00:00 - Introduction 02:03 - What is Epilepsy? 03:45 - Types of Seizures and Epilepsy Explained 04:39 - Different Seizure Types in Practice 05:27 - Understanding Grand Mal Epilepsy and Aura Phenomenon 08:24 - Trigger of Photosensitive Epilepsy 12:48 - Public Health Warnings 13:58 - Dispelling Myths: One Seizure and Driving Eligibility 16:01 - Unprovoked Seizures 16:50 - Brain Tumors and Epilepsy 18:58 - Investigating Epilepsy: Tests and EEG 22:45 - Febrile Seizures 24:01 - "One Free Fit" Concept and Normalizing Single Seizure Experiences 25:24 - Medical Language and Labels 28:56 - Induced Seizures for Treating Depression 29:33 - Electric Shock Therapy 31:04 - Conclusion
hello ladies and gents and welcome back
to the a to z of the nhs you're joining
myself dr james gill and one of the big
dogs dr andy stein one of our renal
consultants and today we're going to
carry on with the letter e so andy what
have you brought us on the e side of
things today today's
topic is going to be epilepsy and i
thought we'd talk about it because a
it's very common and b
we're reminded about it on a daily basis
on the news
okay so i suppose that suggests suddenly
the tv you're watching is a little bit
more exciting than mine perhaps but okay
so we're going to do epilepsy and we're
going to follow with the
the setup that we had in the previous
videos we're going to do a fact versus
fiction we're going to dispel a myth and
also we're going to talk about something
the doctor doesn't tell you when it
comes to epilepsy so what are the three
that we're going to be looking at there
so in terms of
fact or fiction i thought we would
debate whether
flashing lights really precipitate
epilepsy or a single seizure or not are
you a pokemon fan as well andy pokemon
what's that is that is that a form of
sport or what is that well in that case
we'll see how pokemon connects to
epilepsy shortly i think for dispelling
myths we will debate whether having one
seizure
stops you from driving or not in terms
of what the doctor doesn't tell you i
thought we would debate whether
one fit makes you
an epileptic or not
and also i'm going to talk more about
tics and adverbs and why doctors don't
do adverbs right if that sounds
interesting to yourselves join us as we
carry on to discuss epilepsy
start off let's just give a quick run
through for those at home refresh my
memory because i'm only a simple gp
what's epilepsy
epilepsy is a very common condition
affecting one to two percent of the
population to put that in perspective
diabetes is about two to five percent so
it's one of the commoner chronic
conditions
that means that with a population of
about 65 million approximately
half to 1 million people in this country
have epilepsy
if you add all types of
epilepsy seizures and fits in fact it
means 10 of the population
will have a fit at some point in their
lives that's actually a really good
number so i'm very lucky that i still
have a close um connections with the
guys i was at university with not
medical school but from my first degree
and there's about 10 of us got a degree
i know amazingly you never told me that
i've also got a master's as well you
never told me that either i assumed
you're an imposter
anyway on with the show i'm very lucky
the that i was um i've still got close
connections with you know 10 other
people as it um did my first degree and
nottingham with and i don't think them
one of them were mine but one of them
has had a seizure and you know he
doesn't have a diagnosis of epilepsy but
he has had that seizure which has caused
significant issues for him in terms of
driving particularly because he's from
what wales and
in the rural parts of wales you really
do need a car over there to get around
so you know that number is actually
quite you know accurate in my personal
experience not even just as a medic what
is epilepsy
epilepsy is a condition usually chronic
it can be acute in other words you can
have it over a short period and never
again it's characterized by sudden
bursts of electrical activity
that lead to seizures or as they're
sometimes called fits or epileptic fits
that's what epilepsy is so you've said
about epilepsy there what what's the
seizure then
the
clinical the medical event
leading from epilepsy
so epilepsy if you like is
a syndrome of which there are many
causes which we'll talk about later
characterized by these events called
seizures or fits
i thought we'd talk a bit more about
the various types of epilepsy is is that
relevant to you in general practice i
think so because it's
when i'm dealing with the lifestyle side
of things it doesn't matter whether or
not the patient has had a grand mal so
that's the sort of the classic seizure
that people sort of have from tv no the
person shaking doesn't matter whether
it's a grand mal or whether or not it's
an absent seizure they're just you know
not the person's gone vacant they're not
there anymore these still have that same
repercussions in terms of their
lifestyle so absolutely okay so there
are various types of epilepsy
what i'm about to tell you is largely
taken from when i was at medical school
a long time ago but interestingly most
textbooks are now going back to these
older classifications and
the type of epilepsy that most people
have heard of is the one that you just
mentioned which is grand mal epilepsy
this is the tonic clonic seizure which
you think of as classical epilepsy that
you see on the television or in videos
or whatever where
