Body Mass Index of BMI often confuses people, so today BMI Explained - is the next focus for our A-Z of the NHS series
Join myself, Dr James Gill, along with consultant Dr Andy Stein as we look at what BMI means for your health. Whilst BMI is a valid tool for looking at risk, but also in the circumstances where body mass index breaks down - Mr Schwarzenegger we're looking at you!
James discusses some of the facts that contribute to appetite, and how approaches to diet and weight loss cannot be a one size fits all (But don't worry, we elected NOT to use the most emaciated picture of James from the Island to illustrate the point!)
Enjoy!
Please don’t forget to like and subscribe - especially as that will ensure you are notified for when the next session goes
00:00 - Introduction to BMI and Obesity 03:01 - The Prevalence of Obesity 03:55 - Addressing Obesity and Weight Loss Strategies 05:50 - Childhood Obesity Concerns 07:01 - Stigma and Misconceptions Surrounding Obesity 08:07 - Role of Diet and Nutrition in Managing Obesity 09:35 - Personal Experiences with Weight and Appetite Control 11:08 - Practical Steps for Managing Weight 13:02 - Considering Bariatric Surgery 16:11 - Final Thoughts
so we're on to the second half of our
bees we've
already looked at blood pressure and
breast cancer in the previous video the
link should be
try and put it here now what have we got
for our next
two andy okay so the next pair of b's
are going to be bmi or body mass index
and your favorite b12 deficiency
i'd like to start with bmi and i'm going
to use it as a surrogate for
obesity which is a subject i feel quite
passionate about bmi is a made-up number
you calculate it by knowing your weight
in kilos and then dividing that
by your height in meters squared
i went to medical school thinking i
could forget all of this mass and it
keeps coming back to haunt me all the
while
i can do bmi until i have to do the
square and i can't do that in my head
absolutely so it's quite difficult to
calculate the bmi
in your head because as i say it's your
weighting kilos
of your height in meters squared and
therefore
most of us will need a calculator for
that the normal bmi
of a normal human a slim human such as
yourself
is 20 to 25.
if you're 25 to 30
that's considered overweight and if
you're 30
and above that's obesity
i'm ashamed to say that my bmi is 31.
this is one of the reasons i'm
passionate about it because i'm a big
chap and i'm clearly
a little overweight i believe your bmi
is a little lower isn't it james yeah
i'm about 21 at the moment
but this is one of the problems with bmi
bmi is a broad brush stroke tool
so for example on schwarzenegger when he
was at his biggest
he actually was technically obese yet
despite having a body fat percentage
lower than mine at about eight percent
so there's always some issues with the
patient that we're talking about
so we need to make sure we're dealing
with the patient in front of us
not the computer numbers necessarily
absolutely
so bmi is a crude number
and it doesn't take into context
your build your stockiness i'm quite a
stocky chat an ex-rugby player
um it doesn't take into account that
certain races
for example people from west africa tend
to be
very stocky it doesn't take those into
account
nonetheless it's a simple number and
i think everybody should know how to
calculate their own
bmi if we then apply bmi to the whole
population
and look for people with obesity
staggeringly
in 2020 one in four people
25 of the population are now obese
so even though bmi is a broad brush
stroke tool
there is no doubt that a one in four you
know incident
shows that we have a problem and that's
why
we're constantly talking about weight
with patients because it has
so many effects we've already mentioned
today the blood pressure
and breast cancer can be affected can be
influenced by carrying
excess weight and in fact there are 50
known conditions
that are associated with obesity so it's
not just the things you've heard about
such as diabetes blood pressure as we
said earlier
and cancer there's lots of other things
and remember
if you're overweight you're going to be
doing a lot of pressure
on your hips your knees your ankles your
back
and therefore hip replacement and knee
replacements
are heading your way in later life
if you are obese and i actually see the
inverse problem of that in the gp
practice
quite often a patient will have
arthritis of the knee or arthritis of
the hip
but they are too heavy for the operation
to go ahead
patients can be very hurt by this but we
try to explain that that's because
if we put in a new joint then that joint
that operation is going to be
more difficult it'll be harder for them
to heal and recover
so again it's not just about the
long-term
issues that weight can cause but about
trying to get somebody
better than they are at the minute it's
not just obesity that's the problem
as i said 25 of the population is now
obese
35 are overweight so 60 percent
of the british population have a weight
problem and i find that number
staggering i think it's also a problem
for the
the mental approach to something like
this when
something becomes normal it's harder for
