A Point about Spear Usage

MELEE Weapons
4 followers
7 Video Views·Feb 21, 2025
I have already made one follow-up to this one, and I suspect there will be one or two more after that. For more on this topic, see also my video "Dark age re-enactment with commentary".
Right, now this video is about spears.
I don't actually have a spear here with me.
I decided that would be a little bit dangerous to be wielding that.
What I've got is an 8 foot length of doweling,
but it'll do the job of illustrating playing the part of a spear.
Now 8 foot is about the longest a one-handed spear can be.
There were, of course, longer spears,
but they weren't wielded in quite the way that I'm talking about.
The style of spear I'm talking about is one that you could use in melee,
as an individual, with one hand.
My reenactment society, many years ago,
did make a 9 foot spear, and nobody could wield it.
And there were some guys much bigger and heftier than me in the society,
and they gave it a go, and it was considered to be just unwieldy by pretty much everyone.
So 8 foot seems to be about the longest that you can use in one hand.
And some of the smaller, weaker members of the society even didn't like 8 footers.
Now, the principal point I'm going to be arguing
is that I think that most of the time spears were used underarm, not overarm.
Now, it's very important for you to understand exactly what I mean by underarm versus overarm,
so let me try to make it clear.
Overarm, I have the little finger of my hand closest to the enemy that I'm trying to hurt,
and the back of my hand is away from my head,
and I'm using the spear like this, overarm.
Whereas underarm is the other way around,
and my little finger is further away from the enemy,
and I'm using the spear like this.
Now, I can use the spear underarm down here or up here,
this still counts as underarm.
Even if the spear is above my shoulder,
the way I'm holding it is still underarm.
Okay, so that's what I mean by underarm.
Now, I believe that spears were normally used,
not exclusively used, but normally used underarm for several reasons.
Now, the first is reach.
Spears are good because they are long.
That's their shtick, that's their unique selling point.
They can't punch as hard as an axe or a mace,
they're not as wieldy as a sword,
you can't really chop with one,
the blade on them isn't really very useful,
all you can do is thrust, but they are long.
And that's how they are better than other weapons.
So if the enemy's got loads of swords,
and we've got spears, ha ha,
the enemy won't be able to get near us.
Now, if I hold a spear underarm,
I can hold it with my elbow,
very close to the end here, like that,
and that's perfectly stable in my hand.
So here, you can't see it of course,
but there's an awful lot of spear sticking out the front there.
And of course I get the length of my arm,
as well, like that,
and I get the length of my lunge,
which you can't fully appreciate either,
but if you add the 8 foot spear minus most of the cubit there,
plus the length of my arm and the lunge,
it's, I don't know,
it's got to be at least 15 foot reach I've got with this thing.
If I use it underarm.
And if I use it underarm,
I can poke downwards at a guy's feet,
I can poke upwards at his face,
and I can poke, not the guy opposite me,
not the guy next to him,
but the guy too away from him,
over there.
Or, the guy,
I have to avoid deceiving night,
you know, too away from him, down the road,
that way.
I've got a lot of choice in what I thrust at.
If, on the other hand,
I hold my spear overarm,
I have to hold it in the middle.
I've now got very limited range.
For a start, I've now only got a 4 foot spear,
because I'm holding it in the middle,
and if I want to thrust at someone's feet,
that's extremely, in fact,
right, seriously,
he'd have to be standing
only about 2 paces in front,
he'd have to be standing within sword's reach of me,
easy sword's reach of me,
for me to get him in the foot.
And, to get him in the foot,
look how awkward my position is,
and it's a really weak thrust as well.
His foot really isn't a viable target anymore.
His knee, yeah,
I could get him in a knee,
but it wouldn't be very easy.
I could get him in the belly,
from the belly upwards, definitely,
no problem.
I could get the guy next to him
with a bit of awkwardness.
If I stepped out of the line,
out of my formation a little bit,
then I could get the guy either side of him.
But the guys, either side of them,
no, they're out of reach.
So, my angles of attack are fewer,
my thrust,
from most angles, is much weaker.
Admittedly, I can do a very strong thrust
there.
There's one thrust,
if he's standing at exactly the right distance from me,
and I get exactly the right line
of attack,
then there is one very strong thrust.
But, other than that,
all my thrusts are a bit weak and awkward.
Another thing is that
because I'm holding it in the middle,
if you knock
the spear sideways,
this bit of spear
sticking out the back
is a counterweight that's in sympathy with that.
So, knocking the spear here
is very difficult to stop the spear
spinning that way,
because the weight of this whopping great counterweight
is helping that turning motion.
So, if someone wants to knock aside my spear
with his sword, or edge of his shield, or whatever,
he finds that very, very easy.
Whereas, if I've got it braced
against my arm like this,
he can knock it aside a bit,
but it doesn't go anything like as far,
and I can bring it straight back.
Another thing I can do is I can parry
with this spear.
If I've got it like this, underarm,
I can parry, and not just spear's thrust
aimed at me, I can rake
a very large, imagine the volume of air
in front of me, that I can
parry enemy spears in.
It's very large, and worthy of reenactment,
most of the parrying
you do with your spear isn't against
attacks aimed at you, it's protecting
the guys either side of you, and the guys either
side of them. I can, if anyone
does use the reach of his spear
to try to attack the guy two to my right,
he's going to come across me,
and I can then just knock his spear up or down,
and it can be quite
exhausting after a while, because
in a long protracted spear fight, you're doing this
raking spears, raking spears
out of the air all the time, and
it gets quite tiring, but that's what
you've got to do. So I can parry
not just blows aimed at me, but
I can protect all the guys next to me, if I
use my spear underarm. If I use it
overarm, however,
I can't really parry with it at all, and I can't
help the guys either side of me much.
Plus, every time this gets knocked,
don't forget, there were spikes on
both ends of spears.
So I've got a spike on
that end of it, and I'm a danger to
the guys behind me, every time this
spear gets knocked.
So,
those are some reasons that I believe that
spears were used underarm
rather than overarm. There are others.
Oh, and I just want to
make clear as well, that if I do, if I've got
the shield, if I do
want to get over the top of an obstacle,
or whatever, I can just raise the
spear, I can even
take it away from my elbow,
and thrust quite effectively
like that. But we would
fighting across obstacles, quite often
have our, in the reenactment society,
quite often we'd be holding our spears up like this,
and you can fight like that for quite some while.
And so,
you know, getting the
spear high isn't particularly a problem
with an underarm hold.
So you can parry,
you've got the reach,
you're less danger to your friends,
greater help to your friends,
yeah, I reckon underarm's the way to go.