the patient shakes their whole body is
shaking
they become unconscious
they bite their tongue they froth at the
mouth
and after it
they're in a post-epileptic state where
they are drowsy
and confused for a while they may or may
not have an aura that's the feeling that
they're about to have a grand male fit
and this is the type of epilepsy that
most of us consider if you like true
lord classical epilepsy now i find that
that aura the sense that something's
going to happen absolutely fascinating
in the sense that we can't fully explain
what it is yet however we can train a
dog to detect it early so that they can
actually tell the patient you're going
to well
lassie pops up hey you know you're going
to have a seizure so the patient can sit
down on the floor so they're less likely
to have that seizure you know in a way
that could injure themselves yet we've
not got that
thing yet but i think this is the
wonderful thing about medicine how
there's so many things we don't fully
understand yet i mean one of your
colleagues at uhw um prof wycott who is
probably one of the most intelligent
people i know have you seen the stuff
that he did um with professor arister
adam about creating an electronic nose
no i haven't thought absolutely amazing
about smelling cancers in urine and
things like that and wow personally i
think that
dogs are known for their sense of smell
i wonder whether or not the the
electronic nose could be pivoted to have
you know to create perhaps something you
know a handheld device that could be
worn maybe for detection of epilepsies i
must admit i don't know much about dogs
and sniffing and what dogs can do but i
do know from friends who have dogs that
they say they can tell whether their
owner is ill or not and even where the
illness is so i'm willing to believe
that so
it's a disease of which there are
various types we've talked about ground
male epilepsy
there is another type called petty mao
there are other phrases like
simple and complex partial seizures
there are absences and there are other
rarer types of epilepsy i don't think
we'll go through them all today
the key thing is the latter group that
i've described don't always involve a
complete loss of consciousness which
grand male seizures
are linked to well so you know we've got
a good summation there about what
epilepsy is so let's let's go to our
three questions so um shall we try to
spell a fact versus fiction here okay
so
when you watch the news or some
television programs there's often a
warning about flashing lights and either
they say directly that this could lead
to epilepsy or there's an implication
that it might so they tell the entire
world to turn away from the flashing
lights they're about to appear
and
is this true or not is this sensible or
not so
is it true or not well the short answer
yes it is true
there is a subset of people mainly with
grand mal epilepsy
who have a form called photosensitive
epilepsy in other words
flashing lights or things like flashing
lights in other words where there's a
rapidly alternating image such as an
overhead fan
or
uh
the
site of an emergency vehicle
um or a fluorescent bulb on the brink
or the television itself precipitating
an epileptic fit or or a series of fit
so
there is this subgroup of people
for which this happens because it's
actually specifically the change in
luminance from the bright to dark and
those same people could
could actually be affected by simply a
static picture of bars and you know
lights and blacks lights and blacks
could do it as well although that's l it
is rarer but it's still the same pathway
that gets affected we think um i must
admit i i didn't know that i i do know
that this subset of people with
photosensitive epilepsy
are very grateful for these warnings
they are also taught to be careful by
not watching television in a dark room
for example not watching television or
or a video very close up however
and
you can tell viewers whenever i do it
however
i'm not so sure whether we really should
be having these warnings
to us every day
every evening every night every time we
turn the television on what do you think
james well to be fair i don't recall
when i last saw them so i'm not sure
they're that frequent but let me do you
know where that he's such a cyber nut he
doesn't have a television but don't tell
anybody
do you know where the uh you know the
biggest episode of you know seizures uh
came from i don't but i've got a feeling
you're gonna tell me i've been on on the
edge of my seat with this i've got a
pokemon thing for you so pokemon is
japanese for pocket monster 1997 there
was an episode of pokemon this cartoon
show which is shown in japan
and there was a series of flashing
lights in it
that hit that sort of specific frequency
off the top of my head i think it's
about 20 hertz so 20 cycles per second i
could be wrong on that though and that
caused a large number of children i
think about 300 children had seizures
directly as a result of this tv show and
that's one of the way uh
points that the sort of the watershed
hold on we need to make sure that when
there is this going forward we warn
people about it and it can happen with
computer games as well you know anything
sort of rapidly firing like that but the
the warnings on computer games are less
accurate the reason why i say accurate
is we've got a piece of software that we
can put a movie or a tv show or
something or a news clip through and
it'll give a warning hold on there's the
