Andrew Yang at SXSW 2019 (Full Interview)

Andrew Yang
1 follower
#Andrewyang #Politicians
Andrew Yang interviews himself at SXSW 2019.
Hello, everyone, welcome.
So I was supposed to be interviewed by a friend of mine, Kevin Roos,
who had some travel issues.
So I'm now interviewing myself.
And so I decided to ask the question that's been on my mind,
my wife's mind, for quite some time.
Andrew, how do you come up with such innovative ideas?
It's like, well, I'm glad you asked.
A lot of people ask me that.
So thank you all for being here today.
I really appreciate it.
How many of you know a lot about universal basic income?
Raise your hand if you know a lot.
And then do nothing if you know nothing.
I mostly don't know much.
Well, you are here today, so you're what I call UBI curious.
And I seem to be something of a resource for people
who are UBI curious.
So I'm going to tell you a little bit about my arc,
my journey, why I'm doing what I'm doing now,
which is running for president as a Democrat in 2020.
Thank you.
And then we'll take some questions.
And then I'd like to reserve the last 10 minutes or so
just to take selfies and meet people individually,
because I think it's really obnoxious to be in this setting
and be talking from a stage and then like dash off.
And unfortunately, so ordinarily I stick around for a long time,
but I have a rally in Austin a little bit later tonight.
And so I can't because the traffic's murder
and the rest of it.
So my team's like, you must leave relatively promptly.
And so I was like, all right, I got it.
So we're going to take the last 10, 15 minutes or so
just to schmooze it up.
So we've got, I guess, an hour together.
I'll do my thing, talk for not that long,
and then we'll take some questions,
have what I hope is a lively discussion
and then hopefully even meet individually.
So so someone who knows nothing about universal basic income,
what got you to come and devote a very important hour
of your South by Southwest?
You could be exposed to myriad experts from fields,
you know, blah, blah, blah.
Why would you choose this forum?
Like what made you come here?
Anyone want to just raise their hand and say it's like
what got them in here? Yes, miss.
Wow, I love that. What's your name?
Yeah. So Polly's worried about people.
Raise your hand if you're worried about people.
Wow, I love it.
This is a group that has your collective head on straight
because I, too, am worried about people.
I am. And the numbers are more horrifying.
The more you go in, the deeper you go into this space,
the more worried you get.
I have yet to encounter someone who's a deep expert in A.I.
and the rest of it's like, yeah, things will be all right.
That's not the conversation you have.
Unfortunately, like they know a lot.
They'd be like, yo, it's it's deeper and hair than anyone thinks.
I'm like, yeah, yeah, I get it. I get it.
So so I'll give you my background and story
just to lead you on the progression that I had
because I was here at South by Southwest several years ago,
speaking as the CEO of my organization, Venture for America.
So I started an organization called Venture for America to help
train entrepreneurs around the country and generate job growth
because I was very sad circa 2010 and 11
in the wake of the financial crisis.
I thought one of the key problems was that we had so much energy
and human capital and financial capital heading to Wall Street
and Silicon Valley and management consulting firms
and not building generative businesses in Detroit
or San Antonio or Baltimore or Cleveland or St. Louis.
So I quit my job.
I donated one hundred twenty thousand to start this new organization, Venture
for America, and then I started calling rich friends and asked them,
do you love America?
And then the smart among them said, what does it mean if I say yes?
And then I said and I said at least ten thousand dollars.
And then then told them, like, I love America for ten thousand.
I was like, I thought you did.
So so we had a budget of two hundred forty thousand that first year.
Today, Venture for America's budget's around six million thousands of applicants,
hundreds of fellows generated several thousand jobs around the country.
How many of you all like documentary films?
How many of you have access to a Netflix password?
So there's so there's a documentary on Netflix right now
about my organization called Generation Startup that follows six young
entrepreneurs for a year and a half as they try and build businesses in Detroit.
So that's what I've been doing for the last six and a half years.
And then in 2016, Donald Trump became our president.
And I was stunned by this.
I said, wow, this is a terrible, terrible sign.
And I started digging into why he won.
And keep in mind, I'd spent the last six and a half years
working in the Midwest and the South in places that had lost tons
of manufacturing jobs.
And so I looked at the data and the research, and I found that
we'd automated away four million manufacturing jobs in Michigan,
Ohio, Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, Missouri, Iowa, all the swing states
that Donald Trump needed to win and did win.
And if you look at the voter district data, there's a straight line up
between the adoption of industrial robots in a voting district
and the movement towards Trump.
It's like a straight line.
And so then how many of you all work in technology or technology?
Jason Peel, like a bunch of you.
So we all have friends who are working on this stuff.
We know that what we did to the manufacturing workers,
we will now do to the retail workers, the call center workers,
the fast food workers, the truck drivers and the lawyers
and the accountants, the bookkeepers, the radiologists.
So, Polly, when you said you were worried about people,
is this why you were worried about people?
People are having a hard time,
and one of the messages I have is like it's not immigrants
that are making it so that people are having a hard time.
It's the fact that we're making it so that human labor
is less and less central to the economy,
where now it's more normal to have two, three jobs.