people to see that
as a problem so rather than the
you know the you're overweight you need
to do these things
and almost seeming critical i like to
look at it from the other side of things
when i've got patients who haven't liked
their blood pressure tablets and wanted
to come off them
and they improve their diet or they try
and do a little bit of exercise
and they change they lower their bmi and
they feel
good and they have more energy and they
have more enjoyment of life
rather than looking at it from that
negative side of things of
this person is at risk of these issues i
try and phrase it of
these are the benefits that you're
likely to get and how your life can be
enriched
by consciously trying to shift from a
morbid obesity and obesity and
overweight category
and the benefits that come with that
what worries me even more
about obesity is that it's getting worse
as i said 60 of the population are
overweight or obese
but that number was 50 in 1990 that's
30 years ago the biggest the most
worrying problem is children or
our children and unfortunately when you
look at
year six children that's the final year
of primary school
you now find that 15
of them are overweight and 20 are
already obese
so we have an epidemic both
in the population as a whole and
specifically in childhood
this worries me in some ways more than
covert now covid is bad there's no doubt
about that's been bad
for us all but covid will go
there is a problem with an attitude to
obesity that disturbs me
patients who are obese are stigmatized
in our society
in my opinion that affects them
personally
emotionally and also in terms
of their occupation and their ability
to advance in their occupation when we
look at an obese person
we have thoughts sometimes those
thoughts are i bet that person's funny
or i bet that person's jolly
or i bet that person is lazy so maybe
they won't work very hard so maybe we'll
give the job
to this other nice slim person
and i feel that obesity is the next
ism you say that we need to get rid of
obesity and you're absolutely correct
but like covid it's a multi-factorial
disease
and i will have umpteen patients come
and sit in front of me and some of them
in tears saying
i don't eat anything and no i do all the
exercise and i still
can't lose weight and unfortunately
there has been a huge problem with
patient education
and people have connected in the past
obesity with exercise and
appetite yes those two things are part
of it
but one of the things i'm very prominent
in saying to patients is
not all calories are created equal
so if you eat a thousand calories of
mars bars or a thousand calories of
carrots
that's going to have a very different
impact on your body
and this is why it's very difficult to
say your fat
have this diet it probably won't work
because of
each person being different and often
the diet needs to be tailored to the
person whether or not
that's to do with activity as well as
the diet or whether or not that's
due to the component to the diet some of
the patients that i tend to work with a
lot
who have weight issues diabetics
because of how their body no longer
deals with sugars
i frequently suggest diets that do not
involve calories going back to that not
all calories are created equal
so i we help patients lose weight
depending on what
they need and like dealing with breast
cancer
if you have a problem with your weight
and your you know wanting to address
that
come and talk to us we can help but i
can't help you if i don't
know about it and there's lots of things
that you can do online
there's lots of self-help information
but again one size does not fit all
so let us help you work out what you can
do to maximize your own body
and maximize your you know weight
and your control here i have difficulty
some ways when it comes to talking about
weight because i'm a slim person
a lot of the time as as andy has said um
weight gets stigmatized you know that
person is lazy they have issues with
appetite
i just want to highlight how appetite is
not always something that is in our
control
when i was on the island i lost 14 kilos
of weight and i'm sure there's some of
you saying
where is he going he lost weight on tv
how does that apply to obesity
when i came back i could eat
two large domino's pizzas back to back
there are other pizzas of brands
available my stomach would be distended
and uncomfortable
and i would still want to eat
i have been depressed in the past okay
and i'm medically depressed i talk to a
doctor they fix me up
okay and during that time i also had
an insane appetite there are things that
go on with people
that affect their appetite and as a
result of being on the island
my appetite is still shafted i have to
be careful
about how i eat yes again i know i am
slim
but i always now have an insatiable
and lots of people have different issues
whether or not it's mental health
whether or not it's biological
whether it's diabetes that your effect
of calories is different
we cannot say you're overweight do this
every person must be looked at on their
own
talk to us and let us help if you're
struggling with these things
let's think about what a patient can do
