How Zero-Emission Mandates Are Impacting Transportation and Pollution in California | Eric Sauer

California Insider Show
1.9K followers
253 Video Views·Feb 21, 2025
California’s zero-emission truck mandate hit a major roadblock. High costs, infrastructure gaps, and legal challenges led the state to withdraw it. What does this mean for trucking, supply chains, and consumers? We sit down with Eric Sauer of the California Trucking Association to examine the impact and what’s next.
Views expressed in this video are the opinions of the host and guests and do not necessarily reflect the views of The California Insider.
California is dropping the zero emission mandate on trucks.
This mandate had created immense amount of pressure
for truckers in California.
My guest today is Eric Sauer,
who represents the California Trucking Association.
He's here to tell us how this regulation
impacted the trucking space in California
and what's gonna happen moving forward.
I'm Siamak Khorrami, welcome to California Insider.
Eric, it's great to have you on, welcome.
Thank you so much for having me.
Big fan of the show and look forward to the conversation.
There's some big changes in the trucking space
and there was big mandates from California
to have zero emission trucks.
They just dropped it a couple of weeks ago.
Can you tell us what happened?
Sure, absolutely.
But I kinda wanna tell the story
of the trucking industry leading up to it
and just explain to your viewers
the importance that the trucking industry plays
in California.
So one out of every 16 jobs in California
is trucking related.
And I think that equates to over 943,000 people
that are working in some profession
that is related to the trucking industry.
The industry also transports 80% of all
California communities rely solely on trucking
to receive and deliver their goods.
We also, when the public says,
oh, well they don't pay their fair share in road taxes
or beating up the roads,
the industry pays $4.6 billion a year annually
for state and local roads.
And federal taxes to help keep roads maintained and funded.
So which they also only represent 12%
of the vehicle miles traveled.
Safety, that's another issue with the public
probably doesn't know this,
but California has the only state trucking inspection
safety program of its kind.
It's called the Basic Inspection of Terminal Program.
It's administered by the CHP.
On top of that, we also are subject to federal rules.
So the industry has a lot of rules and regulations
that it has to comply with.
Now, when you move into the environmental front
and the rule that you're talking about,
leading up to that rule,
the industry has been subject to two other rules
that basically mandated the industry to upgrade their trucks
to more emission compliant motors.
So it started at the ports
with their Clean Air Action Plan program,
which was in 2008,
which basically set the baseline for trucks
that had to meet a certain model year emissions control
to be able to operate in the port.
So that was the first one.
Which made them cleaner, right?
Yes.
They were diesel, but they will be cleaner diesel.
Correct, they were model.
So as the engine model years got newer, they got cleaner.
They banned, you know, all pre 1989 trucks were banned.
And then there was a phase in that started in 2008.
That was the first regulation.
Because before these regulations,
the trucks that you would see, the big cab overs,
the conventional trucks.
You could see the smoke coming out, yeah.
That, and there was very limited,
if any, emission controls on those trucks.
So obviously the industry knew that it had to do something.
And so that led to these regulations
to clean up the air around the ports.
Following that, California Air Resources Board
adopted what they call the on-road truck and bus rule,
which mandated trucks to meet a certain model year
of emission compliant engines.
And that began in 2010.
So currently right now, all trucks are subject to,
they have to meet a certain standard
to be able to operate in California.
And that standard is,
you have to have a certain model year of truck.
Everybody has to have the same, you know,
or newer, a model year of truck.
And if you don't meet that compliance,
you can't register your truck.
So if you can't register your truck,
you're not able to operate.
California also has,
I believe it's the only state of its kind,
or the only program of its kind in the nation,
a smog check program.
So truckers are also subject to a smog check program.
And then also you see those refrigerated haulers
with the, on the trailers,
they have a refrigerated unit on the front of the trailer,
usually a 53 foot trailer.
California Air Resources Board has regulations
mandating or putting requirements
on newer transportation,
refrigerated units on those trailers.
So there's all these regulations that California truckers
are already subject to,
also out-of-state truckers as well.
Through those programs,
you've seen the industry make dramatic reductions.
So I think it's 98% emissions reductions
from those rules from the trucking industry.
That's fantastic.
Now, is it perfect?
Is there more work to be done?
Absolutely.
And the industry doesn't dispute that.
So 98% a year or 98% overall?
98% overall reduction.
From trucks previously, you're seeing a 98%.
So the new ones, they have 98% improvement.
Correct.
So they are cleaner burning diesel engines.
