Tariffs are once again at the forefront of the news cycle this week. On Thursday, President Trump announced reciprocal tariffs against foreign trading partners, though it could take months to actually implement due to trade negotiations with the aforementioned nations. This all comes after the president signed an executive order imposing 25% blanket tariffs on steel and aluminum earlier this week. What does all this mean for the economy and your bottom line? We get into it. On this week’s episode of Capitol Gains, anchor Madison Mills, Washington Correspondent Ben Werschkul, and Senior Columnist Rick Newman talk about the latest tariff news, breaking down what the legislation means and how they will directly impact the American people. Tax Foundation Policy Analysis Director Garrett Watson joins the show to provide insight on the latest tariff news and look ahead to Trump’s future tax bills. The team also takes a look at DOGE following the latest press conference between President Trump and Elon Musk and the steps the government is taking to reduce the $36 trillion federal debt. Watch more episodes of Capitol Gains here. Capitol Gains is Yahoo Finance’s unique look at how US government policy will impact your bottom line long after the Presidential election polls have closed.
Welcome to Capital Gains, Yahoo Finance's unique look at how U.S. government policy
could impact your bottom line. I'm your host, Madison Mills. Reciprocal tariffs at the top
of President Trump's agenda. Trump ordered federal agencies to calculate new tariffs
to match those of other countries, a move that could shake up longstanding international trade
rules. The tariffs will not be implemented right away. That will happen after negotiations
with affected nations. I have decided for purposes of fairness that I will charge a
reciprocal tariff, meaning whatever countries charge the United States of America, we will
charge them no more, no less. In other words, they charge us a tax or tariff and we charge
them the exact same tax or tariff. Very simple. Trump hopes the tariffs are a revenue builder
on the country's balance sheet. Meantime, Elon Musk focusing on cost cutting. The Tesla CEO
spoke in a press conference from the Oval Office alongside the president this week.
So what does this all mean for the economy and for your bottom line? We're going to get into
all of that today. Plus, Tax Foundation Policy Analysis Director Garrett Watson is stopping by
the show to discuss all of this and more. First up, I want to get into it with my co-stars Rick
Newman and Ben Werschel joining me here. Hey, Rick and Ben. Hey, Maddie. Hey, take it. Ben,
let's go to you first. What's on your note cards this week? For sure. Yeah. So this week,
what interested me about those two topics you mentioned, doge and tariffs, was the kind of
revenue side of it that was present in both. On terms of the doge side, Trump and Musk reiterated
promises this week that doge will cut a trillion dollars annually, will cut the federal deficit in
half. And then on tariffs, the word Trump used yesterday in terms of the revenue coming in there
was staggering. He wouldn't quite say a trillion dollars he was asked, but he said it was going
to be a staggering amount. It's very much TBD how much it actually raises. There's a lot of fact
checking we could do there. But what interested me about that was that there was a third headline
you didn't mention today that essentially sort of points to the fact that this money, whatever it is,
is already been spent to a certain extent by lawmakers on Capitol Hill who are looking at
taxes and sort of averting what could be an effective tax hike at the end of the year.
I won't bore you guys with kind of house budget reconciliation instructions process this week,
but the headline from that this week is that Republicans are setting aside at least four
and a half trillion dollars over the coming decade for the tax cuts, and others say it should
be even higher. The good budget watchdogs at the Committee for Responsible Federal Budget say that
could lead to four trillion dollars in additional debt when you take in sort of the pay-fors that
are in there, even though that there's a big gap there. And the emerging GOP case here is that
doge will pay for it. Tariffs will make up that gap. Regulation cuts will lead to economic growth
that will do that gap. But it's why on my, for my notecard at least this week, I didn't do any of
those three. What I did was the national debt, because we can talk through what we know about
the news this week, but what we do know for certain is that the national debt, the 36 trillion dollar
national debt, isn't moving at all. It's sort of scheduled to go upwards depending on how everything
shakes out this week, and that is clearly not in the crosshairs, no matter how much Elon Musk is
able to do or how high tariffs are able to go. Hey guys, that all sounds pretty important, but
why are we not talking more about straws? I mean, this is really the big news of the week.