Ninety four percent of the new jobs created since 2005 in the US
have been gig temporary or contractor jobs.
And so when I was digging into the numbers, I said,
OK, it turns out that Donald Trump's election
directly linked to the fact that we're decimating manufacturing jobs
and we're just going to keep cycling through these other occupations.
And then when I started doing research for my book,
now out on paperback, more and more people.
But when I started doing research, my book,
the data just got bleaker and bleaker around human beings,
where how many of you knew that America's life expectancy
has declined for the last three years?
And why is that?
Opioids and suicides.
Both of those have now overtaken vehicle deaths as cause of death in the US.
You all want to know the last time America's life expectancy
declined three years in a row?
The Spanish flu, 1918.
It's an anomaly in a developed country.
It is not actually normal for life expectancies to go down
in a developed country. It's almost unheard of.
And so it's not just that our labor force participation rate right now
is at 63.2 percent, close to a multi-decade low
in the same levels as Ecuador and Costa Rica.
No knock in those countries, but still not like where you want to be
if you're an industrialized nation.
Now, almost one in five prime working age American men hasn't worked in a year.
And this is year ten of an expansion.
These are supposed to be like the best times you get, more or less.
And so the data to me was shockingly consistent
with a narrative of an automation wave that we're in the third inning of.
And the fourth and fifth and sixth innings are going to be devastating.
How many of you all have friends who are working on artificial intelligence
or AI related companies like most all of you?
So there's some themes here.
Polly's worried about people and a lot of you work in tech
and know people who are working in tech.
And again, the more you know, the more concerned you get.
The more you're like, wow, do I think that I can outperform
a call center worker who makes fourteen dollars an hour?
Yeah, I do. You know, you always do it like, yeah, sure.
What's the time frame on that?
Now, two years from now,
there are two and a half million call center workers in the United States
making 14 bucks an hour.
What percentage of Americans graduate from college today?
It's 32.
So if you include two years and associates degrees to your programs, it's 42.
So if you think about the workforce, 58 percent of high school
graduates making typically between 14 and 15 dollars an hour.
So what you think about American jobs,
you should think about lots and lots of high school grads.
The most common jobs in the US economy are administrative and clerical work,
including call center workers, retail, food service and food prep,
truck driving and transportation.
Being a trucker is the most common job in twenty nine states.
There are three and a half million truck drivers in this country.
Ninety four percent male, average age forty nine.
Average education, high school or one year of college, a lot of ex-military.
This is going to sound very politiciany,
but I was just with a trucker in Iowa last week, last month.
I mean, I was. Yeah.
Why? Iowa, indeed. Mystery.
I'm actually going there again on Monday for the ninth time.
And and so you look at it and say, OK, there are three and a half
million truck drivers.
Are we pretty confident that we're going to have robot trucks
on the highways in five to 10 years?
Sure, they'll be on the road.
I mean, they're on the road now.
Like they're actually testing robot trucks now.
Are you going to have a robot truck maybe with a human there,
like twiddling their thumbs as like a quote unquote fail safe?
Like maybe.
But eventually, are you going to start thinking, huh,
maybe I can convoy some trucks together, get a human in the first one
and then a couple of robot trucks falling right behind.
Like, that's pretty reasonable.
You know, so so you can start seeing where this is going to go.
Dozens of truckers recently protested in Indianapolis.
They did something called a slow roll, which they had a bunch of trucks.
And then they just started driving their trucks slowly on the highway.
Gums up traffic.
What were they protesting?
They were protesting the electronic monitoring of their driving time
and work shifts.
How do you think they're going to react
when it's a robot truck that's actually taking the job away?
I'm going to suggest they're not going to take that well.
Right now, the average trucker trucker makes a little less than $50,000 a year.
And it's one of the higher paying.
Jobs for a high school grad in this country.
What's their next economic alternative going to be when the robot trucks come?
It's a rhetorical question, nobody knows.
Nobody knows.
Now, I studied economics in college and what my textbook said would happen
if you were to lose, let's say, four million manufacturing jobs.
Who here studied economics? Someone did.
So what did your textbook say would happen?
Retrain, reskill, higher productivity, work, economy grows all as well.
Right. You remember that from macroeconomics that you got to be in?
I got an A.
So, so that is what the macroeconomics textbook says.
And then it turns out in real life, when you go look at the numbers,
what happened to manufacturing workers in Michigan or Indiana?
40 to 44 percent of them left the workforce and were never heard from again.
Now, how do they survive?
About half of that group filed for disability.
There are now more Americans on disability than work in construction.
20 percent of working age adults in some parts of the country.
And if you go to these communities, you can see it.
There are just a lot of people on disability.
Now, are they genuinely disabled?
Yeah, a lot of them had genuine injuries
because if you're working in a manufacturing plant for 12 years,
like you probably have something messed up.
But. In like, would they prefer to be working like in most cases? Yeah.
And so what happened to the manufacturing workers is almost certain
to happen to the truckers.
You know, it's like there is going to be no magical realignment.
You're not going to take 500000 middle aged men and turn them into coders
or whatever ridiculous fantasy someone is peddling.
And and the other aspect of it, too, is that it's like, why on earth
do you think you're supposed to try and turn a truck driver
into a software engineer?