And so everybody has to have a newer model year
or they can't register and they can't operate in California.
There's more to be done.
And we, as an organization,
we knew that the next step was going to be
a zero emissions type of regulation.
And so the regulation that you referenced
in the introduction is what they call
the advanced clean fleets rule.
And that was a transition from diesel engines
to zero emission technology.
So going electric or going hydro?
Correct.
So any type of truck that is zero emission vehicle
would qualify, if it's approved,
would qualify under this regulation.
So the problem with this regulation
or the problem that was when it first came out,
there's no infrastructure to support it.
And the technology, it's not a knock on the technology.
The technology is getting better,
but it just doesn't work in the capacity
it needs to be working.
The infrastructure doesn't support it
and the technology needs a lot more improvement.
For example, the truck is,
the battery for a heavy duty truck, semi truck,
8,000 pounds.
So in California, you are only allowed to,
your gross vehicle weight is up to 80,000 pounds.
So you're already looking at 8,000 pounds reduction there,
which means a loss of payload capacity that you can haul,
which is ultimately going to lead to more trucks out there.
So the trucks are heavier.
Correct.
And then therefore they cannot have enough,
as much stuff on them.
Correct.
So they can't haul, they can't be over 80,000 pounds
or they're in violation
and they're subject to huge fines for being overweight.
So you have to have 10% more probably.
Correct.
Of trucks.
Yep.
Or more.
You have that.
The increased weight, there's been,
I know that there was an initial study
that was conducted about the impact of say,
federally it was allowed to go to 88,000 pounds.
In California, if you increase
the gross vehicle operating weight to 88,000 pounds
to accommodate the 8,000 pound battery,
that would have led to a restriction of,
I believe over 200 and not sure on the accurate number,
but it was around 220 or 230 local roads,
local bridges and state bridges.
So there'd be restrictions on those bridges
that would not allow for trucks to be able to utilize those.
So that just shrinks the network even more
for the industry to be able to deliver products and services.
So there's all these things that had to kind of get addressed
before the rule was even a reality.
And when the rule got adopted,
between the cost of the vehicle,
I mean, you compare the cost of a current diesel truck
on the market, you're looking at maybe 100, 140, 150,000,
a little bit more if it's custom or whatever,
compared to three to 400,000 for an electric truck.
So-
It's more than double.
Correct.
And it's a significant increase.
And these are costs that the trucking industry,
they can't absorb that.
So the way it works is after the on-road truck and bus rule,
you saw a lot of companies implementing
what they call a California surcharge with their customers,
which because of the costs that they had to spend
to be in compliance with that rule,
they had to pass along those additional costs
to their customer,
who then passes it along to us, the consumers.
And that, you know, in California, you see that for fuel.
California has this unique blend of fuel
and truckers are subject to purchasing that fuel.
It's more expensive.
So a lot of them have fuel surcharge.
And so they can't absorb,
most of these are companies that are just transporting
other people's property.
It's not even their products that they're transporting.
So they can't, they just can't absorb it.
So you look at the cost of that truck
and the industry trying to absorb that,
there's no chance,
there's no possibility that they'd be able to do that.
And then you look at the infrastructure,
just a sample study, drive up and down the freeways.
How many heavy duty charging stations do you see?
Probably not many because they're not,
there's not a lot of them out there.
And to an interesting data point that we utilized
was to meet the demand to charge all of these vehicles
under the rule.
California would have to have 300 DC fast chargers
in the ground every week until the regulation ended.
So 300 every week in the ground.
And I don't even know if we have 300 in the state already.
The cost to bring in energy, to be able to charge the fleet,
that would take, to charge the entire fleet,
I think it would take 40% of the electric grid
in California.
40% just to-
Just for the trucks?
Yes, just to charge the entire fleet
that's covered under the rule.
California struggles with its,
we had an energy crisis a few years ago,
which ironically, the day that we were,
Californians were told to not plug in their vehicles
to save the grid was the same day
that this proposal was released.
So me reading that and seeing that,
I was like, wow, that is the biggest advertisement
that this rule is just destined for failure.
We can't even charge cars.
How are we gonna be able to charge these trucks
which have bigger batteries,
which takes longer time to charge?
You're looking at substations that,
to bring more energy to more areas,
you would have to build substations.
That process takes seven to 10 years
and you're talking hundreds of millions of dollars
for each of those.
Our sponsor today is Shen Yun.
There's been some negative press on Shen Yun recently.
