Medieval Spear Play (Part 1)

MELEE Weapons
4 followers
1 Video View·Feb 5, 2025
Weapon handling – How to approach the opponent safely – How to avoid double kills.
This first of two parts explains duelling tactics that are valid for any hand weapon, but become most obvious with longer ones, such as the spear.
Camera: Cornelius Berthold, editing by Karen Schmidt. Special thanks to Julien Reschke for assisting in the demos.
Okay, so I'm now going to do a run through the spear play we were training yesterday.
And I'm going to explain all the important parts. The reason why I had you train with spears
is that everything you do with a spear takes more time. Because when you use it to strike,
because it's just a longer weapon. So if I have to bridge distance here with a long weapon because
it has a long range, that means that I'm bridging longer distances. And bridging a longer distance
always takes more time than bridging a shorter distance. So when you train with these weapons,
you have more time to think. As opposed to training with a dagger or with a sword.
Also, we have both hands on the shaft. So we can do things that we have to do in order to
bring forward the point. Look, the point is not supposed to travel in an arc. So when I strike,
I don't strike like this. It's clumsy. And at this point here, I have little control.
It's also, if you look at geometry, it's a much longer path to get anywhere. As opposed to
bringing this bit, which is the important part in the fight, forward in a straight line.
And to bring it forward in a straight line, you start with this hand,
drawing it down like a paddle in a canoe or in a boat. So it's basically like rowing here,
like paddling. Also make sure that you don't draw down and to the side, because then the spear
would come forward in a much wider angulation. It's harder to see for the opponent if it comes down
at a much steeper angulation to begin with. Also, this is a shorter route than taking the
longer route out on the outside. Here it is harder to see when it comes.
It's also nicer to control for you. There's also an element of body mechanics here.
Striking like this is less strong than striking like this. Because here I have more power.
It's a tighter action as opposed to striking like so. Here I'm striking from the shoulder.
Here the body is aligned behind the part that transfers the pressure. Now it's the fist.
Here it's the spear, okay? So steep action,
moving the hand first, that's really important. You want to move your hand first,
because you want to be able to, if he's charging in, then you don't have to go any further than
this. You want to be able to decide yourself how far you enter. And sometimes, because he's bridging
distance very, very quickly, he's doing your job. That's fine. Then at one point you could
maybe even retreat and you'd be in a perfect position against somebody who's charging in.
However, if in contrast you would insist on stepping, moving your weapon at the same time
as you move your body, if now on the way, now in the process of going forward, you see, oh my god,
they're charging in and you have to shorten distance, you will find yourself in a really
crappy position. If you go forward in false time, moving the whole body and the weapon all at once,
then you are committed to a situation, to a position here and you cannot easily change it
anymore. It takes all the effort it took to get here to get back.
The foot is really slow, because it has to carry the whole body weight, while the hand is really
fast. Whenever you do something and you don't have contact yet, you also rely on visual
information. That means that while I'm striking my blow to gain the center, time passes and I can use
this time to analyze the situation. So while I'm in this process, my brain is working. So if I see
it is not required to actually step, I can just stay here. If I see that he's coming in very, very
quickly, I can retreat to make sure that I achieve my original purpose. Which is the original purpose
when I enter with a blow into a fight. What do I want to do? Gain the center. That's the
correct answer. Now this is a detail that a lot of people miss when they are talking about single
combat. When you enter to strike directly to the head, to directly bring the sharp end into his head
with a strike, then this is a very dangerous approach. Because if the both of us do it,
we have to get... Can you come to me in slow motion and strike, so that you strike into my head.
You have to get fairly close to each other to do this. Okay, so he's in reach with a strike,
I'm in reach with a strike. Also the way the weapons bind, if you just look at it,
both of us do it, then the weapons do bind. That's true, however...
Now you were actually not striking at me, you were checking the weapon, which is more clever.
But you're supposed to strike directly to my head. This is a false example, this is not the way I
suggest to do it. And this is what a lot of people do. They try to hit the opponent with a blow to
the head, this is what you do. And on the way, automatically our weapons will cross and thus
there will be a bind. Now this kind of bind is pretty dead, because we have very short levers
here. You take a look, the leverage here is very close to our hands, or the crossing is very close
to his hand, so it feels less as opposed to a crossing that is here. Here he has a longer lever,
which makes him more sensitive to pressure signals as opposed to this. Here he doesn't
really know how hard the pressure is. This is one flaw of this kind of fighting.
The worst one is that it feels a bit like gambling. It comes down to who strikes harder.
And also if he tries to strike into my head, but I don't, because I'm thrusting at him.
So if he comes towards me to strike in my head and I go to thrusting range, before he gets into
range, he will be dead, because the thrust has much more reach than a blow that covers the line.
So with my blow I cover the line, thus there was a bind in the false example just a few seconds ago.
But with a blow, this hand is lower than shoulder level, but I have maximum, I have more reach
at shoulder level. Your maximum reach is always at shoulder level. If you lower your hand,
your range shortens. So when you strike and your hands are lower than your shoulder level,
then that means that you need to get closer to the opponent. So you need to bridge distance,
and bridging distance takes time. And if you need more time to get your opponent than he,
then that's not a real option. You put yourself at a disadvantage from the very beginning.
So this is why, as you said, we strike from thrusting range, which allows for
taking the center. Yes, and this is the key to all safe single combat. You want to control
the middle. So if I'm standing here and he's standing there, then here's a virtual place,
the center. I don't know, maybe like a plasma ball or like in Harry Potter or whatever.
So imagine the center. You want to conquer this place. You strike to claim it, and if it's
possible, you conquer it. Imagine a castle. You ride up, lay siege to it, you conquer it,
and now only when you have conquered this place, you are allowed to invade the hinterland.
Right, don't ever do this without control of the center, because even if we, if the both of us use
the correct range to start striking, yeah, and then we would end in a different kind of bind.
So we are now striking from thrusting range, probably here. Yeah, here I will be in thrusting
range, so I can get to him with one single action. Don't do anything, please. With one single action
and thrust into his face. This distance is called wide distance, right? It's defined by
being able to reach the opponent with one single action, the maximum distance that you can cover
with one single action. So even if we are striking from the correct distance, right,
but now neither of us controls the center, and both of us start to thrust at each other,
then we're both dead. Yeah, not controlling this center means that you are on the path to the
double kill. This is something you definitely want to avoid with a sharp weapon. So what you want to
do is control the center. Your ideal fight, of course, would be that he's too lame, and once I
come there, you go into your hat, but you start in slow motion, but you leave your tip behind, okay?
So, once I get to the center, his weapon is, I claim the center, and I already control the center,
because there's nothing to, I have to deal with, so I can safely extend into the thrust here.
That would be my ideal fight. Go there, claim the center, and then go to the thrust. From the
outside, it will look as if I thrust him into the face straight away. If it's done with
proficiency, and skill, and the speed that comes as a byproduct, so strike and extend.
But it actually is a two-parted attack, and this is the one thing you really have
to understand with all your combat. It's two-parted attacks. While it is still one tempo, which means
one fencing time, one action, this action is divided into two halves. Safety, securing, control,
and then completion of technique, and killing him. The first part is about
gaining the center, controlling the center, and then you kill him. All right, now comes the run through the technique.
