AKA I gush about books and ramble about paintings. But with pictures, so that's cool!
*All paintings pictured are in the public domain in the United States. Links are below, and all paintings fall under PD-1923 because they were published (or painted) anywhere in the U.S. before 1923. --Additionally, the artist died in 1917, so all of his work is officially in the public domain in the U.S. starting in the year 2017. --I am not profiting in any way from this video.
Hello everybody, my name is Cara, and today I'm here with a weird kind of recommendations
video.
Sometimes I run into books that I really really love and that I want to recommend to people,
but I can't really explain them.
Or maybe I can explain them, I can describe the plot and the characters or the writing,
and I can give you these concrete reasons why I enjoyed the book, but one of the most
important features is just like the vibe or the feeling or the atmosphere.
And that's kind of what I'm trying to communicate to you guys, is like if you're in the mood
for this particular like feeling or vibe, then I think you would enjoy this book.
And then I started thinking about how that's very similar to how we view artwork, like
you can talk about the color palette and the brush strokes and the subject of the painting,
but one of the most important things is like looking at a picture or looking at a sculpture
or whatever, and the way it makes you feel or like the emotional response it has because
it's such a visceral experience.
So I decided to like put those two things together.
Today I'm going to be pairing pieces of artwork with books.
And if this experiment just kind of doesn't work for you, like if you don't really get
the feelings from the paintings or if my explanations don't really make sense to you, that's totally
fine.
You've still got some great books to check out.
By the way, I am not an art student, I am not trained in any way, I just like books
and I like paintings.
And I decided to put them together.
So the artist whose works I'm going to be describing and using today is John William
Waterhouse.
He was a painter during the late 1800s and early 1900s and he was one of the capital
R romantics.
He painted figures and scenes from poetry, from plays, from history, from mythology,
from epic poems, from the bible.
He did a lot of different kinds of work.
And one of the things that I really enjoy about his work is that he painted really complex
and interesting women.
Sometimes it seems like a lot of the artists, like a lot of his contemporaries at the time
pretty much just used women as attractive like set dressing for the painting, like for
the setting.
Or, you know, maybe they did use the female as the main character, but she was primarily
there for eye candy.
And in John William Waterhouse's works, even though most, if not all, of the women are
still very attractive, I feel like they were still allowed to have stronger expressions.
They were allowed to be angry or frightening or powerful.
Like they were allowed to have interesting emotions in addition to being beautiful and
to kind of fitting into this ideal painted version of themselves.
So I tried to pick a mix of books here, like kind of different genres and different styles,
and a couple of them are ones that I have talked about before, but a couple of them
are ones that I haven't really featured on my channel.
The first painting I want to talk about is Pandora.
It was painted during either 1896 or 1898.
I kind of did the best I could with the dates because some of them are a little tricky to
pin down.
And the book that I kind of equate with this painting or with the feeling this painting
gives me is Deathless by Catherine M. Valente.
Here's the cover so you can see it a little better.
Everyone kind of knows the story of Pandora.
She opened the box when she wasn't supposed to and she basically brought misery down upon
the whole human race.
But something that I find really interesting about Deathless and about this painting of
like the story of Pandora is that there's this discussion of responsibility and free
will and choice.
And like in the original Pandora Myth, she was given like a burning curiosity by the
gods.
They gave that to her on purpose because they kind of wanted this to happen or they wanted
to see if this would happen.
So that kind of, to me, that brings up this question of whether or not Pandora is completely
to blame for what she did.
People kind of use her as the scapegoat for bringing destruction and misery on the world.
But if somebody caused that to happen, is it really all her fault?
And the reason that kind of reminds me of Deathless is something I loved about this
book so much is that all of the characters are making decisions that even if you don't
agree with, you can kind of understand why they're doing them.
Even if you see them doing something and you're like, this is a mistake, this is a disaster,
like don't do it, don't open the box.