Shen Yun's mission is to revive ancient
and traditional Chinese culture.
Shen Yun performance started by a group
of Falun Gong practitioners in New York.
Falun Gong is a spiritual and religious group
which believes in living by truth,
compassion, and tolerance, putting others first.
The Chinese Communist Party, CCP,
has been persecuting it since July of 1999 in China.
Since Shen Yun started, CCP has been targeting it
in the U.S. and across the globe
by playing different kinds of schemes
to cancel the shows or impact the performance.
The current negative reporting originated
from some Chinese social media accounts.
And we know that CCP has given a new directive
to go after Shen Yun and Falun Gong in the U.S.
by turning the public opinion against them.
If you hear something negative on Shen Yun,
make sure to do your own research
and your own due diligence.
Despite all of CCP's campaigns against Shen Yun,
the show has managed to grow significantly across the world.
I highly recommend you go see it.
I've been going to it for the last 14 years
as they change the performances every year.
They're coming back to California.
Make sure you go see it.
Now, did they give the industry subsidies
for buying these trucks?
So on the on-road truck and bus rule
and the port rule that I talked about earlier,
there was a probably, I would say,
a more robust program for truckers to access funding.
To get new trucks.
To get new trucks to help offset
the cost of the new trucks.
This rule, it just wasn't as robust.
And you're talking about more expensive trucks.
So it wasn't, and then certain companies were not eligible.
So larger companies are not eligible to access that.
So it just wasn't, you need these subsidies to help out.
And the pot just wasn't as big as what was needed
to be able to comply with the rule
or even to be able to purchase these types of vehicles.
What did you guys think from the industry?
Did you think this is gonna come
and you have to comply with it?
Immediately following the on-road truck and bus rule,
if you read the tea leaves,
we understood that there was gonna be a zero emissions rule
that's gonna be coming down the road.
Did they tell you guys?
Well, we were in meetings.
We, you know, well, we knew that
that people wanted the industry to go.
We understood that.
The industry understands that.
But with this proposal,
we just didn't think that this was going to be the way.
Correct.
And so we've been updating,
we've done a really good job of keeping our members
in the know on the progress and this is coming.
And I would say for the last 10 years,
we have what we call policy committees,
which members are members of the policy committee
and they direct us on what our priorities
and, you know, the kind of the big issues.
So these are trucking companies?
Trucking companies, yes.
So our members are trucking company owners.
And we'd update them and we, you know,
we've been on top of it for the last, you know, 10 years.
And we started going down the path
of preparing a legal response, a litigation response.
And so once the rule was adopted in April of 23, 2023,
we were already kind of preparing our litigation
and we filed litigation in October.
And through that litigation,
we were able to secure what they call
like a withhold of enforcement,
because this leads into the withdrawal of the rule.
When states, you know, the feds set the kind of the bar
on rules and regulations for these types of rules.
And anything that is more strict,
that state has to get a waiver from the federal EPA.
So if they go more strict than the federal law,
then they have to get a waiver?
Correct.
And so they had to get a federal waiver to enforce the rule.
Now the first chip into the compliance game
of the advanced clean fleets rule was for the port haulers.
And that was supposed to be enforceable one, one of 24.
So January 1st, 2024,
if you had to replace a vehicle out of your fleet
in their drayage truck registry.
So if you submitted your truck fleet before one, one 24,
after one, one 24, any substitution,
like if your truck broke down, it was out of service,
you had to pull it out.
Any truck that you replace that with
had to be zero emission.
So the technology, like I mentioned before,
it's just the equipment is not there.
There's not a robust.
So can you tell us what is not there about the technology
from what you guys see?
Sure, so the range.
So right now you can drive state to state on,
if you're fully loaded in a diesel truck,
you can go top of the state down to the bottom of the state.
So you can go like almost a thousand miles, eight, 900.
Yeah, you can go extremely far with the charging
that is needed in the range or the range is,
I think at best you've heard 300 miles.
I don't even know if that's accurate,
but 300 miles, if you're doing long hauls,
that means you have to pull in, you have to charge
and the bigger the battery, the longer the charge
and the infrastructure to support charging the trucks.
It's not like a Tesla charging station
where a truck can just pull into those Tesla chargers
and plug it in.
It's completely different.
So those chargers won't work for the trucks?
They have to specifically have a certain type of charger
that works for the size of the battery,
the battery that's in the truck.
The longer the charge, the longer the truck sits idle.
And so trucks, if they're sitting idle,
they're a stranded asset.
