This Was Worse Than EVERYONE Expected (CPI Breakdown)

Profit Playbook
12 followers
1 Video View·Feb 13, 2025
Shocker of a CPI report; or was it? The bigger shock came afterward when Chevron stunned with its massive shake-up. At the same time - and for the same reasons - the oil market is undergoing a dramatic change of its own. And these are far from inflationary.
Eurodollar University's Money & Macro Analysis
The January CPI report is out with some pretty shocking results, though not as shocking as
what Chevron just announced which basically stole the thunder from the BLS, and behind
both of those, in fact connecting both of those, there's some pretty dramatic shifts
going on in the oil market right now.
So consumer prices across the board came in higher than expected, higher not hotter, and
the reasons for it are all the more the same as what we got this time last year.
There are seasonal problems with the CPI, and the clearest example of those is gasoline
estimates.
Gas prices really haven't gone anywhere, yet the BLS has them soaring by another 1.8% in
January, following a 4% increase in December, even as gasoline prices are materially lower
than they had been this time last year.
So if gas was actually doing what the CPI has them doing, then Chevron would not have
just announced a massive cost-cutting campaign that will reportedly see the company lay off
15-20% of its workforce, 15-20%.
But don't worry, executives have said, there's nothing wrong with the business, just a little
cost-cutting that somehow totals up to 1 in 5 of its workers.
And one of the big reasons why Chevron is going this route is the loss the company reported
in its fuel business.
Refinery margins had fallen too low for the company to turn a profit.
The entire oil market is facing oversupply, which is just a word to use to avoid saying
demand ain't there like everyone thought it was going to be, including Chevron.
So what's happening in oil belies a whole bunch of government data on the robustness
of the economy and the red-hotness of consumer prices.
As far as those go, that's pretty easy.
We did this, this time last year.
All the same stuff, red-hot consumer prices forever.
The Fed was never going to be able to cut.
In fact, many people were calling for more rate hikes.
Everything that you're hearing now, we heard just last year, including consumer prices
themselves, the numbers and their behavior.
We didn't hear what's new is what's coming from Chevron.
What Chevron just announced, it's now planning to lay off 15 to 20% of its global workforce.
That's what they said Wednesday during an internal employee town hall meeting, at least
according to the initial sources.
According to Barron's, what they reported is a top company executive told that media
outlets, layoffs are part of a larger cost-cutting initiative and are not a sign of broader
problems at the company.
They're just losing money in places where they should be making tons of money.
That's nothing to worry about.
I think what they really mean is the company's not in danger of being insolvent.
They're not running out of cash.
They're just simply not performing the way that everyone had expected because the global
economy isn't living up to its expectations or what everyone keeps forecasting.
The forgot how to grow economy is taking more and more casualties along the way, and Chevron
just becomes the latest one.
Back in December, the Wall Street Journal had reported already they were considering
something drastic because of how the economy wasn't performing the way everyone had expected.
Back in December, Chevron announced its first budget cut in the shale patch ever since the
pandemic.
It said it will curb its oil production growth in the Permian Basin while lifting the amount
of cash it can wring from the oil field which straddles West Texas and New Mexico.
Chevron said it's cutting capital spending globally by $2 billion.
That's capital spending.
It's also cutting structural costs by up to $3 billion by 2026, which will include job
cuts across its operations worldwide, which is the announcement that we just got today.
The company didn't say how many jobs would be affected, and it turns out it's a gargantuan
proportion, 15 to 20 percent of all their entire global workforce.
So after years of pumping more and more money into the Permian, Chevron is shifting gears
with a plan to spend as much as 10 percent less in the busiest U.S. oil field in 2025.
And that doesn't sound like things are expected to pick up all that much.
They're not expecting a roaring high oil prices that are going to lead to 1970 style inflation
or what everyone imagines of 1970 style inflation.
What Chevron is instead doing is recognizing how things are not living up to all those
expectations that when they were pouring tons of money into the Permian bases and elsewhere
around the world, expecting that China was going to get its crap together, that the U.S.
was going to live up to its hype, that Europe was eventually going to turn itself around.
None of those things are actually happening.
And so recognizing how none of those are likely to happen, forgot how to grow around the
world. They're now forced into some drastic measures to align their operations with
reality, not inflationary reality, but reality of the world that forgot how to grow.