Like, reflect on that for a moment.
And the reason is that we define ourselves by economic value at this point.
It's like if you don't have any economic value,
then we have to turn you into something that does.
Even if it makes no sense in the world to think that we can do it.
And when I went to Washington, D.C.
with a set of issues, so, you know, I'm a pretty cool guy.
So like I went to D.C.
and was like meeting with various legislators and policymakers
because I was an Obama appointee.
I was an honorary ambassador of entrepreneurship.
I have some stories to tell, but
what can I tell?
I'll tell a stupid story just because I'm not funny.
So so I'm in the White House with Daniel Lubecki,
the CEO of Kind, Kind Bars, you know, little snacks.
And someone's like, I'm hungry.
And then I kid you not.
He like opens his jacket like this, like he's Batman.
And he's like Kind Bars, like all over.
Like he must have had a custom jacket made with like eight extra pockets.
So he's like, whoa, whoa, whoa.
And and there are flavors you've never seen or heard of
and never seen or heard of again.
It wasn't like here's like an almond apricot.
No, it was like some weird flavors.
Anyway, so
and then I was the only person who brought my wife.
I was like, how the rest how did the rest of you stay married?
Like, it's just weird.
And I was like, here's my comms person.
I was like, here's my wife.
Like, what are you guys doing?
Anyway, so I'm a cool guy.
So I'm meeting with various legislators in D.C.
being like, guys, what are we going to do?
We're in the third inning of the greatest economic
and technological transformation in the history of the country.
What is the plan?
And what do you think they said to me when I said, what is the plan?
There's no plan.
I looked at me like I was speaking another language.
The responses I got were, we can't talk about that.
We should study that.
And we must educate and retrain Americans for the jobs of the future.
And then I said, guys, I looked at the studies.
Do you all want to guess how effective government funded retraining programs are?
Yes, zero to 15 percent.
We're terrible at it.
And so then when I said, we're terrible at that,
then the legislator would be like, well, I guess we're going to get better at it
then, and then they just go back to their lunch.
And I just be like, holy shit.
Like, is this what passes for thinking, you know, like at this point?
Are we so far gone as a country that we're not even reckoning
with the fundamental changes that are devastating our communities?
Yeah, yeah, that's where we are.
That's like where we are.
So then I go home.
I'm steeped in this knowledge, this certainty, this dread.
And keep in mind, I'm one of the most celebrated social entrepreneurs
of this generation.
I get medals, awards, accolades, like for being the guy
who created thousands of jobs around the country.
And I am 100 percent certain that my work, as proud as I am of it,
was pouring water into a bathtub that has a giant hole ripped in the bottom.
And no one's going to do a damn thing about the giant hole.
So then I went home and was like, OK, like, what is the plan?
What are we going to do?
And I have two young kids who are six and three.
And so literally, like I'm looking at them being like,
am I really just going to raise them in this country
that's going to disintegrate around them and just like start
trying to sock money away so that we can like have a bunker
like some of my richer friends?
Like, is that really the plan?
And that struck me as deeply
pathetic as a plan.
And so I said, OK, what is the actual plan?
Like, what am I going to do?
And then I thought, well, in order to make it so that the people that Polly
is worried about, like that the people will do better,
you have to actually redesign our economy.
You have to like change the rules so that we don't value ourselves
solely as economic inputs, but we value ourselves intrinsically.
Like maybe we're worth something even if our truck starts driving itself
or the AI is better than us at reading the radiology film
or, you know, my mall closes and like I'm a 39 year old woman
who works in the mall.
So we have to start looking at valuing ourselves
at some other mechanism than the marketplace, because the marketplace
is about to turn on us in epic, catastrophic fashion.
And so it's like, OK, how do you make that happen?
And so then I looked and said, well, the only way to rewrite
the rules of the economy is to get control of the government.
And I said, OK, how do you get control of the government?
You run for president and win.
And then I said, OK, what are the rules for running for president?
Only two rules, it turns out.
Thirty five or older and natural born citizen.
So I was like, check and check.
And then I was like, and then check number three is I went to my wife
was like, hey, baby, I think I'm going to run for president.
And then she was like, she's like, that's nice.
Like, you know, pass the sauce.
So so that's how I came to run for president
on a platform of universal basic income,
which is that we have to start putting a thousand dollars a month
in the hands of American adults as soon as possible
to enable tens of millions of people to make effective transitions.
And as a parent, what excited me the most about this
was that the data very clearly shows it makes children healthier and stronger.
It improves nutrition.
It improves graduation rates.
It improves mental health.
It improves relationships.
Domestic violence goes down.
Hospital visits go down.
It actually just makes life better for people.
If you are interested in female empowerment,
there are millions of American women who right now are in exploited
or abusive jobs or relationships or are doing work
that is unrecognized by the market.
Like my wife.
My wife is at home with our two boys, one of whom is autistic.
And what is the market value her work at?
Zero, unfortunately.
You know, she gets the big goose egg GDP, the same thing
when I know she's working much harder and doing more important work than
certainly like I, you know, like
the average hedge fund analyst or whatever it is.