So in certain, in some applications like parcel delivery,
that would work.
Short range, they make their deliveries,
they come back to home base.
And park at night.
Yep, call it a day, plug it in,
it's ready to go the next day.
Trucking companies, it doesn't work like that.
They're either doing long haul,
they're making multiple deliveries,
they can't just pull in and wait.
Plus you're also having drivers that are subject
to what they call hours of service, being on duty.
So if they're sitting there for hours,
they're still on the clock,
that's gonna decrease their productivity time.
So it's all these things that kind of come into play.
Now again, the technology, it's gonna get better.
And how long is the charge for?
You know, I'm not too sure,
but it's, you know, the range is, you know,
the biggest concern.
It's the biggest limitation is that the range
is just not there to support the range for trucks
to make these long haul deliveries.
Do you know how long it will take to recharge them?
You don't know that, right?
Hours.
And so it could, you know, for fully charged,
I've heard maybe 10 to 16 hours to fully charge, maybe more.
To sit there and wait for it to charge?
Yeah, because I don't believe that they have,
and I might be wrong,
but I don't believe that they have what they call
the fast chargers that you see for cars,
where you pull in and then they charge really quick.
Between the weight and the lack of range, the cost,
it's, you know, there's a lot of issues with that rule,
that what we coined the term fantasy land.
I mean, this is just not a reality.
This rule as written was not reality.
And because of the waiver not being issued,
federal preemption issues, we filed litigation.
And so we've been, we're still in litigation,
even though that, you know, we haven't withdrawn it,
but the, you know, with the waiver being withdrawn
a few weeks ago, following the administration,
probably a lot of people are like,
wow, victory, game over, right?
No, this is California.
We understand that there is going to be another rule.
It's just not going to be something like the ACF.
So probably for the next administration,
if there's a change in the presidency
and it's a democratic leadership,
you could see something like that.
But I think the withdrawal was two things.
One, the administration wasn't going to approve the waiver.
And two, that rule was doomed for failure from the start.
I think they, you know, collectively,
a lot of people understood that there's a lot of issues
with this rule.
And it's, if you're going to make a command
and control type of regulation,
it better have the technology and the infrastructure
and the cost not being cost prohibitive
for companies to be able to comply with.
And all three of those factors, they just weren't met.
I'm sure it must have been somewhat,
might be a little bit scary if you own a bunch of trucks
and then you have to transition
and there's uncertainty, right?
What did your members go through?
I think the cost factor, huge,
but you also have to realize
it's not like you could just pick up the phone
and call your local dealership and say,
hey, I need to buy 20 new electric trucks.
They're going to say, get in line.
They don't exist.
You know, I've got all these other customers on orders.
You know, you may be able to get one,
you may be able to get two.
So they're just, there's not a robust amount of trucks
that are out there for them.
So the cost, but these are expensive
and it's not only cost borne by the trucking company.
They have to go meet with their customers.
They have to say, hey, I don't know if you know this,
but we're subject to this rule.
We're going to have to, you know, buy these expensive,
these three, $400,000 trucks.
We can't afford to move your freight.
We're going to have to talk about the rates
and the company would say,
well, we can't do anything of that significance.
So being able to move the freight and the cost
and then the technology limitations, you know,
let's talk about bringing energy in to your company.
So you're a trucking company
and you want to put some chargers into your facility.
It's not like calling like Xfinity and saying,
hey, I need to get internet or I need to get, you know,
wifi brought in here and they come out
and they give it to you.
No, you've probably had people on your show
that talk about permitting issues in California.
This is one of those things where if you want to bring in,
what we've been told is when you want to bring in power
and you want to bring, you know,
pay for these chargers for your facility,
it's an 18 month process at best.
And each one of those is, I believe over $100,000.
So the amount of trucks that you have,
you want to have a certain amount of chargers to supplement
and be able to accommodate and charge those vehicles.
So depending on the fleet size,
you probably would have a third chargers
just to charge the trucks.
And that's where it gets really expensive.
And you also have to go through the process
of getting permitting done.
And a lot of also the warehouse side.
So a lot of trucking companies,
they'll lease warehousing and operations.
So they don't own the facilities, they lease them.
And some of the warehouses, they were,
well, we're not gonna pay for that.
Then you have these folks that have been
in warehouses for years
and they need to bring charging equipment in,
but they don't own the facility.
So it's a lot of these things that just,
and we understand where things are going
and where they need to go.
And we're not disputing that.