risk of seizure with what's going on
here hence we'll get the warning however
because you can play a computer game
from so many different angles and things
like that i mean you choose how you're
going to go through the dungeon etcetera
and fps you can't guarantee how
the flaming torch on a wall will be seen
by everybody so the warnings on a
computer game are less
accurate than they are for tv if it's on
tv or movie it tends to mean that the
computer algorithm said hold on we've
seen flashing lights at a high enough
frequency here
that's very interesting i must admit i
have no idea what he's talking about all
i know is that these pokemony thingies
and
uh xboxy thingies are a load of
unwanted
crazy hurley burly
warning old man rants at sky i think we
should discuss now just because
something can happen whether we should
warn the public
about everything all the dangers of
everything in life so for example james
why when we're about to watch the news
and the weather is a bit cold and icy
which it often is in our lovely country
does the bbc not warn the elderly
not to go out and if they go out to wear
sensible clark's shoes i just raised
this point viewers because
i think there is a counter argument
whereby
one can warn the public about so many
risks so many problems so many things
that might happen
we can be paralyzed with fear and not go
out at all it's a bit like
negative signage
if you tell people not to spit they may
feel like spitting even if they didn't
start the day thinking they wanted to
spit and i think that
warning people about risks in society
develop a fear and
anti-culture that may not be
mentally healthy
i'm not sure to agree with that
necessarily i'm not sure that someone
sees a danger of seizure sign and says
right i'm going to have one just to
you know annoy the sign however
i do think that generally we can
probably over warn people and as a
result of that you stop paying attention
to the warnings generally
i think we're going to move on now and
talk about dispelling myths is that
right
the myth
we're going to talk about
is whether having one seizure
causes you to lose your driving license
or not um is that a problem for you in
general practice james
the
it's the it's one of the biggest fears
for patients when they have a seizure or
that label of epilepsy hold on am i no
longer going to be able to drive that's
my livelihood done my life's over
because part of our modern world
requires the ability to get from a to b
normally when somebody desires it so
public transport can still be used but
it is very difficult
so i think that's a big issue yes
but is it because it's a big issue or is
there any other reason i've heard that
gps now
often don't investigate and treat
epilepsy themselves they send patients
to a brain doctor called a neurologist
in a hospital is that right
i wouldn't describe it as quite that i'm
batting the work away but we have a
pathway of anybody that's had that first
seizure we put them into the first
seizure clinic now the reason being is
largely it's twofold one how big an
impact is this going to have on the
patient's life
as in can they drive can they go
swimming and things
or
and how big a medical issue is this
going to be so have you had you'll see
what's the cause of your seizure we can
have a provoked seizure such as an
unwarranted episode of pokemon um there
we say right we know what caused it
this may happen again so we have to be
extra cautious with that person
however we may have an unprovoked
seizure where we've got no idea where
and why it's come from in that patient
we want to be so much more cautious
because we don't know what gave rise to
it
now the unprovoked seizure is the
problem for us generally because we just
don't have an answer for it what caused
it when's it going to happen again will
it ever happen again so many unknowns
so we put more restrictions on that
patient
conversely one of the other
things with that first seizure clinic
finding out the cause of it we may find
something
much more troubling than the seizure in
itself so for example you could have a
seizure because of a brain tumor and the
first
evidence of that brain tumor is the
seizure and that's why
we put them into the first seizure
clinic because we have those excellent
consultants that got access to all the
big toys so they can quickly streamline
patients so we can have as minimal
impact and that minimal impact still
maybe six months of not driving on their
life versus actually we've found other
things we can quickly get them into the
system
perhaps to deal with the brain tumor or
something like that
that's a bit worrying about brain tumors
our brain tumor is
are they common cause of epilepsy
thankfully they're not and the commonest
cause of epilepsy is that um or the
commonest cause of a seizure should i
say is that unprovoked one where there's
we don't know why it happened but
thankfully it never happens again for
that patient uh james is right on that
it's about one-third two-thirds so so
one-third of patients
have
what we call an unprovoked seizure or
idiopathic or unknown epilepsy where
there's no underlying cause and that may
or may not go into a chronic condition
in which they have more and about
two-thirds of the mixed bag of other
causes including strokes head injury
metabolic causes like diabetes brain
tumors
in terms of brain tumors it's important
to realize that they're not all cancer
you get benign brain tumors and some of
the cancerous ones are