And so we have all of these perversions
baked into our valuation of ourselves based upon what the market says
is important or valuable.
And so you create this universal basic income, which is not my idea.
Thomas Paine was forward at the founding of the country,
called it the citizens dividend.
Martin Luther King championed it whole like full on
the last year of his life in 1967 before he was killed.
Milton Friedman and a thousand economists signed a study saying
this would be great for the economy.
And it passed the House of Representatives twice under Richard Nixon in 1971
came this close to being lost, called a family assistance plan
would have guaranteed everyone a minimum income.
And the reason it didn't pass was that Democrats in the Senate
wanted a higher income threshold.
And then 11 years later, one state passed a dividend
where everyone in that state now gets between one and two thousand dollars a year.
And what state is that and how do they fund it?
And what is the oil of the 21st century?
Technology. That's right.
I've heard marijuana. I've heard a lot of things on that one.
But it is technology.
And now I'm going around the country saying, look, what they're doing
in Alaska with oil money, we can do for everyone with technology money.
As a matter of fact, we don't have a choice, but to start moving this direction,
because if we follow GDP and capital efficiency,
we're going to follow it off a cliff, which we are doing right now.
We're in the middle of it.
Donald Trump is not business as usual.
Donald Trump is a sign of disintegration and the disintegration is accelerating.
You can see it in any numerical measurement, life expectancy,
mental health, deaths of despair, like any measurement you want,
a business formation, marriage, child rearing, all of them, historic lows,
multi-decade lows, moving for a new job, multi-decade low.
Pretty much any measurement of healthfulness you can find in America
is at a multi-decade low or a record low right now.
We are falling apart.
And so this is a necessary this is an overdue move.
Like this should have happened decades ago.
But here we are. It's 2019 and we have to make it happen now.
So that's universal basic income.
Put a thousand bucks a month in the hands of every American adult.
Now, some of you are thinking like, ha ha, that sounds great.
But isn't that way too much money for us to afford?
Who's thinking that? Raise your hand. Anyone? No one? Wow.
That'd be great.
At least a few people like, hey, that's like three trillion dollars.
Now, what's amazing is that it gets actually very, very affordable, very fast.
For context, the economy is at 20 trillion dollars,
up five trillion in the last 12 years.
So we're at like massive levels of wealth.
And instead of costing three trillion dollars a year,
it actually costs more like one point eight trillion
because we're already spending one point five trillion on income support.
Hundred twenty six welfare programs, social security, other things
that end up just bringing the cost down of guaranteeing everyone a thousand dollars
a month. So what I referenced before about this technology money,
you all saw the headlines where Amazon paid zero in taxes last year
despite record profits, right?
And I'm going to suggest that's not Amazon's fault, that's our fault.
Like if you're Amazon's management team, you're like high fiving.
You're like, yes, another another year of zero taxes.
Well done. Give those tax lawyers a bonus.
And that's cool. That's what they should do.
That's what they're supposed to do.
But what we're supposed to do is say, hey, we have to have a system
that you can't just freaking game that easily.
We need to get the American public a slice of all of that economic innovation
that's happening because the trap we're in right now,
who are going to be the big winners from A.I. and the rest of it?
Who wins? The biggest tech companies, right?
You know, any promising is going to buy anyway because they're worth
a trillion dollars.
You come up with a promising A.I.
company, they're going to buy you for two billion
and then just going to attack you on.
So the big winners are the Amazons and Googles and Facebooks
and Ubers of the world, and they're great at not paying a whole lot of tax.
And so what we have to do is we have to have a tax
that they can't gain their way out of.
And so if you look around the world, every other advanced economy
already has a value added tax, which is very hard to gain.
And so if we adopted a value added tax that even half the European level,
it generates 800 billion in new revenue.
Which, combined with current spending,
all the economic growth that would happen.
Imagine if you all walked out of here with an extra thousand bucks a month.
You know, I dare say your local economies would be a little bigger.
You'd be like, excellent pizza on me or whatever it is you do later tonight.
But multiply that times
every in the economy, you get hundreds of billions of new tax revenue.
You save hundreds of billions on things like incarceration,
homelessness services, emergency room health care.
And then you also generate hundreds of billions of dollars
by having a healthier, stronger, mentally healthier, more productive,
more entrepreneurial, more creative population.
This thing will pay for itself.
This is called the trickle up economy from human beings,
families and communities up. What do you think?
The trickle up economy, the human centered economy.
So that is the game plan.
That is my plan to save humanity.
And ordinarily I have a slide.
I don't always have it, but I've like pictures of my family up.
And if you look at my little boy's faces, you will see
they are not very tough little boys.
They're very, very not tough.
And so I'm doing this to keep the country strong and whole
so that they can grow up, not tough, if you know what I mean.
And so that is the plan.
So hopefully I've answered some of the questions
you might have had about universal basic income on the main idea.
Big gist, if someone asks you, what's universal basic income?
You say it's a policy where everyone in a society
gets a certain amount of money.
No questions asked.
And most of the policies are around the same level I'm proposing,
which is a thousand dollars per month per adult.
So that's what it is.
Why to do it?
Because our economy is being transformed in ways
that are going to displace millions of American workers.
And it's already happening.