Once a rule is in place, we have to comply with it.
We may not like it, but that's the rule.
And that's the bar that's set for everybody
that they should be complying with.
But this is just, the rule was just unrealistic,
unachievable.
What do a neurosurgeon, a country artist,
and a television and radio host have in common?
They all saw the writing on the wall.
Big Bank, sharing your financial information
with big government.
Join them as owners in Old Glory Bank,
the pro-America online bank that protects your privacy,
security, and liberty.
Invest today at own.oldglorybank.com.
How much do you think this could have increased
the cost of goods?
I'm sure it's hard to estimate the cost of goods,
but how much would it increase
the cost of transportation for goods?
Yeah, good question.
I'm not sure how much exactly,
but it would be a significant cost increase for consumers.
Because the customer of the trucking company
would have to, if they're increasing their cost
to transport their goods,
the customer is gonna make that up
by increasing the cost for the goods
that the consumers are gonna be buying.
So you would see a significant increase
based on the cost of goods that consumers are purchasing.
And that's across the board.
And how's the trucking space doing in California?
Did they get impacted by these regulations
or are they doing okay overall
because these regulations didn't come true, right?
So the last few years post-COVID,
trucks have been in somewhat of a reception.
A lot of folks to move the product during COVID,
they kind of went out and bought more trucks
to be able to meet the demand.
I mean, let's be honest.
Trucks were continuing to transport stuff during COVID
and they played a vital role.
If it wasn't for trucks moving goods and services
during that time,
I mean, it would have been worse how things were.
So they, to satisfy their customers,
a lot of folks, they bought more trucks
and leased more equipment.
And so that kind of, after the demand was not there,
then you're sitting there with these unused trucks.
And so between that and the economy tanking
the last few years, it's been a tough market
for a lot of trucking companies in certain industries.
If you're looking at this regulation
and you're looking at the costs,
you're like, wow, we're already in a bad financial situation.
This is just gonna make it even worse.
What was the regulation exactly to move on to electric?
So beginning in 2024, the portholers,
they were subject to the rule.
They made any changes.
They had to plug in a zero emission truck into their fleet.
And then there's other phased in timelines
for the industry to comply with.
So a percentage of your truck,
your fleet would have to meet by this year.
Ultimately by 2042, all of the trucks operating
in California had to be zero emission.
So they dropped all of that.
They withdrew the regulation from the EPA.
So even the port that regulates-
The only one that we're a little,
I'm not too sure about is the public fleets.
So the municipalities, they were subject to the rule.
So I don't know if that remains in effect.
That doesn't affect our members.
That's for your like counties and cities and state,
like Caltrans and those types of vehicles.
They were subject to the rule too.
So I just don't know if they're,
what CARB's next steps are with that regulation.
So they withdrew it.
And so we're supposed to be our,
we'll be meeting with them.
Our council and the attorney general's office
will be meeting in the next few weeks to talk about that.
And the tow trucks were also part of this, right?
Correct.
We actually covered them on-
Yeah, I remember that.
And so there's a lot of,
so everyone thinks a truck is a truck,
but there's so many different types of trucks out there
that move special equipment or tow vehicles,
concrete pumpers, mobile cranes, these types of things,
which I'm not too familiar on
how they would be in compliance.
I just don't know if there's any type of technology
that exists to support certain types of professions
in the industry.
And so the tow is a perfect example.
I don't know if there's a electric tow truck out there.
And if there's, again,
if there's not a technology that exists
and they're subject to a rule,
what are these businesses supposed to do?
So yeah, there's certain exemptions.
I'm not too familiar with the exemptions,
but there's some exemptions in there
that pertain to certain types of trucks.
And so if you meet the exemptions,
then you're exempted from the rule.
But essentially by 2042,
every truck had to be zero emission.
So Eric, if you were to tell the state representative,
people that wanted to actually put this regulation on,
how would you tell them to do it?
How should the state go about this?
So we have always thought was, let's start small.
Let's, you know, there is technology that exists
and works on like a local delivery type of route.
So parcel delivery, let's start there.
Let's start and see how this works.
Let's work towards getting the technology better
to where it's, you know, maybe cheaper.
The infrastructure is coming online.
You know, what we were handed or what was proposed
and ultimately approved was the advanced clean fleets rule,
which was, you know, just unachievable.
The state is regulating the port side
because there's more people living in those areas, right?
They're impacted.
Some people complain about the pollution, right?
And your industry, you guys have done a few modifications.
