into the superfluid phase. In 1949,
the future Nobel laureate Lars Onsager predicted that this frictionless behavior could be partly
explained by a bizarre phenomenon, the formation of vortices, or microscopic quantum tornadoes.
That's really the fingerprint, I would say even the hallmark of superfluidity. So there's a very
simple picture to understand this. Imagine that you have a bucket. If you put a superfluid inside
this bucket, if you rotate the bucket very slow, the superfluid would just stay at rest. It would
not move at all. Then you exceed a critical velocity, and then the system has to respond
in some way. The rotation frequency is so large that the fluid inside cannot ignore anymore that
something is happening. There is all this angular momentum that we are imposing. So instead of
globally rotating, the superfluid creates a number of very small tornadoes. These quantum
tornadoes were also predicted to exist in the supersolid, an exotic phase of matter with both
superfluid properties and a rigid solid structure. You need to detect the two natures of the system.
So you need to detect the solid part and the superfluid part. We knew very well the importance
of observing vortices. To create these vortices, you need to put your system under rotation, but
our supersolid state is quite fragile. And so we needed to find a good way to rotate the system
without destroying it. The Innsbruck team harnessed the magnetic properties of dysprosium atoms to
steer their system. Using lasers, we cooled these atoms down to very close to the absolute zero.
You can trap these atoms and you have that the system behave as a whole single quantum wave.
The team steered the atom's internal magnetic field about 50 times a second, fast enough to
generate vortices while preserving the delicate quantum phase. And we saw the presence of these
little holes. These are the vortices. For the first time, they observed the dual nature of a supersolid.
It was producing exactly the same images as a simulation. They were really able to observe it
and this was a big result. In the long term, studying the dynamics of supersolids could help
us understand mysterious quantum behaviors like superconductivity. But the Innsbruck team already
discovered a surprising link to astrophysics. We recently found a possible application of the
rotating supersolids in nature for a system that is actually very far away from us, which is a
neutron star. The inner crust of this neutron star is predicted to be a modulated superfluid. This is
exactly what we usually call a supersolid state. Some astrophysicists now suspect that a neutron
star's supersolid interior may explain a strange phenomenon known as a glitch, where the star
briefly changes its rotation speed. Sometimes they spin up for a very short moment and then they slow
down. And so one theory says that the vortex, which are created in the supersolids, at some point
during the slowing down of the star, start to escape and they crash into the wall of the star,
transferring angular momentum and making the star spin up. Of course we cannot have access to neutron
stars because they are too far away, but we can have access to rotating supersolids in a lab with
vortices inside of it. We had no idea that we could make this connection and that's the beauty to
science and exchange of ideas and going and speaking with people very far away from
your domain of investigation. It's a very nice project. I'm very excited.
This is the Amplituhedron. Hidden within its geometry is the answer to one of the
most fundamental questions in physics. What happens when particles collide?
In the decades since the discovery of the Amplituhedron, physicists have looked for
other shapes that predict the outcomes of particle interactions. This year, physicists led
by Carolina Figueredo and Nima Arkani-Hamed had a breakthrough linking geometry with real-world
physics. Particle interactions are difficult to predict. Because quantum physics forbids
these events from being observed directly, physicists can learn only the initial conditions
and the outcome. You have a bunch of particles coming in and a bunch of particles coming out
and you don't know what happened in the middle. But the way we have to compute what happens is to
pretend that we're actually kind of following the path of the particles. That's what Feynman
diagrams are about. Physicists use Feynman diagrams to track what might happen in a collision using
lines to represent particle trajectories. A Feynman diagram is one such possibility but because of
quantum mechanics, the final answer is given by the sum over all such possibilities. When you add
up terms for all possible Feynman diagrams, you get a number called the scattering amplitude,
the probability of a certain outcome. But that method has a big drawback. There can be many, many,
many, many pictures that contribute to a given process. The Feynman rules, while very correct,
make it computationally intractable to make predictions for experiments. But every single
time we work very hard to compute some prediction for some experiment, the prediction itself mocks
us by it's how simple it is. This famous prediction that got Feynman his Nobel Prize,
it's many pages of algebra and when all of the dust settles you find the number one.
There's been kind of an effort to try to reveal a certain simplicity that was hidden in the standard
way that you computed. We're trying to find different structures, different ideas that
land you on the answer kind of directly. Arkhani Hamed and his team discovered the
Amplituhedron while exploring a connection between Feynman diagrams and mathematical
objects called polygon triangulations. These triangulations of polygons is literally just
a set of edges that meet on a certain vertex, which is exactly what we use to describe
particle interactions. A Feynman diagram is basically a graph. The Amplituhedron was encoding
the information of all these kind of Feynman diagrams that were found for a particular theory.
The Amplituhedron was a shortcut. It's volume gave the sum of these Feynman diagrams,
the scattering amplitude for the particle interactions outcome.
I could entirely describe how to make predictions in this theory without ever referring to even a
particle, honestly. But there was a catch. It didn't work for real world particles.
Arkhani Hamed's team soon identified another shape, the Associahedron,
which encoded Feynman diagrams for a theory of different particles.
This is when Carolina Figueredo came across a striking coincidence.
Scattering amplitudes take the form of fractions. Physicists often focus on collisions where the
denominator becomes small, which represent likely outcomes for particle interactions.
But Figueredo began looking for situations where the numerator becomes small,
representing unlikely interactions. There was something sitting upstairs
that was encoding some extra information.
First, Figueredo used the Associahedron to look at collisions involving simple particles
known as colored scalars. She found that certain collisions flattened its volume to zero,
meaning that they represented collisions forbidden for these particles.
The amplitude is something which is related with the volume. And so from there,
it was easy to understand that if I found limits where this geometry collapsed,
like reduced in dimension, then the volume would go to zero. So the amplitude would also
have to vanish. Figueredo also looked at collisions
involving pions and gluons, two other real world particles. She found that all the theories shared
the same zeros, meaning that they outlawed exactly the same particle collisions.
What we observed is that for three different theories, a similar feature was there. Not
just similar, but like remarkably similar, like almost identical. This was very striking at the
time just because there was no obvious reason for these zeros to be located at precisely the
same spots. These hidden zeros revealed that the three different theories were described by the
same function, deriving from curves on geometric surfaces.
There's kind of a master object that encoded all the three different theories.
The reason why we understood that there were these zeros is precisely because we have the
formulation in terms of the geometry. This is the first time that amplitudes
for real world particles have been calculated in a geometric way. It builds on the dream of
the Amplituhedron, suggesting that the right shapes can lead to new and more efficient ways
of understanding the quantum world. The complexity of the computation,
it's highly reduced precisely because you're packaging everything in an extremely nice way.
You're exploiting all the structure. It's tremendously powerful to have not
just a machinery for generating scattering amplitudes,
but to have a geometric interpretation behind it. I'm very excited that there's an alternative.