Can we afford it? Yes.
Will it cause inflation? No.
Is it awesome? Yes.
Is anyone trying to make it happen? Yeah, that guy.
And and then now hopefully all of you, too.
So we'd love to take some questions from you all,
but I'm going to suggest to the reason if you came here
because you're worried about people, you are right to be worried
because this economy is going to go from punitive to savage pretty quickly.
The next downturn, the knives are going to come out.
Like I've been a CEO, you don't fire people when times are normal,
but when times get tough, you you like just look around and see
who's not nailed down.
And even if they're nailed down, you start looking for a nail remover.
So in the next downturn, it is going to be savage
and we have to get our shit together between now and then.
So if we don't, if we don't fight for it, none of this will happen on its own.
I've been to D.C. I've seen the machinery.
You know what I'm talking about, too.
Like no one's going to do a damn thing.
So we are going to have to do it for ourselves.
In entrepreneurial circles, there are two mindsets.
One is someone else will take care of this.
And the other is I'm going to take care of it.
And we all know that this is something that no one else is going to take care of.
So thank you all very, very much.
We'd love to take questions.
I think there's a mic for you. Thank you all.
Hi. My question is, it sounds a lot like socialism.
How are you going to prevent that message from changing
from your vision to what we all know is going to come?
Yeah. So I was asked that on Fox last week.
And I said this is capitalism where income doesn't start at zero.
And having money is actually good for business.
Good for the consumer economy. Good for markets.
It helps us all participate in markets.
And I'm a CEO and business person.
I love capitalism.
And that seems to work.
I think it's something about my manner that makes me seem really capitalist
or something where they're like where they're like,
this guy does not seem like a socialist at all.
So that response has been pretty effective so far.
Yeah. The power to tax is the power to destroy.
And you've weaved together two things here that are actually very different,
which is universal income and taxing the thing that's working technology.
Like technology is something that's working best for us.
Why would you go out to destroy that when that's what's actually working?
That's where whatever jobs are going to be provided are most likely to come from
if you don't run it all offshore with your tax policy.
Yeah. So I'd suggest that there's a monumental difference
between a relatively mild tax that even my techie friends agree with
and destruction.
And so when I talk to my friends in Silicon Valley and I'm friends
with many of them and I say, hey, guys,
you're probably automating away all the major jobs.
They're like, yes, we are.
And then I'm like, how do you feel about it?
And they're like, not great.
And then I say, how would you like to take a bit of a haircut
and make it so that the truckers don't necessarily riot
and you don't need to go live in the bunker?
And then they say, deal.
And these are the CEOs of the tech companies.
They are not inhuman.
They're Americans, they're parents, they're patriots.
And they know that it's a much better climate for progress and innovation
if people actually feel like progress is working for them.
So if they think that, I would say that they know what they're talking about.
I've heard a lot of your talks
about implementing this, and obviously the struggles are to get it implemented.
But how do you protect it?
Say we actually do get UBI implemented.
How do you make sure that the next regime doesn't come along and rip it away?
Because if people get that money and they start to spin it,
they'll be spread too thin to live without it.
Well, what I'm inspired by is the experience in Alaska,
which is a deeply conservative state.
It was passed by a Republican governor, and it's wildly popular in Alaska.
So that's one of the great things about universality,
is that if I say there's this program and you're like, oh, someone else gets that,
then maybe you don't like it.
But if this is something that everyone is getting, as is the case in Alaska.
So if you check out what's going on in Alaska, it's been in effect
for 37 years across many, many different administrations.
And it's so popular in Alaska, which is a deep red conservative state
that a majority, a vast majority of Alaskans said
they would accept higher taxes to preserve the dividend.
So if there's something because right now, those of us,
you know, liberal, progressive, conservative,
we still have this sinking feeling that if the money goes to the government,
it just gets sunk into some like bureaucracy and pipe
and we'll never see it again.
But if it's money that comes into your hands, then you're like, wow,
this is something the government actually did right.
And then if I say, hey, I'm going to take it away, you're like,
what are you talking about?
That's like the only thing you guys do well.
And and then everyone else would be like, yeah, that's the only thing
you guys do well, like it's literally like everyone's favorite thing.
So this is what happened in Alaska, and that's what's going to happen
in the whole US of A after I'm president and make this happen.
So I like the idea of a universal basic income,
but my concern is that if I got a thousand dollars more per month
that I would start consuming more, and it seems like with capitalism
and you mentioned economic growth quite a bit, it seems that it always comes
at the expense of the environment.
And there's a need for us as a society to consume less.
And so is there any way that you've kind of coupled that to your framework
as as a person running for president?
Yeah. What's your name?
My name's Daniel.
Daniel, that's such a great question.
And so first, let me say that I think climate change is the second
existential threat facing us, like one a it's like right in peril.
It's in tandem with
the automation of jobs and the dehumanization of our economy.
Now, I'm going to suggest that these two things are linked,
because if you go to people and say, hey, we need to worry about climate change,
a significant proportion of them in a country where 57 percent of people
can't pay an unexpected five hundred dollar bill and 78 percent
are living paycheck to paycheck,
a significant proportion of them will say, I can't pay my bills.
