Why a divided South Korea is part of China’s strategy in East Asia

Lei's Real Talk
1.5K followers
881 Video Views·Feb 16, 2025
South Korea's political landscape has long been a focal point for external forces, including China and the United States. The ongoing political upheaval in the country—where conservatives and liberals are locked in a fierce battle over President Yoon’s impeachment—has its origins.
0:51 Historical review of China and U.S. relations with South Korea
3:33 Why are South Korean politics so divided?
5:31 Why does South Korea matter so much to Beijing in its East Asia strategy?
7:24 The CCP’s strategy in East Asia vs. the “iron triangle”
South Korea's political landscape has long been a focal point for external forces,
including China, the United States, Japan, and the others. The ongoing political upheaval in
the country, where conservatives and liberals are locked in a fierce battle over President
Yoon's impeachment, carries profound geopolitical implications. It's been reported in the West,
but I think very superficially, without depth and real insights. However, its impact extends
far beyond South Korea and the Asia-Pacific region. So before addressing why South Korean
politics are so divided, let's review South Korea's relations with the North, China, and the
U.S. Since its founding, South Korea has consistently faced military threats from the North.
From the late 1940s to the early 1970s, North Korea was far wealthier than the South,
due to two reasons. The first was the support of the Soviet Union, and the second was the
industrialization in the North that was left from the Japanese colonial period.
At that time, South Korea could not compete with the North in terms of economy or military
capabilities. So South Koreans heavily relied on a military alliance with the U.S. to deter
North Korean military threats. Under President Park Chung-hee, South Korea achieved rapid economic
development and democratization, and surpassed the North economically in the late 1980s.
After South Korea and China established diplomatic relations, South Korea took full
advantage of the Chinese market and inexpensive labor, leading to another phase of rapid economic
growth. Since the 1990s, South Korea has adopted a strategy that relies on the U.S. for national
security and depends on China for economic growth. So the policy is referred to as
security from the U.S. and economy from China. However, by the 2010s, China was no longer merely
an economic partner for South Korea, but a major competitor. Xi Jinping's policies,
such as the national security law, the anti-espionage law, and zero COVID, have driven
foreign businesses away. Additionally, the growing pressure from the U.S.-led western countries on
China's economy and security has intensified. As a result, South Korea now has no choice
but to prioritize cooperation with the U.S. for both economic and security concerns,
and China is no longer a primary partner for South Korea. However, many Korean citizens,
Korean elites, and politicians who have been carefully groomed by Beijing aren't ready for
strategic change because Korean politics have always been very divided.
In terms of political orientation, South Korean politics can be divided into conservatives
and the left wing, the conservative People's Power Party and the leftist Democratic Party of Korea.
Internationally, the pro-American faction aligns with the conservative right,
while the pro-North and pro-China faction aligns with the left wing Democratic Party.
The 70-year political history of South Korea is essentially a struggle between these two factions.
The term of South Korean president is only five years, and they cannot be re-elected.
Therefore, every president must complete their political achievements
within the five years to ensure their party can continue governing. Conversely, the opposition
party would do everything to prevent the president from achieving anything or any success. Whatever
the president proposes, the opposition will oppose it. The opposition party does not cooperate with
the president or the ruling party because helping the president succeed will mean no chance for them
to win in the next presidential election. This applies to both parties. Whichever party is in
power, this problem persists. Historically, the relationship between the left wing and the right
wing in South Korea has been terrible. There's a lack of mutual trust and no mechanisms for
collaboration or reconciliation between the two sides. This is one of the biggest issues in South
Korean politics. To complicate the matter, the Chinese Communist Party and the North Koreans
have undoubtedly exploited this gap and taken advantage. For Beijing, the most important foreign
relations is the one with the United States, but the most sensitive one is with South Korea.
So why South Korea holds the most sensitive relations with the CCP? The reason is very
simple. The geographical proximity between the two countries. The shortest distance from South
Korea to Beijing is only 900 kilometers, which is about 550 miles, which is only a half-hour flight
for an ordinary jet and 20 minutes for a more advanced jet. South Korea has a large presence
of American troops. The United States has about 23,000 troops stationed in South Korea. To put
this into perspective, after the war in Afghanistan, U.S. troop levels there never exceeded 10,000
despite daily conflicts in Afghanistan at the time. South Korea, being the country that's
the closest to China, with a large American military presence, becomes a very touchy subject
to the Chinese. For the CCP, the U.S. military presence in South Korea is what people say is
like a dagger placed right next to one's heart. As a result, the CCP has deployed its most advanced
air defense systems in the Bohai Bay area. For example, in the past, the CCP's 39th Army
was always stationed in a heavily fortified area in Wafangdian area in Dalian in the Liaoning
province, with the Luzon port in front and the Huludao in the back.
The U.S. Indo-Pacific strategy has several components. One of them is the military alliance
with Japan and South Korea. It's often referred to as the Iron Triangle. The proximity of this
alliance to the CCP's core regions also makes Beijing uneasy. In addition to the 23,000 troops
in South Korea, the United States has about 36,000 troops in Japan. The combined U.S. troop presence
in Japan and South Korea is approximately 60,000. That's significant. Although ostensibly
aimed at North Korea, this alliance is primarily to counter China and Russia.
In the current geopolitical context, it's mostly to counter China. This is why of all of China's
neighbors, except Taiwan, South Korea is the country where the CCP has exerted the most influence.
For the CCP, breaking this U.S., Japan, and South Korea military alliance is of critical importance.
The weakest link in this alliance is the South Korea-Japan relationship. In other words,
disrupting the relationship between South Korea and Japan has been a key CCP objective. During
Moon Jae-in's administration, the CCP achieved considerable success in this regard. South
Korea's relationship with the CCP became very close, while its diplomatic, political, and military
ties with Japan plunged to a freezing point. Even economic and trade relations were affected.
Military relations were particularly strained, with South Korea and Japan not only
halting all military interactions but also ending intelligence sharing. The U.S.-South
Korea military relations also weakened, with joint military exercises between the two countries
significantly reduced in scale and frequency. The Moon Jae-in era was regarded by the CCP as
the most successful period in dealing with South Korean affairs. However, after
Yun So-hyuk became president, the situation changed dramatically. Not only is Yun pro-American,
but he has also greatly improved relations with Japan, leading to the restoration of the Iron
Triangle. Now with Donald Trump about to take office again, the CCP feels a greater need to
break that Iron Triangle. So this context is an important backdrop to the current situation in
South Korea.