Can you tell us more about what you guys?
As far as modifications, when you, the previous rules,
when they purchased equipment to comply with the rule,
that equipment was, I don't wanna say readily available,
but it was there.
You're talking about improving and cleaning diesel engines.
So that technology has been tried and true for decades
and it's getting cleaner.
The first regulation was the port rule.
They had to, you know, the ports and the surrounding areas
subject to, you know, some of the worst air quality.
You know, you're talking ships coming in,
you're talking planes coming in, you're talking trucks,
you're talking cars.
It's all in a very, I don't wanna say small,
but smaller condensed area.
The ports have done a really good job
on creating those programs that, you know,
helped reduce the emissions.
And I believe the reductions were 90% plus
of reducing emissions.
And I remember as a kid, when I would go to Disneyland
and I was on PSA and we were flying in to Long Beach
or Orange County, and I remember it was just so hazy.
Like the sky was brown.
Now, I don't mean to date myself, but I am 53.
So over time, you've seen massive improvements
of the air quality in the basin and in the port area.
And that's through these measures and regulations
that industries have to comply with.
Now, again, there is more to be done,
but bankrupting companies, bankrupting industries
and industries that can't comply, that's not helping.
So you have to work on, let's, you know,
kind of put together a realistic approach.
And it's not, you know, again,
we understand nationally what is going on
and what the transition is going to look like,
zero emission technology.
I believe 17 other states maybe have signed,
they signed an MOU that they were following
CARB's advanced clean fleets rule.
So they were gonna adopt the same thing in 17 other states.
And so it's known that when California adopts a rule,
it blows eastward and other states wanna follow their lead.
But this was a path that just wasn't going to work out.
So we have to be very careful
with the rules we put in place
because other people are gonna follow.
They're gonna follow,
a lot of states are gonna follow.
Again, if the technology is there to support a rule,
if the infrastructure is there to support the rule,
it's not cost prohibitive.
Those are gonna work.
The on-road truck and bus rule,
it was the first of its kind.
It was the first fleet rule of its kind.
And there was a lot of growing pains going through it.
Obviously we didn't like it, but it was the rule.
And there was ways to, you know, comply with it.
There was incentive funding that helped offset the costs.
But you're talking a different tech,
you're literally transitioning from one technology
to a new technology that is still going through,
I guess you could say growing pains.
And so the time is just not right
in that type of expedited manner for that type of rule.
Your industry, trucking,
do you think people appreciate it these days?
You know, when I was a kid growing up,
I loved trucking shows, trucking movies.
Like I, you know, again, I'm 53.
So the seventies was the heyday of the trucking era.
So you saw a lot of movies that glamorized the industry,
Convoy, Smoky and the Bandit, all these, you know,
so I was hooked as a kid
and I always thought trucks were really cool.
They were like clean, you know, like cool paintings,
trailers had murals on them and stuff.
And there's actually a picture floating around the office
of me and what they call a truck rodeo,
like competitions within companies.
And they drive through cones
and they have to navigate through these like contests.
And I was, I think 11.
And there's a picture of me sitting there
with my buck teeth and my feather cut hair.
And I'm just watching this competition
and I had the Kenworth hat on.
So I've always appreciated what the industry has done.
I think the general public, a lot of them,
they don't really, you know,
they see a truck driving down the road and it's like,
oh, that big truck, you know,
they need to get out of the way.
And the industry provides so much,
not only with just goods and services,
but these companies, they're job creators, job providers.
Every community has some sort of connection
with the trucking industry.
They are very community oriented.
And we have within the state, what we call,
we're a statewide organization.
And so we have regional chapters.
I'm just blown away every year by how much money
these chapters raise for various charities and causes,
like over $400,000 every year.
And these people are hardworking.
A lot of them are multi-generational.
So you have three, four,
we have three, four generation grandsons
that are now running the trucking company.
But what we're trying to do, and it's hard,
you want to paint the picture,
a positive picture of the industry.
And you want to show the good things that they do.
The American Trucking Associations,
they're the national trucking organization.
They do a great job on putting out these campaigns.
So I think that's, you know, that's helpful.
You also helping the public understand
that we've already been subject to all these rules.
We've already spent billions of dollars to comply
with these rules that make the fleet in California,
the cleanest fleet in the nation.
Are we at absolute zero?
No, we're getting there though.
But the industry between safety mandates and regulations
and being in compliance with those, the emissions,
the industry is, they have to adapt to a lot of things.
They're subject to a lot of rules.