not as serious as others
so uh it's important not to wave from
this video thinking that everybody with
epilepsy has a brain tumor and that's uh
serious that that's absolutely not true
you say that you have benign brain
tumors as well one of my bosses uh one
of the senior gps for years she had a
benign brain tumor and she called it
dory
story but i think that was how she'd
dealt with it
there must be something about doctors
and benign brain tumors i know of
another doctor who presented with
epilepsy and was found to have a rare
disease called acoustic neuroma you
could look that one up viewers
which was entirely treatable and
when it was removed he was
fine okay
so
what i'd like to do now is just talk a
bit about
the investigation of epilepsy so uh what
happens when james sends a patient to
the hospital to these first fit clinics
what do you think happens in james what
what test do you think they have
well i imagine it's going to be because
we've got the possibility of an unknown
seizure it's going to be a full top to
tail workup so the bloods to look as you
said the metabolics the scans to make
sure we can't find a cause of it and
that crucial one that i don't know quite
so much about the eeg where we're going
to look at the electrical trace of the
brain
absolutely right so those are the tests
we do basic blood tests imaging such as
a chest x-ray
a ct of the head or even an mri of the
head which is if you like a super
ct and this
funny test called an eeg which you have
electrodes put on your head and the
electrical activity inside the head is
measured and you get loads of wiggly
lines i think most people would follow
along you know right we're getting head
this head that head that why would they
do a chest x-ray
chest x-ray really is just part of the
work-up of of many long-term diseases
there can be things on it that you
didn't predict or there may be a second
diagnosis that may be relevant
but the real reason for doing a chest
x-ray is
if there is a tumor in the brain is it a
primary tumor in other words has it
arisen in the brain or has it spread
from somewhere
and in both men and women particularly
those who have smoked
brain tumors often come from a lung
cancer and that's why we do a chest
x-ray
and in women of course breast cancer
which can spread to the brain as well so
that's the reason why we do a chest
x-ray
talking about breast cancer it's very
important to realize
that the history there the questions we
ask a patient examination are just or as
more important in epilepsy than the
investigations everybody forgets for
example in the breast for example that's
a very important thing to do
but
it's important to do a full general
examination and not just a neurological
examination and part of the reason for
that is
as we said earlier about in a third of
patients investigations revealed nothing
in other words the patient has
idiopathic or
unknown cause of epilepsy and also
because we know that the
eeg
actually isn't that useful uh it's only
abnormal in about 10 of patients with
epilepsy and also the other way around
you can have an abnormal eg
and have a normal brain and no epilepsy
so it's not a great investigation really
and just to link back to our previous
topics if you want to click up here you
can go to our breast cancer discussion
although it's not quite as slick as
the the chats we're doing now should we
move on to the third bit of our
talk today our discussion today and
that's about what doctors don't tell you
yes and i i think i'll i'll start off
this little bit because i i i used to
come across this particular aspect when
i was in the a e department so we've
talked all about seizures at the moment
and the first seizure clinic and all the
associated problems with that but we're
all allowed one seizure it's not the end
of the world to have that single seizure
and that's what you know as doctors we
don't tell people a lot um and i think
the reason being is that one of the
commonest causes particularly in
children is that febrile seizure so
often in the any department i would have
a child come to me with the parents who
they've got a temperature of 40 41
degrees celsius and they'd had a seizure
at home heck even one of my good friends
he brought as an e nurse he brought his
child in having a febrile seizure and i
think that that for me was a great
exercise
in knowledge control because on the one
side he's there as a parent with his
fitting child but on the other side he
has dealt with
parents of fitting children at length
and i must confess i was astonished with
the level of calm and reassurance that
he had for himself and his child with
that one
well funnily enough a similar thing has
happened to me and my family
my
daughter
when she was a lot younger had a friend
who had a single seizure following
a fever what we call a febrile
convulsion as james says
and nobody anywhere labeled her with the
words epilepsy or epileptic
um and neither did i and i was able to
reassure the family that i didn't think
this was going to be a long-term problem
and it and it hasn't been anyway
back to what doctors don't tell you um
my little phrase for it is that we are
all allowed a free fit
uh and that's because
deep down
we all have epilepsy we are all
epileptics because what epilepsy is is a
syndrome
a group of diseases that can have a
cause or may not have a cause but
deeper than that what it is
is a way that the brain reacts when it's
under stress or
combination of stresses
so
