When people want to make an impression, most think a lot about what they want to say. Stanford Business Professor Deborah Gruenfeld cautions you to think twice about that approach. The factors influencing how people see you are surprising: Words account for 7% of what they take away, while body language counts for 55%. There is a body language of power. Gruenfeld introduces the body languages of authority and being approachable. Becoming fluent in matching body language to each situation can be a source of power and influence. Gruenfeld also shares leading social science research on the ways in which body language affects your psychology, in addition to influencing how others perceive you.
Deborah H Gruenfeld is the Moghadam Family Professor of Leadership and Organizational Behavior and the Codirector of the Executive Program for Women Leaders. She is a social psychologist whose research and teaching examine how people are transformed by the organizations and social structures in which they work. The author of numerous articles on the psychology of power, and on group behavior, Gruenfeld has taught popular courses on these and related topics to MBA students and executives at Stanford and at Northwestern University's J.L. Kellogg Graduate School of Management. Gruenfeld joined the Stanford Graduate School of Business in 2000.
Gruenfeld received her BA in psychology from Cornell University in 1983, her MA in journalism from New York University in 1985, and her PhD in psychology from the University of Illinois in 1993.
People are going to decide if you're competent or not in less than 100 milliseconds and then it's over.
So I can trace my interest in this topic back to something that happened to me in the 1980s.
Before I was an academic, I worked for a short time in public relations and found myself one
day in a meeting at nine o'clock in the morning with a very powerful entertainment industry
executive. And he had a little refrigerator at the edge of his desk. While we were meeting,
he would open it up, bottle of vodka, drank vodka straight out of the bottle,
and had a bag of raw onions. He was munching on those while this was going on.
And nobody said anything to him about it. We didn't react while it was happening. We didn't
talk about it afterwards. He didn't even offer to share anything with us. Seemed perfectly appropriate
to him to behave that way in a meeting with us. Would never have occurred to us to do that in a
meeting with him. I want to talk with you about power and I want to try to provide a new way of
thinking about how to approach situations where you want to have impact. One of the things that
I've observed in my work in this area is that most people, when they are trying to prepare for
a situation where they want to have influence, go into a meeting, or change somebody's mind,
is they tend to think a lot about what they're going to say in that situation. So I'm going to
suggest that rather than thinking about what you're going to say in situations like this,
you need to think about what your body's telling people. When people are forming an impression of
what you say accounts for only 7% of what they come away with. What I'd like to do today is to
start first by telling you a little bit about the actual mechanics of the body language of power.
What are the cues that we send and what do they mean? And then I'd like to talk with you about
how you can think about using those different cues to address specific challenges in specific
situations. There is actually a body language of power and we know it, but we know it so well
that we don't know that we know it. It's something that we've been learning through our socialization
since a very, very young age. So we learn how to tune our bodies to specific situations and
specific relationships. When we need to show someone respect or be deferential, we know how
to use our body in a way that allows us to be effective in that role. And we learn how to take
charge with our bodies and how to make sure that other people aren't taking advantage of us.
Most of us are socialized, you know, over the course of our lives based on other people's
expectations of where they think we should be within a hierarchy. And so we learn how to do
certain aspects of this sort of performance very well and other parts we know less well.
And sometimes we find ourselves in situations where the things we do with our bodies that
come most naturally don't fit the situation at all. So I want to raise awareness of the ways
in which we use our bodies and the impact that it has on our ability to have power and influence.
If you want to be strategic about acting with power, there are two objectives that you have
to keep in mind. The first one is that you want to be able to show up authoritative,
in charge, able to make the decisions, and able to privilege your knowledge and experience over
the knowledge and experience of other people. At the same time, you need to be able to show up
approachable, which is open, empathetic, willing to take others' knowledge and experiences into
account and be able to relate to people on a human level. So let me see if I can start by giving
you a framework for thinking about two main objectives for addressing this set of questions
about how your body language can be used to change your impact. There are really two things I think
you need to be able to do if you want to have influence. The first is you need to be able to
show up authoritative. Being authoritative means showing up and letting people know that you're in
charge. And what it involves psychologically and from a body language perspective is that you're
going to be closing yourself off a little bit to other people. You're privileging your knowledge
and experience over and above the knowledge and experience of other people. You're becoming more
directive and more concerned with controlling other people's behavior than from taking direction from
others. The second objective, and it's equally important, is that you need to be able to show up
approachable. Being approachable means that people feel that they can come to you with whatever's on
their mind and relate to you on a human level. Being approachable is just as important as knowing
how to show up authoritative. It's really the basis of your likability. It's the basis of the
extent to which other people want to be close to you. And it requires really a totally opposite
orientation from showing up authoritative. It really involves being more open to other people,
being prepared psychologically to relate to them on a human level.
And if you think about the challenge of showing up authoritative as increasing the psychological
distance between yourself and other people, either by raising yourself a little or by lowering others
a little, being approachable is really about shrinking the psychological distance between you
and other people. It's about lowering yourself a little or raising other people up. So in the
framework that I'm introducing to you today, which I call acting with power, the body language
associated with showing up authoritative is called playing high. And the body language associated with
showing up approachable is called playing low. The actions associated with playing high come from
what we observe whenever we look at animals or human beings in the context of a social hierarchy.