So what Chevron reported, according to CNBC, with its latest earnings, the oil major missed
Wall Street's earnings expectations for the fourth quarter.
Chevron's fuel business, this is an important part, posted a loss of $248 million in the
quarter compared to a profit of $1.15 billion in prior year period as refining margins have
fallen. Refining margins, something we keep pointing out with low gasoline prices,
refining margins have fallen because demand that was supposed to be there isn't there.
Everyone was expecting the economy to pick up in the United States, not just around the
rest of the world. They were expecting demand to be robust.
And so they forecast energy use growth to be way up here.
And it keeps coming in way below that.
It keeps disappointing.
It doesn't pick up like everyone is expecting.
So they're all thinking that maybe there'd be a downturn, a slowdown in 2023, maybe the
first half of 24. But by the end of 24 to 25, everyone was expecting everything would
be going in the other direction.
And instead, what happened is forgot how to grow.
So you look at gasoline prices, wholesale gasoline price, not the stuff that's in the
CPI report, which I'll get to in a minute.
Wholesale gasoline, even today, just $2.13 a gallon at the CME, $2.13 a gallon is way
below where it had been this time last year and this time the year before.
And the year before that, gasoline prices are supposed to be rising because it's winter.
And that's what gasoline prices do in the winter.
But yet they're continuing to stay low, which is pressuring these oil companies, especially
in their fuel business, because it means that margins can't expand.
They can't turn a profit.
And it's all due to the fact that demand is not living up to expectations.
The forgot how to grow economy is now leading to we need to change our business.
And it's not just Chevron.
This is just one of the first ones that we're going to be hearing about who are now
actively laying off lots of workers, lots of good paying jobs, too.
As far as the general oil market behind gasoline, the oil market WTI futures is starting
to really get close to contango.
And it's changed right around February 4th.
Well, just the last couple of weeks, last week and a half or so.
Having been afraid of an oversupply situation, the curve has gone back and forth.
It just burst with these periods of geopolitics intruding.
Back in January, we had the outgoing Biden administration implement sanctions, really
tough sanctions on Russia, which even the Indians said they were going to abide by,
which which threatened even more oil supply coming off the marketplace.
And so oil prices spiked.
The curve itself spiked into steep backwardation.
But it didn't last very long because, again, demand does not live up to its end of the
bargain. So as of today, the March 2025 futures contract in WTI, which is the front
contract, down back down to seventy one sixty per barrel.
But more importantly, the April contract, the one next to it was just seventy one
forty four or one month calendar spread of only 16 cents.
The more important benchmark three month calendar spread is seventy four cents.
So you see the real narrowing and backwardation to the point where the curve is now
like early December.
Last time we were talking about oversupply fears.
The curve is very close to contango, which has to be factoring in Chevron's position.
I don't mean the short run, but the fact that these short run changes are validating the
idea of oversupply, weak demand.
Therefore, oil prices are not going to turn around.
Refining margins are not going to turn around.
Better start cutting costs because the rest of it is just not happening.
Forgot how to grow.
We didn't forget how to grow the CPI consumer prices in the United States in the month of
January. And like I said in the introduction here, we did this last year.
Same kind of thing. And even many mainstream sources are questioning what's going on in
the CPI, starting with seasonal adjustments because something goes on in January.
You can't necessarily fault the BLS because they're trying to do the best with what
they have. And the pandemic created all sorts of new patterns that hadn't been had
been in the data before.
Remember, that's how this works.
Statistics, especially something like seasonal adjustments.
It looks at the past and tries to say this is what a season, this is what usually
happens at this time of year.
So there's been a number of things that have popped up suggesting that some of the
seasonal adjustments and it's not just the consumer price, you see this all over
macroeconomic data that some of the post pandemic patterns are creating difficulties
and seasonal adjustments. So you almost expect consumer prices to rise in a bunch of
categories, even places where they're not actually rising in the real economy.
They're rising because the seasonal adjustments are picking up other things other than
what they're supposed to. Some of that work leads to potential distortions.
But what the numbers the BLS reported for the CPI in January, 0.47 percent month over
month, which is the highest since August of 2023, though we have to note there was 0.4
percent or very close last February, last time we were talking about all this stuff.