I think that everybody wants to know about the presidential order on plastic straws. So just so
in case anybody might have missed this, this order Trump signed this week requires the development
of a national strategy to end the use of paper straws within 45 days. I mean, look, I got these
from New York. These are socialist New York paper straws that I won't have to deal with.
Can you even imagine a more important policy for the swaths of Americans worried about inflation?
Forget about the national debt and these tariffs. I mean, come on, we need better straws.
OK, so I was very excited when Trump signed the straw order, but let's go back to the geeky stuff
that's on Ben's notecard. I think when everybody's hearing about Doge is looking at this agency,
Doge is looking at the next agency, there is sort of a through line here. There is kind of a strategy
and the strategy is to go agency by agency and find pennies under the cushion, if you will,
that Trump can use to finance these tax cuts that are coming at the end of the year. So Ben is
following all the weedy stuff about the reconciliation process in the Senate and stuff like
that. And he's doing good updates on that. But what's really going on here is they're trying to
find some money, enough money to offset four trillion. And it could be a lot more than four
trillion. We can talk about that later if you want to be 11. But that is that is really the big
story in D.C. these days. Well, I think what's really interesting, too, is that all of this
policy this week comes during a critical week for markets. And that is a key economic data point we
got this week. CPI consumer price index coming in hotter than expected. What that means in human
terms is that inflation is running a little hotter than the Federal Reserve wants. Inflation is a
interesting note from Bank of America's Michael Hartnett this morning saying that the pricing
pressure, it might be a blessing in disguise because it could put a lid on Trump's ability to
have tariffs go too far, that maybe Trump will have to keep tariffs in check because we already
have record breaking inflation, that the Fed has not been able to tamper down to its 2 percent
target. And does that mean that Trump has sort of a check on his ability to go as far as he may want
on tariffs? I'm interested in what you guys think about that, because from a market perspective,
stocks are rallying off the back of this idea that we still have time to negotiate on tariffs
and that Trump may be sort of, again, sort of caught on the back foot when it comes to his
ability to go as far as he may want on tariffs. But, Ben, when you talk to sources within the
administration, I mean, I don't know that that is necessarily true. The market might be missing
something. Yeah, well, I think the bottom line with tariffs here, and this is the sense you get
from from folks here in Washington and the administration, is that Trump is trying to
promise all things on tariffs. He wants it to be a big revenue raiser. He wants it to be a way to
lower trade barriers and do this. He wants it to be all these different things. He even had a tweet
this week that somehow tariffs were going to lower interest rates. So there is a there is a sort of
clearly we have he has a plan that he's laid out that isn't going to happen in its full form. And
the question is essentially what what version of that comes through? Does he have to go all the
way forward for the kind of revenue reasons he's talking about? Does he does he scale it back
because of these inflation and market reasons you're talking about? How does that all come
together? What I think the sort of takeaway for markets to be is that these sort of ideas of
steel, of 25 percent steel and aluminum tariffs, reciprocal duties on the whole world, 25 percent
duties on Canada and Mexico and the 10 percent duties on China that are already in place.
Not all of that can happen. And the question is sort of how is it pared down and sort of
how does it balance all these competing things he's trying to do? Something's going to have to
give here, guys. So Trump's tariffs, I mean, they they are taxed on top of the regular costs of
these products. I mean, they just push prices up and they push costs up and prices up. You can't
argue with what a tariff is. You can argue about the dynamic effects, who ends up paying the cost,
but they are inflationary. And Trump is not going to get everything he wants to put it in Ben's
terms. So he said something earlier this week that he has been saying since he took office.
I demand lower rates, lower interest rates. The president doesn't get to demand lower interest
rates and lower, higher interest rates actually go with higher inflation. So Trump is not going
to get lower interest rates. He's going to get higher interest rates. He's not going to get
lower inflation. He's going to get higher inflation. And meanwhile, I contend that the
main message voters said in the twenty twenty four election is we want President Trump to get prices
down, not to push prices up through tariffs or renegotiate the entire global trading system.
People basically said, I want lower prices and we actually have prices taking up a little bit.
We have this situation with eggs and the avian flu. I mean, egg inflation is up more than 50
percent year over year. And last time I looked at my store, eggs were eleven dollars a dozen.