When you look at people with or group members with high rank, what you'll see is a general body
language that reflects a state of relaxation and openness because at the top of the hierarchy,
you have nothing to worry about. Everybody beneath you is going to make sure that nothing bad ever
happens. So playing high in a very general sense will look like a very open, expansive, relaxed body.
When walking, you assume others will move out of your path, taking up maximum space and allowing
your body and your gestures to flow into the space of other people. Other actions associated with
playing high include keeping your head perfectly still while talking and speaking in complete
sentences. So it's not important when you're playing high to have long sentences. In fact, they can be
very short, but they'll have a clear beginning and a clear end point. You'll also see people when
playing high holding eye contact a little longer than normal when addressing someone else. It's
actually an interesting relationship. I think the idea that staring someone down is associated with
playing high is something most people know, but actually it's a little more subtle than that.
So when you're playing high, you stare someone down when you're addressing them. You don't let
them out from under your gaze, so they know you're serious. But when they're addressing you, you're
free to look around. You get other things on your mind, other people you need to talk to, right? So
when you're being addressed by other people, you're free to look away. You don't check other
people's eyes for any reaction to what you've said, and you have no visible reaction to what other
people say either. You can interrupt before you know what you're going to say. It's important to
recognize that playing high is a source of dominance. Other people in many situations are
simply more likely to defer just based on how you use your body. It's also important to recognize
that playing high can be really dangerous. One of the easiest ways to get in trouble in a group
is to play higher than your actual rank. So the most general advice I can give about when to play
high is that you play high to reinforce your actual rank or in a competitive situation when
status is up for grabs. Let's talk about what it looks like to play low. When you observe natural
hierarchies in groups, what you'll see is that lower ranking members have a body language that's
exactly the opposite of what playing high looks like. Low ranking members hold their bodies very
close and tight. They try to make themselves as small as they can, minimize their footprint,
and do sort of prepare themselves to hide from other people or kind of fend off a blow. So you'll
see a much more an attempt to shrink a little bit and hide. So when someone's playing low,
you'll see them leaning forward and sometimes point their toes inward. It's all different ways
of making your footprint a little bit smaller. You'll see people speak in incomplete sentences
and when someone's playing low, you get a lot of fleeting and jerky movements,
talking with your hands near your face, and instead of looking directly at someone, a lot
more glancing around and looking away. They'll talk to you and just glance over to make sure
that it's going okay, but there's no actual eye contact. When a high status person is addressing
a lower status person, that's when the low status person's eyes are riveted.
So one of the other really interesting differences between people who are higher ranking
and lower ranking in groups is that you see a lot more smiling from the low ranking members
and it's not because things are better at the bottom. People in the lower ranks are smiling
because it's their job to make sure that the people above them are never uncomfortable.
So they're not genuine smiles. You get this kind of a fake apologetic smile. It's a badge of
appeasement, a way of making sure that people above them are feeling okay. Playing low is also
really important. It's the basis of building rapport. For a low ranking person, it's really
important that the people above you know that you understand your position and you respect theirs.
Playing low for a high status person actually makes you more approachable. You can gain status
as a high status person by playing low. So you're most likely to be effective when playing low
if you do it to reinforce your actual rank or when you want to lift someone else up.
So the next important question is how should you think about using this?
And I can tell you that I use it in two different ways. To make myself more comfortable in situations
where I'm afraid I'm not going to be able to show up the way I want to and I also use my body
language to help other people feel more comfortable in situations where I'm worried about that.
You can think about using your body language not to change the way you show up every day
in every situation, but as a way of meeting specific types of challenges.
When you walk into a situation and something unexpected happens, people aren't as receptive
as you expected them to be. You find that you're being attacked or you can't get someone who you
thought was going to be open to open up and tell you what you need to know. You can think about how
to adjust your body language to try to shift the dynamic and the relationship. So when you look at
men and women in leadership roles, what you find is that men and women don't actually behave
differently in these roles. They're perceived entirely differently doing exactly the same things.
So let me talk to you for a minute about women in power. And what that means is that we're
socialized to use the body language that's associated with having a lower rank. This is
not necessarily a problem. It just means that many of us are better versed in that body language
than we are in the body language of playing high. And the socialization has implications for how
women are viewed in different types of roles. Let me tell you about a study that was conducted by
one of my colleagues at Stanford. He was teaching a case in his MBA class about an entrepreneur from
Silicon Valley named Heidi Roizen. And she was very successful. And he used the case to illustrate
how effectively people can use social networks as a way of really building a business and building a
reputation. When his students read this case, they were very negative about her. And he was kind of
surprised by that. So he thought that it might have something to do with her gender. So my colleague
took the case about Heidi Roizen, and he changed the name of the protagonist to Howard Roizen,
and left all the other details the same. He gave half his students the case about Heidi.