The year over year rate was 2.999 percent or basically 3 percent, which is the highest
since May. The core rate, though, that one jumped 0.45 percent month over month, which
is the highest monthly increase since April of 2023.
But despite that, the year over year change was only 3.29 percent, which is basically
the same year over year rate as the prior seven months.
In fact, in those seven months, four times we've seen 3.29 percent, including the
latest monthly number.
So these rates are all generally too high.
That that part's unmistakable.
The question is why they're too high.
Is it because of seasonal adjustments?
Is there real things happening in the economy?
Is it genuine inflation?
Well, there are seasonal adjustment problems, as I said, but there are also real economy
factors to consider as well.
Starting with the seasonal adjustments, gasoline prices, as we just went over with the in
the previous segment here, the BLS says that gasoline prices were up 1.8 percent month
over month in January after rising 4 percent in December.
And you have to wonder where the hell those numbers are coming from.
And those numbers are coming from not the real economy, seasonal adjustments.
And given what Chevron is doing, what the oil curve is doing also, you know, the fact
that it's heading toward contango, it's not whatever the BLS is picking up.
It's not like it's not likely that gasoline and energy prices are going to be sticking
where they are for very long.
Not only will there be a seasonal give back at some point in the next couple of months,
there's a very good chance that oil prices overall and gasoline prices overall continue
to be weak for this time of year.
It might even continue to go lower, which would be a benefit to at least the consumer
price estimates.
So while gasoline estimates don't really make any sense in the real economy, some of the
food prices actually do.
Starting with eggs, people have been talking about the egg, pop, egg, egg, a pocket bag
apocalypse. That's hard to say.
The the bird flu that's taking its toll on flocks all around the country, therefore
making eggs ridiculously expensive.
That's one food item.
There's other food items that are legitimately rising.
But for for non-economic reasons, not because the economy's red hot or genuine
inflation, just because there's these one off factors that happen every once in a
while. We still have shelter prices while they're coming down, they're still
relatively high compared to what we what we see in other data around the real economy
and shelter prices contributed 30 percent of the core rate.
Another one that's actually real, but they contribute a lot to the consumer price
number. That's more of a one off and more likely to lead to disinflation over the
future, over the future months.
That's car insurance premiums.
Car insurance premiums absolutely skyrocketed, according to the BLS.
Some of this might be the seasonal adjustment, but there's no doubt that car insurance
premiums really did rise or transportation services of one point eight four percent
month over month, which is the most since June of twenty twenty two.
So there's a lot of stuff going on in the CPI.
We put all these things together.
It has everybody panicking their hair on fire.
The Fed's not going to not going to be able to cut it all this year.
No more rate cuts. The rate cutting cycles over.
They need their next move might even be a rate hike.
And we've heard all of this every single last bit of it before.
We heard it this time last year.
But really, February, March and April, as consumer prices looked like they were not
going to break, they were going to be completely sticky.
They're going to be stuck there forever.
Everyone said forget rate cuts in twenty twenty four.
The next move from the Fed is going to be a hike.
So just go back to last year, last January, after the CPI came in hot, CNBC said stock
market futures fell sharply following the release of the January twenty twenty four
CPI. Futures tied to the Dow Jones industrial average were off more than two hundred fifty
points and treasury yields surged higher.
By the time you get to March and April, the Fed was never going to be able to cut rates.
Inflation was here to stay.
It was 1970s all over again.
In fact, CNN reported inflation slowed substantially in twenty twenty three as the Fed
lifted rates to nearly a quarter century high and held them at that level since last July,
which was July twenty twenty three.
But recent economic data shows there hasn't been much improvement this year.
Then came March's Consumer Price Index report, which showed prices rose three and a half
percent last month from a year earlier, up considerably from February twenty four is
three point two percent and higher than an economist's expectations.
That also marked the highest reading in half a year.
Fed Governor Michelle Bowman, arguably the central bank's most hawkish voice.
She recently said that she would favor a rate hike.
A rate hike should progress on inflation stall or even reverse.
Minneapolis Fed President Neal Cash Carey last week.
Again, this is April of twenty twenty four.
He floated the possibility of not cutting rates at all this year.