And if you could get them. So Trump has had almost nothing to say about this. Luckily for Trump,
eggs are not gasoline. If if it was gasoline that was up 50 percent year over year,
it would be a national crisis. And Trump's approval rating would be in the low 40s or lower.
But people don't depend on eggs as much as they depend on gasoline. But Trump needs to start
paying attention to this stuff. Rick, do you think tariffs can be can be the new gasoline,
as you put it? You had a really interesting survey of Yahoo Finance folks this week about
how people view tariffs and they they're they're pretty clear about the tariffs can increase.
Do you think that there's a moment coming where people are going to see tariffs as
Trump, not just not dealing with lowering prices, but actually actively raising them?
This is the whole game that Wall Street is playing. So Wall Street has been discounting
Trump's tariff plans from before he took office. And the gamble, which is which is still why you
are still seeing stocks are pretty buoyant, is that Trump is threatening all this stuff,
but he's not actually going to do most of it. It's these are this is just a means to an end.
And the end is some other kind of outcome. So, I mean, Trump is really playing a game of chicken
here. I mean, he's he is threatening to push prices up and he has already imposed some tariffs
which are going to put some prices up. And the game he's playing so far is will people notice.
So the tariffs he's put in so far, just to remind everybody, 10 percent on everything from China.
That's not huge, but it's not nothing either. And it's not nothing on on steel and aluminum.
And that is going to show up in higher costs for automobiles, higher costs for
food that comes in in aluminum cans. So I think Trump is betting that people are not going to see
this on store shelves. But if he goes all the way, people are going to see it on store shelves. So we
all wait to see what's the what is the chess master really have in mind here? Yeah, and it's
interesting. I spoke with a source this week who broke it down really well. She was talking about
how something like aluminum tariffs, a tariff on a specific part of a product could increase prices
for consumers in her calculations by about a tenth of a percent. But those tariffs that you're talking
about on finished products, something like a twenty five percent tariffs on everything imported
from a certain country that could increase prices by one and a half percent. So just a very
significant difference when you're thinking about and calculating the impact of the different
tariffs coming out of the administration. And lastly, I'll just quickly mention I did a story
this week on the impact on a can of beer, specifically beer that's imported from Mexico.
I'm dying here. I know. I know. Rick, I'm going to send you the story. You're going to watch it
and you're going to give me great feedback. I know. I know. It's hard to calculate, obviously,
but it's something that these companies like the Constellation brands are really going to
have to contend with because some of these brands that have been importing beer from Mexico are some
of the best performers, the only growers in the alcohol category that's really been under pressure.
So are they going to pass those costs on to consumers and risk losing their spot as the
superior beer brands in the United States in a struggling sector right now? Or will they just
eat those costs? And that is the big question. Of course, as you mentioned, Rick, Wall Street
certainly discounting the idea of those costs getting passed on to consumers and any inflationary
impact of those. And instead, as always, the street just passing on and looking through
the optimistic lens of things. But we are going to have to take a quick break here on capital
gains. But we will be right back with Garrett Watson. We're going to talk tax policy and more
Welcome back to Capital Gains. We are now joined by Tax Foundation Policy Analysis Director Garrett
Watson. Garrett, it's great to have you on. And it's perfect timing because I got a question in
from Yahoo Finance viewer last night specifically about taxes. So I want to start there. He said,
look, you guys cover the policy so well, but I just want to know how this is impacting me
personally. How could any tax changes from the incoming from the current administration impact
taxes for just average Americans? What can you tell us about what that outlook is looking like?
Well, thanks, Maddie. I think the big thing is with everything going on in Washington right now,
folks need to keep an eye on the ball, which is we have what is a four trillion plus dollar
tax like potentially coming at the end of the year. The 2017 tax law that cut taxes for
many folks across the country is scheduled to expire for individuals. And that's going to be
lining up with a big tax cliff that folks will see impacting them as soon as the beginning of
next year with withholding and estimated tax payments. And so that's what's really motivating
a lot of what Congress is doing right now. A lot of the discussions in the White House is how to
avert that. And the challenge before Congress and the White House is how to balance that,
addressing that issue with all the other items before them in terms of dealing with the national
debt, trying to get some spending over to the border, dealing with deregulation energy.