The penguins can wait in line or something obnoxious like that.
And that's just human nature, because if you can't pay your bills,
you actually have your head down like big societal level.
Future oriented problems are not your concern.
You get increasingly disengaged.
You have what's called a mindset of scarcity, which has been shown
to decrease your functional IQ by 13 points or one standard deviation.
And then collectively, we have a much lower chance
of actually activating around something like climate change.
So what we do is we take the economic boot off of people's throats
and then say, hey, we need to address climate change.
And then more of them will get on board because we'll say, yes, yes, we do.
Now, to your concern that we're going to consume more and it's going to cause
more, you know, I'm optimistic and we'll see how this bears out.
Is that if you had a portable income of this kind,
you'd have also more people embracing minimalism and communal living
and going to places where they can have like a community garden
and work on their like art that they've always wanted to.
Like you'd have some things going in both directions.
But the other thing is I want to actually measure economic progress.
As I indicated before, GDP is an archaic measurement.
We made up almost 100 years ago.
And even the inventors said this is a terrible measurement
for national well-being and we should not use it as that.
And so I was suggesting before that GDP is going to guide us astray.
So what would guide us more appropriately would be something
that integrates human health, childhood success rates
and environmental quality.
You actually make it that economic progress is tied to
environmental sustainability.
And then if you grow, you're growing in the way that you actually want to.
Because right now we're growing in this two dimensional way
that's going to kill us and it's going to kill the planet.
So we have to do is we have to evolve to a 21st century economy
that actually is driving things that would help us.
And that definitely includes clean air, clean water
and environmental sustainability.
Hi, I'm an American immigrant that actually now lives in Brussels in Belgium,
and I've been living in the European model for the last four or five years.
And there's lots to be learned over there and ported over.
But and one of the things that's in the conversation there
and it's in the conversation in America as well, if you're paying attention,
the Atlantic did a cover article on it about a year and a half ago,
which is just the end of work period as a concept in the first world.
All the first world economies are up. Productivity is off the scale.
Scandinavian countries are going back, going to a four day work week
and a seven hour work day, sometimes a six hour work day.
Is that what's happening to you, man?
No, I'm a writer, man.
I just I work five jobs at a time minimum.
I haven't and I've been doing it for 20 years.
So that's it.
But it is for to be honest with you, I have a lot of people
who are in the corporate world who look at me and want to make my twenty
five thousand euros a year minimum because I have a certain kind of freedom
because I'm not tied to that sort of economic model.
But there are a lot of people thinking about first world economies
moving towards this concept of end of work, which is deeply related
to obviously also decoupling your worth as a noun.
I am a writer, for instance, or I am a truck driver.
I work and so therefore I have value just and this may be,
you know, ten ten years down the line.
But do you have any comments on that concept as a whole?
The end of work in the first world?
Yeah. So unfortunately, there's been this massive divergence.
So Keynes predicted that we'd have 15 hour work weeks
because our productivity would just keep going up.
Yeah. And you guys are laughing because instead we have like endless work weeks
where it's like I sent you a text at like eleven thirty.
Why didn't you get back to me?
So what happened in America is that our work, we got shorter until about 1980
and then it reversed and got longer and longer.
And that's where it is now.
So in America, you have this divergence where people in various roles
are actually working longer hours than ever.
And then other people are just not working at all.
And and so would America benefit from curbing some of the excesses
in terms of corporate work culture?
One hundred percent, yes.
I mean, studies have shown that a lot of those incremental hours
are not actually adding much productivity.
But will that happen in the absence of some regulation?
Will people just, you know, sort of move in that direction?
Unfortunately, the facts point the other direction in the US
where like the work is, you know, always on culture is actually getting stronger.
And so as president, would I want to try and curb that?
Would I say, look, maybe we should move towards 40 work weeks
for certain industries, make it so that there are like, you know,
times of the day when like you should not be always on
and that companies like should not expect most employees
to like be available for like 16 hours a day and the rest of it.
Yeah, I would.
But it's not going to happen on its own, because unfortunately,
the dynamics of this economy make it that a lot of corporates
will just demand more and more of workers until we drop dead.
Thank you.
Well, that changed the topic a little bit because you're not a one note wonder
and have a whole slate of policy proposals that are quite specific.
And I know one of them is that you're not in favor of free college.
I'm really curious about what you think about public education K through 12
and what you think about the crisis of student loan debt,
what your proposals are around both of those things
and also education in general, which seems essential to our civic health.
Yes. Thank you.
So I have 75 policy proposals on my website.
So it's a UBI and then like 74 others.
So that's what she was referring to, I think, in part.
I love the spirit of free college or free public college.
I just think that it sends the wrong message because
college.
So the first thing is that only 32 percent of Americans graduate from college
and that proportion has essentially been constant for years.
And then as we've tried to plow more people in the college,
what we've done is we've brought down the college completion rate.
The college completion rate in six years now is fifty nine percent.
So 41 percent of people who are starting college do not finish within six years.
And so selling college as a panacea is just not going to work.
And it's subsidizing something that's enjoyed by the top third of the population,
which may or may not be the direction you want to go.
