Menace of the Romans! The Dacian Falx (With Notes on the Sica & Rhomphaia)

MELEE Weapons
4 followers
24 Video Views·Sep 21, 2024
The Dacian Falx was one of the most feared weapons of the ancient world, capable of cutting through Roman armor and helmets with ease. But how did it work, and why was it so effective? In this video, we explore the Falx, along with the Sica and Rhomphaia, weapons that shaped the way Rome fought against the Dacians and Thracians. Join us as we break down their history, design, and battlefield impact!
Hey folks, Matt Easton here, Scholar Gladiatoria. So we're back in the world of the Romans,
or more specifically in this case the world of the Dacians and the Thracians,
and what I've got here is a falx, or is it? Well I'll come back to that in a little bit.
So this is from Iomandy Christian, so link below. You can go check out, he's a knife maker in
Romania, so what was Dacia. Go and check out his stuff, he's making all sorts of weapons of
of this type, but also he is making modern knives and various other types of knives as well,
so he's a very skilled chap, and he very kindly sent me one of these. Now these have been featured
on at least a couple of other YouTube channels as well, so you might have seen similar ones to
this before. Now this does get commonly called a falx, and falx is probably the most common
name that people associate with this type of weapon, but is it a falx? Well when I came to
research these I found that it's a bit of a minefield, quite simply because we've got
conflicting historical documents, texts, talking about weapons like this, both from Dacia and from
Thracia. Over a long period of time there are two main artistic sources of the period that people
refer to, the Tropaeum Traiani and Trajan's Column, and there's some differences between those two,
both in terms of how the weapons are represented but also how they're used,
in addition to which we've got some confusion about different sizes of these, and we've got
some quite nice examples of weapons like this from archaeology, and there is quite a bit of
variation between those as well. So the first thing to mention, I suppose, there are three
main things to focus on here. One is size of, well size of entire weapon, but size of blade as well,
curvature, and hilt construction or hilt design, shall we say. Now those three things show us if
we look at the archaeology, we look at the art, and we look at the written sources, show us there's
quite a bit of variation in these things. If we just look at hilt construction for a moment,
so you will see that this is very nicely made with artistic renditions of art, perhaps Dacian-
the time, and it has a sort of rib, shall we call it, halfway down the grip, a bit like a longsword
might have, or a bastard sword, just to stop, if you're using it one-handed, to stop the hand
sliding down. And there is some evidence for that historically, but I'll come back to that in a
second. So there are various different types of hilt constructions found in the archaeology. First
of all, there are different tang constructions. We find almost full-width tangs, or indeed full-width
tangs, and we find essentially a through tang, a stick tang, which is peened at the end. Now this
sort of has characteristics of both of those constructions, in that the tang does come
through to the end, but it's not peened or rolled over or anything like that at the end, it's just
visible at the end, but then we have a rivet through there and a rivet through there, through
two ferrules. Now there is some archaeological evidence for that kind of construction, however
what I came across, that what seemed to be the most common forms of hilt construction, are a tang
which goes all the way through, like a medieval sword, with a stick tang, essentially a through
tang, that tapers, so it's thicker at this end and it gets thinner towards the end of the
butt or the pommel, and then at the end is sort of peened or riveted or rolled over in some way,
sometimes with some kind of cap at the end. The other form of construction is with pretty much a
full-width tang, where you sometimes find three rivets through, and the three rivets are like
a kitchen knife, conventional kitchen knife grip, or indeed certain types of bowie knife,
you have a rivet through here, a rivet through here, and a rivet through here, and then these
ferrules, if you want to call them that, are put in to prevent the grip splitting, but they don't
usually have the rivets through them. This construction, the rivets have gone through
the ferrules, which is a very strong form of construction, but I'm not going to say, I'm not
going to pretend that it's necessarily historically common, and I don't know what the historical
evidence for that is. So the basic headline is there are various forms of grip and hilt construction
found in the originals, and that obviously creates a certain degree of disagreement and controversy
when people are talking about these weapons, because we have quite a lot of variation within
a fairly small data set, which is a bit problematic, but anyway. Additionally, we
sometimes have very long grips for weapons that are clearly primarily supposed to be used two-handed,
and then we have some very short grips that are obviously weapons that are meant to be used
pretty much only one-handed. I'll talk about the names of these in a second, and there is some
evidence for a middle rib on some grips, both in art and archaeology, like this example here, so
some of them may have been used a bit like long swords, sometimes in one hand, sometimes in two.