Even though they make decisions that you know are mistakes, you, in that moment, you agree
with them or you feel that same need to do something that they do.
And I find that really impressive because one of the most frustrating things for me
when I read a book is when a character does something that is obviously going to cause
problems down the line and it's like they didn't even stop to consider the consequences.
And in Deathless, that doesn't really happen.
Even if they're doing things that I think are stupid, I'm like, well, I don't really
see what choice you had.
Or given your character and given the situation you're in, I get it.
And then another thing I love about this painting that I also really enjoyed about Deathless
is the setting.
So this really dark forest that you can see in the background, it's really shadowy and
it's beautiful but it's a little bit frightening.
And there are one or two settings in the novel in particular that really gave me that feeling.
It's like very old world fairy tale.
Like these are not happily ever after kinds of stories, but you'd still go into the woods
anyway.
That's kind of the feeling I get.
And that's another reason why I think this painting is a good representation of the weird
spooky fairy tale atmosphere that I got from the book.
The next painting I want to talk about is Cleopatra.
This was painted in 1887.
Now this is probably one of my favourite images I have ever seen.
I like to refer to this expression or this look as the I could crush you beneath my feet
and you would thank me for it look.
That's kind of what I think of this expression as.
And the book that I think, and specifically the character that I think really works with
that is The Queen of Atollia by Megan Whalen Turner.
This is the second book in the Queen's Thief series.
And the title character is just so wonderful.
She's very similar to Cleopatra in my opinion because she's this brilliant strategist, this
incredibly complex woman who a lot of people around her kind of write her off as a figurehead
or as just this beautiful woman who somehow got where she is even though she doesn't have
any of her own skills or value.
Just like this whole feeling I get of feminine power and with the value of feminine things
is just really important to me.
I love seeing that represented in books.
I get really sick of seeing women who like wearing dresses or who enjoy makeup or who
like traditionally feminine hobbies.
I get really, really tired of seeing them vilified or criticized by the other characters
in the book.
Or even sometimes it seems like by the authors.
So something that I really loved about The Queen of Atollia is that she uses all of it.
It's somewhat unusual for a woman to be in the position that she is and she's fine with
that.
And it's also unusual for a woman to be comfortable with that and with being really like kind
of what we would call girly.
And I also really loved that.
So a quick note about the series is I have seen a lot of people say that you don't have
to read the first book.
I think the first book is just called The Thief, that you can just go right to this
one.
And you probably could.
I read the first book before reading the second one so I can't say definitively if you would
be confused or not.
But I think that some of the things that happen in this book, like the way the story unfolds
and revelations about characters and things like that, I don't think they would have meant
nearly as much if I hadn't started with the first book and gotten kind of the background
of the world and sort of formed these opinions about other characters or other things in
the books.
So I would really recommend starting with the first one.
But if you start it and you're like, I don't like this at all, like I'm not going to read
the series, then just skip it and go to the second one because it feels very different
in tone to the first one and this is just such a fantastic book.
I need to continue the series soon but I'm kind of savoring it.
The next painting is one a little bit lighter in tone and that is called The Toilette.
And it was painted in 1889.
So in comparison to the last couple, and actually to a lot of John William Waterhouse's other
paintings, this one is a lot brighter, it's a lot more peaceful looking.
And the book that I kind of get this feeling from is I Capture the Castle by Dodie Smith.
It's kind of a perfect book to talk about in this video because one of the things that
I love about it so much is also the hardest to explain.
And that's like the feeling, like kind of the mix of like comfort and melancholy and
also like sweetness that I get from this book.
And that's also what I get from this painting.
So we have these two women who are kind of like getting ready and bonding or you know
spending time together.
I think of them as two sisters, which is also perfect for I Capture the Castle because it
is primarily about a family with two sisters and how they kind of react when a family of
Americans moves into their kind of countryside area.
This is set in England.
And the eldest daughter becomes determined to marry one of these American men in order
to save their house or castle that they live in from basically descending into ruin because
they live in very genteel poverty at this point.