i could develop epilepsy today and so
could you and so could you viewers but
it is
relatively rare though two to five
percent of the population maybe is not
that rare so it's not something i spent
a lot of my life worrying about and i i
wouldn't suggest that you should either
so i think what you're saying there is
that we all have the potential to have a
seizure we all have the potential to
potentially develop epilepsy but our
bodies have systems to ground out excess
activity so it never actually happens
and manifests would that be absolutely
that's really a nice summary
and finally i'd like to discuss
adverbs i have a particular
dislike of adverbs i have a dislike of
them within medicine
because i find them judgmental
in other words if you label somebody
with the
adverb epileptic
or asthmatic or
diabetic
it conjures up a mental picture of what
that person might be like so some people
might think that someone's epilepsy
is less intelligent and if they're less
intelligent they're less able and
therefore you may not give them the job
or it may can drop a picture
of learning difficulties
or it may
conjure up a picture of something else
that is clearly not true
so i think it's very important as health
professionals that we choose our words
carefully
don't do adverbs
actually i would agree with that
completely i think the one tweak that
i'd have with it is mrs jones has
epilepsy absolutely but i think that in
broad context we can talk about
epileptics in the abstract just simply
for use of language
but i agree completely we should not be
labeling people as you are this thing
it's not you you're a person that has
this problem
agreed and so
working on that
mr smith could have diabetes
but we could talk about diabetics in the
abstract in some form of
technical conversation or a presentation
like this
but not describe
mr smith as a diabetic
man or a diabetic engineer or whatever
because
it is as i say
judgmental and creates unusual images in
the brain about them
well it's not only that it's the it's
the way that
so
in gp land one of the things that we ask
is that um you give a quick summary to
the receptionist so they can say what's
you know what is they want to talk to
their doctor about and that means i can
prime my brain beforehand and if um i've
got a patient that's got you know that
said low mood right i know i'm going to
go down this route and if i say you know
foot hurts right i know i'm going to go
down this route however
if we've got you know
diabetic review
then that can prejudice almost because
you create the diabetic image rather
than mrs jones with diabetes so i think
it's really interesting how
we have to work with these
[Music]
phrases but we also need to be very
careful about how
we allow them to control us as
clinicians and make sure we're very
careful about not allowing that to
result in prejudice decision making
actually we talk about diabetics
there but
one of the things that we worry about
with patients with diabetes is that they
potentially could have too much insulin
and they could go hypo they could have
low blood sugar
and as a result of going hypo you can
cause a hypoglycemic seizure
but
this is where that the you know i think
it kind of links that we're allowed a
free seizure because we can use seizures
in in psychiatry
we can induce a seizure
by giving somebody insulin someone who
doesn't have diabetes we'll give them
insulin to produce a hypoglycemic
seizure in the hopes of improving
treatment resistant depression and we
don't do it very often but the patients
that have had it
do say actually this has been
a a life-changing
event for me because it sort of
resets things but that's done in a very
careful very controlled environment
that's really interesting i didn't know
that and it's like the electro electric
shock convulsive therapy where again we
induce a seizure by putting electric
currents through the the brain and
at medical school i thought the concept
of electric shock therapy was barbaric
and i will use that word and that was
because i was prejudiced
probably because i had one flew of the
cuckoo's nest and i thought you know
gosh how could somebody do this this is
terrible
and
i do not have that opinion now for two
reasons one i have seen
the shock therapies performed and the
patients have said that you know
they had not the patient that i've seen
that has had electric shock convulsive
therapy said it completely changed their
life because nothing worked for them the
counseling didn't work the medications
didn't work and they were battling with
thoughts about wanting to kill
themselves we essentially
reset the patient and they still have
you know mental health problems but they
don't have the same horrendous urges
that they did
but that's in the abstract that is in
you know patients that i have seen touch
base with and then life is continued
my grandad
my personal hero one of the best people
i ever knew
had electric shock therapy for treatment
resistant depression
and i would have never known that he had
had those sorts of mental health
problems unless someone told me
so what i think james is saying is from
the undiscovered country
from who's born no man has returned
he has now described some scenarios
where
men have returned
and i think on that point um we'll leave
the shakespeare and the epilepsy be so
thank you very much for joining us i
hope that you found this useful
stimulating and interesting and we'll
see you in the next one thank you take
care bye