Now the names of these. This is problematic. So we have three main names which are associated with
weapons like this. One of them is the falx, which I've mentioned. The other one is the sika, which
I've referred to in gladiatorial videos that I've done. Check those out if you haven't done already.
And the sika is a one-handed sword most famously used, I think, actually in gladiatorial contexts,
used by the Thracian gladiator, but the reason is because it's used by Thracians, and in fact
Dacians, as a one-handed weapon used with a large shield, not unlike the Roman scutum, very similar,
although usually oval rather than rectangular like this later imperial one. And the sika is a
contrast to the straight sword, so the straight sword which would be used, for example, by the
secator or provocator, the curved blade would be used by the Thracian, and this characteristic
to the Thracian, and possibly the daimakeras as well. So there is a one-handed version of this,
but that's not to say that this isn't used one-handed, and in fact the fact that we've got
a rib here and there are some archaeological examples like that, and art examples like that,
suggest that some of these longer handled ones were used either one-handed or two-handed. So
we've got the falx and we've got the sika. The sika seems to always be one-handed. The falx,
the jury's a bit open as to what exactly that refers to. It could be a generic word that could
mean two-handed ones and one-handed ones. And then we've got the rump fire. Now the rump fire is
usually associated with the Thracians rather than the Dacians, a neighbouring culture, obviously
with some shared cultural heritage, and their weapons have some things in common as well.
Now if you look on the internet and various forums, Wikipedia and everywhere like that,
the general statement that people make is that the rump fire is a large two-handed version of
the falx, not to say that the falx isn't two-handed, but should we say the rump fire
tends to be even larger and tends to be less curved and perhaps even sometimes straight.
Now confusing this whole subject is that in later Byzantine times the rump fire is a word which is
repeatedly used for a large two-handed sword, sometimes one-edged, in fact usually one-edged,
but sometimes two-edged as well. So the word, this is the problem we get into linguistics,
is that sometimes the words, what may mean falx to one person doesn't necessarily mean falx to
another or rump fire or sika. So it's a complicated subject and there's much debate about this. Even
when we look at the art sources some people argue that Thracian's column isn't a reliable
representation of Dacian equipment, but the Tropaeum Traiani is perhaps more reliable.
And there are big differences in how the Dacian arms and armour are shown in each of those sources
and how they are shown used in each of those sources as well, but they are the two main
artistic sources that we have to go from. So we've got a very small data set and as always in history
and archaeology when you've got a small data set then you're going to get debate, you're going to
get arguments. So I'm going to speak in more or less general terms here and I'm going to call this
a falx because that's probably the most commonly understood word and a lot of people know about
the falx. It is quite a famous weapon from the Classical era, from the Roman era, because of
Thracian's column. And Thracian's column is a widely used and referenced work of Roman art
that glorifies the Dacian campaign and Thracian's campaign and it's used in a lot of books and
therefore a lot of people are familiar with seeing this combat between the Romans
and the Dacians. And there's another fact that a lot of people know about the falx and that is that
it is possibly the only weapon, or at least one of the only weapons, that definitely brought about
changes in Roman equipment whilst on a military campaign. And famously the thing that most people,
if they know this fact, know about is that the Roman helmets, the culus, had a cross piece or
cross pieces put onto the top of the helmets and there's archaeological evidence from surviving
examples that these cross pieces were added not at manufacture, they've been added after and
therefore on campaign as a response to the effects from this falx. And indeed any of you who know
about this weapon or have paid any attention to this weapon at all will have probably seen videos
or at least photographs on the internet of these being tested on everything from dead pigs
to Roman shields to Roman helmets to lorica segmentata, the plate arm of the Roman imperial
period. So this is quite a famous weapon of the Roman era and it has received a fair
amount of exposure online. And I will be doing some cutting with this, don't fear of that.
But quite a lot has been done with these already and has shown the fearsome abilities of these and
the fearsome cutting ability of these are well documented in texts of the time, both the wounds
that they gave but also the damage that they do to the armour, and we know this also from archaeology.
And in addition to the Roman helmet being adapted potentially against these, and not necessarily
just against the power of the edge, it might be the power of that point penetrating through,
which I think is a large likelihood from my own experiments with armour penetration with weapons.
