Investor disappointment could 'risk' a sell-off

Financial Action Task
1 follower
4 Video Views·Jan 18, 2025
So now for today's strategy session,
and you can see from the chart on your screen right now,
the ratio of tech stocks relative to the S&P 500
is actually at its highest level
that we've seen since the dot-com bubble,
as valuations for those mega cap companies
sit at record highs.
So valuations and earnings expectations at such high levels
could we potentially be due for a sell-off?
Let's bring in Marta Norton,
Empower chief investment strategist.
Marta, it's great to have you here on Yahoo Finance.
Let's talk about maybe what this signals,
the margin for error.
I think maybe that's the question here.
The margin for error this earnings season,
is that very small just given maybe the negative reaction
we could see to any sort of shortfall?
Yeah, it seems as though with expectations being so high,
and these numbers are widely cited,
that earnings expectations for the first quarter
around 11%, and then as you ramp up
over the course of the year,
you're looking at about a 15% earnings growth.
Those are really high expectations relative to history,
and you're pairing that with valuations
that also seem really stretched.
And so we're looking at this
on a price to expected earnings basis.
So incorporating some of those earnings expectations,
and even on that metric, you're looking at a market
that is in the 10th decile
in terms of historical valuation ranking.
That doesn't necessarily mean a sell-off is imminent.
Valuations can remain high, markets can grind higher,
but it becomes more and more of a risk
and kind of raises the possibility of a sell-off
with that little margin of error that you suggest there
in terms of execution or disappointment.
And so with that in mind,
if we did get a reset of some of those expectations,
at least early on in the year,
do you anticipate that that sell-off that we could see
might turn into a full-blown correction?
Well, I think that possibility is out there.
What gives me some encouragement about this market
is when we're taking a look at the economy,
and I know we're on pins and needles
as we follow inflation very closely here,
but broadly speaking, the economy seems very healthy.
There are stimulants out there
when we're thinking about different fiscal policy,
when we're thinking about the possibility
if inflation comes under control of lower rates.
So there's a lot of positives to point to
that could suggest that we're in a healthy place.
The one concern is where our sentiment is
and disappointments on that sentiment
and what that could mean.
But in terms of fundamental weakness,
that could mean some sort of collapse in markets
and some sort of recession.
That seems a little bit further afield for me.
But I'm curious what you've made of the reaction
that we've seen over the last 24 hours,
how the market was quick to dismiss
some of those inflationary concerns,
and we really saw that reaction play out
within the bond market.
What does that tell you maybe
about the volatility that's ahead?
I mean, it just feels like pins and needles,
and frankly, it's a continuation of the trends
that we've seen over the past year or so.
So if you remember, starting into 2024,
the expectation was that inflation was falling like a rock
and we were gonna get plenty of cuts,
then inflation disappointed to the upside,
fears commenced around inflation,
then we have fears turned to labor.
The economic narrative has been shifting consistently
and investors have been falling suit.
And I think the reaction that we're seeing today
is very similar to this high-strung nature
that the market has demonstrated over this time.
I think it's really important to step back
and look at this broader mosaic
where I think we're seeing a cooling labor market
despite month-to-month volatility,
and we're seeing inflation traverse
that very difficult last mile to that 2% target.
So I think that broader mosaic is still entrenched,
but the day-to-day volatility and narrative shifting
is gonna remain something that we have to contend with.
We're, of course, just days away from the inauguration,
and it seems like the Fed is gonna be in wait-and-see mode
to see how policies might get enacted,
whether that looks like
and comes in the form of tariff policy,
whether that comes in the form
of some type of immigration and deportation
that was campaigned on that gets carried through.
All of these have economic implications,
and ultimately, we're trying to get a playbook for investors
and how they should be approaching all of those key events
if they were to play out as campaigned on, at least.
How are you looking at that?
You know, it's complex and it's uncertain,
and I think that's one reason
why we're seeing the bond action that we're seeing.
There's a major redirect from Biden policy
where most of these policies
outside of the protectionism embedded in tariffs
are moving in the opposite direction,
but there's a question on what that magnitude looks like.
And so I think what investors
are really trying to grapple with
as we see the inauguration and policy established
is what that magnitude looks like.
And I think the uncertainty there
is pretty high around a number of factors.
Take taxes, for example.
That feels like an obvious direction
that the Trump policy is heading in,
but we don't really even know exactly
what can be accomplished
given the small majority that we have in the House.
And so I think that there's a lot of assumptions
with not a lot of information around some of these policies.
Now, tariffs seem a little bit more evident
that that's gonna come into play,
but we don't know whether
that's gonna be a slow and steady approach,
whether that's gonna be a big bang phenomenon,
or whether we're gonna have a universal tariff
or targeted tariffs.
So I think that is one of the things
that keeps the market on pins and needles right now.
All right, Marta, thanks so much for joining us
here this morning, Marta Norton of Empower.