There's a lot on their plate and a lot for everyday folks to follow over the coming months,
but that's going to be the single biggest thing that's going to impact folks' pocketbooks coming
into the next year that we're going to have to watch closely. Hey, Garrett, I wonder if you can
bring us up to date on some of the promises Trump made in addition to just extending the tax cuts
that are supposed to expire. So no taxes on tips, no taxes on overtime pay, no taxes on social
security benefits. Ben wrote a story listing, I think, 12 or 13 of them. So does Congress seem to
be making progress on passing those tax cuts or not? It's a couple of things there. One is there
have been several bills put forward in both the House and the Senate to try to come up with some
design for these ideas. So the one that's probably most mature and has the most runway ahead of it is
the idea to accept tips from income tax, several bills there. But there are other priorities that
the White House is leaning on. They reminded folks in Congress about that in a meeting of the White
House about a week ago. They still want to see an exemption for social security benefits from income
tax. They want to see overtime treated better under the income tax, maybe a full exemption there,
along with other priorities. And so the trick for Congress is they need to be able to fit that in
mathematically with all the arcane rules to pass, particularly through the Senate. And right now, it
appears the priority, for the most part, is getting those 2017 tax cuts permanent. The political
challenge, of course, is for a lot of folks, everyday folks, that's just keeping the status quo,
right? That's keeping the current policy in place, but the president ran on further cutting taxes.
So to the extent that the White House really pushes forward on making those a priority, Congress is
going to have to listen and make room for those. But the math is pretty challenging here. Some of
those may end up on a cutting room floor or potentially made temporary, so that math ends up adding up.
Hey Garrett, what are you hearing about SALT? The math problem is pretty difficult there.
This $4.5 trillion number we saw this week from the House Budget Committee, a lot of the commentary
on that was that, can SALT fit in that? And if it can't, can this pass? What are you hearing on that front?
So in my view, the compromise position has always been that there needs to be some sort of cap,
if anything, because it's quite a bit of money. We're talking about hundreds of billions or over
a trillion dollars over 10 years, so that's a significant offset. But there are many members
of Congress, particularly in the House, who want to see it be made more generous because they feel
like that existing $10,000 cap on SALT deductions is too onerous for their constituents. So we may
see that made more generous, potentially a doubling for married filers because that $10,000
amount is applied to everyone and that creates what's known as a marriage penalty and a tax code.
The trick is, is there a compromise that everyone can live with that both makes that budget math
work and satisfies the demands of this constituency? And then there are other side issues,
right? How to deal with, there are various workarounds that states have created. Does Congress
try to deal with that to undermine the cap? Do they look at business SALT deductions? That's
something that apparently a few committees in Congress have been looking at. That will all
have to be set up as well in one integrated whole. And the question is, do we get support across all
the branches of government to sufficiently get that in the package? Because that is one issue
that could sink this whole thing if folks draw that as a red line in their disagreement.
So Garrett, if you're just a regular person listening to this, you're hearing,
okay, Trump wants to raise taxes on one hand through tariffs, which is going to make some
products more expensive, but now he wants to have these other tax cuts on different types of income.
How have you guys gotten to the point of netting this all out? Is this likely to be a net gain,
net loss? Some people will win, some people will lose. How do you tell?
So that's a great question. I think it comes back to what y'all were talking about earlier,
which is how serious and how far does the president go on tariff policy? We provided
estimates that basically assumes the president goes all the way, that he fully fulfills his
campaign promises and goes ahead with a 20% universal tariff, a 60% all-in tariff on China.
And what we find there is a substantial portion of those tax cuts are offset in terms of both
their positive economic effects and the results in American pocketbooks for many Americans.
And so that is just one scenario, though. That's the maximalist scenario. If the president uses
this more as a negotiating tool or holds back and tries to apply this more selectively,
that story gets a bit more complicated. And I think that's more of a story of winners and losers.
Certain folks in certain income categories, depending on their consumption habits,
may end up ahead or behind. And that can complicate the political picture as well
for Republicans on the Hill who are trying to sell this as a major boost to
both economic growth and the pocketbooks of everyday people.
So it does, I think, introduce another source of uncertainty. We talk a lot about business
uncertainty with the tariffs, but it also introduces uncertainty for everyday folks on
the cost side of things and how taxes end up netting out for their pocketbook in the coming
year or two.