It's also fairly well documented that other changes were brought into Roman equipment at
this time. Perhaps next most famous is the inclusion of the mannequin, so the right arm
during the Trajan's campaign started wearing the mannequin on legionaries' arms to protect
their arms from cuts from weapons like the sika and the falx. And this is essentially a piece of
gladiatorial equipment worn by most types of gladiator that use a sword and a shield
to protect the right arm. It probably most of the time involves plates, either of iron or bronze,
but could perhaps in some cases just have been padding or with leather. The jury's out on this,
there's lots of debates also about that topic, about how exactly the typical mannequin was
constructed and worn. So the mannequin was brought in, and there are potentially some other
differences they brought into equipment as well. I have read in a couple of places, and I can't
verify this for myself because I haven't researched this particular topic myself,
that the body armour, there was a greater use of lorica hamata, so that's male, and squamata as
well, so scale, in the Dacian campaign instead of lorica segmentata. Now why should that be the
case? I don't know, and this is why I don't necessarily trust what I've read online about
this being a response to the Dacian campaign, because generally speaking the lorica segmentata
will provide better protection against weapons like this, both in piercing and in cutting and
just in impact. The lorica segmentata is in my view a better armour against that sort of thing.
But there is some suggestion that a lorica hamata, and of course hamata is male, commonly known as
so riveted interlocking links, that is good excellent cut protection, pretty good thrust
protection, although probably not quite as good as the segmentata, and there is some suggestion
that they wore a beefed up subarmalis, so a padded garment underneath the male to give a bit more
kind of shock absorption, energy absorption underneath the male, because male by itself
does absorb some impact but not a huge amount. So this was an influential weapon and continues to
be. Now I want to talk a little bit about its use. So if you look online to people who've reviewed
these or use these, they pretty much always use them as a two-handed implement, but actually
if we compare this is the dynasty forge gladius incidentally, which is not a very good replica,
but it's the one I have to hand, and this is a little bit on the large side for typical
roman gladii of the period, but you'll notice that the weapon is not really much longer,
this one anyway, isn't much longer than the gladius, especially when we consider that
generally speaking this is a chopping weapon, so most chops are actually going to impact
there. So if we assume that is our impact area there, but with the gladius most of the time,
certainly used with the large scutum, you tend to thrust with it. Not to say you can't cut with it,
you can cut with it, but when you use one of these large shields it actually becomes quite difficult
to use a cutting sword, so you tend to thrust more because it's easier to do with a large shield
held in front of you. So the impact area here is up at the tip and actually that means that in
terms of reach this particular falx and this particular gladius, so this is a bit large and
this is not a particularly large one, is about the same. Now one of the disadvantages therefore
in using the falx two-handed is you've got a really short reach for a two-handed weapon and
you're giving up any ability to protect yourself with a shield. If we look at the tropaeum triani
for example, it shows the Dacians wearing no armour at all. Now do we trust that? Well that's
a good question. I think it's probably a romanticised vision. Certainly we see the
Dacians wearing armour on Trajan's Column and we see the piles of weapons that have been gathered
from the Dacians on Trajan's Column and it shows helmets and shields and scale armour and so on
so forth. So I think certainly, and obviously there's variation in the army, so there were
essentially massed levies within the Dacian army and there were nobles and there were perhaps more
like regular soldiers. We know that there's a strong suggestion that the Dacians had actually
been undergoing a long period of romanisation. It wasn't simply a case of the Romans going to
some foreign land, encountering some barbarians they'd never encountered before, running around
in animal skins with giant cleavers and fighting them and killing them. It wasn't as simple as that.
The Dacians and the Romans had been interacting for a long long time and just as in fact all over
the world, the world that the Romans came into contact, there was cross-pollination
of ideas and of culture and of language but also of arms and armour. And so, you know, if we're
looking at Gaul or we're looking at Britannia or we're looking at Dacia, anywhere, Germania,
anywhere we're looking where the Romans came into contact with, you could find equipment that was
to some degree comparable with Roman equipment. So we see the spread of Roman-style shields,
we see the spread of Roman-style helmets which in fact was a Gallic-style helmet originally,
we see the spread of the pilum and the gladius, so we absolutely see and we can guess with a
fair amount of surety based on the evidence we have to hand that there was some degree of Roman
influence already in Dacia before the Dacian campaigns. And so I find it very unlikely that
all of the Dacians were running around shirtless, but it's not impossible that some were,
and we also know that the Dacians did make use of other types of swords comparable to the gladius
with shields and with armour, and so it's possible that perhaps like in later centuries,
for example, the danacs used at Hastings, it's possible that some of these weapons, the falcs,
not so much the sica because the sica is obviously intended to be used with a shield,
but it's possible that the bigger two-handed versions of the falcs were given to elites,
the equivalent of kind of berserkers or housecarls, they were given to perhaps guards,
and if we look at the Byzantine sources later when the ronfire is mentioned, it does seem that
that is associated with guards, with guards to the emperor. So if we look at the savaijando,
the so-called lanconects in the 16th century, the doppelsoldiers that used these big two-handed
there's always this correlation or relationship between these kind of elite shock weapons where
you give up protection like a shield or armour in order to use some really big, lay down some
massive attack, there does seem to be association between those types of weapons and guards,
bodyguards, elites, forlorn hopes, this type of thing, shock troops, grenadiers, so on.