So to me, you're much better off putting a thousand bucks a month
into everyone's hands and saying, if you want to use that to partially pay
for college, that's great.
Do you want to pay for vocational, which we should be massively investing in?
That would be great, too.
If you want to do something independent, maybe you want to start something
like that would be a better way to go.
And it's in tandem with the fact
that we have this educational school loan crisis in this country
where it's up to one point five trillion dollars.
Why has college got two and a half times more expensive over the last 25 years?
It has not gotten two and a half times better.
And so the reason is that they've just invested
in a lot of non-faculty administrators.
And so you have to separate out the different problems.
Has college gone too expensive?
Yes. Saying, are we going to subsidize and have free college as a solution?
To me, it's a little bit too much in one way and not enough in another.
So what you do is you go to colleges and you say, look, why are you so expensive?
You got to get your costs down and you got to get your administrator
to student ratios down to what they were in the 90s.
And if you don't, you don't get school loans.
And then the universities would say that's impossible.
And then you'd be like, well, I have a feeling you'll figure it out.
And then they would.
And and then they would find that it impacts the student experience.
Not at all, because at this point, these schools are like a massive
crushing debt burden. It's like a tax on our economy.
How many of you all have student loan debt?
You all look kind of young. Some of you.
You don't need to be young to have student loan debt.
I had one hundred thousand in school loans myself.
I used to call it my mistress
because I was like writing a check to like a family in another country.
I was like, so it's immoral.
I would forgive a lot of that student loan debt
in an argument for stimulus because young people and like
other people should be starting families, buying homes, starting businesses
and not paying off this phantom school debt that, you know, like was
for an education they got years ago when the school was already paid.
It's purely a financial invention at this point.
And so if you wanted to make an economy that worked for people,
you'd just be like, look, this is a great stimulus to the economy.
Let's just like get some of the school loan debt off of people's backs,
get colleges more to be more cost efficient
and then give everyone a thousand dollars a month and invest very highly
in vocational, because right now only six percent of American high school
students are in vocational or technical tracks in Germany.
That's fifty nine percent.
What do you all think the appropriate percentages for America then?
Twenty five or thirty. Right.
But the problem is we're overselling college to all these kids.
We're like, hey, if you don't go to college, your life is over.
And then they go to college.
They get this debt.
Even if you come out of college right now,
you know what the underemployment rate is for recent college grads?
Forty four percent.
So again, this entire like subsidized free college, like it doesn't solve
the problem.
Like if you come out and you're underemployed, you don't have crushing debt.
Yeah, that's better than having crushing debt.
But like maybe we need to start trying to address the imbalances in our system.
And one of the imbalances is that we're over prescribing college.
We're under supporting vocational trades and apprenticeships,
because if you're going to automate away a lot of the jobs, which we are,
44 percent of the jobs in America are either repetitive, manual
or repetitive, cognitive.
We're going to automate away a ton of those jobs.
But you know, it's really hard to automate away.
Yes, air conditioning repair.
Plumbing, you know, like it's very, very hard
to automate away fine motor work like that.
Those jobs are steady, they pay well, they're they're gratifying.
So we need to start saying to kids like that's a really good way to go.
Like that's a better way to go than a four year degree that might,
you know, that this might lead you nowhere.
No offense. I went to college, you know, I love college and all that.
But but we're just overselling it.
So it's a very long winded answer to a complex set of issues.
But that's it's a multi-pronged problem.
All right, I want to preface this question by saying
I don't know too much about UBI, but I'm enthusiastic about the concept.
In my limited research, I came across two big criticisms,
which I just want to shoot by you. Sure. Yeah.
So what do you say to those who argue that giving everybody
a thousand dollars a month, a thousand dollars a month
would allow businesses to raise the price of goods and services
and create a new social norm?
Yep. Or allow businesses to reduce wages
and subsidize those reduced wages with this income similar to how Walmart
encourages employees to be 100% programs and such.
Yeah. So if you look at our experience as consumers,
we have not had massive inflation in any category, but three education,
which we discussed health care, which has its own massive set of problems.
And so I'm for Medicare for all and just getting like the cost
down and the access up because there's no other way to do it.
There's just so many excesses in that system and then housing.
So if you look at your consumer experiences with clothing
or electronics or media or cars or even food, for the most part,
prices have been more or less stable.
And so if I put money into your hands, all of the markets
where it's a free floating consumer economy with price sensitivity
and competition among firms, you would not see massive price gouging.
If McDonald's decide to double the price of its hamburger,
like after we all had a thousand bucks a month, you'd just be like, wow,
I guess I'm going to go to Taco Bell or, you know, the deli.
And then they'd all have to gouge you simultaneously.
And then it just takes one of them to say, I'm not going to gouge.
And then they get all the business and then all the prices come back down.
It's not like if you have a thousand bucks a month,
you're all of a sudden like made of money.
You know, it's like you still are going to be bargain hunting.
And so that's true across all of the functional markets that,
you know, competition and technology apply to.
It's really the dysfunctional markets that are driving us crazy.
And putting money into people's hands will actually allow us to manage
that inflation as opposed to cause it, because this inflation
is not being driven by purchasing power.
In terms of the worker bargaining power, it's actually the inverse.
