Are You Using Your Backpacking Stove Correctly?

AROUND THE WORLD
406 followers
#trevel #longwalk #adventure #backpacking
Check out PackWizard Here! https://www.PackWizard.com
How do you get the most out of your backpacking stove so it boils water fast while using the
least amount of fuel? Today I'm doing four experiments to test different factors like
fuel can level, whether you use a lid or not, and pot diameter affects stove performance.
I'm doing the four experiments using three different stoves, the Ultralight Leader in
the BRS3000, the MSR Pocket Rocket 2 and Oldie But A Goodie, and a fan favorite,
the Soto Windmaster. I think these stoves provide a good cross-section of stove types
with differences in BTUs, burner diameter, and distance from the burner to the top of the stove
arms. The Windmaster also has a regulator while the other two stoves do not. The first test
involves seeing whether having a lid on a pot or not significantly impacts fuel consumption and
boil times. Being able to leave a lid at home could be a significant weight savings for some
people. As well I'm doing all the rest of the tests without lids so we'll see how much of an
impact that has on the testing. The first test is pretty straightforward, I'll be bringing 500
milliliters of water to a temperature of 80 degrees celsius in pots with a lid and pots with
no lid. I only completed the lid versus no lid test with the BRS stove and the Windmaster, but
did complete the test using three different pots with diameters of 95 millimeters, 115 millimeters,
and 145 millimeters. Room temperature is being held at 23 degrees celsius with no air movement
and the water is being kept at 3 degrees celsius for consistency. I used large size fuel canisters
and a low down stove attachment with the valve open to 50 percent. For the results, under my
testing conditions there was minimal change in boil time regardless of whether a lid was used
or not. In this graph you can see the BRS boil times in blue and the Windmaster in orange. The
darker colors are the times with no lid and the lighter colors are the times with a lid. There's
also a minimal change in fuel consumption as we can see from this graph. As expected, boil times
and fuel consumption are both lower for the Windmaster compared to the BRS. The key takeaway
from this test is that having a lid on your pot seems to only really make a big difference if
you're dealing with long boil times. For example, if you're dealing with cold temperatures, if you
don't have a lot of fuel in your canister, or if you're using an alcohol stove or boiling a lot of
water, in those scenarios it might be worthwhile to have a lid and it might significantly decrease
boil times as well as decrease fuel consumption. The second test involves seeing how much the
amount of fuel inside of a fuel canister affects performance of the stove, whether that's boil
time or fuel consumption. As you use a stove and the fuel inside of a canister is used up,
the pressure inside the canister decreases and this may or may not affect different stoves
in different ways, especially when it comes to regulated versus unregulated stoves. For this
test, I started with a full 110 gram fuel canister for all three stoves and environmental conditions
were identical to the first test and it'll be held the same for all four tests. I brought 500
milliliters of water to 80 degrees celsius in a 750 milliliter tokes titanium pot and then measured
the time it took and the fuel used. I then let the can get back to ambient temperature and repeat it
until the can was empty. The results of this test were very interesting. The trend that I saw was
that the regulated Windmaster maintained pretty consistent fuel consumption and boil time numbers
while the unregulated Pocket Rocket 2 and BRS stoves used more fuel and took less time to boil
with a full canister. But as the fuel was used up in the canister, boil times increased but fuel
consumption decreased. Especially with the Pocket Rocket 2, there was a pretty big difference in
fuel consumption when the canister was full compared to when the canister was closer to
empty. Another interesting result was that the Pocket Rocket 2 and Windmaster only got exactly
11 boils out of a 110 gram canister while the BRS was able to achieve 12. The key takeaway for the
test is that as fuel levels drop inside of the canister, pressure decreases which ends up
decreasing fuel flow, increases boil time, but also increases fuel efficiency. An interesting
observation with this test was that the more BTUs coming out of a stove seemed to result in a lower
fuel efficiency. So with the Soto Windmaster, because it's regulated and was constantly putting
out pretty high BTUs, it was actually less efficient than the BRS 3000 stove. This test
was also representative of other factors that could be influencing fuel can pressure like
temperature as well as altitude. Fun fact, we now have a full database of stoves over on packwizard.com
to add to the sleeping pad, tent, bag and quilt, down jacket, and tent databases. I'll be testing
almost every stove on the market and adding information to Packwizard like boil times,
fuel efficiency, and performance in wind. I'll let you know in a future video when some of that
additional testing data has gone live, but in the meantime you should head over to packwizard.com
and check out the current databases as well as create a gear list. I find creating a gear list
helps a ton with my planning for trips and using the create a checklist feature helps me avoid
forgetting items. The third test involves seeing how stove performance is affected by how high it's
been turned on. Running a stove at full power is known to decrease fuel efficiency even though it
does decrease boil times as well, but what is the optimal amount to turn your stove on and how does
that affect boil times and fuel efficiency? For this test I used the MSR Lowdown stove attachments
to regulate fuel flow from a 450 gram canister to the stove. Using the Lowdown which is fully
open after two full rotations of the valve, I turned the stoves to full power and then turned
the Lowdown valve to 100%, 75%, 50%, and 25% open. For this test I also only used the BRS and
Windmaster stoves. The results show that boil times go down but fuel efficiency goes up as fuel
flow is reduced. The optimum point is having the valves less open. It seems to be the best balance
of boil times and fuel efficiency. The regulated Windmaster didn't see as much of a difference
until the valve was reduced to only 25% open. You can also likely get more efficiency by knowing
and managing your personal stove to an even lower setting. The key takeaway with this test wasn't
really surprising. If you want to maximize fuel efficiency turn your stove down lower. The lower
you turn it down the more you're going to maximize fuel efficiency. You are going to end up with
decreased boil times though. The Soto Windmaster is a little bit of a different story compared to
the other two because it is a regulated stove. We didn't really see that much of a difference with
performance for the Windmaster until we started turning the valve really really low. The fourth
test involves seeing how much pot diameter affects performance. This test is interesting because I
really want to see whether we can maintain boil times with the water diameter pots while
decreasing fuel consumption. We'll also see whether if there is fuel efficiency if the weight savings
of that fuel efficiency makes up for the fact that the bigger pots and wider pots end up weighing
more. To assess how pot diameters affect stove performance I brought 500 milliliters of water
to 80 degrees celsius in titanium pots with a 95 millimeter diameter 115 millimeter diameter and
145 millimeter diameter. The results show that wider pots had progressively lower boil times for
both stoves. The difference in boil times between 95 millimeters and 145 millimeter pots was 54
seconds for the BRS and 50 seconds for the Windmaster. Fuel consumption was also lower for
the wider pots. The difference in fuel consumption between the 95 millimeter and 145 millimeter pots
was 4.1 grams for the BRS and 2.4 grams for the Windmaster. The key takeaway with this test was
that whether using a more powerful stove or a less powerful stove pot diameter both affects
boil times as well as fuel consumption but it may not be worth it for everyone from a weight
saving standpoint because with 110 gram fuel canister and the most narrow pot that we tested
you're going to get five days if you're boiling 500 milliliters of water twice a day whereas the
widest pot that we tested you'll get two more boils of 500 milliliters which brings you an extra day
out in the backcountry without having to bring another canister. That being said where it might
make a big difference is if you're on the cusp and you're ending up going out for six or seven days
instead of bringing a second fuel canister you can increase the weight of your pot a little bit
bring one with a wider diameter and then only need to bring one fuel canister. If you like these
testing videos go check out this video right up here where I take six tents out into super windy
conditions. I set them up and see which ones fail and which ones are able to handle up to 73
kilometer an hour winds.