And what I mentioned in the first, you know,
few minutes about the funding that they pay,
a lot of people for the roads.
You know, oh, these roads, they're beat up.
And the truckers, those heavy trucks.
So we pay $4.6 billion annually.
Goes a long way.
How do you pay that?
Is it a fee or is it-
Yeah, so there's different fees that pay into it.
So your fuel taxes.
We're also subject to a weight fee.
So weight fees, every truck, that's like a heavy fee.
Every truck is subject to a weight fee in California.
And so on top of that, they have to pay
for damage to pavement.
So they're paying for that.
A lot of people don't know that.
And it's interesting, the transportation funding side,
I'm a member of the Road User Charged
Technical Advisory Committee
that's looking at per mile charge.
Because at some point, the current system
is gonna have to change
because of the penetration of electric vehicles.
Because right now, we are paying to gas tax.
Correct, so when you're at the pump
and you put your pump in your car
and then you're done, you put it back, you just paid it.
General public doesn't know that.
So we did, there's been some surveys that were out there
and some of the answers of how do your roads get paid for,
the general public, some of these answers are like,
wow, they don't know.
Educating the public on these types of things,
what the industry does and what they pay for,
paying their fair share.
I mean, they only represent 12%
of the vehicle miles traveled in the state,
yet they're paying $4.6 billion.
I'd say they're paying their fair share.
But it's always an ongoing education with the public.
And I think you're seeing a lot of COVID.
If it wasn't for the industry, things would have stopped.
They would have moved.
People wouldn't, it was tough during those times
to get your products.
The trucking industry, they just kept trucking.
It's a great industry to represent.
It's one of the reasons why I'm still there
is I just really appreciate what the industry provides
and its jobs and its transporting people's goods
and services that they, now you're seeing the demand,
the Amazon, same day delivery.
I mean, how do you think all those goods get
to those warehouses to then feed out?
It's through trucks.
So there's a lot of products that is getting transported
by the industry.
So the regulation dropped, now what's coming next?
What's gonna happen?
You know, it's probably too soon to tell.
You won't see an ACF type rule,
at least until if there's an administration change,
president change.
So you won't see that type of rule,
but we know where the state wants to go.
I guess it's a wait and see to see what's next.
They have other ways that they could start down that path.
And again, if it makes sense and it's a reasonable pathway,
that's maybe something that's workable.
But we knew that the waiver wasn't gonna get approved
with the Biden administration moving on
and the Trump administration coming on board.
It's just, that wasn't gonna happen.
So they pulled that back.
Interestingly enough though,
there was other regulations,
didn't get fully approved as well.
So there's a transportation refrigerated unit regulation
that required a waiver from the EPA
and they only approved a portion of it.
The Biden administration didn't approve it or?
Yeah, the Biden administration
didn't approve the entire thing.
They approved a portion of it,
but they didn't approve all of it.
And so I think that kind of sends a message like,
yeah, maybe these things are a little bit too aggressive
and maybe they're not gonna work.
So to answer the question of what's next,
it's, we're still in litigation.
We haven't withdrawn our litigation,
but it'll be interesting to see
kind of what the next step is
on the transition to zero emission,
which is gonna happen.
It's gonna happen, but it just,
the ACF was just a very unachievable regulation.
It just had, it wasn't gonna work.
In this process, did people,
I'm sure it might, must have been challenging
for some of the members,
you're talking companies, California trucking companies.
Did people get impacted seriously by this?
Yeah, I know one example that was extremely disappointing.
It was leading up to the regulation.
I believe it was,
they decided to close up before the regulation,
but it has a tie-in with regulations
and competitors not being compliant with the rules.
So fourth generation company,
been around for 80 plus years,
large trucking company of four, 450 trucks,
very engaged member of the association.
They had to close up because they had a very large account
and the account went with a competitor of theirs
that probably wasn't in compliance as much as they were.
So this company-
With the regulations in contact.
Correct.
They went all in on,
they wanted to be compliant with the rules,
so they invested a lot of money into being compliant.
To go zero emission or-
Not the zero emission, the on-road truck and bus rule,
just over the years,
because you have to meet a certain model year.
So they actually tried to update-
And they did.
So then they raised their prices.
Well, yeah, and so then the customer says,
well, I'll just go with this guy.
The competitor probably,
and maybe his fleet wasn't in compliance,
but he's able to get that freight.
And so after that, they just said, we're shutting down.
That was very disappointing.
So they went on there, they went out of business.