now i know many of you out there are
more like
me and not like him
i've got a problem in that i'm
overweight many of you
are overweight he is not he doesn't know
what it feels like he hasn't felt that
stigma
he hasn't felt the depression that
sometimes
goes with obesity
but there are things you can do to help
yourself
you can talk about it for one thing you
can talk about it to your friends and
family
you can go and see your gp a gp like
james
you can recognize the problem you can
calculate your own bmi
you can weigh yourself not too
frequently i think many patients
weigh themselves too frequently
and there are things you can do as james
has said there are diets that can be
recommended they may need to be
personalized
there's exercise so exercise is not a
great way of losing weight
on its own you can also focus on your
sleep
having a poor sleep pattern tends to
contribute to obesity so there are
things
you can do i don't know what you feel
about
things like weight watchers and
slimmer's world
james are those things that you
recommend absolutely
yes weight watchers is brilliant
slumming world is brilliant
as long as it works for the patient
patients can get access to those
themselves all through their gps
and if that works for them absolutely
champion
but it might not and that's not a
problem i've got no issue with a patient
coming and saying i've done
three things you know i've tried three
courses i've tried three diets whatever
and it doesn't work that's fine we'll do
a full thing and we'll do a fifth thing
there are lots of options out there and
it's keeping in mind
we have options and we can keep on going
to help you
there's an option i think more patients
should consider and
that is bariatric surgery bariatric
surgery basically
is a phrase for a range of operations
you can have
on your tummy which will help you lose
weight
an example is something called gastric
banding where
an elastic band or a large one is put at
the base of the esophagus
that's the tube from your mouth to your
stomach
just above the stomach they do that at
my hospital and many hospitals
it's a highly effective treatment and
it's one of the best ways of helping
patients with extreme obesity in fact i
have a story about this
a patient of mine who
was on dialysis and
i noticed that she was very obese
she was well above the 30 line in fact
was
nearer 40 for her bmi now
she was a woman in her late 50s and
normally we would consider her for a
kidney transplant
i was unsure as to whether this would be
a good idea
but one day i plucked up the courage to
talk to her about this
and i said madam would you like to be
considered for a kidney transplant
and she said she would i explained that
she was very overweight she recognized
that
she'd tried slemma's world and
weight watchers and everything else she
was a body child as they say
she said that everything had failed over
the years
she was embarrassed about her weight so
i explained to her
that if she wanted a kidney transplant
really there was only one option and
that was bariatric surgery which then i
explained to her i went through the
risks
of both the bariatric surgery and the
kidney transplant and she turned to me
and she said dr steen
i'm a gambler she was scottish you see
and i'll have it and she had both
she had bariatric surgery it worked
it took six months to work we got her
weight right down
and she had a transplant and that
transplant is still working
so her gamble paid off for her then her
gamble paid off
it worked so the go home message really
is
if you have either extreme obesity or
moderate obesity
or mild obesity seek help
but don't forget about bariatric surgery
is a good long-term therapy for obesity
and i don't i'll be honest i haven't had
many patients with bariatric surgery
but those that have have almost
universally credited it with saving
their lives
that they've been able to reduce they've
sometimes secured their diabetes as a
result
they've been able to reduce their blood
pressure medication this can be not
considered a
lifestyle approach but a life-saving
approach
so no matter what your weight is if
you're worried and you're not
affecting it yourself you're not happy
with your weight
talk to your doctors again we are here
to help
and i think that's important phrasing
there we're not here to fix your problem
we're here to help and that might mean
addressing problems you
didn't know that you had or dealing with
problems that you did but it's helping
overall
so please talk to us and i think that's
so far been one of the major messages
on this a to z of the nhs talk to us
about the things you're worried about
bmi is a
very personal and very sensitive topic
for a lot of people
and i think you've given us a really
good overview and
quite a lot of food for thought if
you'll pardon a slightly dubious pun
with bmi out of the way again i hope you
found some benefit in use in this video
if so please consider subscribing to the
channel and
you get updates when the next
video is out speaking of which the next
one
is based on b12 something that i'm
particularly passionate about
in the gp surgery you can find it at the
link just there
take care
[Music]
you