Okay, so in terms of how this was used, well, was it always used two-handed? I think this type,
this type that Ayamandi has made, and again link below and you can look at other examples he's
made, he's made sica and he's made bigger examples and smaller examples, I think this particular
type is essentially, in my mind, kind of like a bastard sword of the medieval period. So can you
use it two-handed? Yeah, absolutely, it's quite a hefty thing, it's not nimble or light by any
means, but it's not unwieldy, it's not ridiculous or anything like that, and I do think, could you
make this lighter? Yes, you could make this lighter, you could make this more nimble, would
you necessarily gain anything by that? Well, you'd make it a bit quicker, but if you're using this
with a shield, then actually as a one-handed weapon, if it's a striking weapon, you don't
actually necessarily want it to be overly light because you want it, when it strikes, to have
a good strong effect, whether it's on someone's shield or helmet or body or whatever, so you do
want some heft to it. That being said, do I think this should be a little bit lighter than it is?
I think possibly yes, and I think that this example probably has more meat in the blade
than is conducive to using really well as a one-handed sword, and funnily enough because of
the length of this and the proportions and the fact that we've got that rib there almost
encouraging you to use it as a one-handed sword, I do see this more like a sika with an extended
grip rather than what I would regard as a true falx. So we do have a size and proportion issue
here in relation to weight as well, obviously when you've got a weapon you're predominantly using
two-handed, well this is light two-handed, it's as light as a nimble longsword, but it doesn't have
the length and reach of a nimble longsword, so I would argue for if you're making something to
decide whether you want it to be a predominantly two-handed weapon or predominantly one-handed
weapon, and I would say that this one is kind of going in two different directions,
in terms of the mass and the feel it feels like a two-handed weapon, but in terms of the size it
feels like a one-handed weapon. So I'd be personally very interested to see Eomandi's
one-handed sika, and you know in a way with some mass reduced this would be I think absolutely
spot on as a one-handed sword, but a little bit short for a two-handed sword. Now in terms
of the quality of the production, well I'm going to talk about that in a separate video, I really
wanted to look at the history here and make you aware of the complications of talking about the
falx and the sika and the ronfa, and quite simply these are actually something really
interesting to research, and if you're for example an archaeology or history student,
classic student, this would be an interesting subject to delve into actually, because there's
a relative, you know, there's a decent amount of art, archaeology and historical material to
research, but at the same time there's debate on it and there's contrasting and conflicting opinions
on these things. My feeling is that probably those words were used for similar or different weapons
by different people at different times, and it's a bit like when we go into the 16th or 17th
centuries and we deal with the word sword and rapier and tuck and estoc and all of these things,
sometimes we argue about the terminology, but sometimes it's just that that historical person
used the word slightly differently to that historical person, so they're subjective as
language often is. So I'm going to wrap it up there, we will be coming back and
looking at this weapon again in terms of what it does, and I'll be talking a little bit perhaps
about how you could use this with the scutum or with the shield, I'll perhaps be
hitting things with it, obviously I'll do some water bottles and wood and my typical targets, but
I might also perhaps look at some striking against shield or armour analogues, and we'll talk about
it in context with some other weapons of the period like the pilum as well, and consider what
place this maybe had historically, and how it was physically used as well rather than just
talking about its name and its importance in history. Anyway I hope that's been interesting,
see you again soon for another video on the channel, give us a like and a subscribe, check out
Iomandi's Facebook page below and have a look at his cool stuff that he's making, he's got a website
as well which is also linked below, we'll look at its construction and do a review of it in a video
really really soon. Cheers folks! Thanks for watching, we've got extra videos on Patreon,
please give our Facebook a like and subscribe if you haven't already. Cheers folks!