They just closed up.
Yeah.
Member of the association, I think 50 plus years,
just great people.
You know, you hear stories like that
and you see the industry, it's tough.
You know, you're seeing a lot of private equity firms
coming in, buying trucking companies.
You're seeing larger trucking companies buying up the,
you know, merging, mergers and acquisitions
continue to happen.
And from an association standpoint,
we have to be mindful of it
because you're losing these companies.
And when the private equity firms come in,
they see the balance sheet.
They're going to look on that balance sheet
and they're going to go, huh?
What's this association stuff?
Anyone know what this is?
I don't, cut it.
And so you also see mergers and acquisition occur.
You absorb one.
So we lose a member there.
And then other companies,
they've just been in a long time.
And California, you know,
it's not the most business friendly climate.
I, you know, I like to call it,
they kind of dare you to be successful.
And I compare it to like an Olympic event.
I think Matt and I call it the decathlon.
And so you compete in all these events.
And if you're able to succeed,
you win the medal.
But you have to compete through all these events
to, you know, be in compliance
or pay for these fees and whatnot.
And at the end of the day,
if you can navigate through there,
get over the hurdles,
you can be successful.
But it's just, you know,
it's getting there is kind of tough.
And I understand that there's, you know,
there needs to be a lot of rules
on safety and environment, labor,
all sorts of stuff.
But sometimes it's some of these rules,
you're just, wow, these are company breakers.
They're just gonna break the company.
So Eric, you seem very passionate about this industry,
but you were not a trucker yourself.
No, I was not.
Can you tell us how you got,
was there a moment that got you more passionate about it?
Yeah, so I went to Sacramento State
and I had some political science courses
and I was in, you know, interesting government.
A friend of mine who I was working with at the time,
her sister was the senior vice president
of California Trucking Association.
So she created this position, legislative analyst.
Her sister said, hey, I think you would like this place
and you'd like this job.
So I interviewed, got the job and that was in 2001.
And I like to remind folks of my first place
where I sat there compared to my office now.
It was a table, like a poker table
and it was facing the wall next to the printer.
And the phone cord had an extension cord that went that way.
And when you get up, you almost tripped over it.
And so I've been there since that time.
So things have changed,
but I was promoted to executive in 2005
and then just kind of made my way to the CEO
as promoted to CEO in 2022.
And I just, I really enjoy representing the industry.
It's fascinating industry.
I'm not an expert by no means.
And my colleague, Matt Trapp, he'll say the same thing.
He's not an expert by no means.
It's an on the job, constant learning
of understanding the industry.
The true experts are the members.
They're the ones who will bring into meetings
and have them tell the real life stories
of how these rules or proposals are gonna have an impact,
not only on their company, but the people that work for them
and they do a really good job of explaining what they do.
And it's just, it's ongoing education.
And what I tell new hires when we bring them in
is it's, there's no playbook, there's no handbook.
You just, you're gonna learn it and it takes time,
but there's just so many different things
that factor into the industry.
It's just ongoing education.
I feel like I'm in school.
I'm still going to school.
Because things change, right?
Absolutely.
While we have you on, are you guys concerned
about the self-driving trucks
and how does that impact you guys?
You know, the autonomous, it's obviously, it's a big issue.
It's a big issue for labor.
The technology, it's autonomous vehicles.
You're seeing more and more testing.
You're seeing it occur in other states.
For us, it's just, we've had our hands full
with a lot of other issues,
like the advanced clean fleets rule and other issues.
Every year at the Capitol, I like to say
there's over 3,000 brilliant ideas that are introduced
that we have to, not all 3,000
are gonna have anything to do with us,
but we have to make sure that we're monitoring
and tracking these bills that do have an impact.
So we always have our hands full
and it's just one of those things that I,
just from our association and our members,
it just hasn't been a priority.
I don't know where that's gonna go.
I think in the next few years,
you could see some movement,
but there's the issue with,
between labor and the technology,
that has to get settled somehow
before that's gonna be moving anywhere.
But again, it's not one of those things
that our members are like,
hey, we want you to go advocate for this
one way or the other.
It's just, we've had our hands full.
Eric Sauer, CEO of California Trucking Association.
It was great to have you on California Insider.
No, thank you so much for having me.
This was great.
I really appreciate it.
Let us know your thoughts
on the zero emission regulation for trucks in California.
You can always reach out to me
at cmx.californiansider.com or comment.
We always read all of your comments and emails.
We'll see you next time.