And it is like a very light and comedic and engaging novel.
I feel like the tone of it is very like sweet and charming without being overly so.
But there are some kind of like darker moments or darker undercurrents in the story that
I think are also really interesting.
So getting into symbolism here, like as you can see in the background of the painting,
there's some plant life that is sort of like taking over the garden area.
Like there's like this very meticulously laid out garden and then there's all this greenery
and it's almost a little bit wild looking.
And that's kind of how I feel about I Capture the Castle is it's got this like veneer of
civility and of like very civilized comedy and that kind of like British classic feeling.
But underneath that there are some darker things going on.
Like the family, the main character and her family are afraid they're going to lose their
house at some point.
And there are also some darker elements with the relationships themselves with like the
desperation of her older sister Rose.
And from her perspective she needs to marry somebody in order to save her family.
I think that really brings out the other aspects of the novel is having that light and charming
atmosphere kind of contrasted with the darker aspects of the book as well.
I think it makes both halves of it feel more real because they are like kind of put next
to the other one.
It's not making any sense at all.
There's also a pivotal scene in the novel that takes place in kind of a garden greenhouse
kind of area.
And that's that also is what I'm reminded of when I look at this picture too.
And finally, the last painting book combo I'm going to talk about today starts with
The Beautiful Lady Without Pity.
And this was painted in 1893.
It is also known by its French name, which I am about to hopelessly mispronounce.
And that is La Belle Dame Saint-Merci.
And the novel I'm going to talk about is one that I have mentioned kind of briefly on my
channel.
And that is My Cousin Rachel by Daphne du Maurier.
Daphne du Maurier is of course known more for her novel Rebecca, but I enjoyed My Cousin
Rachel even more than Rebecca, I think.
And I feel like it's a little bit underappreciated when put next to some of her more famous works.
I think it is becoming more known now because of the new movie that just came out.
But I think this is just such a fantastic novel.
I feel like it really perfectly fits the kind of symbolism and the like depictions in this
painting.
So The Beautiful Lady Without Pity is death.
That's kind of important to know going in.
So as you can see in the painting, there is the beautiful woman, or death, and there is
a knight who is kind of ensnared by her.
And if you look closely, she's actually got him wrapped in her hair.
Like she's literally ensnared him with this symbol of feminine beauty, like with her hair.
And that is such a good representation of the character Rachel from the novel.
But something that's so interesting about the novel is seeing the very different ways
that it's possible to interpret her character, to interpret Rachel.
Because is she using her beauty and perceived helplessness to ensnare helpless men?
Or is she the victim here and she's looking for someone to rescue her?
There are so many ways to interpret her.
And even after reading the novel, it's like I have so many mixed feelings, I'm not exactly
sure what I think happened.
And it's so interesting to go and read reviews for this book after you've finished it, because
there are some people that are just so convinced of this one thing, and there are some people
that just are like me and have like no idea what really happened, but they loved it anyway.
I just think that's so encapsulated in this painting.
And another thing I want to point out is that the male figure in the painting is a literal
knight in shining armor.
And that is very appropriate for the novel as well, because part of what I think gets
Philip into trouble is this need he has to protect someone, whether or not they actually
need it or want it, and kind of how that misleads him into certain situations and how it makes
him misjudge people.
I think that's such a good metaphor for his need to protect what he perceives as this
helpless, beautiful woman, and whether or not that's actually the case is a different
story.
Okay everybody, so that is all I have for this video.
I don't know how this is going to turn out.
I had a lot of fun doing it.
I think it's a really cool way to talk about books that, you know, their central thing
that drew you to them or that made you enjoy them is something that is a little hard to
communicate to people in words.
So that's why I did paintings, you know, worth a thousand words.
Please let me know if you guys have read any of these books, what you thought of them,
or if you're planning to pick any of them up.
I will see you soon with another video, and I hope you love the next book you read.
Bye!