Twenty twenty four.
He also said rate hikes are certainly not off the table, but he said they aren't likely.
Cash Carey is not voting on monetary policy decisions this year.
And so they kept talking about rate hikes and the possibility of them, but the very least
higher for longer.
We're going to be no rate cuts, as Reuters reported that same month, April of last year.
Options on SOFR futures are showing a higher probability that the Federal Reserve could
hike interest rates a quarter point this year and next as U.S.
inflation, the labor market remain resilient.
Sounds really familiar, doesn't it?
Odds for a rise in SOFR are low, though not insignificant.
Few market participants actually expect the Fed to hike again.
It could well be that the Fed just cuts rates once this year or not at all, or maybe just
holds them there higher for longer.
If you look purely at the data and you do not have the rhetoric coming from central
banks, we would be pricing in hikes, not cuts, said Ashkey Single, who's the head of
short term interest rates at Citi.
Again, it sounds incredibly familiar to everything that we're hearing right now.
And obviously none of that happened.
There was no higher for longer.
There certainly weren't any rate cut rate hikes.
Instead, we did get rate cuts because consumer prices, as they do go back and forth.
They disinflated in the middle part of the year as the economy more clearly and more
visibly weakened in the United States as they forgot how to grow economy reasserted
itself on the US.
That's the thing with this forgot how to grow economy.
It's not linear.
It's not in a straight line.
It doesn't follow the recognizable recession pattern.
And disinflation itself is typically bumpy and uneven.
So you have a bunch of these processes that are not linear.
And the result is they go back and forth, just like the Fed.
The Fed goes back and forth like it was last year, early last year.
They were incredibly hawkish.
No more. No possibility of rate cuts.
Maybe we have to hike rates.
Oh, crap. Disinflation really showed up.
Economic weakness.
Labor market turns around.
Now we need to really cut rates.
And they did in September and followed it up.
And then they went back to, OK, now that we cut rates, we see inflation starting up again.
Now we need to hold higher for longer.
Maybe we need to hike as our next policy move.
And then what will happen?
Weakness in the economy will show up again.
Consumer prices will disinflate and they will cut rates all over.
But from the Fed's perspective and for anybody who believes in the Fed
and in the power of rate hiking or rate cuts, for that matter,
this is not the best best result that they can hope for.
After all, it was the most aggressive series of rate hikes in the Fed's history.
Heard all about that in twenty twenty two right on into twenty twenty three.
Interest rates were incredibly restrictive, except
they didn't seem to have any impact on consumer prices.
There is no correlation between the Fed's rate rate policies
and the results in the CPI or the PC deflator.
The PC deflator, CPI, consumer prices, the real economy, the whole thing
seems to be completely uncorrelated to the central bank's main policy lever.
It's as if the consumer prices and the real economy are doing their own thing
for reasons and factors that have nothing to do with Jay Powell and the FOMC.
So you have a bunch of stuff thrown in the CPI, some of which is familiar,
some of which is seasonal, some of it's just real one offs
that are going to make it that much more difficult for consumers
that are already struggling.
Egg prices is a big one.
Car insurance premiums, that's going to really hurt and really sting.
It's going to really lead to more weakness in the real economy
over the months ahead, not accelerating consumer prices.
The opposite, just like we see oil prices spike.
But in the oil market, we're not getting a spike now.
We're getting the market that says things are incredibly weak.
Big oil companies that were making bundles and boatloads of profits off of oil
kept forecasting demand to keep up with prices and demand never did.
Instead, it continues to disappoint year after year after year to the point.
Now, Chevron is saying we got to get rid of a fifth,
maybe as much as a fifth of our entire global workforce
because we don't see this sucker turning around.
The economy forgot how to grow, and it is taking casualties.
It's taking more casualties in the business world
after taking a ton of casualties in the consumer world.
So any increase in consumer prices that are legitimately happening
in the real economy are only going to add more pain and pressure
to the world that forgot how to grow.
With the oil business struggling as much as it is, would anybody really be surprised
that the car business is struggling even more?
Went over the latest details there.
They're not looking good.
Video link below.
As always, thank you very much for joining me.
Huge thank you, URUDAL University members and subscribers.
And until next time, take care.