So check this out.
Let's say everyone's getting a thousand bucks a month
and then Walmart decides it's going to exploit people.
It's going to be like, I'm going to pay you nothing.
You have to work for free.
Then people would be like, of course, I'm not going to do that.
And I know I cannot starve to death
if you don't give me something that's actually worth my while.
It's possible Walmart might actually have to increase their pay.
What you might you might see is you might see people that are, frankly,
very unpleasant employers might have to actually pay more
because at this point, people know they can survive without a job that they hate.
And so you'd you'd see wages change in different fields.
There are some fields where they probably could get away with paying less.
But we might find that to be OK.
For example, nonprofits.
Or like teaching and coaching jobs or some other jobs.
They might be like, hey, we need more people.
We'll pay you a little less.
And then people might be cool with that because they're like,
I kind of want to do that work.
And then the really soul crushing jobs would actually have to pay more.
So it's not a uniform impact.
It would vary.
But the big thing to think about is that it improves our bargaining power.
It makes us actually more exploitation proof, not exploit a bull.
I'm interested in two things.
One is your definition of intrinsic value.
And then I'm also interested in how would you plan to educate people
on the concept of intrinsic value?
If a truck driver can be expected to become a coder,
how can they be expected to become a part time artist or an innovator?
Yeah, so this is in many ways the fundamental challenge that we're facing
is that people actually know men deal with idleness very, very poorly.
If you're an unemployed man, you volunteer less than an employed man,
even though you have more time
and you spend up to 75 percent of your time on the computer
playing video games and other things.
And then your drug and alcohol consumption go up
and your self-destructive behaviors also tend to go up.
Women do not have these issues.
Women are never idle.
They find various projects and pro-social,
go back to school at higher levels, et cetera, et cetera.
This is shocking to zero people in this room.
So it's just facts.
Very, very data driven man.
The opposite of Donald Trump is an Asian man who likes math.
That's why I'm going to beat him in 2020.
It's going to be glorious.
So the so the fundamental question is, like, what how do we teach people
intrinsic value to your point where, like, if you were the truck driver,
loses their jobs, a thousand dollars a month does not magically solve your problem.
Like you need a sense of structure and purpose and fulfillment and meaning.
And so that is the fundamental challenge of this age, to introduce those things
to millions of people as fast as we can.
And these are some of like the deepest questions in human existence.
And the way we get there, I have the answers in this book.
No, I don't. I'm kidding.
Like that. It's called.
Sorry, that's a humor.
So the way we get there is we put this money into people's hands and then a
significant amount of that money goes into nonprofits and civic organizations
and religious organizations and institutions that can help.
Restore a set of opportunities that allow people to find structure, purpose
and meaning in their communities and their work, so there's no easy answer.
It's a generational struggle.
Certainly when I think about intrinsic value, I think about my son who's
autistic, and I think like it's possible that he'll never actually have like the
capacity to have like a normal job.
And so that's what I think of when I think of intrinsic values.
And so you look at the person, you know, they're worth, you know, just as much as
someone else. But it's going to be a very, very difficult journey taking the
current conventional market driven American mindset and helping it move in that
direction. There's a generational gap in people that are more open to the idea of
intrinsic value.
So I think that the studies I've seen have indicated that young people are more
enthusiastic about socialism than capitalism, more enthusiastic about socialism
than older generations.
And I think it's because many young people have seen the excesses and problems with
capitalism over this last number of years.
I have a feeling that young people are more open to seeing people as having
intrinsic value. I'd agree with that.
Hi, my question dovetails pretty nicely with that, I think, which is that for me, I
think the most resonant criticisms of UBI have revolved around the spiritual and
psychological value of work to an individual.
And so I'm wondering what your thoughts on that are and why you propose a UBI
versus, say, just a large jobs program with the same amount of money.
Yeah. So so to me, work is central.
And the great thing about UBI is that it would create over two million jobs in
these communities. And the example that I use is that if you can imagine a town in
Missouri with 50,000 people and right now there's someone in that town that wants to
start a bakery, but the bakery is a dumb idea.
But then I become president and now there's another 50 million dollars in spending
power every month in that town.
And then the bakery might become a good idea.
And then that person starts a bakery and they say, hey, I need to hire a morning
shift baker. And then you end up hiring people for accessible jobs in that community.
And that's only possible because you're supercharging the local economy and helping
restore vitality to those Main Street retailers.
So this isn't like the easiest way is to say, like, hey, what are the jobs that that
community is going to value and support?
Then people will do those jobs because work is central.
The biggest misconception about UBI is that it's somehow anti-work or mitigates work.
It's pro-work.
Like it's pro-work in terms of just creating jobs in those communities that people
actually want to do and can access.
It's also pro-work in terms of like the moms and caregivers and nurturers, because we
know that's work, too.
It's just our market doesn't value it as that.
So that's the big, you know, and that's at least starting to push us in the direction of
meaning. How many of you all are entrepreneurs?
So if you're an entrepreneur, you know what I'm talking about here, where it's like
you're doing something primarily because it's important to you.
Yes, there is money involved.
Yes, it might seem like a good economic opportunity.
But you're driven by the fact that you think that that.