He gave the other half of his students the case about Howard. Before they came into class,
they rated Heidi or Howard on a bunch of different dimensions. First, they were asked,
how humble and genuine and likable was this person? And Howard was the winner of that contest.
The second set of questions they were asked had to do with how self-interested and power-hungry
the protagonist was. And it might not surprise you to know that Heidi won that contest. The female
actor was judged much more harshly for exactly the same behaviors as her male counterpart. Heidi and
Howard were judged as equally competent. But when asked who they prefer to work with and who they'd
rather hire, the students preferred Howard. So the reason I talk about this case in my executive
education classes is because I think it illustrates a problem that a lot of women face.
We're being held to these dual expectations. The expectations associated with our gender roles
require us to behave in the ways that are associated with playing low. It's expected of us,
and it's a way that we can navigate situations where people want us to make them feel good,
because that's what's expected of women. We're also expected in our organizational roles to
behave in ways that are authoritative. So we have to have those tools available to us,
and we have to be able to give ourselves permission to use them when the situation
requires. But I think one of the interesting possibilities for women is to think about,
are there ways of combining those two different ways of behaving that allow us to meet both sets
of expectations? Not necessarily in the same moment, but over the course of our day, over
the course of our careers. A couple of my colleagues at Harvard and Columbia did a study.
They looked at whether putting people into different body positions would affect their
psychology and the way they responded to different types of situations. So they took the participants
and physically posed them either in expansive postures with their arm across the back of a
chair, their feet up on the desk, or they posed them into more constrictive postures where their
knees were touching, their elbows were held close to the side, and they had their hands,
let's say they were sitting on their hands or between their knees. So after two minutes in
these postures, my colleagues measured a number of different things. One of the things they were
interested in was in hormone levels. They looked at two hormones in particular. Measurements were
taken before the participants were posed in the posture to get a kind of a natural or baseline
level, and then measurements were taken after two minutes in the posture. They looked at testosterone
levels. So testosterone is the hormone that's associated with aggression and dominance,
and they looked at cortisol levels. Cortisol is the hormone that's associated with stress
and responses to threat, and it's responsible for a lot of the stress-related illnesses.
After two minutes in the posture, participants who were posed expansively had significant increases
in their testosterone levels, and participants who were posed submissively or in a more constricted
way had significant increases in their cortisol levels. And you can think about using your body
language to intervene in your own state of mind. I've had about six months in my new role, and a
key component of this job is to give presentations to fairly sizable groups of women. When I walk
into these rooms, I know that I have to be very centered, take up a lot of space, use my voice
and project it, but stay very stable. And every time I do this, it becomes more natural. So I'm
trying to figure out how to find that balance between friendliness, which comes naturally to
me, and this display of competence, which I feel like I have and I should show. After taking Professor
Grunfeld's class, it really opened my eyes as to when I walk into a room, I need to look around
and assess and think, do I want to play high or do I want to play low? When I'm listening, it's really
important for me to seem approachable and open. And when I'm presenting, I want to seem authoritative.
The majority of my communication with clients takes place over the telephone, including the
all-important client pitch. So although they can't see me, I completely understand how important it
is for me to convey this strong presence. So I'll do three things. First is I make sure that I'm
standing up. I walk around the room so I'm not constricted in my movements. I use my body language,
my gestures. And the third thing is that I make sure that I project my voice. Often I'll talk to
junior women about managing perceptions. Things as simple as how you're sitting in your chair.
Are you sitting with your head tilted to the side and making yourself small? Or are you occupying
your space and making yourself square and big? What about your voice? Are you going up at the
end of every sentence? Or are you speaking in a calm, controlled manner? Are you making eye contact?
These things are all evolutionary cues that help humans determine one another's status. And it's
really important to be in control of how you're perceived. I've been a professional for 25 years.
It's taken the entire 25 years for me to learn that to go from authoritative to being approachable
can still produce results. And I think I'm still learning. Being successful in an organizational
role is not just about being able to play high. It's not just about being able to play low. It's
about being able to recognize what situations require and to be able to adapt to those
situations. What I'm talking about is making really subtle kinds of changes. This is not about a major
overhaul of your behavior. Sometimes it's just about backing off things that you use in a kind
of an impulsive or knee-jerk way to make really slight adjustments that you'll find can have a
huge impact in terms of how other people see you and in terms of how you behave and how you feel.
It's important for women to recognize that there are dual challenges that we face.
One is to meet the expectations associated with high-level organizational roles,
and the other is to meet the expectations associated with our gender roles. It's the
balance between playing high and playing low that I think makes most managers effective and
this may be especially important for women. I just want to encourage you to give yourselves
permission to try something new. The next time you feel challenged, you go into a situation
where it's important to you to be seen in a certain way, where you want to have a particular
type of impact, think about how you're standing when you walk into the room. Think about how you
sit down. Think about what you're doing with your head and your eyes when you're speaking
and how you look when you're listening and see what happens.
Everything we need is already there. Everything we need is already in us.
It's just a question of giving yourself permission to find it and use it.